Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Canada’s euthanasia for the mentally ill

342 replies

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Expansion of assisted dying for mental illness to be delayed until 2024 in new bill - National | Globalnews.ca

Justice Minister David Lametti has said the delay is needed after the federal government heard concerns that Canada's health-care system might not be prepared for the expansion.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Comedycook · 01/05/2023 10:39

Noicant · 01/05/2023 10:18

Because in certain situations the only way is down.

Well you've totally misunderstood me.

I can see plenty of situations both mental and physical were death would be preferable...but, im against euthanasia because of the possibility of coercion and mistakes happening as well as the perimeters getting wider and wider.

Noicant · 01/05/2023 10:38

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:36

@Noicant I don't know. I don't have that answer, I would want it to be arrived at by people who have expert knowledge in the field of mental health. These would have to include people who have all the data on recovery rates for people with severe and enduring mental illness - that data is out there, I've spent enough time working in MH research to know that. It would not be a quick or overnight decision. It would also not be a black and white rule book, you'd have to look at the full range of mental illnesses and the prognosis where there are comorbidities.

I'd like an answer too, especially from the 'no, never' people on this thread - because they seem to think that leaving someone for decades is just fine. Some people seem unable to see that there are times when hope is a stick that you beat people with. This is never going to be a simple matter to resolve, the ethics are enormously complex. I certainly would not want euthanasia for mental health to be handed out like sweeties; the threshold needs to be high. But saying we should never do it because people who are mentally ill cannot consent is wrong.

Thank you for the considered response.

OP posts:
SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:37

Sudeko · 01/05/2023 10:26

There are not many people who enter and remain in a constantly suicidal state. There are far more who go on to recover and then look back on those dark times and feel grateful to have come through to the other side to a better place. It is placing too much responsibility upon the shoulders of people with impaired decision making to claim that they are capable of making the correct decision with no last minute remorse.

Infact, there was a very harrowing case of a young man in the UK who took that suicide drug (which cannot be legally named online ) which he would have ordered by post (possibly from Canada, I cannot recall). He ran towards his mother and was screaming that he wanted to live and wanted to choose life but he had already ingested a deadly quantity. It reflects sloppy MH care to entrust the vulnerable with the decision to choose a quick fix which runs counter to their true welfare needs, just to lower the burden on a failing system.

Yes, A&E regularly gets patients presenting after having taken an overdose and then suddenly realising what they’ve done.

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:36

@Noicant I don't know. I don't have that answer, I would want it to be arrived at by people who have expert knowledge in the field of mental health. These would have to include people who have all the data on recovery rates for people with severe and enduring mental illness - that data is out there, I've spent enough time working in MH research to know that. It would not be a quick or overnight decision. It would also not be a black and white rule book, you'd have to look at the full range of mental illnesses and the prognosis where there are comorbidities.

I'd like an answer too, especially from the 'no, never' people on this thread - because they seem to think that leaving someone for decades is just fine. Some people seem unable to see that there are times when hope is a stick that you beat people with. This is never going to be a simple matter to resolve, the ethics are enormously complex. I certainly would not want euthanasia for mental health to be handed out like sweeties; the threshold needs to be high. But saying we should never do it because people who are mentally ill cannot consent is wrong.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:35

pimplebum · 01/05/2023 10:33

I cannot think of one mental illness that is “severely life limiting” with treatment.

Ummmm I am guessing you don't suffer with long term MH issues ?

🙄 I do in fact. Have a read of my other posts xx

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:35

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:24

@SwitchDiver I actually don't respect your opinions, because you do not respect mine. You refuse to accept that mentally ill people are capable of consenting to an assisted suicide just because they are mentally ill. Your assumptions about mental illness and capacity are based on your own experiences and you are unable to accept that other people will have very different perceptions and experiences. What you post is just that - opinion and nothing more. You offer no answers to the hard question, which as always is: how long do we leave people with severe and enduring mental ill health to suffer before we accept their choice to not live?

You also do not offer any answers to the questions around the impact of suicide on others.

I have respected your opinions. The most I have called your opinion is “pessimistic” because it was. Other than that I have gently pointed out that your accusations of “arrogant assumptions” and so on are incorrect.

I answered your “hard questions” in regards to how agency and choice are not clear cut when you are seriously mentally ill. Ignored by you. I answer on the suffering issue- truth is no one knows how long a person may suffer or if they will get to a period free of suffering. Even the pp who suffers horribly every day is actively choosing not to die so you going on about suffering like that means a person should just go and die is off putting.

It’s obvious you have no respect for others opinions, especially those of us who have mental health conditions and direct lived experience of being suicidal. You put a lot of stock into testimonials you have read but none into our own testimonials.

Noicant · 01/05/2023 10:35

LakeTiticaca · 01/05/2023 10:32

I watched my mother struggle with vascular dementia for years. She had already declined surgery for a heart complaint that would have extended her life by at least 5 years (she made this decision when she still had capacity)
If my mother had been able to foresee the suffering she would have to endure I feel sure she would have opted for euthanasia had it been available.

I sure as hell will if and when the need arises

Yes I support Euthansia in those circumstances. I would want the option myself.

Just to be clear I am not anti- euthanasia, I think it’s an act of compassion in many circumstances.

OP posts:
MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 10:34

pointythings · 01/05/2023 09:49

@Noicant and @SwitchDiver I do understand your personal concerns. I've worked in mental health for many years. However, when these threads come up it's always in the light of the Canadian approach to this. The Canadian approach is bad, it has insufficient safeguards, it is ill thought through. But other models are available.

I had a cousin in the Netherlands who had psychosis. Nothing helped him. He killed himself by jumping off a block of flats, to the immense distress of the people who witnessed it. This included children. Is that better than offering a way out? Where I grew up there was a stretch of train track that was notorious for suicides. It was horrific for the train drivers. Is that better than offering a way out?

I think broadly speaking the Netherlands has it right. It isn't perfect, but it's a hell of a lot better than leaving people permanently stuck in a life with little or no hope.

My main concerns about introducing assisted dying in the UK is that we have a government that only cares about money and selling stuff off to their wealthy friends. I'd like to see that change, and then I'd like to see the introduction of PR, before we take action on assisted dying. But I have no issues with AD itself, if done properly.

Speaking from personal experience. I have a diagnosis of a severe mental illness (schizophrenia), and over the years I have been very unwell. But I have also received very inadequate support and help. And currently I am doing well. But the thought that there are people working in mental health, like yourself pointythings, who would support me being euthanised, is terrifying. Hopefully I never end up being sectioned again, because the thought of there being staff like yourself on a ward I find really disturbing. I do not want mental health professionals feeling my life isn't worth anything, thanks.

pimplebum · 01/05/2023 10:33

I cannot think of one mental illness that is “severely life limiting” with treatment.

Ummmm I am guessing you don't suffer with long term MH issues ?

LakeTiticaca · 01/05/2023 10:32

I watched my mother struggle with vascular dementia for years. She had already declined surgery for a heart complaint that would have extended her life by at least 5 years (she made this decision when she still had capacity)
If my mother had been able to foresee the suffering she would have to endure I feel sure she would have opted for euthanasia had it been available.

I sure as hell will if and when the need arises

ShimmeringShirts · 01/05/2023 10:31

@pointythings analysing the impact of suicide on others that are still alive is an incredibly selfish thing to do. A person should not have to live just to make another person happy, a person should not have to endure decades of illness to make another person happy. You are saying that their life is more important than the non life someone with permanent mental health issues.

You might love life, but not everyone does. You might see living as more important than anything else but that’s because you’ve not experienced what it’s like to suffer consistently and constantly. You do not get to make that choice for others.

pimplebum · 01/05/2023 10:30

Equality I suppose means just that ?
A mentally ill person may want a peaceful end from the endless torment, especially if they know it's terminal ... yes it's sad and troubling but so is schizophrenia

Noicant · 01/05/2023 10:29

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:24

@SwitchDiver I actually don't respect your opinions, because you do not respect mine. You refuse to accept that mentally ill people are capable of consenting to an assisted suicide just because they are mentally ill. Your assumptions about mental illness and capacity are based on your own experiences and you are unable to accept that other people will have very different perceptions and experiences. What you post is just that - opinion and nothing more. You offer no answers to the hard question, which as always is: how long do we leave people with severe and enduring mental ill health to suffer before we accept their choice to not live?

You also do not offer any answers to the questions around the impact of suicide on others.

Genuine question, how long would you consider enough time being ill before euthansia should be realistically considered as a viable option for someone? A year? 5 years? This isn’t an attack I really am trying to understand. I do have sympathy with your position btw I really do. My fear is that we get it wrong.

OP posts:
Somanycats · 01/05/2023 10:27

pointythings · 01/05/2023 09:19

I'm with @DisquietintheRanks . It's cruel to dangle the carrot of hope in front of someone with severe and enduring mental illness. Nobody ever answers the question of how long you want to force people to suffer, take heavy medication which still doesn't work, be constantly watched, be forcibly admitted to inpatient units. For some people there is no recovery and we have to accept that. I'm from the Netherlands which already allows assisted dying for people who are mentally ill. There have been very few cases because the process is incredibly strictly managed, but the option is there. That's as it should be.

It is also incredibly patronising to assume that someone who is mentally ill cannot consent to assisted dying. Everyone who makes this point should read up on the Mental Capacity Act and the Mental Health Act - you'll find it isn't nearly as simple as you think.

Yes. Exactly. Fiction of course, but if you have read A little Life, why would you not let Jude have this option? Death is not always the most painful option. Life is unbearable for some people. Unrelentingly so. We should not have the right to keep inflicting life on them. And if you cannot imagine how terrible being alive can be, you/we are very privileged

Sudeko · 01/05/2023 10:26

There are not many people who enter and remain in a constantly suicidal state. There are far more who go on to recover and then look back on those dark times and feel grateful to have come through to the other side to a better place. It is placing too much responsibility upon the shoulders of people with impaired decision making to claim that they are capable of making the correct decision with no last minute remorse.

Infact, there was a very harrowing case of a young man in the UK who took that suicide drug (which cannot be legally named online ) which he would have ordered by post (possibly from Canada, I cannot recall). He ran towards his mother and was screaming that he wanted to live and wanted to choose life but he had already ingested a deadly quantity. It reflects sloppy MH care to entrust the vulnerable with the decision to choose a quick fix which runs counter to their true welfare needs, just to lower the burden on a failing system.

Noicant · 01/05/2023 10:26

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:22

“But the fact is that some people will never have happiness and recovery. Why is it acceptable that they should be made to live like that forever, or be driven to commit suicide in a way that has an awful impact on people around them, causing trauma to others?”

Because doctors don’t know which of the mentally ill fall into the never recover, never feel happiness category. The patients themselves don’t know, how could they?

Yes exactly my point.

OP posts:
pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:24

@SwitchDiver I actually don't respect your opinions, because you do not respect mine. You refuse to accept that mentally ill people are capable of consenting to an assisted suicide just because they are mentally ill. Your assumptions about mental illness and capacity are based on your own experiences and you are unable to accept that other people will have very different perceptions and experiences. What you post is just that - opinion and nothing more. You offer no answers to the hard question, which as always is: how long do we leave people with severe and enduring mental ill health to suffer before we accept their choice to not live?

You also do not offer any answers to the questions around the impact of suicide on others.

Flowerly · 01/05/2023 10:23

It's not 'terrifying' FGS. Why are we completely incapable of having a grown up discussion about this?

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:22

“But the fact is that some people will never have happiness and recovery. Why is it acceptable that they should be made to live like that forever, or be driven to commit suicide in a way that has an awful impact on people around them, causing trauma to others?”

Because doctors don’t know which of the mentally ill fall into the never recover, never feel happiness category. The patients themselves don’t know, how could they?

RedHelenB · 01/05/2023 10:21

SleepyRich · 01/05/2023 08:51

Isn't it the expansion of an existing bill to include mental illness as opposed to targeting people with mental illness? I suspect this would be severely life limiting mental illness that the person no longer wanted to live with. It's specifically not for use in cases of depression/suicidal ideation. So a suicidal person would never be offered this under the law,

I'd want it if I developed dementia

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:20

hattie43 · 01/05/2023 10:18

It's Canada . Unless you are in Canada it's a non issue .

Except there is a lot of activism to try and legalise it here in the U.K.

NeedToChangeName · 01/05/2023 10:20

It's terrifying, and I am sure that assisted suicide in uk would start off with robust safeguards, but these would reduce over time

As a parallel, legislation around termination of pregnancy has very high tests which would rarely apply. In practice, these tests are not applied rigorously and most people would regard it the woman's right to choose. (This may be a welcome development, but my point is that the law is no longer applied in the way it was intended)

ShimmeringShirts · 01/05/2023 10:20

I have lived with massive mental health issues for the majority of my life. I’ve been through different medications, different types of counselling, different treatments and supports. None of it has made much of a different, I find this world an entirely worthless and horrible place to live and I don’t want to continue living. Some days not even my children are enough to keep me here, between OCD and ADHD my life feels like a never ending car crash.

I have a plan to end it all if it ever gets too much though. It involves the high speed trains that pass through my local train station and I know all of the times and routes of them. Having that plan gives me strength. When it gets really bad I ask myself if this is it, if I genuinely can’t take it any more, if I genuinely cannot cope with this life any more and if it is then I can go without any guilt because I have fought long and hard against this. Every time the answer has been not yet, I’m not at that point yet, I’m not quite ready to stop fighting yet. And each time knowing I had that choice means I get better for a little while, life isn’t as awful for a bit.

I’d rather have that choice legally, I’d rather be able to go through euthanasia than involve a train driver who has no choice in it themselves. I’d rather have a choice that I could turn down, and have the peace of knowing it wouldn’t be as traumatic for my family scraping my body off the train tracks and it’s people like those on this thread that don’t understand that. I would end my life one way or another, not having euthanasia as an option isn’t going to stop it. Having it as an option means if the time ever comes my family won’t have to live with how violent the end of my life was.

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:19

Our brains aren’t even fully mature by 25. I’m sure there are many people on mumsnet who have children who could be classed as very ill in their teens but by their 30’s are ok.

And many people end up never being OK. Maybe you should read Tara's testimony - she was 30 when she had euthanasia in the Netherlands, after living with the impacts of anorexia for 20 years.

There isn't a simple cut off. As a pp who is a MH nurse said, it has to be assessed rigorously and on a case by case basis. But the fact is that some people will never have happiness and recovery. Why is it acceptable that they should be made to live like that forever, or be driven to commit suicide in a way that has an awful impact on people around them, causing trauma to others?

A blanket 'no, never' approach serves no-one.

hattie43 · 01/05/2023 10:18

It's Canada . Unless you are in Canada it's a non issue .

Swipe left for the next trending thread