Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Canada’s euthanasia for the mentally ill

342 replies

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Expansion of assisted dying for mental illness to be delayed until 2024 in new bill - National | Globalnews.ca

Justice Minister David Lametti has said the delay is needed after the federal government heard concerns that Canada's health-care system might not be prepared for the expansion.

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Noicant · 01/05/2023 11:05

DisquietintheRanks · 01/05/2023 10:11

@Noicant there's no need for the state to provide euthanasia to "anyone for any reason" as most people have recourse to suicide. Euthanasia is (or is intended to be) a safeguard to those who, for whatever reason, are physically unable to act independently.

Just so I don’t misrepresent your position you believe that suicide is fine but you can do it yourself? (Just to be clear I don’t think of suicide as a moral issue)

Would you try to stop someone who expressed intent to kill themselves?

OP posts:
MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 11:04

StressedToTheMaxxx · 01/05/2023 10:58

And check your arrogance - you don't talk for everyone, ceteinly not everyone with treatment resistant mental illness.

Yes , you do seem like a person who has spent years working on inpatient units- the total lack of respect for my concerns about how terrifying this is for a person with schizophrenia to read shows you must fit in really well on the wards. But yeah, reading about how people who I have to "work" with think I should be subjected to their decisions about whether my life is worth living is "arrogant". Thanks for that.

JudgeRudy · 01/05/2023 11:01

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:34

https://globalnews.ca/news/9454089/medically-assisted-dying-bill-mental-disorder/

Canada is in the process of introducing the option of Euthanasia for the mentally ill. It looks like this has been delayed for the time being but AIBU to find this concerning?

Just to be clear I fully support euthanasia as an option for people with terminal or chronic conditions. I think it’s human to offer people a peaceful death when there is no chance of things improving.

BUT this seems utterly mad to me. I’ve suffered from poor mental health in the past and only started feeling better after going through a few therapists and finding the right one. There were many times over 20years where I would have happily signed up for death. If someone is so ill that they are very impaired by their condition are they truly competent to make a decision like this and if it’s milder isn’t there a possibility of recovery?

It seems utterly dystopian. I guess I’m looking for someone to help me understand if I’ve missed something or not understood something that will help me understand why anyone would think this is a good idea.

Well I wouldn't imagine for 1 moment you are able to make these sort of decisions whilst lacking mental capacity. Surely there's some sort of advanced directive.
I've mixed views about voluntary euthanasia however I don't think physical and mental health should be considered differently. I know people with long term mental ill health and their lives are often full of torment and agony against a background of misery. Many fall into addiction so they can have a 'head holiday'.

Comedycook · 01/05/2023 11:00

It's terrifying.

Do you trust the government? Or politicians in general? I don't.

Imagine a future where upon your diagnosis, you're offered a range of treatments and euthanasia as an option.

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:59

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:52

Oh, so you are describing a highly subjective and individual form of assessment then. Strange you think that is superior to actually using the data in an objective manner.

You're still putting words in my mouth!

Using algorithms is bad because computer says no.
Having a panel of qualified people use those guidelines alongside face to face assessment of the patient is bad because it is subjective.

Nothing will ever be good enough for you because your position is 'no, never'.

That's fine and you are entitled to that opinion, but how do you think medical decision making works in the real world? We have the NICE guidelines, which underpin everything. Within those guidelines, medical professionals make decisions. Because they are human beings, those decisions will always contain some kind of subjectivity. That's how the world is!

Your thinking it so completely zero sum it isn't even funny. Medical decision making will never be 100% perfect, just as there is no such thing as a medication that is 100% safe. In your world this means that no decisions should ever be taken, and no medication prescribed, if we take it to the extreme.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 01/05/2023 10:58

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 10:56

I have schizophrenia and have been sectioned many times. While in hospital I have sadly come across a lot of mh staff who clearly think people with psychosis are some kind of different species. We're not, we are people who are unwell. As for people never recovering - have those people received the correct support? Or are they stuck in a system where they are seen as too hard to treat+ too much effort to work with.

Again, I have schizophrenia. If you work in mental health, and think euthanasia is an acceptable response to psychosis, for the love of God, get another job. I don't want you anywhere near me.

And check your arrogance - you don't talk for everyone, ceteinly not everyone with treatment resistant mental illness.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 01/05/2023 10:57

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 10:46

Please get a different job @StressedToTheMaxxx . I don't want to be forced to work with mh staff who would be happy to see me euthanised.

I don't need to get a different job, I'm actually very good at it going by feedback from staff and patients alike. I'm not sure if you have problems with reading but that's not what my post said at all. Clearly you're letting your own personal experiences cloud your little outburst there.

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 10:56

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 01/05/2023 10:49

Please get a different job @StressedToTheMaxxx . I don't want to be forced to work with mh staff who would be happy to see me euthanised.

@StressedToTheMaxxx never said they'd be happy to see you euthanised. They can understand why some people would choose it, I can understand why some with mental illness would also.

I have schizophrenia and have been sectioned many times. While in hospital I have sadly come across a lot of mh staff who clearly think people with psychosis are some kind of different species. We're not, we are people who are unwell. As for people never recovering - have those people received the correct support? Or are they stuck in a system where they are seen as too hard to treat+ too much effort to work with.

Again, I have schizophrenia. If you work in mental health, and think euthanasia is an acceptable response to psychosis, for the love of God, get another job. I don't want you anywhere near me.

SpringCalling · 01/05/2023 10:55

I can highly recommend this podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/first-person/id1624946521?i=1000610839932
It's a Psychiatrist in the Netherlands wrestling with exactly this question. He starts out as an advocate as his mum was euthanised (although with a physical not mental illness) so in theory he is in favour. But he does research on it, still probably thinks there is a place for it but tellingly has not yet signed off anyone ...

It is worth a listen

First Person: They’re Severely Mentally Ill. Is It Ethical to Help Them Die? on Apple Podcasts

‎First Person: They’re Severely Mentally Ill. Is It Ethical to Help Them Die? on Apple Podcasts

‎Show First Person, Ep They’re Severely Mentally Ill. Is It Ethical to Help Them Die? - 27 Apr 2023

https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/first-person/id1624946521?i=1000610839932

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:54

Especially, given this governments attitude towards the disabled and mental health. I have zero confidence that offering a final solution would encourage better mental healthcare services. I can envision too that disability benefits for mental would have a time limit based on ‘data’ and ‘studies’ that say anyone not well enough to work after x years should sign up for euthanasia.

This I agree with fully. We should not implement anything until we have not just a change of government but a full change of governance.

hereiamagainn · 01/05/2023 10:53

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:50

I’m not sure that would happen. I am afraid that there would be a if you can’t handle life, then just end it attitude. A we tossed some anti-depressants in your direction and gave you six weeks of online CBT, if you’re not better then just go already no useless no-hoper attitude. People would be afraid to seek help for complex or stubborn mental health conditions because the expectation would be if it’s not an easy and quick recovery, then you get binned as a human being.

Especially, given this governments attitude towards the disabled and mental health. I have zero confidence that offering a final solution would encourage better mental healthcare services. I can envision too that disability benefits for mental would have a time limit based on ‘data’ and ‘studies’ that say anyone not well enough to work after x years should sign up for euthanasia.

I see what you mean, a terrifying vision indeed.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:52

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:47

So what you are describing is a mathematical algorithm that assesses a patients likelihood of recovery or death based on past patients.

Don't put words in my mouth. What I am describing is a set of evidence based guidelines, like those which are used in physical health. The assessment should always be made by real human beings, in collaboration with the patient and their family, over time. What you've just done is the worst kind of dishonest argument.

Oh, so you are describing a highly subjective and individual form of assessment then. Strange you think that is superior to actually using the data in an objective manner.

Pheasantplucker2 · 01/05/2023 10:50

I am really conflicted by this.

SENS AND TRIGGERING

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

My 15 year old DD is suffering with psychosis and suicide ideation, and keeps trying to kill herself. She frequently begs me to let her die. It is heartbreaking and horrific. I cannot tell you the agony in her face and that's reflected in my heart.

I do not want her to die. I want her to get better and live a life free of the demons that torment her. But she has already read about this and is talking about going to Canada for this express reason if and when she would qualify.

I cannot tell you the constant terror we live with, that today will be the day she succeeds. But I also know how unbearable the torment is for her. She constantly hears voices telling her how worthless she is and to kill herself.

We have been through many meds and weekly psych sessions. None of them work. She is being given every help that's available.

I hope for her that her MH improves once she's through puberty and an adult. But her dad's sister has been living with complex MH all her life and she has never been able to lead a successful and independent life. I see what has happened for her aunt and I dread her future.

I can't imagine life without my gorgeous girl. But what would be worse, finding her after suicide or allowing her a planned and dignified death? And who possibly feels qualified to make that decision?

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:50

hereiamagainn · 01/05/2023 10:43

Quite honestly, I feel that anyone should have the freedom to opt out of this life safely and legally. It would be awful, there would no doubt be thousands of deaths, but it would force us to take a good long look at our society and make changes that would make life more tolerable and, dare I say it, enjoyable. We are not developing in a way that is conducive to good mental health and legalising suicide would force change for the better, long term, imo.

I’m not sure that would happen. I am afraid that there would be a if you can’t handle life, then just end it attitude. A we tossed some anti-depressants in your direction and gave you six weeks of online CBT, if you’re not better then just go already no useless no-hoper attitude. People would be afraid to seek help for complex or stubborn mental health conditions because the expectation would be if it’s not an easy and quick recovery, then you get binned as a human being.

Especially, given this governments attitude towards the disabled and mental health. I have zero confidence that offering a final solution would encourage better mental healthcare services. I can envision too that disability benefits for mental would have a time limit based on ‘data’ and ‘studies’ that say anyone not well enough to work after x years should sign up for euthanasia.

NurseCranesRolodex · 01/05/2023 10:50

Noicant · 01/05/2023 08:59

Yes it is an extension and I don’t expect that people will be offered it very easily.

It just seems a bit hopeless to me. I find myself conflicted here, your life should be your own to do what you wish with but I worry about reconciling someone being so severely unwell but also trusted to make this decision.

I assume you would have to have some suicidal ideation to want to actually apply in the first place?

Someone with a wish to die DUE TO a mental health illness should be offered high quality health care. Their judgement is compromised. This is very 3rd Riech. Fascists can use this to clear prisons, get rid of waiting lists and prune benefits claimant numbers. How bloody depressing. So what's the next step, MH patients can't procreate? When is the western world going to wake up. Tranada is a shit show.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 01/05/2023 10:49

Please get a different job @StressedToTheMaxxx . I don't want to be forced to work with mh staff who would be happy to see me euthanised.

@StressedToTheMaxxx never said they'd be happy to see you euthanised. They can understand why some people would choose it, I can understand why some with mental illness would also.

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:47

So what you are describing is a mathematical algorithm that assesses a patients likelihood of recovery or death based on past patients.

Don't put words in my mouth. What I am describing is a set of evidence based guidelines, like those which are used in physical health. The assessment should always be made by real human beings, in collaboration with the patient and their family, over time. What you've just done is the worst kind of dishonest argument.

Mooshamoo · 01/05/2023 10:46

I agree with it. If a person is in terrible mental suffering, I think that they should be allowed to do it.

Comedycook · 01/05/2023 10:46

OhmygodDont · 01/05/2023 10:42

Everyone who wants to use use a service should be allowed to. It’s their bodies their lives, it’s a non traumatic death.

It’s all good and well saying people have bodily autonomy but then go oh yeah but actually no not you, you don’t fit the list sorry bye.

For them to then possibly kill themselves in a horrid way that’s also traumatic for others isn’t the right answer either it.

People are made to stay alive when they don’t want to or kill the selfs in some terrible ways that’s not humane.

Whilst I can see the argument for this from a theoretical perspective...the reality would be very frightening. Coercion would be a real concern and if you wanted to catastrophise what if we ended up in a place were people with certain conditions were immediately assumed to do this.

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 01/05/2023 10:46

StressedToTheMaxxx · 01/05/2023 10:13

There are some mental illnesses that are treatment resistant. Sadly, some folk with severe mental illness have no quality of life, none whatsoever.

As a mental health nurse, I've worked with some patients who have been under the services for years, in and out of hospital. Even at their best, they barely function. I'm talking mainly about the likes of chronic schizophrenia. Of course many people with this condition live very meaningful lives, with the correct treatment regime and support. But yes, there are those who don't have a quality of life (and not just in my opinion, in their own opinions).

It's something that would have to be assessed very very carefully and on a case by case basis. I can understand the controversy. But I can also understand why some people who live daily with such a torturous illness wouldn't want to go on.

It's certainly a very thought provoking argument.

Please get a different job @StressedToTheMaxxx . I don't want to be forced to work with mh staff who would be happy to see me euthanised.

pointythings · 01/05/2023 10:45

@MrsEdnaWelthorpe I wouldn't support you being euthanised! You have said yourself that you have had periods when you are well. That in itself is enough to rule you out.

But there are people who never have periods when they are well. The option should be there for them, under extremely tough regulation.

@SwitchDiver I do not accept that you respect my opinions. I just don't, simply because your position is set in stone and it is that a person with mental ill health never has capacity to make the choice to end their life. I vehemently disagree with that opinion. You are of course free to hold it, but that freedom has consequences - those consequences will include suicide and its traumatic impact on others.

I have been fortunate enough not to have experienced mental ill health myself, but as I have described above, I have experienced the impact it has had on members of my family, one of whom took his own life in a violent and traumatic manner. Dismissing my experiences, such as they are, is disrespectful.

I put equal stock in your testimonials and in those that disagree with you. I don't want people euthanised willy-nilly, but I do want people to have agency.

You and I will not agree.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 01/05/2023 10:44

maddening · 01/05/2023 09:23

It was a disabled athlete asking for a wheelchair lift
https://nypost.com/2022/12/03/canada-offered-to-help-euthanize-christine-gauthier/

wtf did I just read!

hereiamagainn · 01/05/2023 10:43

Quite honestly, I feel that anyone should have the freedom to opt out of this life safely and legally. It would be awful, there would no doubt be thousands of deaths, but it would force us to take a good long look at our society and make changes that would make life more tolerable and, dare I say it, enjoyable. We are not developing in a way that is conducive to good mental health and legalising suicide would force change for the better, long term, imo.

SwitchDiver · 01/05/2023 10:43

“I would want it to be arrived at by people who have expert knowledge in the field of mental health. These would have to include people who have all the data on recovery rates for people with severe and enduring mental illness - that data is out there, I've spent enough time working in MH research to know that. It would not be a quick or overnight decision. It would also not be a black and white rule book, you'd have to look at the full range of mental illnesses and the prognosis where there are comorbidities.”

So what you are describing is a mathematical algorithm that assesses a patients likelihood of recovery or death based on past patients. When we leave it up to mathematical models you know what happens? We do an algorithm and a computer says yes or no. You know what would happen over time if euthanasia were then encouraged and this data were updated?

OhmygodDont · 01/05/2023 10:42

Everyone who wants to use use a service should be allowed to. It’s their bodies their lives, it’s a non traumatic death.

It’s all good and well saying people have bodily autonomy but then go oh yeah but actually no not you, you don’t fit the list sorry bye.

For them to then possibly kill themselves in a horrid way that’s also traumatic for others isn’t the right answer either it.

People are made to stay alive when they don’t want to or kill the selfs in some terrible ways that’s not humane.

Swipe left for the next trending thread