Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect some fanfare from DH for end of breastfeeding journey?

237 replies

Calmondeck · 30/04/2023 22:07

Just that really… I always intended to breastfeed (but had no concept of how all-consuming it is in the first 6 months and didn’t really know how/when to stop) and DH was quite anti-formula. When DC was 18 months I declared myself ready to stop but he was diagnosed with cancer and DH thought breastfeeding could be a tool to help with the many many hospitalisations. Now at 23 months, DC has decided he’s done. Which feels wonderful it’s come to its natural conclusion. DH has not reacted in any way. I don’t know what I expected, AIBU to expect anything? Secretly I wish he would take this moment to reflect on how much I have given… (not just milk)…

OP posts:
Smallyellowbird · 01/05/2023 15:27

I think you've done a fantastic thing - especially continuing when you wanted to stop but your husband wanted you to

I felt emotional when I stopped breastfeeding when I finally got to parent with my bra on as a pp said. I was relieved as i'd been hoping for self weaning but didn't happen, but it had been such a big part of my life that it was a bit sad too.

I think you should talk to your husband, about how this is an emotional time for you, and how you're really proud of yourself for breastfeeding for so long, and that you'd like him to acknowledge this.

Saniflo · 01/05/2023 15:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

allmyliesaretrue · 01/05/2023 13:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yet another mean-spirited response. I don't know where you people crawl out of. Mentioning breastfeeding is like a red rag to a bull!!! So much jealousy around it. Why can't people just own their choice? Breastfeeding is a huge commitment which is clearly one of the reason some mums choose not to do it. You are your baby's sole source of sustenance, 24/7.

If you didn't or couldn't, that's fine. It doesn't take away from the fact the extended b'fing in particular in this country, is an achievement.

So @Tessabelle74, because you feel that someone marking the end of breastfeeding makes women like you feel shit, you have decided to make the OP, with her little boy ill with cancer, and currently heavily pregnant, feel shit instead. Oh my. The sisterhood!!!

The OP only wants her husband to acknowledge it, you know, the guy who was so keen on breastfeeding in the first place?? She doesn't give a flying one about the likes of you and your nasty remarks.

@Calmondeck - your update shows that you absolutely deserve recognition - I'm not sure I could have breastfed during early pregnancy, as well as everything else you had going on. Congratulations on your pregnancy, hope all goes well. I hope your little boy will soon be cancer-free too. x

For all of you who feel the need to carp about breastfeeding, take your nastiness elsewhere! As for those of you who have posted shitty responses, you should hang your heads in shame (and get them deleted!)

JulianCasa · 01/05/2023 13:07

Oh, and birth! Forgot that little thing we have to get over to bring our children into the world 😂

JulianCasa · 01/05/2023 13:06

Calmondeck · 01/05/2023 09:38

Thank you, yes I’ll mention it. @Comedycook I hear what you’re saying, recognition it always nice, but I really do think the physical/hormonal/logistical elements of breastfeeding are huge. That alone deserves a clap.

Any woman who breastfeeds or tries to, even just once is amazing. It’s a big thing to give part of yourself to another human, especially after the marathon that is pregnancy.

You deserve celebrating xxx ❤️

JenniferBarkley · 01/05/2023 13:05

Judgyjudgy · 01/05/2023 12:37

I agree OP. Incredible, it would have been so comforting for your child and I hope it will hold special memories for me too. I was slightly happy when my DC stopped breastfeeding, as it meant my DH could now do bedtime. But everyone and then I do miss it, it's such a special experience. I can't believe I'm thinking it, but I almost wish it had lasted longer! (But also no!). Fabulous OP, we will celebrate with you! A milestone 🙌

Another one here with many a flying fuck to give.

When feeding my eldest I was in a breastfeeding FB group. Mostly I muted it, but there was a woman who had been about to wean when her toddler was diagnosed with an aggressive cancer with a poor survival rate.

Every time I found it gruelling being the only one to be able to comfort my daughter in that way, I thought of her. Every time I was grateful to get nutrients in mid tummy bug, I thought of her. Every time I felt exhausted from the night wakenings and slightly resentful that DH couldn't do half the overnight,I thought of her.

I think both she and OP are incredible.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 01/05/2023 12:44

I'm sure some will be annoyed with my post, but I don't think everyone should be angry at the husband. My husband spent hours doing research, came to all my scans, appointments and classes. He really wanted me to breastfeed and to have a natural birth, he had done the research and knew it had the best outcomes for our baby and for me. I would assume OPs DH is the same and there's nothing wrong with that. There is a difference between encouraging and forcing. You can share information and knowledge with someone while still respecting them and their choices, and supporting them in whatever they decide

Judgyjudgy · 01/05/2023 12:37

McGoadyFromFuckingGoadyville · 01/05/2023 12:03

It's true though. Not one other single person in the world gives a flying fudge about how I used my tits when my babies were young. It's just fact. Breastfeeding is great, many can't do it though and those expecting ticker tape parades for doing it make THOSE women feel like shit. So breastfeed if you want, but it's seriously not something anyone else cares to mark as an occasion (unlike weddings etc, stupid comparisons let's be honest 🙄)

I give a flying fuck. I think breastfeeding a child while they're sick with cancer is fucking incredible.

I agree OP. Incredible, it would have been so comforting for your child and I hope it will hold special memories for me too. I was slightly happy when my DC stopped breastfeeding, as it meant my DH could now do bedtime. But everyone and then I do miss it, it's such a special experience. I can't believe I'm thinking it, but I almost wish it had lasted longer! (But also no!). Fabulous OP, we will celebrate with you! A milestone 🙌

Cooknook · 01/05/2023 12:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I mean it's sad if your spouse and the father of the child you've fed can't even say anything supportive to acknowledge it, especially as he seemed very keen on it. Of course strangers on the whole aren't bothered, but what a sad state of affairs we are in if people can't talk about breastfeeding for fear of upsetting others. I agree with a PP, extended breastfeeding your child with cancer is bloody brilliant, and that's not a sleight to anyone who didn't BF.

McGoadyFromFuckingGoadyville · 01/05/2023 12:03

It's true though. Not one other single person in the world gives a flying fudge about how I used my tits when my babies were young. It's just fact. Breastfeeding is great, many can't do it though and those expecting ticker tape parades for doing it make THOSE women feel like shit. So breastfeed if you want, but it's seriously not something anyone else cares to mark as an occasion (unlike weddings etc, stupid comparisons let's be honest 🙄)

I give a flying fuck. I think breastfeeding a child while they're sick with cancer is fucking incredible.

Tandora · 01/05/2023 10:56

Calmondeck · 01/05/2023 09:22

Thanks for all of the feedback.

I do understand where negative commentators are coming from with lines like “this is what breasts are for” etc. I think that’s why I’ve persisted, a part of me has seen this as what I’ve signed up to becoming a mum. Even if, where I’m living, I’m the last mum by a long long way still feeding, so at times it’s been a little isolating.

For financial reasons I had to return to work full time when my DC was 9 months old (or post-cancer diagnosis, as full time as possible around the hospital stays and operations) and I do feel like it’s an achievement to juggle the commitments of paid employment with nourishing your child.

Perhaps I’ve demonised DH on here by saying he’s anti-formula - he’s definitely a fed is best man, but in our pre-natal classes there was a lot of emphasis on the partner encouraging breastfeeding, and listing the million and one benefits, that I think it made him very pro-breast if it was possible for us.

When our little guy was diagnosed with cancer, we also discovered I am pregnant with DC2. I’m proud I did breastfeed DC1 through the most intense days of chemotherapy and other treatment - it was a mission because it went from minimal feeds to suddenly up every 2 hours at night in hospital, frightened, with him wanting this comfort, as he was connected to a million wires and tubes. I think with a second pregnancy on top of this, and breast sensitivity in the first trimester, it did feel like a big push to continue to provide. Of course DH wasn’t breathing down my neck about it, but with a very upset 1yr old it was clear DH hoped I’d continue to provide that comfort when nothing else seemed to work.

Thanks to those saying “tell to DH, he’s not a mind reader”. I’ll admit, I hadn’t really had the time to think about the end of breastfeeding as being a big thing either. But now that I’m a week into a child-led wean, it’s suddenly struck me that ‘wow, breastfeeding for 2 years was a huge undertaking. Natural and normal, but also hugely time consuming, at times uncomfortable, and a lot of logistics. Ending does feel like a milestone”. You’re right, I’m not expecting trumpets, banners or an event in my honour, but some kind of acknowledgment along the lines of “you’ve given A LOT, I’m proud of you, enjoy this freedom before it’s starts again in 2 months with DC2” would have been nice.

Though perhaps it’s just one of those things that breastfeeding can look magical and easy from the outside, but impossible for anyone but the woman herself to understand the complex myriad of feelings about it.

Im not sure I’ll go so far as to immortalise my breastmilk, but I love the suggestion of a massage.

OP you and your DS have been through so much and my heart goes out to you ❤️❤️ I hope with all my heart that your DS gets better soon and you can put this all behind you .

hearthelp · 01/05/2023 10:54

I just read your update. I think you are truly amazing. And although my previous post was positive. I feel I need to say it louder.

You have done such a wonderful thing for your child at a time they really needed it.

Doesn't matter what anyone says. You have made a true sacrifice and you should be incredibly proud of yourself.

I BF for 2 years as my son was constantly ill. But by no means have I been through what you have been through. People don't really understand, how hard it is. Flowers

Tessabelle74 · 01/05/2023 10:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

User2538309 · 01/05/2023 10:19

You sound like a truly amazing mum.

I’ve done BF for comfort and pain relief (and sometimes the only form of nutrition) through prolonged and painful DC hospital stays and I have done surviving a subsequent pregnancy through prolonged hospital stays. No one who hasn’t done it could have a fucking clue what it’s like.

And I’ve not ever had to do both together. And yes, the physical, emotional, hormonal and sheer logistical elements are massively undervalued by most. Also the fact that it means you have to do every single hospital night. Once your husband has to do some of them he may realise how that alone is a massive undertaking,

I’m organising you a parade. Floats and a brass band. A red arrows fly past. I hear there’s a big sparkly hat not in use in until next weekend, you could totally borrow it! 👑

Calmondeck · 01/05/2023 09:51

@User41 🥳 thank you, you made me laugh a lot

OP posts:
User41 · 01/05/2023 09:42

OP last comment from me I just wanted to say that I think your response is kinder and far more measured than a number of these commenters deserve. I am so pleased though they haven’t managed to make you question or underplay your achievement. It wouldn’t have taken so much strength, grit and determination to persevere through the circumstances you have and to keep showing up for your child in the way that you did. I’m glad to hear at the very least you are having a massage. Although personally I’d see no issue if you did fancy some trumpets and banners on arrival for said massage 🎉. Why the fuck not x x

Calmondeck · 01/05/2023 09:38

Thank you, yes I’ll mention it. @Comedycook I hear what you’re saying, recognition it always nice, but I really do think the physical/hormonal/logistical elements of breastfeeding are huge. That alone deserves a clap.

OP posts:
Comedycook · 01/05/2023 09:29

I don't think it's actually about the breastfeeding per se....I think you just want some recognition for being a great mum during a very difficult time.

Wishing your son well xx

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 01/05/2023 09:28

How about mentioning it to him @Calmondeck like I said, I would expect him to say something. You have done amazing, absolutely amazing and that's coming from a mum who formula fed! Surely he's seen you power through. I think sometimes men take for granted just how much us mums give when our babies are small. That goes for both breast and formula feeders. I would mention it.

Calmondeck · 01/05/2023 09:22

Thanks for all of the feedback.

I do understand where negative commentators are coming from with lines like “this is what breasts are for” etc. I think that’s why I’ve persisted, a part of me has seen this as what I’ve signed up to becoming a mum. Even if, where I’m living, I’m the last mum by a long long way still feeding, so at times it’s been a little isolating.

For financial reasons I had to return to work full time when my DC was 9 months old (or post-cancer diagnosis, as full time as possible around the hospital stays and operations) and I do feel like it’s an achievement to juggle the commitments of paid employment with nourishing your child.

Perhaps I’ve demonised DH on here by saying he’s anti-formula - he’s definitely a fed is best man, but in our pre-natal classes there was a lot of emphasis on the partner encouraging breastfeeding, and listing the million and one benefits, that I think it made him very pro-breast if it was possible for us.

When our little guy was diagnosed with cancer, we also discovered I am pregnant with DC2. I’m proud I did breastfeed DC1 through the most intense days of chemotherapy and other treatment - it was a mission because it went from minimal feeds to suddenly up every 2 hours at night in hospital, frightened, with him wanting this comfort, as he was connected to a million wires and tubes. I think with a second pregnancy on top of this, and breast sensitivity in the first trimester, it did feel like a big push to continue to provide. Of course DH wasn’t breathing down my neck about it, but with a very upset 1yr old it was clear DH hoped I’d continue to provide that comfort when nothing else seemed to work.

Thanks to those saying “tell to DH, he’s not a mind reader”. I’ll admit, I hadn’t really had the time to think about the end of breastfeeding as being a big thing either. But now that I’m a week into a child-led wean, it’s suddenly struck me that ‘wow, breastfeeding for 2 years was a huge undertaking. Natural and normal, but also hugely time consuming, at times uncomfortable, and a lot of logistics. Ending does feel like a milestone”. You’re right, I’m not expecting trumpets, banners or an event in my honour, but some kind of acknowledgment along the lines of “you’ve given A LOT, I’m proud of you, enjoy this freedom before it’s starts again in 2 months with DC2” would have been nice.

Though perhaps it’s just one of those things that breastfeeding can look magical and easy from the outside, but impossible for anyone but the woman herself to understand the complex myriad of feelings about it.

Im not sure I’ll go so far as to immortalise my breastmilk, but I love the suggestion of a massage.

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 01/05/2023 09:19

Sorry to read about what you have gone through with your DC. I would not expect a fanfare, but at least some kind of acknowledgment of what you have done.

Barnbrack · 01/05/2023 09:14

Twiglets1 · 01/05/2023 06:42

I think what was unreasonable was you carrying on with the BF past the point you actually wanted to. I'm sure it is perfectly possible to feed bottled milk to babies in hospital, just a bit more planning than BF. I am detecting a slight resentment towards your husband as his request for you to continue BF sounded logical and reasonable in the circumstances so you couldn't argue with it, but actually you could because it puts a lot of pressure on a woman and you were at the point you wanted to stop and get your body back.

As someone who kept breastfeeding a child for longer due to medical reasons there are stark differences. When my son had seizures he would neither eat nor drink other than breastfeeding for comfort. Breastfeeding saved him countless hours on fluid IV. When your child's immune system is compromised the passive immunity is hugely beneficial so I imagine a child undergoing cancer treatment would benefit there. A child with lots of medical appointments and the upheaval that comes with that benefits massively emotionally from anything that brings comfort and certainly for my son who was hospitalised roughly once a month for 2 years it was hugely valuable.

Yes you could feed formula or cows milk but the situation is different especially for a child who has been breastfed all along.

Also you're pontificating to a woman whose child has cancer about something that has let her feel she's helping in a situation where as parents we feel so helpless. If you can't fathom the motional toll of all that you should probably work on yourself.

User41 · 01/05/2023 09:08

OP you should absolutely get all the fanfare you want. I breastfed for 3 months and had to stop because I found it so mentally taxing to be the sole source of food for all hours, all of the time. Like many women I had trouble expressing and my daughter wouldn’t take from a bottle for AGES so it was really difficult to allow myself any time alone. It was also very painful at various points.

So to breastfeed for as long as you did and past the point you wanted to in such stressful circumstances was an incredible thing to do. Being a mum to a toddler going through a cancer diagnosis is incredible in itself regardless of how you choose to feed. It deserves ALL the fucking fanfare. Ignore the commenters on this post making derisive sneery comments. Imagine having to wake up every day going through life being that mean spirited and unkind.

Ive noticed mumsnet has a LOT of internalised misogyny and there’s a great number of posters who seem to hate any suggestion that mothers should be celebrated or even supported by wider society. If you were working on a stressful, demanding project in work for 2 years that came to successful fruition, it would be completely normal for it to be acknowledged and even celebrated. In my workplace, we normally acknowledge the completion of big projects with a shout out a team meeting, sometimes the award of a token small voucher or the project team going out for drinks/lunch. Other people might receive a bonus or even a promotion.

There’s absolutely no reason why the work women do in the domestic sphere shouldn’t also be acknowledged and celebrated. But the culture on mumsnet seems to be that we should all just quietly trudge through motherhood without ever seeking to draw any attention to ourselves. Otherwise we’re ‘entitled’ or ‘spoilt’. Maybe it’s just this generation of women are increasingly starting to learn their worth.

I would suggest you spell out to your partner that you want to be acknowledged and ask for what you want. You’ve fucking earned it. A genuine heartfelt Well done from me and I sincerely wish the best for the recovery of your child x x x

Sux2buthen · 01/05/2023 08:58

Next time there's a post where someone asks if Mumsnet is getting nasty and everyone shouts her down with 'oh this again' they need to be directed to this thread.
I've seen some shit on here (a LOT) but the stream of nasty sneering piss taking comments from...I'll say women because the real word might get this post deleted....to a mum of a child with cancer is the worst I've seen.
And as for the turning it into formula conversation, bore off, OP is talking about breastfeeding.
Which, incidentally, is harder and a massive commitment whether people like it or not.
Well done OP, I wish you and your family well, I hope everything improves for you all.

VixenAndKits · 01/05/2023 08:51

I think by OPs "fanfare" they just mean some appreciation. Which they deserve after BFing for so long. Just a "thank you", a cuddle. Anything. Though I'm also assuming the cancer (I'm so terribly sorry, I hope your child gets well very soon) has stressed both parties out.

Though this is just a PERSONAL red flag for me, but the idea of my partner making me feel I had no choice but to BF past what I wanted? ...No thanks. I'm glad my fiance was very supportive of my feeding choices since it was, yknow, my body? Heard this a few times now "my partner was anti-formula so I had to BF longer than I thought" Ick...
Can't be helped now I guess.