Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think depression isn’t an excuse for selfishness

39 replies

Satansgourd · 30/04/2023 13:09

This has only just occurred to me. I was having a chat with a friend of mine, who I am sure is depressed. She does not have the best home environment, and I know it gets her down. But, having spoken to her yesterday for the first time in a while, I realize that she has not asked me anything about myself in months. We chat daily, mainly at my instigation, and it’s always to ask how she is. I wondered yesterday if she actually is severely depressed and this is making her self focused. Am I wrong? AIBU

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IloveJudgeJudy · 30/04/2023 18:34

When DD was stuck in deep depression a former colleague told me that depression is a selfish illness. She said when she was suffering, even though she had DC, the first thought upon waking was, ‘how am I today?’

imnotsadyouresad · 30/04/2023 18:27

@Satansgourd I'm struggling a lot at the moment, and I'm grateful for the friends who have stuck by me. If any felt like they had to withdraw for the sake of their own mental health, I would understand. I mean, I know what it's like to be dealing with something all-consuming, and if you didn't have enough mental energy left for me, I'd get it. But I'd hope we could pick up again in the future when at least one of us was more resilient.

I truly believe good friendships don't have to be constant, and a pause is always acceptable. With good friendships, you always pick up where you left off.

I don't think you would be wrong to insist on your friend seeking help in order for you to feel comfortable in the friendship. Your friend can't make herself better, but she can show a willingness to try. You have the right to ask her to try to help ease your concern.

JudgeRinderonTinder · 30/04/2023 16:57

No, people shouldn’t be selfish and it’s not really an excuse to treat people badly, but at the same time, depressed people are frequently selfish in some ways, although not purposefully, because the illness is all gripping/consuming. Only a person with very little knowledge would think otherwise.

Satansgourd · 30/04/2023 16:43

Thanks for all the comments on both sides. I think I am particularly frustrated because her home situation (causing the depression) could be changed but there have been no proactive steps at all for 10 years. Maybe this is what I struggle with, and I would agree that that is selfish on my behalf. But friendship is give and take. I won’t say she has taken, but I sure have given.

I had therapy a few years ago about many things, and I started to wonder at the time if she was a bit of a toxic factor in my life. But I stopped therapy and life moved on and I became less mindful about the friendship. Maybe I am just questioning it altogether again.

OP posts:
Redebs · 30/04/2023 16:09

Sorry you don't understand depression OP.

You could look it up maybe?

Why do you want her to ask about you? Is it because you don't think it's fair to talk about her only?

LindorDoubleChoc · 30/04/2023 16:05

Depression is a very selfish and isolating illness. Not many people have the mental fortitude to cope with a severely depressed friend/relative/partner long-term.

Trinity65 · 30/04/2023 15:45

GOW56 · 30/04/2023 13:25

When someone is seriously clinically depressed they can hardly function themselves. They aren't going to ask about you or anyone else because just getting through the day is difficult.
Yes they are selfish but not consciously so. It's a facet if the illness.

This

Sirzy · 30/04/2023 15:31

My first thought is is chatting daily too much for her? Even when done with best of intentions it may end up feeling a bit like a chore for her

Daffodilmorning · 30/04/2023 15:31

I don’t think it’s that simple. Yes, depression can sometimes cause people to act in a selfish way, but if it’s a symptom of their illness, they can’t be held fully accountable for it.

Of course some people are selfish regardless of their mental health, and it can be difficult to separate the person from their mental illness.

Was she selfish before she became depressed?

ToWhitToWhoo · 30/04/2023 15:30

I think YABU on the particular issue, yes. I don't think that depression is an excuse for spitefulness, bullying or scamming. But a lack of reciprocity in conversation is a *social' fault, rather than a crime; and I think that depression, or indeed any serious illness, can excuse it.

One could similarly ask, 'Is cancer an excuse for selfishness?' I don't think it's an excuse for cheating or bullying, but if someone is so preoccupied with their illness that they don't ask after other sufficiently, I would cut them a lot of slack. And most forms of cancer don't directly affect mental and social functioning in the way that depression can.

AlizeeEasy · 30/04/2023 15:28

I get this. My best friend has no idea that I just got a promotion at work. I have no idea how to even tell her without being insensitive to how rubbish things are right now, but I feel like if I don’t tell her she will be upset that I didn’t. Can’t really win, but I know she is going through an awful time, so I try my best to be sensitive and allow her to focus on herself when we speak

XenoBitch · 30/04/2023 15:26

She might not be depressed at all... and just has some heavy things going on that is making her more self-focused.
Being "selfish" does not mean she is depressed, so I think YABU for thinking it does.

FourTeaFallOut · 30/04/2023 15:25

I'd feel utterly claustrophobic if I had a friend who wanted to talk to me most days. And I don't have depression. Is this something that she wants or has asked for? If it isn't, then this could be why she isn't asking how you are and is trying to shorten the social contact?

TwilightSkies · 30/04/2023 15:22

Friendships should be reciprocal the majority of the time. Otherwise the person is using you.

MyFaceIsAnAONB · 30/04/2023 15:22

(And yes I am sertraline myself)

MayThe4th · 30/04/2023 15:21

It’s a reason but tbh mental health is constantly being a used as a justification for all manner of behaviours. It’s become a get-out for people to behave as they like and we must never blame them because “they’re mentally ill.”

I think you can understand that people are selfish because of their mh but I don’t think anyone should just be expected to put up with it, so if people who have depression/anxiety lose friends because of their behaviours they can’t be resentful of that fact.

Most people with depression are actively seeking help not to be. It’s the people who aren’t actively trying to get help who seem to be the most selfish and expect the most leeway.

MyFaceIsAnAONB · 30/04/2023 15:21

YANBU. Whenever my FIL acts appallingly his excuse is always ‘but I’m depressed, I’m depressed! I’m on ANTI-DEPRESSANTS!!’….. yeah you and half the country mate.

Stop instigating OP!

Vallmo47 · 30/04/2023 15:19

You’re not unreasonable to get tired of being the one constantly offering support- friendship is a two way street. It is exhausting dealing with people who are unwell, be it physically or psychologically. I say that as someone who has been on both sides of the coin. I agree with posters who suggest taking a small step back and reducing the amount of times you check in. Like someone said, it could work in favour of both of you. When you’re in a really bad way, it truly can be impossible to reach out. Equally you deserve support and need it sometimes also. It doesn’t make you a bad person that you are sometimes at the end of your tether with it all, it makes you human. You sound like a caring friend to me. ♥️

Satansgourd · 30/04/2023 15:13

@imnotsadyouresad very insightful, thank you.

OP posts:
I8toys · 30/04/2023 14:59

I don't think its intentional. She probably has no idea she's doing it. When I get "in my head" my thoughts aren't rational. Its hard to describe but also having ocd I have a one track thought pattern that is difficult to break and it becomes very self centered.

imnotsadyouresad · 30/04/2023 14:54

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/04/2023 13:22

It isn’t an excuse, it’s a reason.

This.

I'm struggling to deal with something so big that I don't have the mental capacity to see outside myself at the moment. This isn't who I am - this is the illness.

I am seeking help, which includes offloading my feelings onto a counsellor. Luckily, my close friends recognise that I'm not a selfish, horrible person; I'm just dealing with an illness that makes me behave in ways that I don't want to.

One of my close friends made clear that a condition of continuing to be friends with her was getting a therapist. It sounds harsh, but she was right to push me in that way because I was pushing her to her limit, and as much as she loves me, she needed to protect herself.

I do tend to withdraw, and TBH, I would find someone asking me how I was daily to be intrusive. I would feel like answering was me being a good friend and not ignoring you, given I would find it such a chore right now. But you wouldn't be getting much back about you, and you wouldn't see it as me putting in the effort even though it would take a lot out of me.

I don't think you should stop talking to her, as that's not helpful either, but I would reduce the frequency of your conversations as I suspect they're not good for either of you. If you spoke to me less often, it would require less headspace for me to respond, and I might hopefully be able to be more two-sided thanks to the space in between.

I find it really difficult to look after myself and get out. Seeing friends is good for me, but I need to have lots of notice so I can mentally prepare to leave my space.

I'm coping by seeing this as temporary. I'm getting treatment, and I know I'm not currently acting like me. Luckily, my friends are special enough that I know they forgive me for being out of character and will still be there when I'm recovered. I think the main thing for them is to know that I am talking to a doctor and I am talking to a therapist - it would be harder for them to stay friends with me if I wasn't seeking professional help. Knowing that I am doing these things lets them dial down their worry about me to an acceptable level.

DemelzaandRoss · 30/04/2023 14:21

Even to have met up with you would have been a challenge. Getting up is a challenge. You just feel like staying at home & doing nothing.
You know you’re supposed to do the right things & you pretend a lot. The voice in your head is extremely persuasive.
Hopefully your friend will begin to improve. Then she will become a better friend to you. In the meantime just let her know you’re there for her.

Fromage · 30/04/2023 14:14

It can be incredibly hard to be in any kind of relationship with someone who has depression or anxiety or any kind of mental illness.

I would guess your friend can't see the wood for the trees and has no idea how she is coming across, nor might she have the energy or ability to think beyond her own pain.

And I say this as someone depressed enough to have jettissoned all of my friends.

Bluevelvetsofa · 30/04/2023 14:09

If you are depressed, clinically depressed, as opposed to being fed up or sad, you are living in your own head and you can’t see a way out of it, so it’s not surprising that your friend doesn’t ask about you. She’s too busy being inside her head and trying to function, to have space for you, I’m afraid.

It doesn’t matter what people say, mental ill health is still frequently regarded as self indulgent and something that people can get over, if they just try harder. It hasn’t been helped over the last few years, because the lines have been blurred by self diagnosing and people who are a bit fed up deciding they can’t cope.

That isn’t what real depression is. It’s something you wouldn’t wish on anyone.

FixTheBone · 30/04/2023 13:59

That's like saying 'isn't having a broken leg a poor excuse not to be out playing football with us...

People still don't understand mental illness.

All the talk about' poor behaviour' winds me up... As if just trying a bit harder is all that's required to cure depression.

Swipe left for the next trending thread