Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The future of essential women’s roles looks grim

32 replies

Londonlassy · 30/04/2023 12:43

I previously worked in the hospital system as a registered nurse. Leaving bedside nursing was the best thing I could do for my physical and mental health. I became a nurse to follow in my mum’s footsteps. I loved hearing my mum’s stories from the ward. My mum absolutely encouraged me to entering into nursing. She told me I would always have work, make a difference and get to see the world. However I have discouraged my DC and nieces from going into nursing. My feedback is it’s a job with enormous responsibility but no autonomy. The workload is unmanageable. You feel guilty and depressed because the job you would like to do is just not possible and you can’t meet your own or your patient’s expectations

I caught up with a teacher friend who entered her profession as she was inspired by a role model teacher she had in high school. She is in the process of leaving teaching and she is really honest with her students about the harsh realities of the role and spends time discussing other careers with better conditions and pay.

So many women enter into traditional women’s work ( childcare, teaching, nursing, social work) because an older female inspired them or they believed an idealistic idea of the role. No ones encouraging our young women to go into these roles and men aren’t putting there hands up to do it. I just think the future for essential women’s works looking dire.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Olderandolder · 28/06/2023 18:38

Londonlassy · 30/04/2023 12:43

I previously worked in the hospital system as a registered nurse. Leaving bedside nursing was the best thing I could do for my physical and mental health. I became a nurse to follow in my mum’s footsteps. I loved hearing my mum’s stories from the ward. My mum absolutely encouraged me to entering into nursing. She told me I would always have work, make a difference and get to see the world. However I have discouraged my DC and nieces from going into nursing. My feedback is it’s a job with enormous responsibility but no autonomy. The workload is unmanageable. You feel guilty and depressed because the job you would like to do is just not possible and you can’t meet your own or your patient’s expectations

I caught up with a teacher friend who entered her profession as she was inspired by a role model teacher she had in high school. She is in the process of leaving teaching and she is really honest with her students about the harsh realities of the role and spends time discussing other careers with better conditions and pay.

So many women enter into traditional women’s work ( childcare, teaching, nursing, social work) because an older female inspired them or they believed an idealistic idea of the role. No ones encouraging our young women to go into these roles and men aren’t putting there hands up to do it. I just think the future for essential women’s works looking dire.

Do you not feel disgusted that Govt decides who is “essential”?

madroid · 30/04/2023 16:26

@PriOn1

I think you're so right. It's the culture of distrust and lack of respect for professionals that made my DH leave education. He is very well qualified and committed but felt disrespected and dumbed down by the whole job - entitled parents, unrealistic heads, monotonous targets/admin, under resourced.

Now earning more, doing less hours and soo much happier.

Curseofthenation · 30/04/2023 16:25

I think if the pay in these professions improves then more men and women will choose these career paths. No amount of inspiration is going to override this fact.

I would have been a teacher if the pay and working conditions were better. I'm so glad I didn't. My teaching friends are all on anti-depressants and absolutely bloody miserable. They all want out.

Hbh17 · 30/04/2023 16:21

There may have been statistically more women in these jobs in the past, but they are not "essential women's roles". Maybe young women don't want to be stereotyped in their job choices? Both nursing and teaching badly need more men involved, and it would be great to eventually have a 50/50 split, to reflect the actual population.

JenniferBooth · 30/04/2023 16:17

And the vaccine mandate was insanity

PriOn1 · 30/04/2023 16:04

I think there’s a wider problem here, in that those jobs were traditionally jobs where it was assumed that people would be doing their best and where there was some admiration and appreciation from the wider population. So even if they were not financially especially well rewarded, there were other less well defined rewards for doing them. Nowadays there are a lot more angry, demanding people whose expectations are unreasonable, but who will kick up a fuss, while the management, who have never actually done the job themselves, tend to throw them to the wolves rather than working from a basic assumption that the staff are doing their best, even if something has gone wrong,

I don’t know so much about nursing, but there are obvious problems in the teaching profession, where there is now an assumption that, unless everyone is meeting certain (frankly arbitrary) targets, that they are not doing a good job. Everything has to be measured and everyone has to prove themselves over and over. So instead of finding their own way to pass on their knowledge, they are pushed more and more into a treadmill of meeting targets, which also removes any previous “perks” such as extended holidays, as meeting those targets also means working a great deal outside the contracted hours.

That general attitude: that we can’t just trust that most people will do their jobs adequately if we mostly give them free rein, but instead must assume that if people are not constantly monitored, they will probably slack off, leads to feelings of distrust. Assuming people will always be lazy and need checking up on constantly, tends to be self-fulfilling. Arbitrary targets and general distrust (and thus lack of respect) lead to a situation where previously enthusiastic people will end up demoralized and will work to meet them and no more.

So I don’t just think that it’s just that women’s expectations have changed and they are no longer willing to be put upon. I think societal attitudes to those people have changed. The jobs have less autonomy and the people doing them are frequently shown little or no respect. My experience is that those things can be as important to me as wages, assuming the wages are not so low as to make living impossible.

As the wages are still relatively low and the stress and lack of job satisfaction has been ratcheted up, fewer people are willing to carry on. Those remaining are being pushed harder and harder, so you end up with a domino effect as well as a preponderance of people feeling hard done by, who are less and less willing to go the extra mile.

I hope all this will be reversed at some point, or that the current, dysfunctional model will be replaced with something that regards people as human beings and not as resource units, but I’m not optimistic. It’s just very sad that careers that used to be fulfilling, no longer are.

DisquietintheRanks · 30/04/2023 15:52

From what I can see both nursing and care work are moving from being jobs that white British women do to jobs done by immigrants (some white, many not). I guess that helps keep the pay low. Maybe teaching will go the same way?

JenniferBooth · 30/04/2023 15:46

The way they will get round it is to force unemployed women on UC to take the jobs There is a thread running on here at the moment with posters INSISTENT that there wont be a higher chance and risk of abuse if people who really dont want to do jobs like care work are forced into it. THATS how much this work is valued. As the Job Centres default setting. IMO care work should be taken OUT of the remit of Job Centres altogether. Im not saying everyone who the JC pushes into care work will abuse residents Of course not. But the RISK is higher if you force someone into it who does not want to be there.

Jonniecomelately · 30/04/2023 15:34

I think many many jobs are a lot more stressful than in the past. It's partly a demographic thing - fewer workers, aging population, employers struggling to recruit, economics meaning its harder for some businesses to make money so employees are pushed harder and harder.

GCAcademic · 30/04/2023 15:28

LoobyDop · 30/04/2023 12:44

YABVU to describe these as “women’s roles”.

Oh give over. We all know these roles would be better paid and have better working conditions if they were not - in practice and seen by society as - "women's jobs".

Maray1967 · 30/04/2023 15:24

Convovulus · 30/04/2023 14:20

Yanbu. It's like the scales have fallen from the eyes of women in caring jobs. They might have started out thinking its more about making a difference than the money, but they've been pushed too far with the lack of funding and have realised they've been taken advantage of

Well said. Let’s not turn the focus away and concentrate on choice of words. The main issue is a very serious one. Jobs traditionally more likely to be done by women are struggling to recruit and many women currently in these roles are dissuading the next generation from entering those careers because of how awful the jobs now are.

GettingStuffed · 30/04/2023 15:17

I wanted to become a teacher but my father, a male junior school teacher, refused to pay my grant top up because of the way the profession was going. This was in 1982

LightlySearedontheRealityGrill · 30/04/2023 15:11

The jobs still need to be done though. So its good thing young women are refusing to go into these roles, because ultimately it will mean the pay and conditions will have to improve until people will be willing to do them. There will of course be a painful period of transition.

Society and economy has relied far too long on the good will of females who care and want to 'help'. It's not valued properly, and the sooner woman start getting a bit more savvy about this (like men are) the better.

Pythonesque · 30/04/2023 14:39

It's about undervalued work in general, which I agree includes a lot of "traditionally female" professions. But doctors too are much more likely to discourage their offspring from entering the profession nowadays. (And there are interesting discussions around the "feminisation of the medical workforce" and its declining status, chicken or egg question possibly)

Public sector / public service - really important questions of how we value essential work and the people who do it.

Cooknook · 30/04/2023 14:26

Typically female jobs have always been undervalued and underpaid. I do think this is a more general public sector thing- I come from a military family for example and don't know a single person who would recommend their child join, when the opposite used to be true. You are right that this recommendation and encouragement from parents is becoming less prevalent now and it is no doubt having an impact on recruitment.

Convovulus · 30/04/2023 14:20

Londonlassy · 30/04/2023 14:06

But 75 percent of teachers are female that’s why it’s relevant. Female”s have traditionally entered roles that’s have poor pay and conditions and focused on extrinsic rewards ( improving lives etc). However I don’t think this generation on females will accept poor work conditions that previous generations had. I don’t see men stampeding to enter roles that have such poor conditions

Yanbu. It's like the scales have fallen from the eyes of women in caring jobs. They might have started out thinking its more about making a difference than the money, but they've been pushed too far with the lack of funding and have realised they've been taken advantage of

Londonlassy · 30/04/2023 14:06

Flyonthewall01 · 30/04/2023 13:49

lack of good teachers due to poor pay is what will screw up our children. Whether they are male or female is irrelevant. Why must we categorise jobs according to sex?

But 75 percent of teachers are female that’s why it’s relevant. Female”s have traditionally entered roles that’s have poor pay and conditions and focused on extrinsic rewards ( improving lives etc). However I don’t think this generation on females will accept poor work conditions that previous generations had. I don’t see men stampeding to enter roles that have such poor conditions

OP posts:
ladycardamom · 30/04/2023 13:56

I'm have actually been talking to my son about nursing. He is just about to turn 13. He is kind of a practical boy, but gentle soul. He is really interested in anatomy and physiology. For an easy life, I'd probably encourage physio. He does seem interested in the physiology of illness, though, hence the nursing.

Flyonthewall01 · 30/04/2023 13:49

Londonlassy · 30/04/2023 13:37

I would say the lack of female’s wanting to be teachers and the slow death of this profession is what’s more likely to screw up our next generation of children

lack of good teachers due to poor pay is what will screw up our children. Whether they are male or female is irrelevant. Why must we categorise jobs according to sex?

Londonlassy · 30/04/2023 13:37

Reugny · 30/04/2023 12:53

Then say that rather than women's roles.

Gender stereotyping like you are doing is what is screwing up today's children.

I would say the lack of female’s wanting to be teachers and the slow death of this profession is what’s more likely to screw up our next generation of children

OP posts:
Londonlassy · 30/04/2023 13:35

Reugny · 30/04/2023 12:53

Then say that rather than women's roles.

Gender stereotyping like you are doing is what is screwing up today's children.

Talk about derailing a thread.

OP posts:
MatildaTheCat · 30/04/2023 13:20

Aside from the immediate derailment of your OP I pretty much agree. I was both nurse and midwife and very much hesitant when anyone asks for advice or an opinion on joining these professions.

Having said that I passionately believe that these professions need bright, enthusiastic (and maybe a little idealistic ) people to have any chance of things improving.

My closest friend’s DD has begun MH nursing quite recently. When I was first aware of her ambition I was really guarded in my reaction but then, what I’ve written above became more clear in my mind. We need to campaign for better working conditions and support all those who are brave enough to take on the challenges.

carriedout · 30/04/2023 13:14

Britain is more sexist now than it has been for a while

I agree Sad

RosaGallica · 30/04/2023 13:12

Londonlassy · 30/04/2023 12:50

89.6 percent of nurses in the NHS are women. So yes it is traditionally a female role

Yep. Leaving aside the politically correct wish list, the reality is that jobs/ professions in Britain are massively skewed by sex. And the traditional female ones are particularly low paid with high responsibility and the constant narrative of ‘needing to give something back’.

It is still normal to see news articles talking about women being taken on in traditionally male job roles - and usually followed by comments on their appearance.

Britain is more sexist now than it has been for a while.

carriedout · 30/04/2023 13:10

A role done by lots of females now or in the past does not mean it has to be that way in the future. Same with roles up to now done by males.

The real issue for all of us is that teaching/nursing/doctoring/care/police - none of these are good career choices at present due to falling real pay rates, stripping out of non-pay benefits, workload and the pressure of awful working conditions.