Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to be treated like a free taxi service…

90 replies

Clarabell77 · 30/04/2023 08:47

Sorry this is long for something relatively minor…

DD almost 18 and boyfriend were at a party last night, at her friends house. I dropped them off at 6.45pm and agreed to pick them up. To collect them, drop boyfriend and get us home takes about 40 mins in total. So I said I’d collect them at 11.30ish which would get me in bed just after midnight. I’m an early bed/riser so this is late for me.

When the time came she didn’t want me to go at half 11, she was texting that it was too early. I was knackered so gave an extra 20 mins and collected them at 11.50pm, dropped him and got home around 12.15am. I said it was 11.50 or nothing and they’d need to get a taxi to stay later.

DD was whinging when I picked her up saying she can’t afford taxis, she isn’t working at the moment as she’s in the middle of exams, so is a bit strapped for cash (but can find it for other stuff…). A taxi would have been about £22, to stop at ours then drop her boyfriend off. We allowed him to stay in our spare room at new year because taxis are extortionate but don’t really want to make a habit of this. I might even have ended up paying their taxi if they’d chosen that which is what I did at new year, because I was having a drink and couldn’t collect them. I had already given her some money for her friends birthday gift too and because she was being a bit cheeky I didn’t offer.

I should also add we have dropped and collected the 3 parties she’s been at since the new year one. I did one, then DH, then me again.

I’m interested to know how others manage these situations as it’s just going to continue. I was completely on my own when it came to this when I was young, I’d never have got picked up, but I know times have changed.

I am being unreasonable - I should have let them stay later and collected them or offered to pay their taxi.

I am not being unreasonable - they were lucky enough to get a lift at all and it’s up to them to pay their own taxi if my timings don’t suit.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Caroparo52 · 23/06/2023 19:45

Pretty typical for 17. Start saving for the driving lessons.
Why can't ddbf'p do 50% pick ups?
Can a group of them share a taxi?
If she gets too lippy then cancel mum's cab service and tell her why

thing47 · 30/04/2023 12:21

I told my 3 when they were teenagers that I would always pick them up if they needed it (though tbh it was usually DH as he was happier staying up late than I was) as we were their parents. But that offer did not extend to any friends whose parents did not reciprocate. It was the principle of it – I don’t consider ferrying my own DCs around ‘being a taxi driver’, but picking up or dropping off other people’s DCs? Nah, not doing that unless other parents took their turn.

Catshaveiteasy · 30/04/2023 11:27

My DH always picks up our dc unless it's very late - we have paid for an uber for one sometimes. I'm likely older than you and my dad or my friend's dad always collected us from parties in the late 70s/ early 80s. Parties usually didn't end before midnight.

I do feel my DH is too soft at times, especially in the day time, when youngest has a cheap travel card and public transport is readily available here (London). But youngest also has anxiety attacks so it is sometimes the best thing to do anyway.

usernother · 30/04/2023 11:22

She's 18. She can get herself home. No money for taxis? That's up to her to sort out.

Madamecastafiore · 30/04/2023 11:22

I'd collect her, make be a bit later for a special occasion like this party but not regularly. I'd never forgive myself if something happened to her if i'd refused and I'm silly maybe but if my son is out I don't drink in case he needs collecting from somewhere. Once they can drive it's more anxiety and I don't sleep until I know he's in safe and sound.

My friends dad always picked us all up from parties regardless of time and once came into central London to get us when we were young and stupid and I thought I'm always going to be that parent because frankly mine didn't give a shit and it would have been my fault in their eyes if id ended up at the bottom of a river with my head bashed in,

caffelattetogo · 30/04/2023 11:20

Is she learning to drive?

Brefugee · 30/04/2023 11:16

i had missed the comment about ordering desserts. WTF? nip that in the bud, what a waste of money.

Where i live (not UK, village is 5 kms from nearest small town with a station) there are zero taxis. They stopped waiting for the last train about 5 years ago, and now if you do call for one, coming off the last train at just gone midnight, the answer is always "it will take an hour" if you order one to pick you up from the station, they will just take the first person who turns up - regardless of name/destination. Account with taxi company? still applies - they can't be arsed working for a couple of fares on a Saturday night so they don't. (having said that - they don't seem to work at weekends at all) One of the reasons i rarely drink, tbh

Unlighted country roads with no footpath, and drunk drivers (who can't get taxis) just add to the worry.

SecretVictoria · 30/04/2023 11:08

When I was that age, my boyfriend and I lived in opposite directions from the main town. We’d get a taxi back and stay at each others houses - I know you said you don’t want to encourage that but that seems a bit U to me as that’s far cheaper.

Hankunamatata · 30/04/2023 11:00

I never asked for lifts after 16 for nights out but I also walked home often alone for part way as couldnt afford taxi 😯

EustaceTheMonk · 30/04/2023 10:56

Set up an account with a cab firm. What my mate did for his DDs. Worked out cheaper than the petrol in the long run.

onedone · 30/04/2023 10:54

At 18 (also doing exams) I had a part time job so could get taxis etc; if we got lifts anywhere they were shared between other parents

Not sure why she can't get a part time job so she'll have more money? Exams don't prevent this
You made the point about ordering desserts already ....

Not sure if it's been covered - could they both get a taxi to yours (so it's cheaper) and then sleep in separate rooms? (if that's your house rules)

But equally collecting at the time you did I can see both sides - she's saying it's early; because parties normally went on to 2/3am and leaving before 1am is probably too early for her - but equally - if you're wanting collecting; then you leave when the driver turns up!

Thehonestbadger · 30/04/2023 10:49

Parents who live rurally really need to accept being a taxi service if there are no other cost effective modes of transport in the place they decided to live.

I agree with this up to driving age, or if money is so tight they can’t access driving lessons, but at 18 they should be driving.

Sophie1980 · 30/04/2023 10:47

She buys a scooter and you pay for lessons. Independence for all.

Brefugee · 30/04/2023 10:46

I just used to go to bed and let them call me when they needed picking up, and just suck up interrupted sleep.

If they went to festivals, one of their friends parents used to drive them there (or we did) and the other parent collected them. Sometimes a 2 hour drive in the middle of the night.

We chose to live at the back of beyond (without really thinking it through in terms of parent-taxi-service for teenagers 😂) and I'd rather they were safe than dead in a ditch due to walking down unlit roads at night.

(in fact once i picked them up from somewhere equally remote, and on the way back nearly ran 2 young people over who didn't have a parent taxi. So i stopped, asked them where i could drop them and then when they'd gratefully got strapped in, told them off for getting in a strangers car )

ChickenDhansak82 · 30/04/2023 10:41

I used to live in a rural village. When it came to parties we took it in turns to drive and not drink with my friends. The driver stated the time everyone was leaving!

Or we got a taxi back to one of our houses and all slept there.

I would NEVER have expected my parents to pick me up after midnight!!

11.30pm parent taxi is reasonable. If they want to stay later they save for a taxi.

Can't the boyfriends parents collect?

LlynTegid · 30/04/2023 10:38

A party is optional, it is not something required say as part of a job. Your DD should (begrudgingly) accept your timings.

Stand your ground in future. Taxis are not always available at the time you want them in any case.

HerMammy · 30/04/2023 10:35

Only on MN do I see 17/18 yr olds unable to work due to exams, every teen I know has a part time job and is fairly independent, my DD would never want picked up from a gaff at 11.30 and certainly not by me!

Georgieporgie29 · 30/04/2023 10:31

I think you’re perfectly reasonable to give a cut off time for a lift.

I don’t understand the living in the sticks comment, we don’t live in the sticks and are actually quite close to a biggish town popular with stag do’s etc. and our public transport finishes at midnight. Surely it’s only bigger cities that don’t have the problem of no public transport?!

If a taxi was £22 then surely they would split it. If I was feeling generous then I would have maybe given her a tenner towards her half but if they have money to order desserts deliveries etc. then they need to learn to save some of that for an emergency taxi.

growing up my dad would say if it’s before 12 I’ll pick you up and sometimes I would ring him (at 1 minute to 12) for a lift and other times I would want to stay out so would get a cab. I certainly wouldn’t complain about the cut off time though, he might not offer again!

JudgeRudy · 30/04/2023 10:30

Singleandproud · 30/04/2023 08:52

Did you actively pick a place to live with a poor public transport system?

Parents who live rurally really need to accept being a taxi service if there are no other cost effective modes of transport in the place they decided to live.

You wouldn't need to 'actively pick a place....with poor transport'. The majority of towns do not have public transport running passed 11pm.
I grew up in a medium sized town. Most of the parties/nights out were in my home town. I'd either get a taxi, but most likely walk (about 3 miles). If I went out of town I'd be responsible for my own arrangements, especially at nearly 18.

QueenofLouisiana · 30/04/2023 10:29

We share the lifts between families. So there have been about 5 parties since new year (all stopped due to A Levels now) and I’ve done one pick up/ drop off and one pick up. Other families do the other runs and we drop the kids off at their homes. I think the boyfriend’s family should be doing some.

Not everywhere has taxis- the wait time on a Friday night is about 90 minutes from our nearest town. No buses or trains.

ShowUs · 30/04/2023 10:26

The very idea that children/teens will be more independent if you can't be fucked to be a good parent to them when they need you is farcical, and yet also depressing and worrying.

Absolutely this!!

ShowUs · 30/04/2023 10:24

I wouldn’t want my DD doing some of the stuff I did…

I agree.

I would walk home or get a lift from some random person, usually a man driving round looking for drunk women or someone who had been drinking themselves.
I do not want my DD to do either.

You can have boundaries and rules so she doesn’t take the piss but I would pay the price of having a few nights of broken sleep a month to make sure she’s home safe rather than by putting her into dangerous situations just so I could prove a point.

PrettyMaybug · 30/04/2023 10:21

dottiedodah · 30/04/2023 09:51

I think yes times have defo changed! As a teen I rarely had a lift.However we have been driving DD around, and I think here and there to expect 11.30 to be a bit on the early side TBH. Can you and hubby take it in turns? Also the BF parents should be taking their turn .I would also consider a Taxi sometimes as well

I rarely had lifts anywhere, either as a child or a teenager. But I don't want this thread to turn into a four Yorkshire men thing where we had to walk 10 miles in the snow just to fetch a dozen eggs for our mother. And walk 15 miles to school. (In 3 foot deep floods.) And it were all fields....... 🙄

Yes, I did not get lifts anywhere, BUT In the 1970s/1980s in my childhood/teens my life was literally like Coronation Street ...Everything was within 20 minutes walk, or a short 5 to 10 minute bike ride.. There were 2 factories where many people worked, about 30 shops, including a butchers and bakers and paper shop. Hairdressers. Dentist. doctors. Opticians. Flower shop. 3 or 4 banks. Chiropodist. Supermarket Haberdashey shop. Fishing tackle shop. Pharmacies..... And loads more. Everything was within a 20 minute walk, as were my entire extended family. (About 20 people at the time.) And all my friends.

My dad was a 10 minute bike ride away from his work. My mom didn't work. There were 20 pubs within half an hour walk, (probably 15 within 10 minutes walk.) And my high school was a 15 to 20 minute walk away. The primary school was a 5 minute walk away. My workplace - The first one - was actually a 15 minute walk away. I didn't even need to learn to drive until my mid 20s. I moved to a couple of big cities in my early 20s and didn't need a car there either.

Unfortunately life not like that anymore. People live in sprawling suburbs where it's a 10 minute walk to the bus stop and only probably one bus an hour to the main town centre - where you have to get bus to the area of the town you work. And public transport is now SHIT! Exorbitant prices, and unreliable service. Many villages and semi rural areas have had the bus service removed!

Even with those who do have a bus service still (who live in suburbs/towns..) I know a few people who have to leave the house an hour and a half before work starts when it would only be a 10 or 15 minute drive. And a lot of bus services stop at about half eight or 9 at night. They ran til 11.30pm when I was a teen in the 1980s.. Things are definitely not like they used to be, and teenagers and children and young people unfortunately do need lifts now. And as a previous poster said, taxi rates are absolutely extortionate and unless three or four of them are sharing it's just too much.

It used to take my daughter an hour and a half to get to college on the bus. It was only 6 miles away. It took me between 7 and 10 minutes to drive it. It was an no-brainer. Of course I was gonna bloody drive her. I was not having her wasting three hours of her day on the frigging bus. Just get into bloody college.

Some parents who couldn't be arsed to take their kids - even though they didn't work AND they had a car, said 'it gives them independence, and it gives them a chance to their homework on the bus.' Fuck off, they never had 3 hours a day homework at college. They just couldn't be fucked to do it. Also, if you missed the bus at 4.15 pm, the next one wasn't for an hour, so many kids didn't get home til nearly 7 at night! My DD had been in for 3 hours at that point.

AND they have their whole life to get 'independence.' Hmm As I said, some people are just shit parents. Sad thing is, they really cannot see it.

For the record, my DD (now late 20,) went to uni at 18, she moved in with her her boyfriend at 22, and they travelled for a couple of years to a dozen or so countries, then bought a house and got married in summer 2022. They are both on £55-65K. She is 100% independent. The very idea that children/teens will be more independent if you can't be fucked to be a good parent to them when they need you is farcical, and yet also depressing and worrying.

NowItsSpring · 30/04/2023 10:20

This needs a discussion before next time, including how often. Personally if I am providing transport, then I set the time. If they wanted to stay later and the taxi was about £22 (need to check if more after midnight?), then I would agree to pay half.

KimberleyClark · 30/04/2023 10:19

Where are the boyfriend’s parents in all of this? Can’t they do the ferrying occasionally?