Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bank of mum and dad

190 replies

squidwid · 30/04/2023 08:41

To think it's very hard to have it all, house, kids without the help of bank of mum and dad nowadays?

OP posts:
wewol · 30/04/2023 10:06

JustFrustrated · 30/04/2023 09:01

Nope. Disagree...

I imagine it is more difficult depending where you are in the country.

But I think the main thing that makes it hard, beyond costs, is people want things immediately. They're unwilling to go, grotty bedsit/small flat/small house/normal house/big house for example. They want to go from living at home to buying a 3 bedroom house with garden, whilst not changing their lifestyle. It seems this is the expectation (judging purely on what i see online/with younger colleagues etc)

I'm only 33 so not old. I, and DH, come from poverty - hiding from the provident man/not having 3 meals a day/shoes too small with holes in etc.and with that, the lower education chances, etc

Neither of us had or have any help from family, be that financial or meaningful childcare support.

But we've managed to buy a house, both of us worked full time whilst having young children and completed our degrees via open uni at the same time.

Maybe it is easier to sacrifice, if you never had anything that required sacrifice.

It wasn't easy at all, but it's doable. You have to cut your cloth.

Completely agree

wewol · 30/04/2023 10:05

I think a lot of people are unrealistic in their expectations. I did it without help but had to make compromises - for example I had to move away (45 mins away from where I grew up) to buy a house in a cheaper area. Got a tiny house in a slightly unpleasant location 10 years ago (had rented for years before that so hadn't stayed with parents to save, moved out at 18.) Sold it 5 years later, house prices had increased and had paid a good amount of the mortgage off and then had a nice deposit to get the bigger house in the nice location, then had kids after that. So many people seem to expect to be able to buy the family sized house the next street over from their parents without any compromise. Or they have kids before buying a house which immediately makes everything much more tricky in terms of expenses.

I also see a lot of younger adults (20s) happily living at home with their parents with minimal expenses, going out every weekend, expensive holidays and spending a huge amount on finance for brand new cars and then being surprised when they don't have a deposit for a mortgage. (Equally I see the sensible ones using that opportunity to save and getting on the housing ladder fairly quickly.)

It is certainly much tricker than it used to be but I feel It's often about the choices of the individual more than anything else.

Azandme · 30/04/2023 09:56

Surely once you have kids you ARE the mum and dad?

I have a house, I am a mum, I've worked my ass off to be in a position where I can pay my own way.

My parents did the same - the thought of relying on them as an adult with my own children makes me cringe.

They managed the 15% mortgage rates, the general strike, the miner's strikes, the utter shit show that was the 80s - I can manage this.

cocksstrideintheevening · 30/04/2023 09:48

No I don't agree. We have had no help and it never occurred to me to expect help. My dad died years ago and my mum has no money.

febrezeme · 30/04/2023 09:46

JustFrustrated · 30/04/2023 09:01

Nope. Disagree...

I imagine it is more difficult depending where you are in the country.

But I think the main thing that makes it hard, beyond costs, is people want things immediately. They're unwilling to go, grotty bedsit/small flat/small house/normal house/big house for example. They want to go from living at home to buying a 3 bedroom house with garden, whilst not changing their lifestyle. It seems this is the expectation (judging purely on what i see online/with younger colleagues etc)

I'm only 33 so not old. I, and DH, come from poverty - hiding from the provident man/not having 3 meals a day/shoes too small with holes in etc.and with that, the lower education chances, etc

Neither of us had or have any help from family, be that financial or meaningful childcare support.

But we've managed to buy a house, both of us worked full time whilst having young children and completed our degrees via open uni at the same time.

Maybe it is easier to sacrifice, if you never had anything that required sacrifice.

It wasn't easy at all, but it's doable. You have to cut your cloth.

Absolutely this

The problem is now we want it all and we want it now. There's no sacrifices seemingly made - I remember my dad working 2-3 jobs and my mum doing extra work to afford a "normal" standard of living. One second hand car. Foreign holidays were a once every 5 years expense

Now people want several foreign holidays a year, flashy car, latest apple products and TVs and multiple subscriptions and then complain they can't afford things

SunnySaturdayMorning · 30/04/2023 09:45

It’s not that hard, it’s just people aren’t willing to compromise or sacrifice anymore.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 30/04/2023 09:43

I wonder at the people saying so vehemently that children should never benefit from parental financial support past a certain age, does that work the otherway too?

I think you'll find such posters would indeed say it is not a child's responsibility to provide for their parents in retirement and that they'd never ask their DC for money.
I'm not one of them but I do think they're consistent!

Butchyrestingface · 30/04/2023 09:38

Blackcatsalwaysrock · 30/04/2023 09:08

DS (our only child so will get everything when the survivor of DH and I go) never asks for money but we give him quite a bit because we want to, can afford to, and want to see him enjoy it or have his life made easier because of it. Inheriting it after we’ve gone wouldn’t, obviously, give us the same pleasure.

That was my late mum's attitude too. Smile I was able to buy my first home (late 00s) with a large deposit from her as she wanted the pleasure of seeing me happy and settled whilst she was still alive.

Didn't benefit from any bank of dad (fucker never paid a penny of child support when I was a kid, never mind deposits for mortgages).

I wonder at the people saying so vehemently that children should never benefit from parental financial support past a certain age, does that work the other way too? If my mum had ever needed money for anything and I had been able to help her out, I would have given the money without thought, hesitation or strings attached. Because she was my mum, I loved her and would have wanted to make her life easier in any way that I could.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/04/2023 09:36

There is a lot of money in the older generation but only in SOME of it - only in some families, not everyone.

So perhaps in more cases than in the past, young to middle aged people with perfectly good jobs and reasonably modest lifestyles are ending up “having to” ask their parents for some help.

But crucially it’s not everyone that’s able to ask their parents to help, so it perpetuates the gap in wealth over generations.

That’s probably how this govt wants it though

bamboonights · 30/04/2023 09:31

Very, very hard and I dont think it's even 'having it all', it's just the basics that most people aspire to.

Survey99 · 30/04/2023 09:30

It really depends on where you live and your expectations.

My niece is 28 and in the last 5 years has got married, bought her own 4 bed home and had a baby. She works tills in sainsburys her dh brings home just a little bit more than she does but is doing training to help boost his income - they will never be high earners or able to afford holidays abroad every year, but are comfortable . It is in her home town, an ex-LA house, tiny garden, but perfectly reasonable place to live. Apart from a £4k ISA her mum gave her they did it themselves. When she does go back to work the plan is to use as little childcare as possible by working opposing shifts.

My other niece 29 has just stopped renting and bought a 2 bed flat with her fiance on the outskirts of a city close to us. He works in a library she is an average earner. Again they saved by themselves.

They are not much different than I was when I bought 30 years ago, maybe 5 years later than I did but they started working FT later than me too.

GoodChat · 30/04/2023 09:29

It's completely dependent on so many variants. Where you live, what you do for work, what you earn, how well you work as a team, what you want or expect in life.

We have a lovely life with no family nearby and no financial support. We have two children and a nice home. We've worked hard but also got lucky with lots of things along the way.

updin · 30/04/2023 09:29

I can't agree as don't have parents/family to help.

So have you found it easy?

Deadpalm · 30/04/2023 09:26

Depends where one lives. Not everywhere is expensive south. You can still get 3 bed houses for abou 100-150k in many, many areas. Sometimes even for less if you look at postcode few streets away.

Doing blanket statements about UK is not doing favours to anyone because it discourages even people in affordable areas. If you read everywhere how your gen will never buy a house, it does make you feel that includes you even if you have 5 properties for 60k on market nearby

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 30/04/2023 09:23

Yes and no I think.

Kids are very used to having it all, being able to go out, have the latest iPhone, clothes, they want a car each, want the first house to be a decent size. With that mind set it is going to be hard. Those things are expensive and if you continue to buy them you'll never be able to save or pay a mortgage.

If you go without and save and work, be realistic in what you can afford then it is doable.

My first place was a 1 bed flat, not in a great area. I couldn't afford to go drinking with my mates or buy loads of clothes, my car cost me £150 and it was an old banger. But I saved up the deposit and had to go without until I could afford not to.

On talking to my dd I'm not sure she would do that. But tbh apart from saving up about 5k for her which she'll get at 18, she'll have to if she ever wants to own her own place.

WandaWonder · 30/04/2023 09:22

squidwid · 30/04/2023 08:54

Not everyone has help but if you want 2.4 kids and a house. Then it's very difficult.

There is a difference in wants and needs

Noicant · 30/04/2023 09:21

I think it depends where you are in the country, if you are saving as a couple, how much you earn, are you living at home. Some areas of the country it’s perfectly doable. Tbh I have one kid and increasingly feel relieved about it. I’m not worried about meeting the costs of her education or helping her onto the property ladder but I think I would start worrying a bit with two. it would be doable but we’d probably looking at a much poorer retirement.

MoroccanRoseHChurch · 30/04/2023 09:21

I think it’s double edged. If you’ve a wealthy mum and dad, you’ve likely got some start up cash available. You’ve ALSO got a role model. Someone who has trodden the path before you who you can aspire to. If your parents have never been to uni, never bought a house, you’ve not seen anyone do it. I’m projecting here because that was me and my brother. It was my best friend from school who pushed me out of minimum wage jobs and into University. But I had no idea that a bigger world existed out there.

In the end I was still £4k short for my first house, which my lovely DM and DF loaned me. So, yeah, I think most people have help.

BMrs · 30/04/2023 09:20

Neither of our parents were or are in a
Position to help so never been able
To help us financially but my mother in law has helped with childcare saving us costs that way.

squidwid · 30/04/2023 09:13

@skippy67 exactly a massive help

OP posts:
skippy67 · 30/04/2023 09:12

My DC both earn a lot more than me and DH. I think they'll both be fine without our help! I didn't get any help from my single parent when I bought my house either. Actually, that's not entirely true. I was able to live at home while saving for a house deposit, which was a huge help.

SoShallINever · 30/04/2023 09:10

JustFrustrated · 30/04/2023 09:01

Nope. Disagree...

I imagine it is more difficult depending where you are in the country.

But I think the main thing that makes it hard, beyond costs, is people want things immediately. They're unwilling to go, grotty bedsit/small flat/small house/normal house/big house for example. They want to go from living at home to buying a 3 bedroom house with garden, whilst not changing their lifestyle. It seems this is the expectation (judging purely on what i see online/with younger colleagues etc)

I'm only 33 so not old. I, and DH, come from poverty - hiding from the provident man/not having 3 meals a day/shoes too small with holes in etc.and with that, the lower education chances, etc

Neither of us had or have any help from family, be that financial or meaningful childcare support.

But we've managed to buy a house, both of us worked full time whilst having young children and completed our degrees via open uni at the same time.

Maybe it is easier to sacrifice, if you never had anything that required sacrifice.

It wasn't easy at all, but it's doable. You have to cut your cloth.

Just wanted to say congratulations.
I'm from a similar background but I'm almost twice your age. Your achievements are all the more when you have had no help or support.
Sometimes I think my DC have no real understanding how hard life can be for kids growing up in poverty.

Blackcatsalwaysrock · 30/04/2023 09:08

DS (our only child so will get everything when the survivor of DH and I go) never asks for money but we give him quite a bit because we want to, can afford to, and want to see him enjoy it or have his life made easier because of it. Inheriting it after we’ve gone wouldn’t, obviously, give us the same pleasure.

cptartapp · 30/04/2023 09:05

thimblewomgee247 · 30/04/2023 08:56

In most cases "bank of mum and dad" comes with strings attached. It's better to be independent if at all
Possible and make your own path

This. We're beholden to no one now.
SIL on the other hand....

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 30/04/2023 09:03

I think it's hard without any help but not necessarily financial. We didn't have help buying our current house, although we have since had some inheritance to make some overpayments. If we didn't we'd just have carried on paying til the end of the mortgage term.

What we couldn't really have done without is parental childcare for DS in school holidays and the help when he's been hospitalised a few times, which has helped us continue working. Local holiday clubs don't work timing wise.