Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bank of mum and dad

190 replies

squidwid · 30/04/2023 08:41

To think it's very hard to have it all, house, kids without the help of bank of mum and dad nowadays?

OP posts:
AlienEgg · 30/04/2023 11:16

strawberryjeans · 30/04/2023 08:54

I think in the long term it will have all sorts of impacts, people sticking to one child or not affording kids at all, it will become normal to rent. There was only a piece on the news the other day, projecting that babies born today will have only a 1 in 3 chance of being a homeowner in their lifetime. I think that’s optimistic to be honest

Do you have a link? I'd be interested how they have calculated this.

updin · 30/04/2023 11:15

you mean when many people bought houses on 100% mortgages before fixed deals were commonplace and saw interest rates climb to almost 15%? Yeah they had a ball

Yes that's the time I mean, I'm not making this into the pathetic (and boring) intergenerational debate you are. My parents would be the first to admit, along with most people, that it was EASIER TO BUY A HOUSE then vs now, I'm not talking about maintaining it. My parents since divorced and my dad has never been able to buy again and my mum only could because of pension drawdown (unfortunately the house they bought wasn't the best investment and sold at the wrong time).

It was easier to buy previously, that is just a fact. Yes there is more nuanced stuff around that. But I think in terms of home ownership, bank of mum and dad has been more influential recently than in recent decades. (No, not saying necessary).

JudgeRudy · 30/04/2023 11:13

squidwid · 30/04/2023 08:41

To think it's very hard to have it all, house, kids without the help of bank of mum and dad nowadays?

I think it's very hard to 'have it all' full stop. For most people that's always been the way. It's continually about choices, the rule being you can't have both. In my experience it's time v money which is the main one.
Yes I could afford to attend the out of town wedding if I take cheese sandwiches and a yoghurt to work every day. Of course I could make a tasty and nutritious lunch instead....if I get up half an hour earlier. I could get out of my PJs and go and pick the kids up, or stay and watch the movie and transfer a tenner for a taxi.
When my children were young my mum would often buy practical treats for them. Now I'm a grandma l'm doing the same. I paid for a short mini break with my adult children (to accompany on something I wanted to do) but that's the biggest thing financially I've ever done for them. My dad gave me his old work car that he'd been offered £200 for and they took me on holiday one year with my then BF.
That's it. Is it normal in MN land to get regular income from parents. As far as lm aware, this hasn't happened to my friends and family (some inheritance from houses following death). What sort of things do grandparents pay for?

Deadpalm · 30/04/2023 11:11

I didn't realise how low parenting bar is when being able to stay at home until 18 or finishing ft education is considered a help from parents 😳

Camablanca · 30/04/2023 11:10

Deadpalm · 30/04/2023 09:26

Depends where one lives. Not everywhere is expensive south. You can still get 3 bed houses for abou 100-150k in many, many areas. Sometimes even for less if you look at postcode few streets away.

Doing blanket statements about UK is not doing favours to anyone because it discourages even people in affordable areas. If you read everywhere how your gen will never buy a house, it does make you feel that includes you even if you have 5 properties for 60k on market nearby

People aren't stupid. They calculate things themselves with Rightmove, online affordability calculators. House price data is also available freely online.

Also the 'South' is a big place... I don't think those prices exist for anywhere commutable to London without a catch (auction, major structural issues) etc.

Male101 · 30/04/2023 11:04

There is no bank of mum and dad for me and OH , everything we have have been saved for. No loans, no finance, we live in a HA flat, so we have relatively cheap rent but we are looking to buy next year through one means or another.

Emotionalstorm · 30/04/2023 11:04

My husband and I have a combined income of £2M plus a year or thereabouts.

My parents have been very generous and have brought us a family home in Wimbledon and they also put the maximum amount into a junior ISA for my daughter each year so that she will have funds for uni and to get a good start at life.

This has allowed us to do things like save for retirement. Maintain a second residence in the City of London so that my husband's commute is reduced and he has more time with the kids.

We also have a cleaner and recently hired a nanny so we can concentrate on things that give us more joy in life.

Our parents also buy our little one lots of gifts so we hardly need to buy any clothes or toys.

Is it necessary to have help from mum and dad? No. Is it easier? Always.

RosaGallica · 30/04/2023 11:01

I think a lot of people don’t recognise the whole help they have had from mum and dad.

Living “at home” after getting to 16/ 18 is an immense help. Always having the safety net of being able to “go back home” in an emergency or in any difficulty is an incredible safety net. Having a mum and dad who you can call for help at any time, who will have your kids for an hour, a day or a week, is an incredible amount of help. That frees you up to work and gives you so much more flexibility in jobs.

I had none of it, and actually know very few people in the same position. Those few I know have always found life a struggle and we all get sick to the back teeth of the entitled assumptions of life from the vapid rich who have it and forget.

Geography also matters, as living in isolated areas in the north is an entirely different proposition from living in London with its vastly greater opportunities, facilities and public spending.

Now, in current times, it has become almost impossible and I am sick of having the luck of the odd one or two who could rubbed in our faces on the news and social media. It does not change the cost and inaccesibility of help for us.

EustaceTheMonk · 30/04/2023 11:01

I don't think this is a new thing. When we got married back in the 70s (when if you believe the media houses were virtually being given away), we only managed to buy a 2-bed terraced in an unfashionable part of South London because of a generous cash gift from my DW's grandfather. And that was with a cheap "staff mortgage" from my employer.

It's just that the media makes an issue of it today.

Babyroobs · 30/04/2023 11:00

Yes it's hard. We have 4 dc and trying to support two of them through Uni. We are helping the others by letting DS1 and Ds2 and Ds's gf live with us virtually rent free so they can save as much as possible. have also helped them with driving lessons, first cars etc. It is all horrendously expensive. I feel for those parents that are struggling and can't do it, We literally have few treats and no foreign holidays etc ourselves to do this. Private rents around here are 1k for a 2 bedroomed place, they would never be able to save if they had to pay rent.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 30/04/2023 10:55

A lot will depend IMO on where you live, and local house prices. Anywhere around here I would guess that many people would need help - unless they are very high earners.

RandomMess · 30/04/2023 10:53

It is a lot more difficult than it was 20 years ago. We live in a more affordable area in the NW even house prices here have more than doubled whereas salaries haven't. What one person on a low salary could have bought on their own 25 years ago now needs two salaries.

We used to live in the SE 20 years ago we bought with 4 x our joint salary plus 15% deposit would now cost 8 x the equivalent joint salary plus 15% deposit - DH has the same job!!

Inthesamesinkingboat · 30/04/2023 10:53

@updin you mean when many people bought houses on 100% mortgages before fixed deals were commonplace and saw interest rates climb to almost 15%? Yeah they had a ball

updin · 30/04/2023 10:50

@Inthesamesinkingboat well it was easier when you didn't need a large deposit. My parents bought a house with a 100% mortgage, no parental help and minimum wage jobs in the 80s, in the SE in their early 20s! Of course it's been easier.

Inthesamesinkingboat · 30/04/2023 10:47

I don’t know that it’s ever been easy to be honest. Buying a home has always required struggle and sacrifice. I don’t know when the mythical golden age was when people seem to think things were easy, they must do it they say things are hard NOW.

my grandparents struggled starting out, my parents struggled and I struggled. We did it though.

Tarantella6 · 30/04/2023 10:45

I think one off help makes a huge difference - I lived at home rent free for a while so I could save, and my Dad gave us a lump sum for this house. We would still have bought a house but it would have been a cheaper one!

I don't fully understand parents who keep topping up their adult children. I don't think it does them any favours in the long run, presumably there is an inheritance coming but even so, they've never had to live within their means so surely they'll end up spending the lot and then be looking around for more?!

Abacusporttaco · 30/04/2023 10:44

In the context of these threads, whatever your parents did for you is framed as a ‘massive parental help’.

E.g. “your parents fed you every day and didn’t kick you out at 16? See? Massive help. Loads of kids don’t get that.”

“Your parents supported you in a normal way during secondary education and sixth form, allowing you to achieve the A-levels, which in turn won you a place at university, which in turn won you a decently paid grad job in the city, which allowed you onto the property ladder at 27? See? Massive help from the bank of mum and dad…”

Emotionalstorm · 30/04/2023 10:41

We don't need it because my husband earns a lot but it certainly makes life easier. We dip into it all the time.

TheSnowyOwl · 30/04/2023 10:39

Surely as grown ups and parents, we need to teach our children to be self sufficient and not set the example that you expect others to constantly bail you out.

DoctorManhattan · 30/04/2023 10:37

I think the post about people wanting everything immediately rings very true.

I have very wealthy parents. Very expensive house, portfolio of rental properties, other business interests, huge fleet of expensive cars and so on. All self-made. My wife’s parents weren’t wealthy like that but still comfortable.

I’ve had so many comments over the years about my house and wedding and so on, with implicit suggestions that my parents must have done it all for us. What many people don’t realise is they didn’t start getting any serious returns from their businesses until I was finishing my GCSEs, so I grew up in what was - to me - a relatively normal income household. I moved out at 19 so was quite independent from day one (as is my wife) so we both agreed early on that we would be paying for our house and wedding ourselves and not taking parental handouts. And that remains the case to this day.

By contrast, my sister is quite younger than me so grew up in what was - to her - a high income household. Now late 20s, she still relies on our parents to pay for everything - car, holidays, clothes, you name it. She seems completely oblivious to her own behaviour as I’ve heard her make comments about others are who ‘freeloaders’ before. Her instagram-centric lifestyle also means that only the best of stuff will do, and if she takes a notion that she wants something, it absolutely must be purchased immediately and pics put on social media for immediate praise from followers - the notion of waiting and saving is alien to her.

So yes, the bank of mum and dad is a very real thing. I think personally that those who take such handouts and are unwilling to stand on their own feet will suffer in the long run from a lack of independence and poor financial management, but I also think the mums and dads who facilitate this are to blame too and need to stop being enablers.

Starseeking · 30/04/2023 10:33

On an average wage, I agree it would be difficult, especially if you are a single income household.

Saniflo · 30/04/2023 10:23

I don't know anyone that has this help. I left home at 18 to go to uni and never went back. Rented for a bit, as you do, worked hard and bought our first tiny house. Few years on, and 4 kids later, we live in our "forever house". This is what most people I know have done.

ohtowinthelottery · 30/04/2023 10:15

I think it's difficult but not impossible. We are helping our adult DS who came back home after Uni. He is living rent free to save a deposit and we've been feeding a Help 2 Buy account for him for the last few years up to the £12000 to get maximum bonus. He works 9-5 plus has a casual job in hospitality. Plenty of scope for more hours in hospitality if he wanted/needed to earn more money if we weren't helping him though.
So if you are committed to giving yourself a good start without the bank of M&D then I think you can do it by working 2 jobs and not wasting money on all the modern day frivolities that young people seem to spend their money on these days. But not everyone wants to live like that.

Sighhhhh · 30/04/2023 10:10

Bear in mind though that for some people, living at home for longer isn’t cost-free. For some, it means covering all the bills and contributing to the mortgage if there is one, caring for elderly parents or GPs (obviously, without being paid for this time/effort), and/or buying/cooking your own meals. And of course, the trade-off with your freedom to do whatever you like because you’re still under your parents’ roof. All things that I’ve seen.

Living with parents isn’t as cheap or as fun as it is for some people, particularly when parents are poorer and in expensive areas like London.

supadupapupascupa · 30/04/2023 10:06

Of course it's possible. You go without. You live in a happy shit hole. You save up.
It takes years of hard work and little luxury.

If your expectations are leave home and into nice house, you're gonna need someone else to pay for it