Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bank of mum and dad

190 replies

squidwid · 30/04/2023 08:41

To think it's very hard to have it all, house, kids without the help of bank of mum and dad nowadays?

OP posts:
CaffeineFirstPlease · 01/05/2023 09:14

I am very lucky. I would not have the life I have without all the help I have had.

Deadpalm · 01/05/2023 09:12

Survey99 · 30/04/2023 21:57

Yes, there is affordable housing down the whole of the west coast of Scotland and similar in many similar cheaper areas of the uk. It might in many cases be characterless boxes, the weather is crap but there is a strong sense of community. My nieces 4 bed, terraced box cost around £100k. No idea what other nieces flat cost but just checked get area and they come in around £190k (which would buy my 3 bed detached which is 30 min drive to Glasgow off peak!)

My parents are not originally from this area but took the option available to everyone to move to where they could afford to raise a family and it is our home now. I couldnt afford many places in the UK so I don't expect to buy there.

It's not just your area.
I know waitresses and warehouse workera in NW who bought within last 6 years including recently. One of the girls boight by herself on waitress salary 4 years ago (would be harder now obviously). One couple of friends lived in sharedhouse with their baby for a year to save up deposit (different city to me).
You can still score 3 bed here for 100k. Not glam area, but livable. There are some for 70k but that might be step too far because they will need LOADS to refurbish.

ExLA houses are great. Not sure why so many people turn their noses up on them. I have one. 3 bed, garden, calm area (under 150k)

But smaller new builds here go for double or triple the price of these former LA houses😱

thecatsthecats · 01/05/2023 09:01

Survey99 · 30/04/2023 21:57

Yes, there is affordable housing down the whole of the west coast of Scotland and similar in many similar cheaper areas of the uk. It might in many cases be characterless boxes, the weather is crap but there is a strong sense of community. My nieces 4 bed, terraced box cost around £100k. No idea what other nieces flat cost but just checked get area and they come in around £190k (which would buy my 3 bed detached which is 30 min drive to Glasgow off peak!)

My parents are not originally from this area but took the option available to everyone to move to where they could afford to raise a family and it is our home now. I couldnt afford many places in the UK so I don't expect to buy there.

Yes, my first flat was in north Cumbria and cost bobbins.

Take home - £1050
2 bed flat rent - £350 inc water rates
Savings - £200
Spends - £200

I didn't always spend the full remaining £300 on bills either - I could walk to work and the shops.

Some places are still incredibly cheap to live, even relatively now. And technically I could have been sharing, or had a smaller flat.

My friend's first house was 90k - 5 bed in the North East.

There's still loads of places where housing is cheap.

brunettemic · 30/04/2023 22:13

Just depends what “have it all” means. Usually it’s keeping up with other people and giving off the impression you’ve got loads of money. There must be a lot of people seriously loaded with debt to live the lives they do (as in you know the jobs they have so earnings aren’t that hard to guess) but everyone thinks they just “have it all”. We have zero financial or childcare help and it does impact your lifestyle but we own both cars, have a nice house (or at I least I like it!) and no debt. Sure, I could have an Audi instead of my Peugeot but I’d be in debt.

Survey99 · 30/04/2023 21:57

AlienEgg · 30/04/2023 19:39

If any of that is true you must live in an incredibly cheap part of the country. And presumably you're aware of that so don't try to hold it up as average when you know it isn't.

Yes, there is affordable housing down the whole of the west coast of Scotland and similar in many similar cheaper areas of the uk. It might in many cases be characterless boxes, the weather is crap but there is a strong sense of community. My nieces 4 bed, terraced box cost around £100k. No idea what other nieces flat cost but just checked get area and they come in around £190k (which would buy my 3 bed detached which is 30 min drive to Glasgow off peak!)

My parents are not originally from this area but took the option available to everyone to move to where they could afford to raise a family and it is our home now. I couldnt afford many places in the UK so I don't expect to buy there.

Camablanca · 30/04/2023 21:45

produ · 30/04/2023 15:53

@Camablanca I'm not sure if your point? I was simply answering why some people don't move. I'm a Londoner as is everyone I know pretty much. On Mns we are apparently unicorns but there are plenty of us here 😆

Didn't mean anything was just an observation.
Logically speaking I don't think 'Londoners' would move out. After all they can live rent free in the capital if at home, and plenty are wealthy.
But a lot of people living in London didn't grow up there anyway

thecatsthecats · 30/04/2023 21:17

JustFrustrated · 30/04/2023 09:01

Nope. Disagree...

I imagine it is more difficult depending where you are in the country.

But I think the main thing that makes it hard, beyond costs, is people want things immediately. They're unwilling to go, grotty bedsit/small flat/small house/normal house/big house for example. They want to go from living at home to buying a 3 bedroom house with garden, whilst not changing their lifestyle. It seems this is the expectation (judging purely on what i see online/with younger colleagues etc)

I'm only 33 so not old. I, and DH, come from poverty - hiding from the provident man/not having 3 meals a day/shoes too small with holes in etc.and with that, the lower education chances, etc

Neither of us had or have any help from family, be that financial or meaningful childcare support.

But we've managed to buy a house, both of us worked full time whilst having young children and completed our degrees via open uni at the same time.

Maybe it is easier to sacrifice, if you never had anything that required sacrifice.

It wasn't easy at all, but it's doable. You have to cut your cloth.

I know this gets pushback, but I do agree to some extent.

I'm 34, and we bought at 28. Moved around for jobs, second hand cars after a few years of commuting by train, sim only phone contracts and cheap phones. One or two "proper" nights out a month, other get togethers done on the cheap at each other's houses.

I didn't have a totally stingy and joyless time in my twenties, but I saw my friends - all on similar or lower incomes - frankly pissing money up the wall with constant shopping, iPhones, Sky TV, lease cars etc

It wasn't a big mystery to me why I had such better savings.

AlienEgg · 30/04/2023 21:14

Kazzyhoward · 30/04/2023 20:00

@thebaneofmylifeisacat

Times were hard as in the 90s when mortgage rates jumped up from 10 to 15 % IN ONE FUCKING DAY!!

Only for one day. They were reduced back to 10% the day after!

Exactly. Hardly the same as 25 years of zero salary growth. 🙄

And 10 or even 15% of fuck all is a lot less than 5% of a shitload.

But never mind the maths, eh? Blame the avocado eating, coffee drinking, lazy people. 🤦🏻‍♀️ Some people could really have done with learning a little more maths perhaps, not that I agree with anything else that comes out of Sunak's mouth.

batsandeggs · 30/04/2023 20:51

It’s never occurred to me what life would be like if my parent helped me out with money. My husband and I have built our lives independently and it has been difficult, and although I earn decently I don’t think I’d have managed to save enough alone to buy a home.

We hope to gift our own children reasonably when they’re older, because it is incredibly difficult otherwise.

LysHastighed · 30/04/2023 20:41

I find it easier to some extent not to have any perspective of help from parents or in-laws (and in fact have to help them out on occasion). We knew that we had to crack on and do it ourselves, and we did.
People who grew up more comfortably seem to have a sense of entitlement about what it their due that really holds them back.

squidwid · 30/04/2023 20:34

@Heedless same.

OP posts:
Kazzyhoward · 30/04/2023 20:00

@thebaneofmylifeisacat

Times were hard as in the 90s when mortgage rates jumped up from 10 to 15 % IN ONE FUCKING DAY!!

Only for one day. They were reduced back to 10% the day after!

thebaneofmylifeisacat · 30/04/2023 19:55

We gifted our ds1 10 grand for a house deposit. Will hope to do the same with the younger 3. Her mum and dad gifted 2 grand. It's what we could all afford.

It's bloody ridiculous now. We brought our first house for 30.000! 4 bed detatched nice area. We had a deposit of £500 on a credit card and 100% mortgage.

Times were hard as in the 90s when mortgage rates jumped up from 10 to 15 % IN ONE FUCKING DAY!!

But the youngsters now it's bloody unfair. House prices are mad and mortgages need to be far more long term and manageable

AlienEgg · 30/04/2023 19:49

SunnySaturdayMorning · 30/04/2023 09:45

It’s not that hard, it’s just people aren’t willing to compromise or sacrifice anymore.

You might want to look at inflation-adjusted salaries versus house prices in the last 70 years. And in particular that the UK is alone in all developed countries in having had no real terms salary increases in 15 years, and the fact that economists so not expect us to even get back to 2019 levels by 2028. So that will be 25 years of NO real terms salary rises. Unprecedented in 300 years of recorded economic history. But of course, all because the generation living through that for their entire working lives is not as virtuous as you, or something? Go learn some economics, then come back when you have any useful insights with any factual basis.

AlienEgg · 30/04/2023 19:44

Blackcatsalwaysrock · 30/04/2023 09:08

DS (our only child so will get everything when the survivor of DH and I go) never asks for money but we give him quite a bit because we want to, can afford to, and want to see him enjoy it or have his life made easier because of it. Inheriting it after we’ve gone wouldn’t, obviously, give us the same pleasure.

This is how most people think about it IME. It's horrible for those whose parents can't help set them up, and for those whose parents are so dumb they'd rather pay 40% of family wealth to HMRC than do appropriate tax planning and pass family assets on to the next generation when they are young and need them and preserve them for generations after that. Sadly there seem to be many families that gained wealth in the last generation or two who squander it in this way, which those with "old money" never do: they always consider it a family asset to be passed down when needed and as efficiently as possible.

Heedless · 30/04/2023 19:43

We (me, DH & 2 DC) definitely wouldn't be in the fortunate position we're in today if it weren't for my parents, and I'm forever grateful to them for that.

AlienEgg · 30/04/2023 19:39

Survey99 · 30/04/2023 09:30

It really depends on where you live and your expectations.

My niece is 28 and in the last 5 years has got married, bought her own 4 bed home and had a baby. She works tills in sainsburys her dh brings home just a little bit more than she does but is doing training to help boost his income - they will never be high earners or able to afford holidays abroad every year, but are comfortable . It is in her home town, an ex-LA house, tiny garden, but perfectly reasonable place to live. Apart from a £4k ISA her mum gave her they did it themselves. When she does go back to work the plan is to use as little childcare as possible by working opposing shifts.

My other niece 29 has just stopped renting and bought a 2 bed flat with her fiance on the outskirts of a city close to us. He works in a library she is an average earner. Again they saved by themselves.

They are not much different than I was when I bought 30 years ago, maybe 5 years later than I did but they started working FT later than me too.

If any of that is true you must live in an incredibly cheap part of the country. And presumably you're aware of that so don't try to hold it up as average when you know it isn't.

AlienEgg · 30/04/2023 19:34

MoroccanRoseHChurch · 30/04/2023 09:21

I think it’s double edged. If you’ve a wealthy mum and dad, you’ve likely got some start up cash available. You’ve ALSO got a role model. Someone who has trodden the path before you who you can aspire to. If your parents have never been to uni, never bought a house, you’ve not seen anyone do it. I’m projecting here because that was me and my brother. It was my best friend from school who pushed me out of minimum wage jobs and into University. But I had no idea that a bigger world existed out there.

In the end I was still £4k short for my first house, which my lovely DM and DF loaned me. So, yeah, I think most people have help.

So what is the "double edge"? All you listed here were positives to it?

thebestbirtheraccordingtoDD · 30/04/2023 19:16

We have 3 kids 2 of which are dependant.

I've never asked my mum & dad for anything. I bought my first 2nd and 3rd house alone.

Scottishskifun · 30/04/2023 19:07

squidwid · 30/04/2023 18:52

@Wenfy 100% this. My parents did this. I had my kids late 20s/early 30s and we were "young". We struggled and still are. However, my parents are older and they'd be too old to enjoy them if we'd started having them now.

Something has to give. Pick two below:
Kids before 35
House
Good job.

Even then, jobs aren't guaranteed.

Both parents need to work and childcare is a joke.

Sure , there's a difference between want and need but we'll soon be needing a working population to look after the elderly. Do you really need care? 🙈

People can (and do) have all 3 of those though without being a millionaire!
Both DH and I have good jobs but we worked our way up, moved jobs (and locations) to achieve it. Bought a house which was considerably less then what a bank was prepared to lend us (and now very glad we did). I'm just past mid 30s. Like I said previous people have to make sacrifices to get it though.

We saved before having children because we knew the costs of childcare and family childcare wasn't a option. But childminders are cheaper then private nurseries for instance.

As for parents would be too old to enjoy grandchildren......my husbands grandmother is 96 and plays chase/hide and seek etc with her great grandchildren she just uses a mobility scooter! Young children have been proven to keep older adults more active both physically and mentally.

GoodChat · 30/04/2023 19:03

Something has to give. Pick two below:
Kids before 35
House
Good job.

You don't have to only pick two if you do your list in reverse.

squidwid · 30/04/2023 18:52

@Wenfy 100% this. My parents did this. I had my kids late 20s/early 30s and we were "young". We struggled and still are. However, my parents are older and they'd be too old to enjoy them if we'd started having them now.

Something has to give. Pick two below:
Kids before 35
House
Good job.

Even then, jobs aren't guaranteed.

Both parents need to work and childcare is a joke.

Sure , there's a difference between want and need but we'll soon be needing a working population to look after the elderly. Do you really need care? 🙈

OP posts:
AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 30/04/2023 16:21

Contrary to popular belief there is a sweet spot between "commutable to London" and "£55k terrace in a pit village in County Durham with 40% unemployment".

The SW is great for this. Plenty of decent towns here within 45 minutes of Bristol and Bath for work, with houses from about £200k. Obviously you still need a £10k deposit but it's a lot more doable than many places.

produ · 30/04/2023 16:16

@Wenfy I remember getting on my first bus outside London when I moved for uni. I waited about 45mins for it & it was £2/3. I was shocked! 😆

Wenfy · 30/04/2023 16:10

produ · 30/04/2023 14:30

I also don't understand why so many stay in London/SE if they can't afford it. There are plenty of jobs in much more affordable areas. So why don't people move?

Jobs
Family
1st/2nd gen immigrants so feel more comfortable

Lets not forget the ‘London lifestyle’ too - transport is the cheapest in London, you don’t really need to drive if you live within zones 1-6, and many people are tricked by their employers into believing other cities like Birmingham and Machester don’t also receive the equiv of London allowance. Eg in Birmingham, Edinburgh and Manchester most STEM jobs pay the same as London because there’s a skills shortage.

Swipe left for the next trending thread