Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bank of mum and dad

190 replies

squidwid · 30/04/2023 08:41

To think it's very hard to have it all, house, kids without the help of bank of mum and dad nowadays?

OP posts:
AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 16:15

Yep, stamp duty incurred by repeated moves can add up and will be part of the equation for some people. We know that fiscal drag applies here too.

The reality is that people wanting to buy a bigger home as their first purchase are responding to a very, very different set of incentives to someone who bought their first property years ago and was happy with a small flat.

Yes. The fiscal drag on stamp duty has been brutal, dragging many whom it was never intended to target into very high rates for very normal family homes. And I agree entirely, it's such a different landscape now in many parts of the country that people commenting on what they did even 20 years ago, or what their family are doing now in a cheap area, shows a huge lack of understanding of the costs in many areas now.

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 16:12

*My car is 8 years old. I've had it about 4 or 5 years. Cost me about 7k. Current value on we buy any car and other sites is about 5300.
My breakdown is £32 for the year.
I've just had to buy a new battery about £130 . Think I had 2 new tyres last year. That's all the money I've ever spent on it. Tax is £20 for the year. You won't convince me that paying 200 a month upwards is a better deal. I don't do a lot of miles as I wfh but my husband is in a similar position, his is about 10 years old and only now starting to cost a little in repairs. He does a lot more miles than me.

Why would I be trying to convince you? It's great that for you it's worked out cheaper that way. My point was that a previous post was asserting that people are wrong to think a leased, new car is more expensive than buying a second hand one, when this is not always the case. That fact it is cheaper in your particular circumstances doesn't make it cheaper for everyone, in some cases leasing can be cheaper and more predictable and less stressful, as my example demonstrated. The fact is that to work out what is better value people will need to do their own calculations based on their own circumstances.

Citadel8 · 01/05/2023 16:10

I didn’t get any help but have helped my son a bit. Not excessively though. I can’t understand some people who lavish money on their kids when they haven’t secured their own financial future.

Camablanca · 01/05/2023 16:10

Wenfy · 01/05/2023 16:02

Lol you made up numbers out of thin air. To get a good quality 2nd hand car that requires minimal garage costs you must pay at least 8-10k. Eg My 2nd hand car was 10k. Over 5 years just the purchase alone would be £166 + insurance is 45/mth. I can get a small 3-5 door run around, new, on lease for £200 and in many cases includes insurance

This. @BashirWithTheGoodBeard exactly.

Mate is currently looking at cars and a 7 year old Toyota Yaris, good condition, full service record etc is about 8K. A VW make (they have a reputation!) is about 3-5K more for the same specs././

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 01/05/2023 16:04

I think sometimes people don't realise what has happened to the cost of used cars since 2020.

Wenfy · 01/05/2023 16:02

thecatsthecats · 01/05/2023 12:35

I have run secondhand cars for the past 11 years.

The FULL cost - petrol, purchase, insurance, repairs, tax, aa membership etc - is £55/month. Be super generous and add a £25/month "my car broke down and I needed to get a taxi instead fund" (this has happened maybe three times in 11 years), and it's still £80/month.

And my current car still has years left in it, so that average will keep going down. It's my third car.

I do wish people wouldn't keep perpetuating the idea that secondhand cars aren't cheaper than lease cars. I think it scares young people off from dealing with repairs etc in an adult way, selling them the dream that for £200/month (not including petrol), you don't need to worry.

Lol you made up numbers out of thin air. To get a good quality 2nd hand car that requires minimal garage costs you must pay at least 8-10k. Eg My 2nd hand car was 10k. Over 5 years just the purchase alone would be £166 + insurance is 45/mth. I can get a small 3-5 door run around, new, on lease for £200 and in many cases includes insurance

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 01/05/2023 15:58

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 13:25

Also extortionate stamp duty!! I made this mistake, bought a smaller home with my ex-H as our first house. Then just a few years later we had to move for work. Then a few years after that we separated and sold up and I bought my current house. So in less than a decade I had spent £35,000 on stamp duty. It makes far more sense to stretch to buy a bigger property and not move, in many cases, now that stamp duty is so punitive even on smaller homes in more expensive areas.

Yep, stamp duty incurred by repeated moves can add up and will be part of the equation for some people. We know that fiscal drag applies here too.

The reality is that people wanting to buy a bigger home as their first purchase are responding to a very, very different set of incentives to someone who bought their first property years ago and was happy with a small flat.

Cosyblankets · 01/05/2023 15:53

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 14:16

Plus brand new vehicle often comes with breakdown cover included, so save having to pay for that as well.

My car is 8 years old. I've had it about 4 or 5 years. Cost me about 7k. Current value on we buy any car and other sites is about 5300.
My breakdown is £32 for the year.
I've just had to buy a new battery about £130 . Think I had 2 new tyres last year. That's all the money I've ever spent on it. Tax is £20 for the year. You won't convince me that paying 200 a month upwards is a better deal. I don't do a lot of miles as I wfh but my husband is in a similar position, his is about 10 years old and only now starting to cost a little in repairs. He does a lot more miles than me.

NoMoreLifts · 01/05/2023 14:42

Deadpalm · 30/04/2023 11:11

I didn't realise how low parenting bar is when being able to stay at home until 18 or finishing ft education is considered a help from parents 😳

It used to be common for young people and their families to factor in the need to earn a wage vs continuing into Higher Education, even when there was a full grant.
So things change, but it's always been easier for those with parents you can and do help them, of course

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 14:16

Plus brand new vehicle often comes with breakdown cover included, so save having to pay for that as well.

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 14:15

£20k for faults over the years is £138 per month average. Servicing and MOT and general maintenance, new tyres etc works out £45 per month average. Then the depreciation between buying at 5 years old and selling at 10 years old was an average of £65 per month, across various "sensible" second hand vehicles during my ownership. That's £248 cost per month already.

Road tax on newer vehicles is cheaper, fuel economy better, and insurance was lower. So altogether I could lease a vehicle for over £300 per month, take less personal risk on depreciation etc, have a brand new car, and spend the same or less in total. And that's before you apply a discount rate for spending the money upfront to buy a second hand car outright whereas payments on a leased car are monthly so don't have to pay it all in advance and have the opportunity cost on that money.

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 14:05

I have run secondhand cars for the past 11 years.

The FULL cost - petrol, purchase, insurance, repairs, tax, aa membership etc - is £55/month. Be super generous and add a £25/month "my car broke down and I needed to get a taxi instead fund" (this has happened maybe three times in 11 years), and it's still £80/month.

And my current car still has years left in it, so that average will keep going down. It's my third car.

I do wish people wouldn't keep perpetuating the idea that secondhand cars aren't cheaper than lease cars. I think it scares young people off from dealing with repairs etc in an adult way, selling them the dream that for £200/month (not including petrol), you don't need to worry

Which is cheaper depends entirely on the circumstances. You have been extremely lucky if the full cost of running any car has been only £80 per month! Many people have to spend two to four times that in petrol alone, depending on commute distance. And insurance - my insurance alone increased £30 this year with no change in underlying facts (full NCD discount and never had an accident), so how £80 could cover all car costs including repairs, tax, servicing, insurance, fuel is baffling to me, but lucky you!

I always bought cars roughly 5 years old outright until recently. Over the years I have had to pay out nearly £20k to fix major faults, repair electrics, air conditioning, random warning lights popping up on the dashboard, wheel re-alignment, etc. All for supposedly sensible and reliable, well-made cars. 🤔

I made a spreadsheet and worked out the true costs. Leasing a brand new one with better fuel efficiency, no need to MOT, any faults covered under warranty so not for me to pay for, lower insurance costs... it worked out cheaper to lease a brand new car. So that is what I do now. And even better, the costs are fixed and entirely predictable and spread out, rather than getting slammed with a £2.5k bill unexpectedly because something is wrong with the electrics.

Male101 · 01/05/2023 13:39

thecatsthecats · 01/05/2023 12:35

I have run secondhand cars for the past 11 years.

The FULL cost - petrol, purchase, insurance, repairs, tax, aa membership etc - is £55/month. Be super generous and add a £25/month "my car broke down and I needed to get a taxi instead fund" (this has happened maybe three times in 11 years), and it's still £80/month.

And my current car still has years left in it, so that average will keep going down. It's my third car.

I do wish people wouldn't keep perpetuating the idea that secondhand cars aren't cheaper than lease cars. I think it scares young people off from dealing with repairs etc in an adult way, selling them the dream that for £200/month (not including petrol), you don't need to worry.

Agreed I've had 2 cars both £500 . One car lasted 5 years with nothing major going wrong ,the only reason it was scrapped was because the cost to to put through the mot £180ish. I wouldnt of gained anything by fixing it then selling it . I already had a 2nd car so I took the lazy route and scrapped it

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 13:25

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 01/05/2023 09:34

One of the reasons people want to go to bigger first properties now is because as a cohort, first time buyers are older than they used to be. It's fine buying a pokey one bed flat when you're 27. Less so when you're 34 and know you'll need to crack on soon if you want a family.

Also extortionate stamp duty!! I made this mistake, bought a smaller home with my ex-H as our first house. Then just a few years later we had to move for work. Then a few years after that we separated and sold up and I bought my current house. So in less than a decade I had spent £35,000 on stamp duty. It makes far more sense to stretch to buy a bigger property and not move, in many cases, now that stamp duty is so punitive even on smaller homes in more expensive areas.

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 13:22

Yes, there is affordable housing down the whole of the west coast of Scotland and similar in many similar cheaper areas of the uk. It might in many cases be characterless boxes, the weather is crap but there is a strong sense of community. My nieces 4 bed, terraced box cost around £100k. No idea what other nieces flat cost but just checked get area and they come in around £190k (which would buy my 3 bed detached which is 30 min drive to Glasgow off peak!)

My parents are not originally from this area but took the option available to everyone to move to where they could afford to raise a family and it is our home now. I couldnt afford many places in the UK so I don't expect to buy there.

That's great for you and your family. But many people have reasons why they cannot just go and live somewhere else: they need to be where they are for work, or to care for family, etc.

My point was that you can't hold up your unusual situation of living somewhere with unusually cheap property and pretend it's easy for young people to buy one. Your situation is not the norm.

Average first time buyer purchase in London now is almost £500k. For the UK as a whole excluding London it is £250k, so given some areas like yours are cheaper which brings the average down, for many people they will need £300k-£400k, for a first and modest home. The average age of a first time buyer in the UK is now 33. So don't present the very lucky situation in your area as the norm, that's all I am saying.

SunsetsInVenice · 01/05/2023 12:57

If you are single and living in London or near about areas and relying on one income it's incredibly difficult. My aunt back in the 90's was able to rent a flat on a one person fairly low income. Now she wouldn't have a chance.
People say 'Well go and rent a bedroom out in someone's house' but even that is ridiculous in terms of cost and means that you can't save in order to rent your own place or buy. It won't get any easier anytime soon either. Especially factoring in the cost of living, food prices, energy costs etc.
It's absurd to say that things have not become a hell of a lot harder. I know a lot of my female friends would probably still be at home if it wasn't for their high earning partners.

Mortimercat · 01/05/2023 12:44

MoroccanRoseHChurch · 30/04/2023 09:21

I think it’s double edged. If you’ve a wealthy mum and dad, you’ve likely got some start up cash available. You’ve ALSO got a role model. Someone who has trodden the path before you who you can aspire to. If your parents have never been to uni, never bought a house, you’ve not seen anyone do it. I’m projecting here because that was me and my brother. It was my best friend from school who pushed me out of minimum wage jobs and into University. But I had no idea that a bigger world existed out there.

In the end I was still £4k short for my first house, which my lovely DM and DF loaned me. So, yeah, I think most people have help.

So yeah, I think most people have help

So because your parents helped you, you think most people have help. Confused. No they don’t, they really don’t.

LBFseBrom · 01/05/2023 12:39

Yes, that is what people do. They also progress in their careers and start to earn more. The flat is a decent enough start on the ladder and if it is fairly modern, will be easier to maintain than a house; some of the maintenance comes out of service charge so the occupants can get on with their lives without worrying too much about that sort of thing.

thecatsthecats · 01/05/2023 12:35

I have run secondhand cars for the past 11 years.

The FULL cost - petrol, purchase, insurance, repairs, tax, aa membership etc - is £55/month. Be super generous and add a £25/month "my car broke down and I needed to get a taxi instead fund" (this has happened maybe three times in 11 years), and it's still £80/month.

And my current car still has years left in it, so that average will keep going down. It's my third car.

I do wish people wouldn't keep perpetuating the idea that secondhand cars aren't cheaper than lease cars. I think it scares young people off from dealing with repairs etc in an adult way, selling them the dream that for £200/month (not including petrol), you don't need to worry.

Camablanca · 01/05/2023 12:31

LBFseBrom · 01/05/2023 10:01

There are people in their thirties, sometimes with a small child, who have bought one bedroom flats and are happy about it. Their flat has increased in value, they are paying less on mortgage than they previously paid in rent and they realistically plan to move in a couple of years or less.

Increase in flat values don't actually help as the houses you want to buy will also be more expensive. Usually with a bigger increase than the flat. Unless you save up/earn more then buying it with a view to moving in under 2 years is very unrealistic.

Bear in mind also that moving is expensive and you'll have used up your first time buyer privilege. So have to pay stamp duty.

Of course the other side of the coin is, if your mortgage is much cheaper than rent this will enable you to do the hard save and move....

Wenfy · 01/05/2023 11:03

Cosyblankets · 01/05/2023 10:41

Fully agree with this. There are too many who want everything instantly. Phone contracts, lease cars, big house. My husband is saving at the min for a big purchase that he could easily get a loan for and have it now. But neither of us were brought up like that so it can wait. Phones can be sim only, cars can be second hand, house with 3 bedrooms and a garden with fake grass and grey Instagram look can wait.

I guess it depends on why you want something.

  1. For most young people a lease car often works out cheaper than buying a car, maintaining it, and insuring it. If you are self-employed a leasehold car can offset some of your tax. When you consider the costs of running a second hand car it’s rarely cheaper.
  2. Phone contracts if picked carefully can work out cheaper than if you buy a phone directly. You just need to shop around.
  3. A big house is an investment. 3/4/5 bed houses do increase in value faster than smaller houses /bigger houses - so I can understand why people work so damned hard to own one. Once you’re on the property ladder you definitely have more financial options in the UK.
  4. The OU is no longer the most cost effective option to get an online degree and in many non-accredited subjects it’s value is diminishing. In fact mostnbricks and mortar universities deliver better value for online studies now.
Cosyblankets · 01/05/2023 10:41

JustFrustrated · 30/04/2023 09:01

Nope. Disagree...

I imagine it is more difficult depending where you are in the country.

But I think the main thing that makes it hard, beyond costs, is people want things immediately. They're unwilling to go, grotty bedsit/small flat/small house/normal house/big house for example. They want to go from living at home to buying a 3 bedroom house with garden, whilst not changing their lifestyle. It seems this is the expectation (judging purely on what i see online/with younger colleagues etc)

I'm only 33 so not old. I, and DH, come from poverty - hiding from the provident man/not having 3 meals a day/shoes too small with holes in etc.and with that, the lower education chances, etc

Neither of us had or have any help from family, be that financial or meaningful childcare support.

But we've managed to buy a house, both of us worked full time whilst having young children and completed our degrees via open uni at the same time.

Maybe it is easier to sacrifice, if you never had anything that required sacrifice.

It wasn't easy at all, but it's doable. You have to cut your cloth.

Fully agree with this. There are too many who want everything instantly. Phone contracts, lease cars, big house. My husband is saving at the min for a big purchase that he could easily get a loan for and have it now. But neither of us were brought up like that so it can wait. Phones can be sim only, cars can be second hand, house with 3 bedrooms and a garden with fake grass and grey Instagram look can wait.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 01/05/2023 10:27

LBFseBrom · 01/05/2023 10:01

There are people in their thirties, sometimes with a small child, who have bought one bedroom flats and are happy about it. Their flat has increased in value, they are paying less on mortgage than they previously paid in rent and they realistically plan to move in a couple of years or less.

Interesting that you left out the word pokey there. If I'd meant one bed flat per se I'd have said that: after all, some one bed flats are very spacious, have their own gardens, may be quite luxurious. Naturally, these are liable to be more expensive than a pokey one bed flat in the same area, and as such first time buyers are more likely to be in the latter.

LBFseBrom · 01/05/2023 10:01

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 01/05/2023 09:34

One of the reasons people want to go to bigger first properties now is because as a cohort, first time buyers are older than they used to be. It's fine buying a pokey one bed flat when you're 27. Less so when you're 34 and know you'll need to crack on soon if you want a family.

There are people in their thirties, sometimes with a small child, who have bought one bedroom flats and are happy about it. Their flat has increased in value, they are paying less on mortgage than they previously paid in rent and they realistically plan to move in a couple of years or less.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 01/05/2023 09:34

One of the reasons people want to go to bigger first properties now is because as a cohort, first time buyers are older than they used to be. It's fine buying a pokey one bed flat when you're 27. Less so when you're 34 and know you'll need to crack on soon if you want a family.