Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bank of mum and dad

190 replies

squidwid · 30/04/2023 08:41

To think it's very hard to have it all, house, kids without the help of bank of mum and dad nowadays?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 02/05/2023 07:41

squidwid · 02/05/2023 07:27

@MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel oh no, that's awful. Why would you do that to your son. It's one thing making your own way - it's another when you risk illness from being cold.

PIL will openly say they support SIL as they worry about her more. She is the same as us, long term partner, good jobs, 2 kids, large house etc. But they are awful with money. I'm talking council tax debt, repossessed cars, MIL would order food shopping for SIL yet when we were really poor my friend 200 miles away posted me cartons of baby milk because we couldn't afford to buy any.

It hurt then, now I think it's made us stronger. We survived, we improved our situation and we did it on our own. SIL is 40 and still needs financial support from her parents.

squidwid · 02/05/2023 07:27

@MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel oh no, that's awful. Why would you do that to your son. It's one thing making your own way - it's another when you risk illness from being cold.

OP posts:
Beezknees · 01/05/2023 20:10

No bank of mum and dad here, I don't have a dad and my mum struggles for money herself. I live in a housing association flat, will never own a house unless I win some money.

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 20:03

Yes, management charges are a major issue. I've also got a friend who bought in Liverpool - management charges went up 50% in a year. Maintenance not done, hallways filthy, etc. She's in the middle of a protracted battle with the management company to contest it, but it's very difficult and expensive. There's very little regulation.

I don't think anybody sensible contemplates buying any property with "management charges" these days, it's well known to be a total rip off and mean your property is worth way less than one a comparable size without them, maybe 50% less if you calculate it properly.

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 01/05/2023 20:00

I think having any access to the bank of mum & dad is a tremendous privilege which most people don't have.

We worked hard, 3 kids, 2 cars, big house with zero help from parents. Not childcare, not emergency loans, nothing. We lived without heating for 2 years with a baby and a toddler as our heating broke and my inlaws are millionaires.

Granted, we will benefit when they die, but we are proud of getting no help. SIL always had access to the bank of mum & Dad which DH didn't, which was grating when we were freezing and they bought her a new car as hers was repossessed but it is what it is.

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 20:00

Kazzyhoward · 01/05/2023 19:35

@AlienEgg

(once new cars become more available again second hand prices are likely to drop significantly, back towards long-term trend levels, with much higher depreciation)

Not too sure they'll fall to be honest. There's quite a demand for "petrol" cars now that most manufacturers are moving over to hybrid or electric, which aren't suitable for lots of people for one reason or another, so I suspect demand for second hand petrol cars will remain high for several years.

I addressed that point in my posts.

Camablanca · 01/05/2023 19:55

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 01/05/2023 19:37

There are enormous problems with buying flats not-in-London that have bitten people on the arse.

One, cladding regulation changes meaning many cannot sell.

Two, increasing "management" charges. My friend in the NE was paying £150pcm on a £100k flat meaning her mortgage plus that was not, in fact, less than rent.

Three - Covid. Houses have increased less due to lack of outdoor space.

Yes, management charges are a major issue. I've also got a friend who bought in Liverpool - management charges went up 50% in a year. Maintenance not done, hallways filthy, etc. She's in the middle of a protracted battle with the management company to contest it, but it's very difficult and expensive. There's very little regulation.

But then again, there's very little 'need' to buy a flat outside London - if you're willing to live a bit further from anywhere you can get a 2 bed flat for a bit more. Unless you insist on living in the Cheshire Golden Triangle or whatever. But that's not a necessity if you can't afford it.

1offnamechange · 01/05/2023 19:53

Wenfy · 01/05/2023 16:02

Lol you made up numbers out of thin air. To get a good quality 2nd hand car that requires minimal garage costs you must pay at least 8-10k. Eg My 2nd hand car was 10k. Over 5 years just the purchase alone would be £166 + insurance is 45/mth. I can get a small 3-5 door run around, new, on lease for £200 and in many cases includes insurance

Agree that second hand cars have increased a lot recently but you are missing out the fact that if you get one in a good condition even after 5 years you should be able to sell it on/part exchange it for something.

So it's not 8-10k over 5 years if you get 2k for it afterwards.

I've also been lucky with 2nd hand cars in that I've always had them from family members so know they are in good nick and got a good price. It's always worked out much cheaper for me than renting.

But its horses for courses - different options are better depending on what individuals want, there's no absolute "best" solution.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 01/05/2023 19:49

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 01/05/2023 19:37

There are enormous problems with buying flats not-in-London that have bitten people on the arse.

One, cladding regulation changes meaning many cannot sell.

Two, increasing "management" charges. My friend in the NE was paying £150pcm on a £100k flat meaning her mortgage plus that was not, in fact, less than rent.

Three - Covid. Houses have increased less due to lack of outdoor space.

Er, flats have increased less. Not houses! Mistype.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 01/05/2023 19:37

There are enormous problems with buying flats not-in-London that have bitten people on the arse.

One, cladding regulation changes meaning many cannot sell.

Two, increasing "management" charges. My friend in the NE was paying £150pcm on a £100k flat meaning her mortgage plus that was not, in fact, less than rent.

Three - Covid. Houses have increased less due to lack of outdoor space.

Kazzyhoward · 01/05/2023 19:35

@AlienEgg

(once new cars become more available again second hand prices are likely to drop significantly, back towards long-term trend levels, with much higher depreciation)

Not too sure they'll fall to be honest. There's quite a demand for "petrol" cars now that most manufacturers are moving over to hybrid or electric, which aren't suitable for lots of people for one reason or another, so I suspect demand for second hand petrol cars will remain high for several years.

Kazzyhoward · 01/05/2023 19:32

We've been out looking for a car for our 21 year old who's just finishing Uni and will need a car for his new graduate job starting in the Summer. Found loads of decent cars under £10k that we'd be happy with. Including a 6 year old Ford Focus in immaculate condition, full service history and below average mileage for £8k - not a particularly nice colour, but our son doesn't care.

We also found a cracking little 15 year old car that was literally identical to my car - same age, same colour, same mileage, same full service history, for £2,750. Mine is still going strong, minimal service costs, immaculate as I've looked after it cosmetically and driven carefully. I confidently expect mine to last another 2 or 3 years, so son is seriously considering buying this identical one and taking a punt on it as he learned to drive in mine and currently uses it, so it's literally "like for like" for him and minimal cost!

Cars last an average 13 years at the moment, so anything under 6 or 7 years old is probably only half way through it's life, and a full service history and below average mileage will mean it's likely to last even longer and not need too much in the way of repairs, etc.

Just stay away from the big firms and main dealerships who are profiteering at the moment. Find some local independent reputable used car dealers - we've such a dealer in our village with about a dozen cars on his forecourt - we've lived in the village 26 years and he's been here all that time. Locals are happy to buy from him as he's trustworthy and knows he has a reputation to maintain.

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 18:56

The opposite in fact: a second hand car bought pre-Covid can currently be sold with little depreciation because of the shortage of new cars increasing second hand prices. So it's a very good time for second hand car owners to sell and lease instead (once new cars become more available again second hand prices are likely to drop significantly, back towards long-term trend levels, with much higher depreciation). And yes, very bad time for any new buyer to buy a second-hand car for the first time, because prices are sky high compared to norm. Trading from one second hand car to another won't make much difference as both are being sold/ purchased for much more than they are really "worth". But a PP who said young people who are looking for a first car should automatically think a second hand car is a better deal atm was totally wrong: they would pay an inflated price for it and take on a lot of risk plus opportunity cost in terms of upfront cash and leasing a new car might be far better for them.

I think a lot of these posts come from not understanding economics and so you get the "I have always done this and it works for me" posts without any comprehension of wider economic circumstances.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 01/05/2023 18:36

I can well believe a decent three year old car could be got for 3k in 2014, and that with careful maintenance it's still going. And a car having been bought before covid and lockdown completely revolutionised the second hand car market is a more likely explanation than someone lying.

However, it's not going to tell us anything much about the choices people face between used cars and leases now. The situation for people who are continuing to run second hand cars that they brought pre 2020 is very advantageous, yes, but also not one that continues to be available to new entrants.

thecatsthecats · 01/05/2023 17:09

Wenfy · 01/05/2023 16:02

Lol you made up numbers out of thin air. To get a good quality 2nd hand car that requires minimal garage costs you must pay at least 8-10k. Eg My 2nd hand car was 10k. Over 5 years just the purchase alone would be £166 + insurance is 45/mth. I can get a small 3-5 door run around, new, on lease for £200 and in many cases includes insurance

Actually, those are calculations based on real figures, and I didn't make them up.

It is extremely rude of you to say so.

My car is a 12yo Yaris, bought at 9yo with a full dealer service history and full MOT for £3100. I have spent £100 total on the last three MOTs. It's actually worth more now.

Don't be so bloody rude in future.

@Camablanca - no, not exactly. Figures provided above.

Plenty of people run cars this way.

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 17:07

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 17:05

Yes, it's better than it was. But has by no means kept up with inflation. See the figures I posted above about first time buyer properties. And those who then have a family and need to move to a larger home, now slammed with very high stamp duty on very modest sized properties in many areas. The first time buyer dispensation is quite new (in terms of years), and good. A few years ago even they had to pay the same rates as everyone else so a big whack of stamp duty to pay even on a small flat in many places. It disincentivises moving for work and therefore damages social mobility, too. A very regressive tax.

All tax thresholds should automatically be uprated with inflation. That would solve a lot of problems. But the tax system needs total overhaul as well, in general.

Sorry, this was to @Deadpalm

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 17:05

Yes, it's better than it was. But has by no means kept up with inflation. See the figures I posted above about first time buyer properties. And those who then have a family and need to move to a larger home, now slammed with very high stamp duty on very modest sized properties in many areas. The first time buyer dispensation is quite new (in terms of years), and good. A few years ago even they had to pay the same rates as everyone else so a big whack of stamp duty to pay even on a small flat in many places. It disincentivises moving for work and therefore damages social mobility, too. A very regressive tax.

All tax thresholds should automatically be uprated with inflation. That would solve a lot of problems. But the tax system needs total overhaul as well, in general.

Maray1967 · 01/05/2023 17:01

thecatsthecats · 01/05/2023 12:35

I have run secondhand cars for the past 11 years.

The FULL cost - petrol, purchase, insurance, repairs, tax, aa membership etc - is £55/month. Be super generous and add a £25/month "my car broke down and I needed to get a taxi instead fund" (this has happened maybe three times in 11 years), and it's still £80/month.

And my current car still has years left in it, so that average will keep going down. It's my third car.

I do wish people wouldn't keep perpetuating the idea that secondhand cars aren't cheaper than lease cars. I think it scares young people off from dealing with repairs etc in an adult way, selling them the dream that for £200/month (not including petrol), you don't need to worry.

Agreed. I saw a tv programme that claimed to be helping people struggling to sort out their budget. One episode featured a woman who was paying about £350 a month for her car. I waited - in vain - for the presenter to ask about the car payment. I’d just bought my 3 year old fiesta and had taken out a bank loan and was paying £135 for it. To me it was obvious where the pressure on the budget was coming from. There was no reason given for the purchase of a newer, bigger car - no long commute or anything. 4 years on, loan paid off, and my fiesta is still going great.

Deadpalm · 01/05/2023 17:00

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 16:15

Yep, stamp duty incurred by repeated moves can add up and will be part of the equation for some people. We know that fiscal drag applies here too.

The reality is that people wanting to buy a bigger home as their first purchase are responding to a very, very different set of incentives to someone who bought their first property years ago and was happy with a small flat.

Yes. The fiscal drag on stamp duty has been brutal, dragging many whom it was never intended to target into very high rates for very normal family homes. And I agree entirely, it's such a different landscape now in many parts of the country that people commenting on what they did even 20 years ago, or what their family are doing now in a cheap area, shows a huge lack of understanding of the costs in many areas now.

Stamp duty is currently on 250k which I think is quite solid. 425k for forat time buyer. Unless I remember numbers wrong

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 16:48

Citadel8 · 01/05/2023 16:10

I didn’t get any help but have helped my son a bit. Not excessively though. I can’t understand some people who lavish money on their kids when they haven’t secured their own financial future.

That's a very different mentality. We view family money as a legacy and the entire point of saving or obtaining assets is to secure future for future generations, and pass these down. Doing so earlier in life gives them a better chance at life, to secure their own financial security and safety and then save to provide for the next generation and so on, as well as passing down what is passed to them. With people living longer, receiving an inheritance in your 50s or 60s is not hugely helpful, people need help to get established in 20s or 30s, so many families design their lives that way so they can get children set up with a home for adult life etc. And can pursue careers without worry about a roof over their heads. The whole point of working hard is to give your children and their children more opportunities and less stress than you had, not to enrich yourself. For what? To lie on a death bed knowing you've a five or six figure sum in the bank while they've been struggling? I can't understand that mentality to money at all. Everything I've done and everything I work for is with a view to enriching my children's - and hopefully in the future granchildren's and great-grandchildren's l- lives long after I'm gone.

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 16:40

Cosyblankets · 01/05/2023 16:31

@AlienEgg my point about the phone contract was more about keeping the old one and going sim only when it runs out. Rather than buying another phone outright. I kept my last one for 2 or 3 years after the contract ran out and went right down to a £10 a month or something until the battery gave up and I'm now back to paying 50odd. But I saved loads changing to sim only

I'm confused, where did I comment on a phone contract?

I always do those SIM only also, much cheaper than "buying" a phone within a contract.

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 16:36

In answer to OP, yes, it is very hard. I managed to do it as have lots of friends (self-fund, buy a house etc). I'm a lone parent now paying a mortgage alone a huge childcare. It can be done, but it is not easy and required me spending teens and 20s working extremely hard: working while I did my education and qualifications to self-fund, working very long hours to build a career in my 20s while everyone else was out having fun or on holidays, to get to a point where I could do all of this on one salary and provide a good life for my children alone. I imagine it would be easier with two parents.

It's possible but very much harder than in our parents' generation, and it is grating when you hear them complain when they seem to have little clue that many houses where someone on average wages could sustain a family with a SAHP on one salary in the 80s/ 90s, now cost £3m+ and would be completely out of reach even for a professional couple both working full time. Who will also be slammed with another 9% tax each for student loans when parents got grants, and also have to pay as much as the mortgage again in childcare because no SAHP. And no final salary pensions to look forward to!

Life is very much harder now and a bit of acknowledgement of that from Boomers would go a long way I think.

Cosyblankets · 01/05/2023 16:31

@AlienEgg my point about the phone contract was more about keeping the old one and going sim only when it runs out. Rather than buying another phone outright. I kept my last one for 2 or 3 years after the contract ran out and went right down to a £10 a month or something until the battery gave up and I'm now back to paying 50odd. But I saved loads changing to sim only

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 16:26

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 01/05/2023 16:04

I think sometimes people don't realise what has happened to the cost of used cars since 2020.

Yes there's also that! Will be scewing the calculations atm. Can resell old ones for far more than usual because of the lack of supply. So it was a very good time to sell the second hand one I owned and lease one. Second hand values are unlikely to hold up so well in the future, unless whatever Government we have then does bring in the ban on new ICE vehicles from 2030. Although I can't see that happening tbh, given there will not be enough places to charge electric ones or indeed enough electricity capacity in the grid for people to do so at home. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Cosyblankets · 01/05/2023 16:21

AlienEgg · 01/05/2023 16:12

*My car is 8 years old. I've had it about 4 or 5 years. Cost me about 7k. Current value on we buy any car and other sites is about 5300.
My breakdown is £32 for the year.
I've just had to buy a new battery about £130 . Think I had 2 new tyres last year. That's all the money I've ever spent on it. Tax is £20 for the year. You won't convince me that paying 200 a month upwards is a better deal. I don't do a lot of miles as I wfh but my husband is in a similar position, his is about 10 years old and only now starting to cost a little in repairs. He does a lot more miles than me.

Why would I be trying to convince you? It's great that for you it's worked out cheaper that way. My point was that a previous post was asserting that people are wrong to think a leased, new car is more expensive than buying a second hand one, when this is not always the case. That fact it is cheaper in your particular circumstances doesn't make it cheaper for everyone, in some cases leasing can be cheaper and more predictable and less stressful, as my example demonstrated. The fact is that to work out what is better value people will need to do their own calculations based on their own circumstances.

I didn't necessarily mean you specifically. I've had cars on the Ford options deal if that's what it's called where you pay monthly and then pay a balloon payment or swap the car etc. Had a few of those but I they were at least 200 a month. If I had a job done on my car and it was 200 I would consider that a lot to pay out now. When I had the other cars I factored that in. I will keep this car until such time as it starts costing me money.