Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this homage to the King will go badly wrong?

559 replies

MRex · 30/04/2023 06:40

According to BBC news: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65435426

There are hopes that people will say out loud: "I swear that I will pay true allegiance to Your Majesty, and to your heirs and successors according to law. So help me God."

The Archbishop of Canterbury will then proclaim "God save the King", with all asked to respond: "God save King Charles. Long live King Charles. May the King live forever."

This is surely madness. Asking everyone in the Abbey - sure. People crowding nearby might be swayed to say "Hail the King" or something similarly short. But hoping for video footage of crowds in parks and pubs shouting a great long sentence that most don't fully buy into, then doing it again and with "live forever"! Does Charles really think he's liked that much? Is he? It doesn't seem very British at all, and seems destined to be a mess of people saying random stuff loudly.

The new photos were taken in the Blue Drawing Room at Buckingham Palace

Coronation: Public asked to swear allegiance to King Charles

The pledge is among several changes to the service, which will incorporate female clergy and other faiths.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65435426

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
BadgerB · 01/05/2023 11:29

Tangled123 · Today 10:54
I find the concept of a king/queen bizarre. Maybe in olden times when they led an army to defend people’s homes or something but definitely not now.

But isn't the whole point that it is anachronistic, mediaeval, and fancy*
As a medieval historian I am all in favour.

  • see what I did there?
BadgerB · 01/05/2023 11:20

rattymol · Today 09:50
@mainsfed the royalists are basically trying to detract attention from Charles by saying Diana was promiscuous.

Don't be ridiculous! Diana is presented as some kind of a saint in order to show Charles in a bad light. She was a normal young woman (girl even) who thought she was living in a Barbara Cartland fairy tale. Marry a Prince, happily ever after.

They were so different in every way it could never have worked in modern times.
Maybe would have in the past when kings and princes had their mistresses, and Queens pretended not to know. Like QE's parents, and great-grand-parents. I don't think her grandfather had a mistress - more interested in his stamp collection.

And I'm prepared to disparage members of our RF and our elected representatives when I feel they need it.

vera99 · 01/05/2023 11:18

Therese Coffey was also hung up on Oxford commas - apropos, of nothing.

rattymol · 01/05/2023 11:07

@Livingtothefull agreed. A narrative is being promoted that Charles, a 32 year old man, had no choice but to marry a 19 year old naive woman.
If he really had no choice it was an illegal forced marriage and Elizabeth and Philip broke the law.
But the truth is it was not a forced marriage. Charles wanted to marry a naive young woman who he thought would not object as he carried on seeing other women.

Outgrabe · 01/05/2023 11:04

Tangled123 · 01/05/2023 10:54

I find the concept of a king/queen bizarre. Maybe in olden times when they led an army to defend people’s homes or something but definitely not now. Like what has Charles physically done to deserve my allegiance? Then again, I don’t really understand celebrity/ influencer worship either and it’s a similar thing.

Did you not see Charles patrolling your area in hi-vis last night, like a Royal Vigilantes R Us member? After the coronation, he gets to wear a hi-vis crown too.

Tangled123 · 01/05/2023 10:54

I find the concept of a king/queen bizarre. Maybe in olden times when they led an army to defend people’s homes or something but definitely not now. Like what has Charles physically done to deserve my allegiance? Then again, I don’t really understand celebrity/ influencer worship either and it’s a similar thing.

determinedtomakethiswork · 01/05/2023 10:46

Sorry, I mean the comma is there to separate those two.

Outgrabe · 01/05/2023 10:44

determinedtomakethiswork · 01/05/2023 10:22

I think the Oxford comma is there to separate true allegiance and legal allegiance.

It’s not an Oxford comma! An Oxford comma is placed after the second-last item in a list of three or more items, before the final conjunction.

For example:

The coronation is expensive, anachronistic, and pointless.

or

The Cambridges have three children: George, Charlotte, and Louis.

determinedtomakethiswork · 01/05/2023 10:22

Xenia · 30/04/2023 06:42

I think they might have been better just leaving thing as they were for the previous monarch.

I have already been exercised by what I think is called an Oxford comma before the "and" which I really don't think should be there.

I think the Oxford comma is there to separate true allegiance and legal allegiance.

Livingtothefull · 01/05/2023 10:05

BadgerB · 01/05/2023 05:49

mainsfed · Yesterday 22:23
He committed adultery with her. Once a OW/OM, always a OW/OM.

In how many marriages was Diana the OW? But death apparently clears all guilt.

Charles should have been allowed to ask Camilla to marry him when they were both in their 20s, but she wasn't aristocratic enough - and had a bit of a wild reputation.

The Family learned their lesson. Both of Charles's sons married commoners. With mixed results....

Let's not bring Diana into this. It is neither here nor there what we think of her; you don't need to think she is blameless to believe Charles & Camilla behaved despicably. How about we just let her rest in peace? Diana died far too young and doesn't need to impress us any more; Charles and Camilla, on the other hand, do.

And what's all this about Charles not being 'allowed' to marry Camilla? He managed to assert himself OK when it came to promoting Camilla after Diana's death. I suppose you would think that Charles was forced into marrying Diana - a man in his 30s.

Yes Charles' sons married commoners - maybe after the Diana debacle they couldn't find any aristocrats who wanted to marry them. And yes the results are mixed - it is evident which is the happy and successful marriage and it is not the one in the UK.

mainsfed · 01/05/2023 09:54

rattymol · 01/05/2023 09:50

@mainsfed the royalists are basically trying to detract attention from Charles by saying Diana was promiscuous. It's the oldest trick in the book. Detract attention from a man by claiming a woman was easy.

Agreed. At least Diana went into her marriage with good intentions, when Charles did not, as he was in love with another woman and openly disparaging of the idea of being in love with Diana to the press.

rattymol · 01/05/2023 09:52

Charles ego is obviously so monstrous that I expect him to continually fuck up. He is going to constantly act as if he is far more important than he is.

rattymol · 01/05/2023 09:50

@mainsfed the royalists are basically trying to detract attention from Charles by saying Diana was promiscuous. It's the oldest trick in the book. Detract attention from a man by claiming a woman was easy.

mainsfed · 01/05/2023 09:39

BadgerB · 01/05/2023 08:47

The thread is about Charles and Camilla, why bring Diana in to it? In which marriage was the OW? And why you asking me?

Because you seem to think being the OW is unforgivable.
Here's Diana's list -
James Hewitt – 1986-1992
James Gilbey – 1989
Oliver Hoare – 1992 to 1994
Will Carling – 1995
Hasnat Khan - 1995 to 1997
Dodi Al Fayed - 1997

They weren't all married, but some were. Seem to remember Will Carling's wife made a fuss...

Harry and Meghan seem happy and committed to each other,
Well, he seems committed; her - not so much; following fame and money. He will soon be irrelevant. Now she has two royal children they'll be her "connection".

William got a super-injunction from the court to stop newspapers reporting on his alleged affair.
Really? How do you make that out, since the supposed "affair" never seems to have happened.

Again, why are you bringing Diana into it, when OP has just said again the thread is about Charles?

And why have you listed unmarried men at all? To try to portray Diana as promiscuous?

rattymol · 01/05/2023 09:26

Queen Elizabeth did not ask the public to do this. Charles has a monstrous ego.

cakeorwine · 01/05/2023 09:25

DonnaBanana · 01/05/2023 08:59

People slagging off all people who swear allegiance to the royal family are also denigrating our armed forces because they all swear allegiance.

They HAVE to swear allegiance.

I wonder how many people in the Armed Forces don't give a shit about the RF but swear allegiance because they have to or else they don't get in.

""I swear by almighty God that I will be faithful, and bear true allegiance to his Majesty King Charles III, his heirs and successors, and that I will as in duty bound, honestly and faithfully defend his Majesty, his heirs and successors in person, crown and dignity, against all enemies, and will observe and obey all orders of His Majesty, his heirs and successors and the generals and officers set over me.""

I guess that if you don't believe in God, then this allegiance doesn't matter.

dontgobaconmyheart · 01/05/2023 09:19

It would be laughable if it weren't so ridiculous.

I can't see how it would present any meaningful issue though - those who don't want to say it, won't, and the whole thing will carry on exactly as it always would. I have next to zero interest in the RF and hadn't ever even considered watching the coronation so just don't any investment really. I highly doubt there will be anti royalists disrupting the peace outside my house so expect to play the day our as I would any other. None of it is obligatory, and I'm fairness hasn't been advertised as being anything other than.

Whilst I don't wish ill on anyone, RF included. Charles is no spring chicken so you have to wonder how long he'll hold the throne anyway. In most of our lifetimes things will move on again in that respect.

rattymol · 01/05/2023 09:08

Makes me laugh. A thread about a ridiculous request for people to swear allegiance to Charles denigrates into slagging off the women instead. So many royalists do this. Pure misogyny.

MRex · 01/05/2023 09:01

The thread is about Charles and Camilla, why bring Diana in to it?
Actually it isn't about Charles and Camilla either. This thread is about Charles's egotistical desire for the whole country to recite long statements. I definitely agree to leave Diana out of it though. There's bound to be a thread or two about Diana and Camilla for those who find such debate interesting, but personally I have no interest in who this set of people shag or have shagged. I'm only interested in the potential for farce with crowds shouting random stuff at screens.

OP posts:
DonnaBanana · 01/05/2023 08:59

People slagging off all people who swear allegiance to the royal family are also denigrating our armed forces because they all swear allegiance.

BadgerB · 01/05/2023 08:47

The thread is about Charles and Camilla, why bring Diana in to it? In which marriage was the OW? And why you asking me?

Because you seem to think being the OW is unforgivable.
Here's Diana's list -
James Hewitt – 1986-1992
James Gilbey – 1989
Oliver Hoare – 1992 to 1994
Will Carling – 1995
Hasnat Khan - 1995 to 1997
Dodi Al Fayed - 1997

They weren't all married, but some were. Seem to remember Will Carling's wife made a fuss...

Harry and Meghan seem happy and committed to each other,
Well, he seems committed; her - not so much; following fame and money. He will soon be irrelevant. Now she has two royal children they'll be her "connection".

William got a super-injunction from the court to stop newspapers reporting on his alleged affair.
Really? How do you make that out, since the supposed "affair" never seems to have happened.

mainsfed · 01/05/2023 08:08

BadgerB · 01/05/2023 05:49

mainsfed · Yesterday 22:23
He committed adultery with her. Once a OW/OM, always a OW/OM.

In how many marriages was Diana the OW? But death apparently clears all guilt.

Charles should have been allowed to ask Camilla to marry him when they were both in their 20s, but she wasn't aristocratic enough - and had a bit of a wild reputation.

The Family learned their lesson. Both of Charles's sons married commoners. With mixed results....

The thread is about Charles and Camilla, why bring Diana in to it? In which marriage was the OW? And why you asking me?

Both of Charles's sons married commoners. With mixed results....

Yes, Harry and Meghan seem happy and committed to each other, whereas William got a super-injunction from the court to stop newspapers reporting on his alleged affair. Mixed results indeed.

emanresu000 · 01/05/2023 07:46

Perhaps giving the people the opportunity to voluntarily pledge their allegiance to the monarch and his heirs, rather than assuming that allegiance is quite a significant gesture from the King to his subjects.

BadgerB · 01/05/2023 05:49

mainsfed · Yesterday 22:23
He committed adultery with her. Once a OW/OM, always a OW/OM.

In how many marriages was Diana the OW? But death apparently clears all guilt.

Charles should have been allowed to ask Camilla to marry him when they were both in their 20s, but she wasn't aristocratic enough - and had a bit of a wild reputation.

The Family learned their lesson. Both of Charles's sons married commoners. With mixed results....

CelestiaNoctis · 01/05/2023 02:01

*they're