Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this homage to the King will go badly wrong?

559 replies

MRex · 30/04/2023 06:40

According to BBC news: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65435426

There are hopes that people will say out loud: "I swear that I will pay true allegiance to Your Majesty, and to your heirs and successors according to law. So help me God."

The Archbishop of Canterbury will then proclaim "God save the King", with all asked to respond: "God save King Charles. Long live King Charles. May the King live forever."

This is surely madness. Asking everyone in the Abbey - sure. People crowding nearby might be swayed to say "Hail the King" or something similarly short. But hoping for video footage of crowds in parks and pubs shouting a great long sentence that most don't fully buy into, then doing it again and with "live forever"! Does Charles really think he's liked that much? Is he? It doesn't seem very British at all, and seems destined to be a mess of people saying random stuff loudly.

The new photos were taken in the Blue Drawing Room at Buckingham Palace

Coronation: Public asked to swear allegiance to King Charles

The pledge is among several changes to the service, which will incorporate female clergy and other faiths.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65435426

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
17
Blossomtoes · 07/05/2023 18:14

CriticalAlert · 07/05/2023 13:41

You are so right! Along came Thatcher with the ethos that the working class had had it too good for too long! The Tories are now eating us alive.

That wasn’t Thatcher’s ethos at all. Her aim was to turn the working class into Tories by bribing them with the chance to buy council houses at knock down prices and urging them to buy shares in the public services she sold off.

Earlydancing · 07/05/2023 14:42

Out of interest, did the homage go badly wrong yesterday?

Earlydancing · 07/05/2023 14:38

Slimmed down monarchy hasn't appeared and if it does , it will not mean less money taken by the Windsors
Just more money for a smaller group

But that's because the money that's given in the sovereign grant doesn't go to pay any wages. It goes on things that would still have to be paid for no matter who was in charge. Like upkeep of buildings and hosting and entertaining.

derxa · 07/05/2023 14:19

nd you didn't need a load of stuff to be happy. I basically had a free university education Well people seem to need a lot of stuff to be happy now. Keir isn't going to give people a free university education either.

CriticalAlert · 07/05/2023 13:41

vera99 · 07/05/2023 12:01

Remember them - I saw them and was a bit of a punk and trot back then, derxa. So no change there. I took part in 1977 Stuff the Jubilee and still have my badge ! But it was a lot easier to muddle along, drop in or out if you wanted to, cheap rents, squatting was a thing, and you didn't need a load of stuff to be happy. I basically had a free university education from lower middle class parents and dole in the holidays was there to be had and could buy a studio flat in Eastbourne for 2x my salary. Rock against Racism gigs, the GLC Red Ken - happy daze. Then came Thatcher .....

You are so right! Along came Thatcher with the ethos that the working class had had it too good for too long! The Tories are now eating us alive.

BadgerB · 07/05/2023 12:30

SinnerBoy · Today 12:06
Queenie didn't and Chucky certainly hasn't.

Any argument that feels the need to use name-calling can't be worth even considering...

Novella4 · 07/05/2023 12:25

@Hollyhead

Slimmed down monarchy hasn't appeared and if it does , it will not mean less money taken by the Windsors
Just more money for a smaller group

I'm sure people on working on it now
At least I hope so !
The monarchy can stay if people want that .Just separate it from our democracy and no more money.
I think the Windsors would walk first once the money stops
The House of Lords need reformed
Let an elected person rubber stamp laws - rather than letting the Windsors have a look to see what they exclude themselves from before letting it all apply to the rest of us
I mean , it's a mockery what they get away with

If they were subject to the law and paid all their taxes that would be a start

Hollyhead · 07/05/2023 12:15

@Novella4 well I’ve got more left wing with age so that doesn’t necessarily come in to it.
Based on facts, a slimmed down monarchy - which I think Charles will start, is still my preference over making constitutional changes based on emotion, which is what we did on Brexit and look where that got us.

SinnerBoy · 07/05/2023 12:06

sashagabadon · Today 10:59

Under 45’s grow up though and start to value duty and service

Oh god, not the duty and service, they work so hard and just think, if we got rid of them, we could get President Boris schtick!

They're massively over privileged, with vast amounts of unearned wealth. They're born with hot and cold running lackeys and none of them lift a finger, even if they do shake hands with Mugabe etc.

Aside from anything else, they don't stay out of politics, Queenie didn't and Chucky certainly hasn't. They've had a veto on what the BCC could say about them in the behatment rigmarole.

vera99 · 07/05/2023 12:01

derxa · 07/05/2023 11:54

Like you I grew up in the 60's and 70's. It certainly wasn't the land of milk and honey that you portray. Don't you remember the Sex Pistols?

Remember them - I saw them and was a bit of a punk and trot back then, derxa. So no change there. I took part in 1977 Stuff the Jubilee and still have my badge ! But it was a lot easier to muddle along, drop in or out if you wanted to, cheap rents, squatting was a thing, and you didn't need a load of stuff to be happy. I basically had a free university education from lower middle class parents and dole in the holidays was there to be had and could buy a studio flat in Eastbourne for 2x my salary. Rock against Racism gigs, the GLC Red Ken - happy daze. Then came Thatcher .....

derxa · 07/05/2023 11:54

vera99 · 07/05/2023 11:44

62 and I can remember at school arguing against the monarchy way back then. Quite a bit of the residual support is tied up with affection for the timeless Queen of whom most people knew no other, and she never put a foot wrong publically. She rode the wave of post-war austerity to post-war prosperity, where most people could expect a good job, a house, a pension, good free education at all levels, peace and an NHS that was there for them. The monarchy was a luxury item that seemed to go with that package.

These are very different times now and if we as a society can't get the same for our younger generation then they will increasingly be seen as a luxury that we can't afford and at jarring odds with who we have become.

Like you I grew up in the 60's and 70's. It certainly wasn't the land of milk and honey that you portray. Don't you remember the Sex Pistols?

Novella4 · 07/05/2023 11:46

@Hollyhead

That thinking is out of date

The younger generation is not experiencing the same secure steady increase in standard of living
We have more information now and from different sources

It is wrong to say the young will become conservative

vera99 · 07/05/2023 11:44

62 and I can remember at school arguing against the monarchy way back then. Quite a bit of the residual support is tied up with affection for the timeless Queen of whom most people knew no other, and she never put a foot wrong publically. She rode the wave of post-war austerity to post-war prosperity, where most people could expect a good job, a house, a pension, good free education at all levels, peace and an NHS that was there for them. The monarchy was a luxury item that seemed to go with that package.

These are very different times now and if we as a society can't get the same for our younger generation then they will increasingly be seen as a luxury that we can't afford and at jarring odds with who we have become.

Rockybooboo · 07/05/2023 11:06

sashagabadon · 07/05/2023 10:59

Under 45’s grow up though and start to value duty and service, I was anti monarchy in my teens and twenties now pro monarchy.

I've gone the opposite way. I see the monarchy as the opposite of duty and service.

Hollyhead · 07/05/2023 11:02

I never think the under 45s stat is very worthwhile to be honest. I would have said I opposed the monarchy aged 14-25ish. It’s only as I learned about the system that I realised some of the arguments for it despite some of the flaws. And there’s no stronger argument against an elected president than Boris Johnson, who is exactly the kind of president the British would elect. Stephen Fry summed it up beautifully yesterday when he said the king is for everyone and no one, a president is always only the half of the people - those who elected them.

sashagabadon · 07/05/2023 10:59

Under 45’s grow up though and start to value duty and service, I was anti monarchy in my teens and twenties now pro monarchy.

vera99 · 07/05/2023 09:05

Xenia · 07/05/2023 08:50

I did watch it but cannot remember what was changed so glad I read this thread today. I think I remember words like if you want to say .... Anyway I chose not to say it (thinking it was the original oath).

It is a long time since we have believed in the divine right of Kings in the UK. I am a royalist (as are 75% of people in the UK) because they give us a stability and bind us together. However I did not give the suggested oath - not least because the service is very much protestantism (I am a Catholic) as indeed, largely, is the history of the monarchy since Henry VIII and the oath was voluntary and just a suggestion that if you want to give it do so.

We have kept our royals in the UK since the Russians got rid of theirs in about 1914 and despite a huge swing to the left after WWII, because they have no effective power and do not impose their own political views - that is how it has worked in my view for the last 100 years - they are indeed in a sense our servants as King Charles and the service made clear yesterday.

Woah 62% actually and less than half of the under 45s.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/863893/support-for-the-monarchy-in-britain-by-age/

Support for the monarchy Britain 2023, by age | Statista

Although the British monarchy is supported by a plurality of people across most age groups in Great Britain, it is among over 65 year-old's where the level is support is highest at 79 percent.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/863893/support-for-the-monarchy-in-britain-by-age

Xenia · 07/05/2023 08:50

I did watch it but cannot remember what was changed so glad I read this thread today. I think I remember words like if you want to say .... Anyway I chose not to say it (thinking it was the original oath).

It is a long time since we have believed in the divine right of Kings in the UK. I am a royalist (as are 75% of people in the UK) because they give us a stability and bind us together. However I did not give the suggested oath - not least because the service is very much protestantism (I am a Catholic) as indeed, largely, is the history of the monarchy since Henry VIII and the oath was voluntary and just a suggestion that if you want to give it do so.

We have kept our royals in the UK since the Russians got rid of theirs in about 1914 and despite a huge swing to the left after WWII, because they have no effective power and do not impose their own political views - that is how it has worked in my view for the last 100 years - they are indeed in a sense our servants as King Charles and the service made clear yesterday.

OP posts:
EmmaGrundyForPM · 07/05/2023 05:34

I didn't see any of the news coverage, did people do the swearing allegiance thing?

Coxspurplepippin · 06/05/2023 17:05

QueenMegan, don't you have a birthday party to prepare for? Thought you'd be making fairy bread and cornflake crispies rather than hanging around disparaging a royal family that don't impact you one iota.

vera99 · 06/05/2023 16:57

I found the Archbishop kneeling at him a bit much and don't get me on Camilla.

QueenMegan · 06/05/2023 16:50

Outgrabe · 03/05/2023 16:20

And yet it didn’t require modern media for it be be generally known that Edward VII was a spendthrift, irresponsible playboy with an estimated 55 documented liaisons with everyone from actresses to prostitutes, numerous I acknowledged children, and almost called as co-respondent in a high-profile divorce case. He died in 1910 so most of the men who went to fight in WW1 would have lived through his reign. Not to mention his son having to change the family surname and for them to give up all German titles to placate anti-German feeling during the war.

Hardly much ‘mystery’.

If that's true surely some of his prodigy would be up selling their stories by now. Claiming their ancestry.

QueenMegan · 06/05/2023 16:47

I'll call you old fashioned. So bloody what. So many people work in the front line of professions changing lives making lives better. Turning up for the odd event so he should.

QueenMegan · 06/05/2023 16:44

Look it won't go horribly wrong if the British people stop thinking such an outdated institution has any relevance in the modern world. It's cute and twee but really just no longer fit for purpose.
The figures bandied around about all they do for the economy is utterly inflated compared to their cost. Besides we don't them all. They have a dangerous sense of self importance that's not fair on anyone especially them. Look at how immoral they have behaved over the years The poor Queen God bless her she couldnt even retire and worked right up to her death out of duty.

Swipe left for the next trending thread