Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell auntie that my mum is dying

82 replies

Busybeezs · 30/04/2023 01:36

My dad has one brother. Both met their wives when they were all teens and are all still married now. Dad and uncle have a very explosive relationship and regularly have major bust ups and fall outs. Neither marriage is happy. Mum and auntie (related by marriage) have sustained a near 50 year friendship throughout this and have never let the (very difficult and unpleasant men) impact their relationship.

My dad and uncle had a major, major falling out about 2 years/18m ago. I have no idea what happened but it in some way involved my cousin (uncles son) and following this, my mum stopped hearing from my auntie. After about 6 months, my mum rang my auntie to see if they were still friends and it turns out my uncle and dad were involving cousin (male, 40s) in their arguments and it was taking a toll on cousins MH. as a result, auntie went NC with my entire family - though she did not say this explicitly. When my mum called, auntie expressed relief that they could stay in touch and they had a great talk, and said she would call.my mum soon
... but never has. My mum understood and respected that auntie is just looking out for her son but I know she is hurt That she is collateral damage due to the behaviour of two grown men.

In the past year, my mum has been diagnosed with stage 4 cancer and may have only between 6m and 2years left, depending on how palliative treatment works, but honestly she isn't fully cognisant of this and still thinks they will be able to cure it. She has said she wants as few people to know what's going on as possible as she's embarrassed at how ill she is and wants to get better.

My AIBU - should I tell my auntie what's going on and give her the opportunity to call.my mum 'out of the blue' and reestablish their relationship while.mum is still around? I want to be respectful of both of their boundaries, but I have a horrible feeling my auntie will be left feeling regret. Although I run the risk of overstepping by contacting my auntie, I worry that not giving her the opportunity might also hurt her. It also.makes me sad to think my mum is dying and thinks one of her oldest and closest friends doesn't care about her. If auntie declines to make contact, mum is none the wiser and I have a clear conscience.

YABU - NC is NC, keep out of it
YANBU - surely she deserves to know so she can make an informed decision

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
19lottie82 · 02/05/2023 13:23

My Mum was NC with her Sister. I struggled with this exact same dilemma when she was diagnosed with terminal cancer. I decided to just leave it, I don’t think my Mum would have appreciated me going behind her back.

can you speak to your mum about your auntie and suggest she gets back in touch?

LaMaG · 02/05/2023 13:19

How is your relationship with your Aunt? Its always the case when people fall out it trickles to the next generation. I think maybe you should contact your aunt and try to reconnect with her. Your mum may not encourage this but she can't tell you who you may contact. If your aunt enquires after your mum you could suggest she calls herself and leave the rest to your mum. Likewise when mum hears you have been chatting to aunt she might want to reconnect too. I think it would be a 'gentle nudge' rather than interfering. Sorry about your mum and your idiot dad.

Chezza2502 · 02/05/2023 13:07

I can say what I friggin want to say...I feel so yeah if that makes me Mystic Meg then so be it you waste of space, if you can't understand what figure of speech is then that's your problem.

Conkersinautumn · 01/05/2023 19:41

No way. If your mum wanted to she would reach out. This would be a massive overstep on your part

feellikeanalien · 01/05/2023 19:37

I lost DP to cancer almost three years ago. The only member of his family that he was still in touch with was his sister but that was very sporadic and she would often not be in contact for months or even years.

I asked him if he wanted me to tell her and he was certain that he did not want her to know. There was a very short time between diagnosis and his death and I think he had enough difficulty trying to cope with the situation himself without his sister knowing. His view was that she would just create more drama. He was going through so much without also having to deal with the fact that I would have been going against his wishes. Maybe ask your mum if she would like you to get in touch but if she says no then you should respect her wishes.

I had felt that DPs sister would want to know but in the end it was down to him. His family also had a lot of family drama and he just couldn't cope with it. Maybe your mum feels the same.

GoodChat · 01/05/2023 19:14

Willmafrockfit · 01/05/2023 12:38

you could tell your aunty but swear her to secrecy, explain why

Secrets like that will never stay secret. Someone will slip up at some point.

thecatsthecats · 01/05/2023 12:45

phishfoodforlife · 30/04/2023 07:04

The absolute most you should do is contact your Aunty and say your mum would love to hear from her. Do not tell her about your mum's illness! That's a massive breach of trust and I'd be furious.

This.

Can't believe people are advocating breaching the mother's trust in this way, it's absolutely horrible.

It's demeaning to think that her wishes don't matter, like she's a child, because of her diagnosis.

Let her come to terms with it OP - and come to terms with it yourself - rather than playing God with your family relationships and potentially ruing the last months of your mum's life.

Willmafrockfit · 01/05/2023 12:38

you could tell your aunty but swear her to secrecy, explain why

HowDoYouDoWhatYouDoToMeIWishIKnew · 01/05/2023 12:27

I currently have cancer.

I can't control it, I can't control what's happening to me, the side effects, the impact on my dc, there's very little about this whole situation I have any control over at all.

If someone took it upon themselves to override the small amount of say I have about my own situation I would be furious, even if it was with the best intentions in the world.

It's my health, my life, my cancer and my story to tell, to who I choose, when I choose.

Please don't do this without your mum's express permission.

Merchantadventurer · 01/05/2023 12:15

Fraaahnces · 01/05/2023 05:09

Definitely tell your auntie. Your mum obviously needs and wants to speak to her. Sounds like she misses her terribly.

Sorry to pick on this one message to highlight my point but it was one of the more recent …

If OP’s mum needed and wanted to speak to her SIL then she can do it herself or ask someone to do it for her if she isn’t able. She has cancer - she hasn’t lost her mental capacity (I assume or the OP would have said).

can people please not make decisions for people just because they are ill!

autienotnaughtym · 01/05/2023 07:12

My mother died of cancer 4 years ago. She didn't want anyone on dads side to know (partly due to feeling embarrassed about being ill and partly a slight fu because they snubbed her once ten year's previous. ) she also didn't want friends /work Colleagues etc to know. So literally the only people who knew were her two children, husband, sister, brother and her best friend. 6 people. We respected her wishes but invited everyone to the funeral and explained she was a very private person.

snitzelvoncrumb · 01/05/2023 05:15

If you think your mother wants to be in contact with her then I would mention it. But if not just leave it. Your aunts feelings shouldn’t be taken in to consideration.

Fraaahnces · 01/05/2023 05:09

Definitely tell your auntie. Your mum obviously needs and wants to speak to her. Sounds like she misses her terribly.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 30/04/2023 10:23

GuevarasBeret · 30/04/2023 07:06

Why has no one ever told you Dad to stop being such a cunt.

How dare he and his brother cause so much upset over years and decades.
How dare he ruin your mothers friendship.

Tell him to get to fuck, and to stop being an arrogant prick.
Preferably do this whilst his brother is there to get the same message.

Absolutely agree with this. Your dad and his brother are a pair of selfish old men who should leave the childish behaviour in the past, where it belongs.
But you already know this. Whatever you do op you’re damned, these two would turn it all round on you.
I can imagine this happening.: your dad.“ Not your place to tell her”
Your Uncle, “Why didn’t you tell us she was so ill, Mary is so upset, I’ll never forgive you for not letting her say goodbye” And so the dramas continue.
I’d ask mum if she’d want her sister in law to know.
I know someone like them, she thrives on the drama, loves causing grief and the sad thing is she’s got her daughter involved, she’s turning out to be just like her mother. I will never forgive them for the way they treated my sister when she had terminal cancer, or the way they behaved at her funeral. Cunts the pair of them.

ClematisWren · 30/04/2023 10:17

You mum is an adult and you need to respect her feelings about wanting to keep her diagnosis private, even if that makes it harder for you, even if you think she is wrong.

It sounds as though she is still in the process of coming to terms with her prognosis, which is often a gradual thing. Years of work in palliative care have taught me that denial is a powerful and necessary coping mechanism for many people. Breaking her confidence could force her to deal with complicated feelings before she is ready, which could be harmful to her mental health, over and above the painful loss of trust in you that she may experience if you share her sensitive medical information.

Why not have a conversation with her and ask whether she would like your help to get back in contact with Aunt? That way you've raised the issue, but treated her respectfully and maintained her dignity.

I would recommend reading 'With the End in Mind' by Kathryn Mannix, which discusses these issues much more eloquently than I am managing!
💐for you OP, it's really hard when someone becomes very unwell and there are complicated family dynamics. My FIL died without any of his siblings even having known he was unwell, due to a painful family fall-out, so I do know something of what you are going through.

MILLYmo0se · 30/04/2023 10:16

Do not take away the little bit of control your mum has over her life and her decisions around her illness. Its a terribly sad situation for the friendship to be in, but you cant ignore her specially stated wishes.

longtompot · 30/04/2023 10:08

gavisconismyfriend · 30/04/2023 09:40

If you tell your aunty, won’t she also tell your uncle? Surely that could cause all kinds of things to kick off and you might then be the bad guy in it all, with everybody cross with you? Maybe better to be open with your mum - “mum, if aunty had cancer again I think you’d really want to know, so would you like me to tell her you’re unwell?” If your mum says no then you need to respect that. It is nice that you’re thinking of your aunty’s feelings but this really should be about your mum.

I voted yanbu but I think this might be the best way to go about it.

I am so sorry about your mum💐

MRex · 30/04/2023 10:02

I wouldn't disclose specifics, but call your auntie and tell her mum really needs a friend at the moment. If she still chooses not to, then she can deserve the guilt.

Tumbler2121 · 30/04/2023 09:56

Also .. maybe your mum had been embarrassed to tell you that she's tried to keep friendship going and it hasn't worked ..

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 30/04/2023 09:52

Honestly what do you think is better for your Mum? Not seeing your Aunt or the predictable family drama. Personally I would leave it.

SnoozeToMe · 30/04/2023 09:46

I would be so upset that you went against my wishes and did this. I would probably be very careful what I told you in the future.

GoodChat · 30/04/2023 09:42

After reading the opinions of people in the same position as your DM, I've changed my mind. I think you should take their thoughts on board and respect your DM's feelings.

gavisconismyfriend · 30/04/2023 09:40

If you tell your aunty, won’t she also tell your uncle? Surely that could cause all kinds of things to kick off and you might then be the bad guy in it all, with everybody cross with you? Maybe better to be open with your mum - “mum, if aunty had cancer again I think you’d really want to know, so would you like me to tell her you’re unwell?” If your mum says no then you need to respect that. It is nice that you’re thinking of your aunty’s feelings but this really should be about your mum.

CornishTiger · 30/04/2023 09:36

You need to ask your mum. It’s that simple. Would you like me to talk to Aunty X and see if I can broker some kind of contact. She was your friend for so many years and both of you have put your husbands first out of loyalty but your friendship still remains.

slowquickstep · 30/04/2023 09:31

Do it before it is too late and while you are at it tell your Father to grow up. I couldn't forgive my Father if he had made my Mums life hell.

Swipe left for the next trending thread