Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is time to quash all convictions for all convicted witches in the UK

88 replies

duvetcovereddissident · 29/04/2023 20:13

Around 3500 executions, and many thousands more tortured and convicted after "confessing" - more than 90% of them women. Most of these in the 1600s.

These are women convicted on evidence such as loving their cats, and having hairy chins.

AIBU to say all these convictions should be quashed. It would have mattered to those who were convicted, and it matters as an illustration of the way our country has treated women, and still does, in allowing these convictions to stand.

OP posts:
YouWonJayne · 29/04/2023 22:30

Blamunge · 29/04/2023 22:26

People who can do magic don’t exist. Some people like to call themselves witches because it floats their boat. I could call myself a unicorn but it wouldn’t make me a horse with a magical horn. Because unicorns, and real witches, don’t exist.

You do realise you’re insulting people’s religion now don’t you? AFAIK Unicorn isn’t a religion.

homeeddingwitch · 29/04/2023 22:27

ChopperC110P · 29/04/2023 22:12

Witches do exist. Witch comes from Wicca, and Wiccan is a religion in which its practitioners call themselves witches. They often say “white witch” to let the ignorant know that just like Glinda in Oz, white witches are GOOD, not evil.

I agree. The word witch is derived from the word wicca which also has roots in the word wizard and the word wise.
Witches do exist in the pagan tradition. A witch is a wise woman who is in tune with and worships nature. Unfortunately the word has been associated with satanism and devil worship (probably started back in 1600s), mainly by men who wanted to control and manipulate in the name of religion.

OP I see what you’re saying and I think it would be lovely but like others have said, there are probably more prsssing matters. I think some of us really feel the ‘witch wound’ (misogyny) more than others though so I can see how you feel so passionately about this x

Blamunge · 29/04/2023 22:26

ChopperC110P · 29/04/2023 22:12

Witches do exist. Witch comes from Wicca, and Wiccan is a religion in which its practitioners call themselves witches. They often say “white witch” to let the ignorant know that just like Glinda in Oz, white witches are GOOD, not evil.

People who can do magic don’t exist. Some people like to call themselves witches because it floats their boat. I could call myself a unicorn but it wouldn’t make me a horse with a magical horn. Because unicorns, and real witches, don’t exist.

PumpkinQueen1 · 29/04/2023 22:23

I don't think that convictions for witchcraft from the 1600s should be quashed.

The witchcraft trials are an important part of our history, and serve as a reminder of the misogyny and horrors that women have faced.

Women's rights have come a long way since then, but not far enough, and we need to remember how far we have come, in order to progress.

Although there were men accused of Witchcraft, the vast majority were women.

https://www.english-heritage.org.uk/learn/histories/eight-witchcraft-myths/

Witchcraft: Eight Myths and Misconceptions

Witchcraft is an area of history that most people feel familiar with. The problem is that most of what we think we know is wrong. Professor Diane Purkiss debunks eight of the most common myths about witchcraft.

https://www.english-heritage.org.uk/learn/histories/eight-witchcraft-myths

Knittingisacraptherapy · 29/04/2023 22:22

Well, speaking as a card carrying hedgewitch, most other witches I know don't give a rat's arse about 'pardons', we just potter on under the wire the way we've always done for generations.

The ones over the wire are probably Gardnerians (Gerald Gardener devotees) the nouveau cult that came into being when witchcraft was decriminalised in 1951 in England. Total nutters.

However, that aside, I'm more concerned about Bible thumping christians who believe every word and base their lives on its 'teachings'. I've had some very interesting chats with them on how far they'd be willing to go with Exodus 22:18. Don't worry about looking it up, it's 'suffer not a witch to live'. :-)

ChopperC110P · 29/04/2023 22:12

KrisAkabusi · 29/04/2023 22:04

You say (and I agree) that we know there are no such things as witches. But hundreds of women on this site believe that there are! Look at the number of people on threads over the years that have said they have been to visit "white witches". And fortune tellers, psychics, etc.

Witches do exist. Witch comes from Wicca, and Wiccan is a religion in which its practitioners call themselves witches. They often say “white witch” to let the ignorant know that just like Glinda in Oz, white witches are GOOD, not evil.

polkadotdalmation · 29/04/2023 22:09

OfAllThePeopleWhyDoIHaveToBeMe · 29/04/2023 21:38

Op, I agree. Late justice is better than no justice.

I agree with what you said that many of those women would have hoped to clear their name.

However, it would also benefit is now. All of us who would like to live in a civilised, just country.

It would be a reminder how important it is that we have rights to protect us against the arbitrary power of the state.

A very timely reminder at a time when too many people are too willing to give up those rights.

Clear their name? Who the hell do you think believes they're actually guilty?

Utter waste of money even if they could do it for £10

BibbleandSqwauk · 29/04/2023 22:08

Witch trials are one option on A level syllabi now; it's an increasingly popular theme of novels; someone (sorry can't recall who) has recently written a really interesting sounding book, reviewed in the Times about how the "Karen" thing is the 21st century version of witches, the demonisation of powerful, or at least capable, confident women over 25. Why don't we invest resources in eradicating that? Over on another thread, I and a few others have been battling a really unpleasant little man about the fact that single mothers are by and large screwed over and demonised. I'd love to see more light shone on that than a 400 year old issue that there's no real debate over.

polkadotdalmation · 29/04/2023 22:07

And everyone knows they were innocent women anyway

polkadotdalmation · 29/04/2023 22:06

Why do you think it'll make any difference to them?

No idea why people want to rewrite far off history

KrisAkabusi · 29/04/2023 22:04

Luredbyapomegranate · 29/04/2023 20:28

Well I’m not sure a blanket pardon would be meaningless, on account of we now know witches don’t exist, so none of them were guilty of causing harm via magic. Which also means there is nothing for anyone to investigate.

You say (and I agree) that we know there are no such things as witches. But hundreds of women on this site believe that there are! Look at the number of people on threads over the years that have said they have been to visit "white witches". And fortune tellers, psychics, etc.

SparklyLeprechaun · 29/04/2023 21:55

BashfulClam · 29/04/2023 21:50

It’s been done in Scotland.

Not quite, they only issued an apology. I remember rolling my eyes when Nicola offered the apology, Russia had just invaded Ukraine and there were fierce battles reported all over the news and she had nothing better to do than this.

ChopperC110P · 29/04/2023 21:53

The word you are looking for is exonerated.
I think it’s a pointless waste of time and virtue signalling nonsense.
It’s not going to make any difference to women murdered 400yrs ago that we are saying now, oops you were innocent. They knew that already.

It’s a dark bit of our history changing legal records just sound very whitewashing. What’s next? Change all the records showing the sales of slaves to retroactively free them when it’s centuries too late?

BashfulClam · 29/04/2023 21:50

It’s been done in Scotland.

DogInATent · 29/04/2023 21:47

Blamunge · 29/04/2023 21:12

If we think about wrongful convictions for other crimes, for example homosexuality - people can apply for their historical convictions to be quashed. But there hasn’t (as far as I know) been a blanket quashing of all past convictions. And it happened much more recently. So why should there be a blanket quashing of convictions for witchcraft when they haven’t done that for other things which were once considered to be criminal acts?

Blanket pardons/quashes have been considered for historic homosexuality convictions. They have, so far, only been done on an individual basis - e.g. Turing. The closest attempt to achieving a blanket approach was blocked by an individual MP exploiting parliamentary procedure.

LakeTiticaca · 29/04/2023 21:39

People used to be hanged for sheep rustling in the past. Those were the laws of the time, no matter how harsh we now realise those sentences were, we can't change the past

OfAllThePeopleWhyDoIHaveToBeMe · 29/04/2023 21:38

Op, I agree. Late justice is better than no justice.

I agree with what you said that many of those women would have hoped to clear their name.

However, it would also benefit is now. All of us who would like to live in a civilised, just country.

It would be a reminder how important it is that we have rights to protect us against the arbitrary power of the state.

A very timely reminder at a time when too many people are too willing to give up those rights.

Namethischange · 29/04/2023 21:37

It’s time to stop hand wringing about history and start learning from it. No point at all wasting public money apologising with all the work that would involve. What next? Trace their descendants to pay compensation? I’m a strong believer in looking forward to improve the lot of people now and in the future.

DrWhoNowww · 29/04/2023 21:32

FourTeaFallOut · 29/04/2023 21:26

No. It's ridiculous. It makes no material difference to the women who were victimised by a misogynist ideology. Let the convictions stand and highlight the lineage of women hating. Society can apologise when it stops treating women like shit.

This. Set against the current background of continued global attacks on women’s rights and freedoms a pardon for witchcraft convictions is purely performative.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/04/2023 21:26

No. It's ridiculous. It makes no material difference to the women who were victimised by a misogynist ideology. Let the convictions stand and highlight the lineage of women hating. Society can apologise when it stops treating women like shit.

icanneverthinkofnc · 29/04/2023 21:17

Ponderingwindow · 29/04/2023 21:12

Apologizing for things done by our ancestors is a waste of time, resources, and is completely unproductive. Doing better now and in the future has real meaning, not meaningless performance.

This..would be better use of time and energy to ensure convictions today are just, relevant and proportionate. Too many ludicrous sentences, time off for good behaviour, they wouldn't be there if they had behaved ffs, a sentance passed should be served.

carriedout · 29/04/2023 21:16

DemiColon · 29/04/2023 21:04

They all reflect differences in how people saw reality compared to today. Presumably, we don't think any of those kinds of things were actually bad. If we are going to take a perspective where people should have convictions removed if we no longer think the same ay about the crime, why stop with witchcraft?

For that matter, if we believed that people could make deals with the devil for evil magical powers, we'd likely make it illegal too. So it's more that we just don't think witches exist in the way people in the early modern period did.

But it wouldn't make an ounce of difference to the people convicted, nor to anyone today, since everyone now pretty much already agrees that we shouldn't be convicting people of witchcraft. It's a completely empty gesture.

It's a gesture, but not empty.

Ponderingwindow · 29/04/2023 21:12

Apologizing for things done by our ancestors is a waste of time, resources, and is completely unproductive. Doing better now and in the future has real meaning, not meaningless performance.

Blamunge · 29/04/2023 21:12

If we think about wrongful convictions for other crimes, for example homosexuality - people can apply for their historical convictions to be quashed. But there hasn’t (as far as I know) been a blanket quashing of all past convictions. And it happened much more recently. So why should there be a blanket quashing of convictions for witchcraft when they haven’t done that for other things which were once considered to be criminal acts?

maddiemookins16mum · 29/04/2023 21:09

Oh please, I know you ‘mean well’ but this is just ridiculous. Do you actually sit and think about things like this?