Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry that AI will alter the world beyond all recognition, and not for the better?

146 replies

Appalonia · 29/04/2023 19:45

I know it's only in its infancy but it's already created music, screenplays, works of art, photos, essays, marketing, and has the ability to create so much else which will basically erase the necessity for so many jobs, including creative ones. What will pp DO when most of us are essentially irrelevant? And what will be the purpose of life when there's no point learning a skill when AI can do it so much better, and cheaper? I was watching an interview with Elon Musk who was saying that universal basic income is the only way forward. Which is great, but, if human beings are going to become essentially redundant ( apart from purely physical jobs such as cooking, building, hairdressing, beauticians, farming etc), what will be the point of us?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
saoirse31 · 29/04/2023 23:34

As a sentient being you can surely find a purpose in your life

longtompot · 29/04/2023 23:22

PuffinPuffinPenguin · 29/04/2023 20:32

I voted YABU because people are not defined by their jobs and it's not their "reason for living". You don't need a reason to live, you are entitled to exist. Learn for the sake of learning, do for the sake of doing. Maybe we'll have a new idle rich class like in the 1800s, or a new idle poor class like in the 90s. None of us know how this will pan out. But for the record I use AI for work and it is still really crap at writing and needs loads of human input.

However, if you are an artist for example, and also disabled so your ability to get a job and earn money is very limited, then AI is very much taking away some peoples reason for living, because what is the point if you make wonderful art and AI tools scrape (steal) the internet for images

EmmaEmerald · 29/04/2023 23:08

The NHS example I can see - if it works, great.

the "Companies cut customer service agents from 10 to 5 to save money, leaving customers with long wait times" - this is usually about paying someone on £1million + even more, so to me, the answer is, stop reducing staff to line the pockets of the already high earners, have more humans available so humans feel happier in the first place.

it does all lead to a very horrible "us and them" society. I can see that digital twinning might save a worker going to check something in the sewage system. But then that's more job losses.

JamSandle · 29/04/2023 22:41

Youre 100% right. It could be the next big shift and would change so much.

roundcork · 29/04/2023 22:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

Justalittlebitduckling · 29/04/2023 22:37

So many technologies in the past have altered human existence immeasurably. This will definitely be the next one!

Camablanca · 29/04/2023 22:29

EmmaEmerald · 29/04/2023 22:24

How would it do that?
i can see how it creates problems, not fixes them.

do things like digital twinning for, say, water pipes, come under AI?

Well depends on how you look at it.

Companies cut customer service agents from 10 to 5 to save money, leaving customers with long wait times.

Deploying an automated chatbot reduces wait times and allows the same 5 agents to answer the really complex queries. Result!

There's a lot of work in the world that's not going to be 'taken away'. It just doesn't get done. And now it will.

We have a shortage of teachers, carers, mental health professionals etc. All over the world not just the UK.

The problem is once profit goes to the few, how will this be shared?

Btw AI is not the cause of the social contract 'do job, get money' breaking. Regardless of it the accumulation of wealth gives more rewards now than an income. That has to be fixed regardless.

YouWonJayne · 29/04/2023 22:28

EmmaEmerald · 29/04/2023 22:24

How would it do that?
i can see how it creates problems, not fixes them.

do things like digital twinning for, say, water pipes, come under AI?

There are NHS Trusts using AI to allow sitar waiting lists, make diagnoses, and triage people in appropriate ways. And we are not talking about a ChatBot like you get when you try and talk to a utility company. This intelligence is developed closely with doctors to ensure accuracy and safety. It means waiting lists will be shorter, doctors time will be freed up and people will get the diagnoses they need more quickly. It could literally save lives. The NHS is no longer fit for purpose, and the likes of AI won’t take over the work of HCPs but it can help alleviate problems that HCPs alone can’t solve.

EmmaEmerald · 29/04/2023 22:24

YouWonJayne · 29/04/2023 22:20

When people start seeing AI as a resource that can address problems we have in our society, and not ‘the robots are taking over’, the better

How would it do that?
i can see how it creates problems, not fixes them.

do things like digital twinning for, say, water pipes, come under AI?

PeaceLilyCactus · 29/04/2023 22:23

The gap between the poor and super rich will continue to get greater and greater until the poor are all battling for the little resources available to us. I work for a bank and they’ve already brought in AI so when you message them online, it’s a robot who initially answers the web chat, without the customers realising they are talking to a robot. It’s just the start. I think the channel 4 drama Humans raised some really important theories that will probably come into being.

YouWonJayne · 29/04/2023 22:20

When people start seeing AI as a resource that can address problems we have in our society, and not ‘the robots are taking over’, the better

JaneJeffer · 29/04/2023 22:19

Elphame · 29/04/2023 22:13

It has a way to go yet - I asked Bard for a Mumsnet poem and this is what it produced.

A Mumsnet Poem

O Mumsnet, thou great and glorious site,
Where women can come to share their woes,
And find support and friendship in the night,
From those who know just what it goes.

Whether you're a new mum or a seasoned pro,
There's always someone who can offer help,
Whether it's advice on feeding or potty training,
Or just a shoulder to cry on when you're feeling down.

Mumsnet is more than just a website,
It's a community of women who care,
Who are there for each other through thick and thin,
And who will always be there to lend a hand.

So next time you're feeling lost or alone,
Remember that you're not the only one,
And that there are thousands of women on Mumsnet,
Who are just waiting to offer their support.

The Vogons would be proud of it!

It's like the school magazine

EmmaEmerald · 29/04/2023 22:18

Some oh i think I've seen a petition doing the rounds about stopping Crispr.

Camablanca · 29/04/2023 22:18

*how AI

Camablanca · 29/04/2023 22:17

Do you know 'AI' actually works OP?

Motorcycleemptyness · 29/04/2023 22:17

That is a fucking terrible poem. I think you are worrying unnecessarily, OP!

SomePosters · 29/04/2023 22:16

Just wait til you hear about crispr.

There is no stopping change, it will happen around you and eventually you and your generations way of doing things will die.

There will be positive and negative consequences to each new technology and people will adapt. Some will do well from it others will suffer because of it but nothing will halt the waves of time.

EmmaEmerald · 29/04/2023 22:16

stbrandonsboat · 29/04/2023 21:56

There is no way the rich will tolerate UBI. We'll all be reduced to doing manual work that the AI physically won't be able to do. I can't see the rich agreeing to keeping anyone alive who can't contribute. I can envisage a Logan's Run type world. I understand Canada are half way there rather than paying out disability benefits.

Are they? I will google...yes I'm aware of the irony.

stbrandonsboat · 29/04/2023 22:15

That's a pretty bad poem 😂

Elphame · 29/04/2023 22:13

It has a way to go yet - I asked Bard for a Mumsnet poem and this is what it produced.

A Mumsnet Poem

O Mumsnet, thou great and glorious site,
Where women can come to share their woes,
And find support and friendship in the night,
From those who know just what it goes.

Whether you're a new mum or a seasoned pro,
There's always someone who can offer help,
Whether it's advice on feeding or potty training,
Or just a shoulder to cry on when you're feeling down.

Mumsnet is more than just a website,
It's a community of women who care,
Who are there for each other through thick and thin,
And who will always be there to lend a hand.

So next time you're feeling lost or alone,
Remember that you're not the only one,
And that there are thousands of women on Mumsnet,
Who are just waiting to offer their support.

The Vogons would be proud of it!

LongTermLurker · 29/04/2023 22:12

HappyHourStartsNow · 29/04/2023 20:40

I can’t imagine this either.

I also don’t believe it could ever replace humans within the helping professions, counselling for example.

There is a connection that comes from empathy and eye contact and genuine moments where lived experience and compassion and presence collide. That connection is one that helps to heal and comfort and I don’t believe it could ever be replicated by AI. Not in a way that one could ever feel no matter how many factors were considered and copied and programmed in.

This is interesting, and I mostly agree (I'm a counsellor btw!). That said, I've been recently turning to chatgpt for advice about a number of parenting issues rather than posting on here. The responses have been calm and wise, albeit anodyne, and at times of parenting stress I've felt that was a safer option than running the gauntlet on here 🤣.

ohfook · 29/04/2023 22:09

It could go on of either two ways in my opinion. It could take over a lot of different jobs leaving humans free to work less, pursue their passions and spend their waking hours connecting with their loved ones.

Or people will just find another way to keep working people into the ground.

LaMaG · 29/04/2023 22:06

It terrifies me. Already we have handed so much power to a small few rich Americans who we allow dictate how we live and think, influencing our social norms and even our emotions through social media and the online world. Sometimes I wonder when it will all end. Then on the flip side people in the 60s believed a pill could substitute a meal and social eating would be a thing of the past yet the restaurant industry thrived and the food industry is huge.

CheriseNuclearNuland · 29/04/2023 22:06

what will be the point of us?

What really is the point of any life? You’re asking this on mumsnet.

It’s to produce more life.

Aylestone · 29/04/2023 22:01

ThinkTheresBeenAGlitch · 29/04/2023 20:32

Can AI really create art, novels, music that moves us? I can't really believe these endeavours of human creativity could be successfully done by machines! But someone on here posted an article recently that explained how as soon as AI becomes sufficiently intelligent, it will wipe out all human life within about half an hour so maybe it's all a moot point.

I guess they can. I downloaded the chat (gpt?) app that someone on mn mentioned yesterday. I had it writing all funny poems about my kids and my friends. I then decided to put in a few details about my 2 dogs. It wrote such a beautiful poem about them that I was in tears, I’m having an actual artist write the piece with their portraits. It’s almost like it can read between the lines of what you’re saying and come up with such uncanny details from the few facts you give it.