Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think only the super rich will be able to afford private schools?

232 replies

donniedarko89 · 29/04/2023 19:09

I live in a fairly affluent area, full of private schools. We are comfortable, not wealthy, and considered private for secondary eventually (and who knows, with the cost of living crisis), while enriching the state primary's offer with lots of extra clubs and activities. Noticing that more and more families are doing the same, even high-earners who would in the past have gone private by default. Are private schools going to become only for the ultra rich, especially if the fees spike up with a Labour government?

OP posts:
RC1234 · 30/04/2023 07:01

I don't hate private schools, but honestly in the grand scheme of things my concern is more for people struggling to feed, clothe and house their children than those struggling to send them to a posh school. Yes, there are private special schools, but given the state pay for that provision and you only get that if your child is assessed as needing it I consider them to be different. I think blanket tax breaks for private education should be scrapped and replaced with a system like the tax free child care system up with a max rebate set as equivalent to what you get for a regular state school education. I do think it should be managed via that awful, clunky HMRC website just like tax free child care. If it good enough for me, it is good enough for thee. I suspect this wouldn't affect the no frills prep schools, but might possibly affect the high end schools like Eton. However those ones have massive endowments that they can dip into. Oh and these education 'vouchers' can only be spent at Ofsted approved establishments and only available if at least one parent is tax domiciled in the UK.

dottiedodah · 30/04/2023 06:59

Only something like around 7 per cent of children are private anyway! So 93 %are state or grammar school. Private education is for wealthy people. Some parents will make sacrifices for sure.but these will be not having new cars or holidays,not going without food or heating!

QuintanaRoo · 30/04/2023 06:58

Maybe it’s not a bad thing and if kids who in the past would have gone to privates now have to attend state maybe it will help drive standards up across the board? Though guess there is the argument it will just further burden the state sector?

CoozudBoyuPuak · 30/04/2023 06:52

BibbleandSqwauk · 30/04/2023 05:31

Whoops, sorry. I meant to type....if state education was at least adequate for ALL, not just those who are able to cope pastorally and academically in the current set up , then there would be an argument for saying we should do more to inhibit the inequality private education brings. These threads always assume that everyone chooses private for the status, to not rub shoulders with "oiks" to get their kid ahead of everyone else's. There are many of us who have screwed our finances to afford it because the state provision simply is not there to meet the needs of our children and vat on fees will not change that.

I agree with you and we are in this same position too - but I also agree that having the resources to go private in these circumstances is still a position of privilege, despite it not feeling like a luxury.

We aren't wealthy, our household wealth puts us about in the 4th "quintile" ie in the 60-80% block if the population was divided into 5 blocks in order of wealth. Paying out private fees is manageable because we live a lifestyle as if we were in the 2nd quintile (ie the 20%-40% block.

But kids who are just as needy as our DC and are just as failed by the inadequate state system but whose families were already in the first, second or third quintile to start off with do not have that option. They must stay in the inadequate and failing state provision or (more likely) drop out of education altogether.

So despite our sacrifices of the comfortable lifestyle we could have been having feeling like a necessity, I do see that it's really a privilege.

I am not totally opposed to VAT being added but I would hope for some nuance in how it's applied. eg perhaps only apply VAT to the proportion of the fees that are in excess of the average per-head funding that goes to state school pupils, and perhaps have a system where individual schools can apply for a status which allows them to charge only 5% vat rather than 20%. To qualify, they would need to be audited to demonstrate they are genuinely non-profit-making, with no excessive salaries and no excessive spending on luxury provisions like golf courses and other high-end sporting facilities, and a minimum proportion of the full-fees money going into significant bursaries that are only accessible by those in the lowest 2 quintiles of wealth, just proving a decent and adequately funded education at cost-price. Then the top end of the luxury market can still be taxed at full rate while the more modest end can be somewhat shielded, and schools have an incentive to proudly choose and advertise that they are doing their best to be affordable, and are actively striving not to be a bastion of elite privilege.

pompomdaisy · 30/04/2023 05:50

There's a few families around us who send their kids to private school. Think their grandparents pay tbh. The money has already been put aside. The actual families aren't rich.

BibbleandSqwauk · 30/04/2023 05:31

Whoops, sorry. I meant to type....if state education was at least adequate for ALL, not just those who are able to cope pastorally and academically in the current set up , then there would be an argument for saying we should do more to inhibit the inequality private education brings. These threads always assume that everyone chooses private for the status, to not rub shoulders with "oiks" to get their kid ahead of everyone else's. There are many of us who have screwed our finances to afford it because the state provision simply is not there to meet the needs of our children and vat on fees will not change that.

BibbleandSqwauk · 30/04/2023 05:21

I would have no use

Remaker · 30/04/2023 02:30

I think private schools should be the domain of the super rich. If you get yourself into the position that Australia is in, where governments subsidise independent schools so that anyone with a half decent income can afford them, you will undermine the state system which will be given the task of educating the most underprivileged children, without sufficient resources. Then parents will declare the state system ‘horrific’ and decide they must send their kids private. And around you will go with everyone scrabbling to buy some privilege for their kids, demanding the government fund it as their right, and bugger everyone else.

The most hilarious part of it all is that research in Australia consistently shows these schools do not improve academic outcomes. And that privately educated kids have poorer results and higher rates of drop out at university than those who attend comprehensive state schools. The low fee options don’t even have the swanky facilities to recommend them and almost all are church-based, where parents turn a blind eye to their homophobic beliefs and declare the pastoral care ‘amazing’ for white-skinned Oscar who is on the rugby team. The ‘cheap’ Christian schools exist purely for the middle classes to buy their way out of the state system, and congratulate themselves for ‘valuing education’. Meanwhile their kids would be better served with a state education and some trips to see other parts of the world.

Emotionalstorm · 30/04/2023 01:49

SamShortForSambuca · 30/04/2023 01:45

I went to a no frills sort of private school, which attracted a lot of families who had to make big sacrifices to send their kids there. It was academically solid but not somewhere likely to attract the super rich; peeling paint was everywhere, ponies were unheard of. I believe it cost about £9000 in 2003.

Bank of England inflation calculator tells me that's £15,357 in today's money.

The same school is now charging £17250 per year - but that now includes school trips, which definitely weren't included in my day.

It's a slightly above inflation cost increase but is it really so far above inflation as to exclude all but the super rich?

It's not. Everyone on Mumsnet just feels entitled to private school because they have a job.

SamShortForSambuca · 30/04/2023 01:45

I went to a no frills sort of private school, which attracted a lot of families who had to make big sacrifices to send their kids there. It was academically solid but not somewhere likely to attract the super rich; peeling paint was everywhere, ponies were unheard of. I believe it cost about £9000 in 2003.

Bank of England inflation calculator tells me that's £15,357 in today's money.

The same school is now charging £17250 per year - but that now includes school trips, which definitely weren't included in my day.

It's a slightly above inflation cost increase but is it really so far above inflation as to exclude all but the super rich?

Matchymatchylemonscratchy · 30/04/2023 01:40

Spendonsend · 29/04/2023 19:30

I think a market will open up for no thrills independent schools. Selecting on behaviour and academics but not really doing small classes and impressive facilities.

In Australia we have this already. The top private schools in Sydney are now tipping over to $40-43k per year for tuition (and that’s before uniforms, books, excursions etc.). Our great local independent in Sydney is $17k and gets better academic results.

I can’t imagine paying all that extra money just for the prestige, and given I’ve worked my life in big corporations and never discussed schools I’m not sure the prestige gets you very far anymore. It’s really just about keeping up with the Joneses.

There will be less and less people able to afford these expensive schools going forward. Everyone I know that sends their children to them is helped out financially by the grandparents. This next generation simply won’t be in the same position to do so. The schools will have to adapt their business model.

Emotionalstorm · 30/04/2023 01:28

SnackSizeRaisin · 29/04/2023 22:36

Did they teach you that Labour policies are communist?

No they were very left wing. I came to that conclusion myself.

whumpthereitis · 30/04/2023 01:04

Loria · 30/04/2023 00:52

Well that's all the argument we need isn't it.

Case closed.

Human nature is a complex interplay of a multitude of factors, innate and environmental. Whilst altruism absolutely is one aspect, so is the desire to put one’s own at an advantage. This varies on an individual level, but getting what is perceived to be the best for yourself and your loved ones is without a doubt a driving force.

My point about communism is that it doesn’t eradicate this drive. It was still displayed in communist countries, and when opportunities arose as a result of those systems collapsing, people absolutely did seize them, regardless of the indoctrination they had been subjected to.

Loria · 30/04/2023 00:52

Well that's all the argument we need isn't it.

Case closed.

JockTamsonsBairns · 30/04/2023 00:52

My DB and SiL are/were high earners (London City jobs) and have always privately educated their 3 DCs. They basked in their advantage without a single care.

DB's income took a battering during the pandemic, and now they're struggling to meet the fees.
Ironically, he is now furious that private education gives an advantage, and feels very hard done to that they are feeling the pinch.
He definitely didn't choose private education for the small class sizes, or the SEN provision, or the pastoral care.
He loved the advantage it gave his children, until it didn't.

whumpthereitis · 30/04/2023 00:41

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2023 00:27

That isn’t a reason for not trying.

Yes, I have encountered plenty who think the countries that tried it just ‘did it wrong’, and if they had the chance to enact it, it would of course be different. Safe of course in the knowledge that they’ll never be required to test that theory.

Both my parents grew up in communist countries. They sent me to private school.

greenteafiend · 30/04/2023 00:39

MermaidMummy06 · 29/04/2023 23:12

Where I am (Australia) it's a similar situation. However, private enrolments are climbing (60/40 I think), despite the current climate.

I find it's priorities, and options, though. I have worked with women who said they returned to work soley to pay school fees (eats entire wage) and they live a frugal life & drive old clapped out cars and never buy themselves new clothes.

Then people like myself & DH who will pay private for secondary only, because the public option (were strictly catchment managed) is horrific, and we are paying off our house beforehand to afford it.

A friend will send her kids to that same public high school because they can't afford the fees... they're leaving on their second overseas trip this year, in a few weeks (equivalent so far of two years worth of fees).

So, for some it's wealth and some it's priorities.

Australia is completely different.

Australian "private schools" are highly affordable and (IMO) not really fully private schools at all in the true sense of the world, because they 40 to 70% of their funds come from the state. They are really just semi-private schools where parents pay a top-up, not full fee; of course they can be afforded merely by careful budgeting for a lot of people.

Blossomtoes · 30/04/2023 00:27

whumpthereitis · 29/04/2023 23:59

Actual Communist and socialist countries couldn’t manage it.

That isn’t a reason for not trying.

whumpthereitis · 30/04/2023 00:23

CuriousMoo · 30/04/2023 00:03

?

Eradicating privilege, in schools and elsewhere.

Fansandblankets · 30/04/2023 00:15

My sister sent her kids to private school. Originally it was because the private pre school worked out about the same as nursery fees. Then they just ended up staying in private schools because they’d made friends and were happy there. She wasn’t super rich but definitely comfortable.

The kids are adults now and have posh mates but shit jobs 😂😂

CuriousMoo · 30/04/2023 00:03

whumpthereitis · 29/04/2023 23:59

Actual Communist and socialist countries couldn’t manage it.

?

CuriousMoo · 30/04/2023 00:02

drcb83 · 29/04/2023 23:42

@CuriousMoo well I also had an academic scholarship and we had a hardship bursary and ate off the allotment a lot but yes I suppose they must have had some spare cash.

Interesting, your first post portrayed it as a matter of just refusing to spruce up the house and spending the cash on fees instead.

whumpthereitis · 29/04/2023 23:59

CuriousMoo · 29/04/2023 23:38

No, you really can. You just wouldn't like that.

Actual Communist and socialist countries couldn’t manage it.

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 29/04/2023 23:57

Loria · 29/04/2023 23:47

If your parents had no carpets that's neglect, not private schooling. Consider therapy. .

Look, as far as I'm concerned private schools have always been for the super rich. Maybe now they're for the super super rich as opposed to the just super rich but really once you're talking about whether a person can afford £18k a year as opposed to £12k a year on something non essential it's such a rarified class of people that it makes little difference who's in it and who's not.

Agreed.

Loria · 29/04/2023 23:53

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 29/04/2023 23:16

Weren't you listening? We've all got to get used to being poorer.

Yup. Just look at those lovely new black passports any time you're feeling sad about it. That'll lift your spirits.

Anyway according to many threads on Mumsnet we're all out and about going to coffee shops and bars etc so actually the entire idea that our living standards are falling through the toilet is just anti brexit propaganda. Or something.