Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think only the super rich will be able to afford private schools?

232 replies

donniedarko89 · 29/04/2023 19:09

I live in a fairly affluent area, full of private schools. We are comfortable, not wealthy, and considered private for secondary eventually (and who knows, with the cost of living crisis), while enriching the state primary's offer with lots of extra clubs and activities. Noticing that more and more families are doing the same, even high-earners who would in the past have gone private by default. Are private schools going to become only for the ultra rich, especially if the fees spike up with a Labour government?

OP posts:
DisquietintheRanks · 02/05/2023 09:25

In what way is that gaming the system @Peverellshire ? What system are you even talking about?

Peverellshire · 02/05/2023 09:10

If ‘top’ private schools confer no advantage re: ‘top’ university entrance, and maybe even ‘disadvantage’, they’ll exist increasingly as a ‘brand’ name for internationals. (Elite boarding).

I see London families increasingly ‘gaming’ system, good, central comp, then fluency in other languages/bespoke arts/cultural mentoring & precision tutoring on side. Result, ‘Down to earth’ kids with a serious ‘edge’…

pfftt · 02/05/2023 08:53

Poopoolittlekitten · 01/05/2023 20:32

My heart bleeds for those poor private kids who may have to leave to go to state school. How will they ever cope.

Oh it will be fine. They'll just move to the catchment area of a top school and pay for tutoring and somehow people who hate private schools will be ok with this

Hoppinggreen · 02/05/2023 08:45

Yes, I had a choice and I consider myself very lucky to not have to send my DC to a State school that even teachers who worked there advised me to avoid.

gawditswindy · 01/05/2023 20:45

That's the thing - all those posting 'I had no choice but to send my child to private school due to SEN/crap local school/etc', yes, you did have a choice. Some people's children struggle with state schools or have to go to the worst state schools because their parents literally have no choice because there is NO MONEY. Even if they cancel holidays, never eat out, don't drive, sell the carpets, there is still NO MONEY.

Poopoolittlekitten · 01/05/2023 20:32

My heart bleeds for those poor private kids who may have to leave to go to state school. How will they ever cope.

Spendonsend · 01/05/2023 10:39

BungleandGeorge · 01/05/2023 10:17

@Spendonsend
theyre not all ‘crap schools’. And you only need to fulfil one criteria. You really need to dig further in the criteria a few points;
FSM; this is generally at any point during schooling. So if it’s a brief period age 5 is it that relevant? If it’s because your usually average well off family had a brief dip in income due to job loss/ covid furlough is that relevant? Is someone whose parent earned 16k yet owns an home or lives with well off family and then got child tax credit plus maintenance payments on top actually badly off? You can stay on FSM until the end of that phase of education despite not qualifying anymore. What about if your well educated and diligent parent chose to stay at home rather than work?

there are loads of exceptions for the other criteria too. I’ve already stated why a sixth form college may be ‘underperforming’ but not actually underperforming at all. Perhaps in your city you see it working but across the country the criteria are so blunt so can be totally ineffective

I only looked at the criteria for the course my son wants to do at a range of universities and they varied a lot or they didnt exist.

All i really meant was it would be daft to make decisions such as which house should I live in, which school should I pick, shall i ask for my child to go to foster care, based on the fact your child might get a contextual offer because the criteria are not fixed or universal.

Peverellshire · 01/05/2023 10:31

The top boarding schools will increasingly become status symbols for internationals. As USP top grades, this will turn up pressure for all.

Workerbeep · 01/05/2023 10:31

Considering only 7% of children attend private schools in England and 4% in Scotland, it does not really affect that many people.

BungleandGeorge · 01/05/2023 10:17

@Spendonsend
theyre not all ‘crap schools’. And you only need to fulfil one criteria. You really need to dig further in the criteria a few points;
FSM; this is generally at any point during schooling. So if it’s a brief period age 5 is it that relevant? If it’s because your usually average well off family had a brief dip in income due to job loss/ covid furlough is that relevant? Is someone whose parent earned 16k yet owns an home or lives with well off family and then got child tax credit plus maintenance payments on top actually badly off? You can stay on FSM until the end of that phase of education despite not qualifying anymore. What about if your well educated and diligent parent chose to stay at home rather than work?

there are loads of exceptions for the other criteria too. I’ve already stated why a sixth form college may be ‘underperforming’ but not actually underperforming at all. Perhaps in your city you see it working but across the country the criteria are so blunt so can be totally ineffective

Spendonsend · 01/05/2023 09:50

BungleandGeorge · 01/05/2023 09:39

So you think a sample of 5 schools is representative?! It’s absolutely possible to play the system and not that difficult

But do you really want to send your child to a school that has a very poor track record of getting pupils to pass gcses, a levels and onto university and live in a polar 4 quintile whatever postcode just in the hope your child gets a contextual offer for a course when some universities dont do them and they arent for every course or they have different criteria like being an asylum seeker, or a carer or its now only one specific local crap school that is different than the one you picked put aged 11

I dont understand how its easy to game the system.

BungleandGeorge · 01/05/2023 09:39

TheaBrandt · 01/05/2023 07:55

That’s just not true. Only one state school in our city of 5 state schools gets contextual offers and it’s very unlikely you would send your child there just for that. My dds state doesn’t get them but very bright children from genuinely challenged families (no one ever been to university/FSM etc) are fast tracked and supported to get into the best universities and rightly so.

So you think a sample of 5 schools is representative?! It’s absolutely possible to play the system and not that difficult

TheaBrandt · 01/05/2023 07:55

That’s just not true. Only one state school in our city of 5 state schools gets contextual offers and it’s very unlikely you would send your child there just for that. My dds state doesn’t get them but very bright children from genuinely challenged families (no one ever been to university/FSM etc) are fast tracked and supported to get into the best universities and rightly so.

BungleandGeorge · 01/05/2023 07:46

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/04/2023 14:10

Contextual offers are designed to help state school pupils who are disadvantaged compared to most other state school pupils. They are not designed to help average state school pupils gain an equal footing with private school pupils.

It's not true that it's easier to get into university from a state school than a private school. Those pupils who get contextual offers are at a big disadvantage in other ways that are unlikely to apply to anyone in a position to be considering private school.

And my point is that the criteria for contextual offers is indiscriminate and many who aren’t actually disadvantaged fit the criteria. Indeed people deliberately ensure they fit the criteria to get a contextual offer. Likewise I’m sure there are loads of students who are disadvantaged but don’t meet the criteria. It’s all just to appease the ‘hard done by’s’ rather than to actually improve access. We considered playing the system, it would have been very easy to do

Yellowdays · 30/04/2023 15:09

@whumpthereitis in that case I suppose it's about confidence building, which private schools are good at. That is replicable, though.

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/04/2023 14:10

BungleandGeorge · 29/04/2023 23:02

It depends on the university. And the criteria for schools isn’t that they’re ‘poor’. It’s low continuation to higher education. So if they teach a lot of vocational courses (plus a levels) where students aren’t aiming for uni they can qualify despite being high quality establishments. Loads of people will
have been on FSM temporarily due to covid. Contextual offers are also offered on lots of courses at some unis.

Contextual offers are designed to help state school pupils who are disadvantaged compared to most other state school pupils. They are not designed to help average state school pupils gain an equal footing with private school pupils.

It's not true that it's easier to get into university from a state school than a private school. Those pupils who get contextual offers are at a big disadvantage in other ways that are unlikely to apply to anyone in a position to be considering private school.

Joey1976 · 30/04/2023 13:06

jeaux90 · 30/04/2023 11:25

I'm not super rich, I'm a lone parent and send DD14 to private school because she is ASD and ADHD. The SEN provision in the local secondary is shit, and she can't cope with the large classes and noise.

She is thriving in her "affordable" private school because class sizes are 12 and only two classes a year.

If they make private schools less affordable then the state will get inundated with SEN kids who are academically ok but can't cope with mainstream school.

Honestly this private school bashing is really stupid. Treating all kids the same in terms of the state school provision is sometimes the most unfair thing to do.

This. I'm so tired of the assumption that private school parents are selfish, ultra rich, conservative idiots.
When my DD was at the local state school I didn't think anything about private school parents because I've got bigger things to worry about.

donniedarko89 · 30/04/2023 13:01

Zipps · 30/04/2023 11:25

What a way to live. I actually knew someone who did similar. Hell bent on sending her dc private but could barely afford basics and had a lot of debt. It seemed neglectful and far too much sacrifice. I felt sorry for the dc.

My friend's sister had a similar experience - won a scholarship to a private school at a time where her family had been hit financially and couldn't pay even for the most basic extras (she mentioned an advanced calculator being an issue, as well as the most expensive educational trips and ski holidays etc). I wonder if this was worse in terms of developing her self confidence than going to a state school.

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 30/04/2023 12:28

@zipps but again it depends what the alternative is. Mine know that going to private school means going without certain things but they equally know how they were struggling and suffering in the state school that failed them. This desire by some posters to insist that there is no benefit other than snobbery and connections for going private are extremely blinkered.

Zipps · 30/04/2023 11:25

drcb83 · 29/04/2023 23:34

I went to private school but my parents sacrificed for it - we had no holidays, and we had no carpets on our concrete floors and no tiles in the bathroom. I never wanted to bring my friends home but the education was excellent. Just saying - not all private school kids have wealthy parents.

What a way to live. I actually knew someone who did similar. Hell bent on sending her dc private but could barely afford basics and had a lot of debt. It seemed neglectful and far too much sacrifice. I felt sorry for the dc.

jeaux90 · 30/04/2023 11:25

I'm not super rich, I'm a lone parent and send DD14 to private school because she is ASD and ADHD. The SEN provision in the local secondary is shit, and she can't cope with the large classes and noise.

She is thriving in her "affordable" private school because class sizes are 12 and only two classes a year.

If they make private schools less affordable then the state will get inundated with SEN kids who are academically ok but can't cope with mainstream school.

Honestly this private school bashing is really stupid. Treating all kids the same in terms of the state school provision is sometimes the most unfair thing to do.

GnomeDePlume · 30/04/2023 11:04

So much depends on the area.

Where I live (in a very large semi rural county) the state provision at secondary is one school in each town. Currently all the local schools are rated as 'Good', none are outstanding.

There is one private school. It's main USP is that it is private. It's results are better than the state schools but not by much. All that keeping the riff raff out doesn't seem to benefit that much compared to the fees (£16k+ per year, minimal bursaries available).

To my mind a school such as this is a luxury and should be taxed as such. If that would push fees above what the market would bear it would be no loss.

BibbleandSqwauk · 30/04/2023 10:16

I used to work in a very well to do area in a state school. The catchment area consisted almost entirely of houses that would be 700k plus. Those parents chose to invest in an asset that gave them access to a school with similar outcomes to private but that was just as unreachable for most as fee paying. The school itself wasn't doing anything different to the ones ten miles down the road in a very deprived area but those schools were tanking in terms of results and care because the demographic was so different. There are many thousands of people who do actually earn enough to pay for private but they are a) lucky enough to have kids that don't need small classes etc and b) can afford to buy themselves out of the problematic areas. How is that better? Unless we completely overhauled the catchment system so every school had a demographic mix, let's not pretend the stars system is immune to financial factors.

whumpthereitis · 30/04/2023 10:14

Yellowdays · 30/04/2023 09:21

I agree that most people are already priced out. Plus, the top 1% have become much wealthier whilst everyone wise poorer over the last two years (Oxfam).

That said, my children went to state schools and haven't been disadvantaged job-wise. And according to recent research, the advantage for private school kids is lost at uni anyway, where they perform more poorly than state kids.

Apparently private school graduates earn on average 35% more by age 25 than their state school counterparts. They’re also more likely to start their careers in a processional or managerial position.

That said, it isn’t always about achieving a highflying outcome. A lot of parents will choose private school because they believe it will provide their children will a better school experience overall.

Yellowdays · 30/04/2023 09:53

@SpongeBob2022 I'm pretty sure that there is research somewhere which shows that even if you want to use private education, there is no educational advantage before 11. I heard that from a school's advisor a few years ago.

Swipe left for the next trending thread