Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think only the super rich will be able to afford private schools?

232 replies

donniedarko89 · 29/04/2023 19:09

I live in a fairly affluent area, full of private schools. We are comfortable, not wealthy, and considered private for secondary eventually (and who knows, with the cost of living crisis), while enriching the state primary's offer with lots of extra clubs and activities. Noticing that more and more families are doing the same, even high-earners who would in the past have gone private by default. Are private schools going to become only for the ultra rich, especially if the fees spike up with a Labour government?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Poopoolittlekitten · 07/07/2023 09:25

More and more 'good' unis are rejecting private school candidates in favour of state schools ones- having too high a private % is going to start affecting funding and they can't afford that.

Peverellshire · 04/05/2023 15:55

Haven’t some (?) one, Uni, Edinburgh, (?) given contextual offers to all from state schools?

SamShortForSambuca · 04/05/2023 12:07

GnomeDePlume · 04/05/2023 11:26

@Poopoolittlekitten not guaranteed and also unlikely to be that much of a difference compared to normal offers

Typically two grades lower (e.g. AAA becomes ABB) but it requires multiple indicators of disadvantage with eligibility varying from uni to uni. In many cases the widening participation programmes require quite a bit of legwork on the part of the student - anything from essays to a residential.

Tabitha who switched to a state sixth form, parents have degrees, no FSM history and a leafy postcode isn't going to get a contextual offer. Her parents are fooling themselves if they think they're gaming the system.

Danny who switched to a state sixth form, but whose parents were making big sacrifices to send him to a private school for GCSEs, first in his family to into higher education, lives in a postcode with low rates of progression to higher education and whose education was disrupted by health issues - he will be eligible for some (but not all) contextual offers.

GnomeDePlume · 04/05/2023 11:26

@Poopoolittlekitten not guaranteed and also unlikely to be that much of a difference compared to normal offers

Poopoolittlekitten · 04/05/2023 10:01

'Only an idiot would move their DC to a school to get the 'advantage' of a contextual offer.'

Absolutely - they're far from guaranteed

SamShortForSambuca · 04/05/2023 09:58

carriedout · 04/05/2023 08:44

We may as well have the vat then, to support the state sector for the benefit of all.

Also, this thing about switching to state sixth form for 'advantage' is urban myth. Private schools are still massively over-represented in university places.

Not as overrepresented as people think; while at GCSE only 7% of DC are privately educated, at A Levels it's 18%.

The difference is that state school DC are more likely to go and do other things like apprenticeships which tend not to take them in a university bound direction, and BTECs which are less widely accepted than A Levels.

Nationally only 9.8% of university entrants are privately educated. This does vary significantly between institutions - but even at Cambridge it's only 27.5% privately educated. It's disproportionate, but not vastly disproportionate compared to the demographics of those taking A Levels, and certainly lower than many assume.

GnomeDePlume · 04/05/2023 09:28

Only an idiot would move their DC to a school to get the 'advantage' of a contextual offer.

Contextual offers are generally only a grade or two lower than the normal offer which hardly compensates for lack of across-the-board high quality A level teaching and university application support which is my experience of a struggling state school.

I suspect that claims of 'gaming the system' are made by parents who have had to take their DC out of private school for other reasons: can't afford the fees or DC didn't make the grade to get into private 6th form.

carriedout · 04/05/2023 08:44

donniedarko89 · 03/05/2023 20:15

100% this. I have also seen families taking DC out of private school for A-Levels so that they can have a competitive advantage to get into top Unis.

We may as well have the vat then, to support the state sector for the benefit of all.

Also, this thing about switching to state sixth form for 'advantage' is urban myth. Private schools are still massively over-represented in university places.

GnomeDePlume · 04/05/2023 07:19

@SamShortForSambuca I agree

Having had all 3 DCs go through a failing school I would say that it is at the break points - choosing GCSEs, choosing post GCSE options, choosing A levels, applying to university - that the school really struggled.

In the sixth form there was a lack of really good teaching across the board. Only maths had a pair of totally committed and inspirational teachers.

The 6th form target was CCC and the local University. Anything beyond this was unsupported which did lead to a lot of imposter syndrome and stunted ambition (I saw a lot of this in DCs' friends).

If your DC is a good student (able and committed) then GCSEs will likely take care of themselves. It's at A level and preparing for what comes next that you want the best teaching and the best advice.

SamShortForSambuca · 04/05/2023 00:10

100% this. I have also seen families taking DC out of private school for A-Levels so that they can have a competitive advantage to get into top Unis.

They are hugely misguided.

I've worked in student recruitment and widening participation, and had plenty of contact with admissions.

Universities can see what schools applicants went to from 11 onwards, so they're not fooling anyone.

Grades are typically higher in private sixth forms; those higher grades will be the most important part of their application.

UCAS advice is often better in private sixth forms; having visited more schools than I care to remember in both sectors, there often is a huge difference. Some of the most fulfilling memories I have from my time in the sector were filling in the gaps in the advice they'd received; I'll always remember the girl who told me she was torn between a degree in MFL and a journalism career; no one had told her that an MFL degree could be great preparation for a journalism career. The look on her face was priceless. I digress, however...

WP schemes have much wider criteria than going to a state school. Often they look at free school meals, having been in care, caring responsibilities, being at an underperforming school, parents didn't go to university etc. Indeed it's possible in some circumstances to attend a private school and get onto a WP scheme such as https://www.leeds.ac.uk/access-to-leeds/doc/am-i-eligible

It is unusual for the deciding factor between two applicants to be the school they attended.

If I were short on funds but trying to maximise university entrance chances for my DC, I'd send them to a good state school for GCSEs and private school for A Levels. Sixth form does seem to be where you get more bang for your buck in that regard.

donniedarko89 · 03/05/2023 20:15

Peverellshire · 02/05/2023 09:10

If ‘top’ private schools confer no advantage re: ‘top’ university entrance, and maybe even ‘disadvantage’, they’ll exist increasingly as a ‘brand’ name for internationals. (Elite boarding).

I see London families increasingly ‘gaming’ system, good, central comp, then fluency in other languages/bespoke arts/cultural mentoring & precision tutoring on side. Result, ‘Down to earth’ kids with a serious ‘edge’…

100% this. I have also seen families taking DC out of private school for A-Levels so that they can have a competitive advantage to get into top Unis.

OP posts:
potatohead1 · 03/05/2023 08:38

Peverellshire · 02/05/2023 09:10

If ‘top’ private schools confer no advantage re: ‘top’ university entrance, and maybe even ‘disadvantage’, they’ll exist increasingly as a ‘brand’ name for internationals. (Elite boarding).

I see London families increasingly ‘gaming’ system, good, central comp, then fluency in other languages/bespoke arts/cultural mentoring & precision tutoring on side. Result, ‘Down to earth’ kids with a serious ‘edge’…

Exactly yet so many people don't see this as an inequality like private schools are. They are no different still spending lots of money but choosing a different method. Still not available for the masses

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 23:25

...if they can't afford to pay the extra tax **

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 23:24

GnomeDePlume · 02/05/2023 14:43

In principle I agree with this. Private school for the majority is a luxury and should be taxed as such.

It would be possible to set up a tax scheme whereby fees are taxed normally but exemptions apply for non luxury private school pupils (eg SEN pupils where no suitable state alternative is available).

I thinl they should just get more resources at state schools if they cannot afford to From the perspective of the other parents they have paid lots of money not so their kid's classroom can be filled with SEN kids who might slow their learning down. This is one of the reasons why we are only applying to selective private schools for our daughter where this won't be an issue.

GnomeDePlume · 02/05/2023 14:43

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 12:19

I agree with you.

In principle I agree with this. Private school for the majority is a luxury and should be taxed as such.

It would be possible to set up a tax scheme whereby fees are taxed normally but exemptions apply for non luxury private school pupils (eg SEN pupils where no suitable state alternative is available).

Hoppinggreen · 02/05/2023 12:53

My DCs Private school costs £12k per year, yes a lot of people can’t afford it but it’s not just the Super Rich who can. The Parents of my DCs friends are generally professionals such as Accountants, Doctors, lawyers, senior management etc where BOTH parents have good jobs.
It is nothing like the local failing comp though. People seem to think that all Private schools are like Eton, many many are not

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 12:25

Hoppinggreen · 02/05/2023 12:19

I mean how will it help with equality if ONLY the super rich can afford them?
I know you have to be pretty well off to afford Private schooling but we aren’t all Oligarch/Banker wealthy

Do you want to pay for private school that is a lot cheaper but everyone is allowed in and it looks like the local comprehensive ? If that's the case it's not even worth £5 a year. Equality is a nice concept but unrealistic unless you live in a communist country and most of the time not even then.

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 12:19

Blossomtoes · 02/05/2023 12:18

Exactly. And they should be taxed as such.

I agree with you.

Hoppinggreen · 02/05/2023 12:19

I mean how will it help with equality if ONLY the super rich can afford them?
I know you have to be pretty well off to afford Private schooling but we aren’t all Oligarch/Banker wealthy

Blossomtoes · 02/05/2023 12:18

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 12:16

Why should private schools help with inequality. They're a luxury good. Should Chanel be making sure supermarket workers are rocking their bags.

Exactly. And they should be taxed as such.

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 12:16

Hoppinggreen · 02/05/2023 11:00

Why?
It will hardly help with inequality will it?

Why should private schools help with inequality. They're a luxury good. Should Chanel be making sure supermarket workers are rocking their bags.

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 12:16

Hoppinggreen · 02/05/2023 11:00

Why?
It will hardly help with inequality will it?

It's meant to be exclusive. They're not meant to let any person in.

Hoppinggreen · 02/05/2023 11:00

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 10:40

"To think only the super rich will be able to afford private schools?"

Good.

Why?
It will hardly help with inequality will it?

Emotionalstorm · 02/05/2023 10:40

"To think only the super rich will be able to afford private schools?"

Good.

Peverellshire · 02/05/2023 09:48

@DisquietintheRanks contextual offers at some schools, staying within ‘rules’ for a smooth passage to end goals & not making that difficult. Eg, if French is practically native, do it for A’level even though deathly dull for you. Bandwidth then focused on super curricula, poss in an ‘easier’ although well regarded A level subject. I’ve noticed those focused on Ivys seem to do this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread