Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really annoyed by this?

89 replies

mychel · 29/04/2023 10:16

So myself and dh are on our first holiday in 5 years. My dh has a medical condition that requires medical treatment while abroad so my father offered us the use of his house abroad. When it came to the holiday and logistics we decided that it might be easier to stay near the treatment facility where it would be easier to get to and from. Then about 2 weeks before we departed my father announced he was going out to his house and would be there during our stay. I was surprised as his partner wasn’t going with him just him alone but decided ah it would be nice to see him whilst out here. The first morning while my husband was at treatment my father asked to come meet me for coffee. During this coffee he dropped a bombshell that actually it turns out he’s possibly not my father after all and wants me to take a dna test. (Yes I’m actually serious) he’s decided after 40 something years and about 10 years since my mother passed away that he wants to know for sure if I’m his. So of course I’ve been in shock and very upset that I’ve been lied to for years and years but I’m more upset that he’s decided to do this now during our much longed for holiday after a very tough ( years of health and family issues). I’m also obviously annoyed that I’ve been lied to my entire life but he also has basically banned me from discussing it with anyone outside of dh. Am I being unreasonable to be so upset at the fact that he has destroyed our holiday?

OP posts:
LaMaG · 29/04/2023 14:50

I would be furious about ruining the holiday. His timing was selfish and unfair. However it is done now and finding out the truth is obviously very important to him and I'm sure he is not a young man. IMO this man raised you and went through all the crap that goes along with raising a family. If you doing this test brings him piece of mind then I think you should do it for his sake. If he is your father then it's just a storm in a tea cup. If not, he resolves whatever issues he has. Chances are that's where the story ends unless he knows who the other man is. He will still always be your Dad no matter what so remember that.
I'm sorry you are dealing with this now when you should be relaxing. Hugs xxx

zurala · 29/04/2023 14:37

If it were me, I would message him:

I've thought about it and decided I don't want to do the test. It doesn't matter to me either way, you have always been my dad and that's how I see you. If you're doing this to decide whether to write me out of your will, just do that anyway, if you've decided you no longer want to be my dad. I don't know why you are suddenly so obsessed with this and it's really hurtful. I thought you loved me, but it doesn't feel like it the way you are acting.

I would be so, so hurt. OP I'm really sorry you are going through this. He is being utterly shitty. He should have done this years ago, the boat has sailed.

Stemmingthetide · 29/04/2023 14:26

@Outgrabe its the timing the op is angry about.

After 40 years he chooses to gatecrash her much needed holiday to tell her the news. He is then constantly harassing her, on her much needed holiday, rather than giving her space to absorb the information.

Lefteyetwitch · 29/04/2023 14:00

He can't tell you what to do!
Tell people.
Tell all your siblings!

You can do it or not.
I would message him stating that you will be blocking him for the remainder of your holiday.
That you have not yet made a decision on if you will do the DNA test or not and that he has no say in this.
That he's not to contact you until you contact him.

Outgrabe · 29/04/2023 13:50

mychel · 29/04/2023 12:45

I would probably say I’ve had a closer relationship than any of my siblings bar one sister who idolises him. I’m not that type of character but I used to work along side him in family business, was the one looking after him when my mother passed away. So yes we have always had a good relationship albeit broken currently. Honestly if you had asked me to predict this I wouldn’t have been able to

I must say that from the tone of your posts, I had also assumed you had a poor or actively hostile relationship with him.

I’m also very struck by how angry you are that he’s told you this, rather than being angry with both him and your mother for not telling you for all those years. Obviously it’s your right to feel how you feel about something that is potentially destabilising to your family and your sense of self, but I can’t imagine not wanting to have all the information about my origins, even if I was determined not to meet any biological parents that might emerge.

Nimbostratus100 · 29/04/2023 13:45

speaking as someone who once had to be traced by distant relatives and warned of potentially lethal genetic disease in the family, I can see his point

mychel · 29/04/2023 12:45

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 12:16

Op do you like him? Close to him?

because it seems you can’t stand him

so presumably element of relief

I would probably say I’ve had a closer relationship than any of my siblings bar one sister who idolises him. I’m not that type of character but I used to work along side him in family business, was the one looking after him when my mother passed away. So yes we have always had a good relationship albeit broken currently. Honestly if you had asked me to predict this I wouldn’t have been able to

OP posts:
mychel · 29/04/2023 12:24

YeOldeTrout · 29/04/2023 12:03

ho hum, you've had 40+ years of not having this info, which lack of information you obviously prefer. But what if you Preferred to know? How dare he deny you of this information if you actually prefer to know. So he can't win, he can't presume which knowledge status you prefer without giving you a choice.

He's still the only dad you have. Nothing has actually changed but a bit of your family history you didn't know before.

You can cooperate with him on condition him that he's never to tell you the result because it makes ZERO difference in your life. I don't think he was U to tell you now, there was never a right time.

I had a very similar decision to make once, by the way. Am speaking with some experience. FWIW, in our family, most of us greatly wanted to know and some wanted to stay ignorant.

I guess without knowing everything and the whole history and circumstances you might be right but my questions were why now? I have no desire to put another family through turmoil and everything else that comes with this. I’m not denying anyone anything I’m an adult who’s just been delivered this news I should be allowed to process and decide what to do. I’ve asked for space which he’s not respecting I’ve had 3 calls today alone and it was the same the last 2 days I already told him this morning and last night I had plans this morning he’s not respecting my boundaries. I’ve told him to organise the test and I’ll do it just to know one way or another but either way I’m done now. I have always been the one at beck and call when he needs something and I actually feel quite used. I just want to go home now to be honest and not be here. There may never have been a good time for this conversation but I actually feel he has robbed me of the one thing I needed most and that was a complete break and rest. I’m going home broken and a complete mess as opposed to relaxed and rejuvenated.

OP posts:
Floralnomad · 29/04/2023 12:19

Are you sure he hasn’t already done the hair thing and knows the answer but doesn’t want to admit it .

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 12:16

Op do you like him? Close to him?

because it seems you can’t stand him

so presumably element of relief

YeOldeTrout · 29/04/2023 12:05

Is he generally impatient & demanding, is this what he's like about everything?

YeOldeTrout · 29/04/2023 12:03

ho hum, you've had 40+ years of not having this info, which lack of information you obviously prefer. But what if you Preferred to know? How dare he deny you of this information if you actually prefer to know. So he can't win, he can't presume which knowledge status you prefer without giving you a choice.

He's still the only dad you have. Nothing has actually changed but a bit of your family history you didn't know before.

You can cooperate with him on condition him that he's never to tell you the result because it makes ZERO difference in your life. I don't think he was U to tell you now, there was never a right time.

I had a very similar decision to make once, by the way. Am speaking with some experience. FWIW, in our family, most of us greatly wanted to know and some wanted to stay ignorant.

mychel · 29/04/2023 12:01

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 11:58

He openly admitted this?

He did!

OP posts:
mychel · 29/04/2023 11:58

MargaretThursday · 29/04/2023 11:55

He may haven it as a possibility since you were born, but maybe something has just come up which has led to him questioning further. Maybe someone has come forward to say they think they're your dad/halfsibling etc.

No 3rd party in this apparently. The other person involved has no idea.

OP posts:
Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 11:58

mychel · 29/04/2023 11:46

He was going to try to steal some hair or some of my child’s hair to test behind my back. There was ample opportunities over the years to do this.

He openly admitted this?

MargaretThursday · 29/04/2023 11:55

He may haven it as a possibility since you were born, but maybe something has just come up which has led to him questioning further. Maybe someone has come forward to say they think they're your dad/halfsibling etc.

mychel · 29/04/2023 11:46

TreeLine23 · 29/04/2023 11:37

You don't have to have a DNA test if you don't want to.

He was going to try to steal some hair or some of my child’s hair to test behind my back. There was ample opportunities over the years to do this.

OP posts:
mychel · 29/04/2023 11:43

Ponoka7 · 29/04/2023 11:25

Totally selfish, I suppose he hasn't even thought of your children in all of this? They could have biological relations that they'll want to meet etc. He should have got you tested as soon as the tests were reliable, or took it to the grave.

No he certainly hasn’t thought of the devastation this will cause to my children. He very obviously has his favourites anyway so this will only cement that in my children’s minds.

OP posts:
TreeLine23 · 29/04/2023 11:37

You don't have to have a DNA test if you don't want to.

mychel · 29/04/2023 11:32

I would say getting it off his chest benefits him allot more than me. There have been plenty of times in the last 20 or so years he could have brought it up. I feel like I’ve been handed a family secret that is like a bomb waiting to go off. I have seen first hand the effects of stuff like this on families and the irreparable damage it can do. All of his justifications when I asked why now appear to be purely for his benefit. Aside from the fact he has 4 other children with my mother. He swears it’s not inheritance related. He maintains it’s in case I ever needed something medically related highly unlikely. My parents got married very quickly after meeting which I’m assuming was because my mother was pregnant. So I’m sure he feels that he was hoodwinked. Apparently my mother told him before the wedding that there was a very slim chance that baby might not be his. I just don’t see the benefit of bringing any of this up now apart from him to clear his own head and possibly related to him telling his partner.

OP posts:
Stemmingthetide · 29/04/2023 11:27

@mychel what a shitty thing to do.

Email or text “I was clear we badly needed this holiday after all that has gone on over the last year. You have specifically chosen this badly needed holiday to drop a bombshell on me when you have had over 40 years to tell me. Please do not contact me again until I have had time to process this devastating news.”

When you get home organise the DNA test, not just with your Dad but also at least one sibling.

Ponoka7 · 29/04/2023 11:25

Totally selfish, I suppose he hasn't even thought of your children in all of this? They could have biological relations that they'll want to meet etc. He should have got you tested as soon as the tests were reliable, or took it to the grave.

ThinWomansBrain · 29/04/2023 11:11

if you don't want to talk about it with him now, block the calls.
Maybe he didn't bring testing up when you were a child because of his relationship with your mother?
Does he suspect that she had an affair, or know for certain that she was sleeping around/having an affair?

Mortimercat · 29/04/2023 11:10

mychel · 29/04/2023 10:46

Thanks everyone so back story is he has known since I was born that there is a slight possibility. He’s had over 40 years to bring this up. I was also very sick when I was very small where he could have had this brought up and tested and he would have known one way or another. In relation to my focus on the holiday. This holiday our whole family has known that we have needed a complete break for a very long time we had 2 close family members pass away in the last year. 2 major health conditions to deal with in our immediate family and he flew out here especially to do this here. The reason he doesn’t want other people to know is he knows my siblings will freak out with this type of news. He has also now totally monopolised our holiday he is calling and texting constantly asking to meet up. I have made it clear I want space but he wants to rush to get dna tests done now etc. in my opinion he had no need to bring this up ever. His claim is that if I ever needed medical treatment etc and he would be denying me the right to meet this other person. Who I’ve already decided i don’t want to this person is married and possibly has a family who’s lives would be torn apart also. I feel like I’ve just been handed an awful piece of knowledge that really benefits no one bar him and I feel there’s very selfish motivations behind this.

I had assumed he had just found something out and was as affected by this as you are. I guess him knowing for forty years puts a different slant on it, but there was never going to be a good time to bring this up. I don’t understand why you think this benefits him? Surely this will be devastating for him?

He didn’t have to bring it up, he could have gone to his grave with it, but I also think he had the right to bring it up if that was what he needed. You are not the only person impacted by this. Perhaps as women we can never understand how it might feel to not be sure if a child is biologically ours and shouldn’t try to.

I certainly think you are entitled to tell him you need some space to process this and leave you alone for the time being.

mychel · 29/04/2023 10:46

Thanks everyone so back story is he has known since I was born that there is a slight possibility. He’s had over 40 years to bring this up. I was also very sick when I was very small where he could have had this brought up and tested and he would have known one way or another. In relation to my focus on the holiday. This holiday our whole family has known that we have needed a complete break for a very long time we had 2 close family members pass away in the last year. 2 major health conditions to deal with in our immediate family and he flew out here especially to do this here. The reason he doesn’t want other people to know is he knows my siblings will freak out with this type of news. He has also now totally monopolised our holiday he is calling and texting constantly asking to meet up. I have made it clear I want space but he wants to rush to get dna tests done now etc. in my opinion he had no need to bring this up ever. His claim is that if I ever needed medical treatment etc and he would be denying me the right to meet this other person. Who I’ve already decided i don’t want to this person is married and possibly has a family who’s lives would be torn apart also. I feel like I’ve just been handed an awful piece of knowledge that really benefits no one bar him and I feel there’s very selfish motivations behind this.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread