Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really annoyed by this?

89 replies

mychel · 29/04/2023 10:16

So myself and dh are on our first holiday in 5 years. My dh has a medical condition that requires medical treatment while abroad so my father offered us the use of his house abroad. When it came to the holiday and logistics we decided that it might be easier to stay near the treatment facility where it would be easier to get to and from. Then about 2 weeks before we departed my father announced he was going out to his house and would be there during our stay. I was surprised as his partner wasn’t going with him just him alone but decided ah it would be nice to see him whilst out here. The first morning while my husband was at treatment my father asked to come meet me for coffee. During this coffee he dropped a bombshell that actually it turns out he’s possibly not my father after all and wants me to take a dna test. (Yes I’m actually serious) he’s decided after 40 something years and about 10 years since my mother passed away that he wants to know for sure if I’m his. So of course I’ve been in shock and very upset that I’ve been lied to for years and years but I’m more upset that he’s decided to do this now during our much longed for holiday after a very tough ( years of health and family issues). I’m also obviously annoyed that I’ve been lied to my entire life but he also has basically banned me from discussing it with anyone outside of dh. Am I being unreasonable to be so upset at the fact that he has destroyed our holiday?

OP posts:
Bunnichick · 29/04/2023 17:09

I agree with @JudgeRudy

I agree that the timing is poor but some people just don't think the same way as you and he may have thought it was better to tell you away from the family. He can't insist you do anything or that you do it on his timescales and he can't insist you don't tell anyone else. If he being push tell him you're on holiday and not replying to any more of his messages.

Having said that, his feelings matter too and this could be on his mind and sounds like it has been on his mind for some time. If it really is just the timing of the holiday then it's bigger than the holiday anyway so I consider that a bit of a red herring.

limoncello23 · 29/04/2023 16:59

What a self-centred and thoughtless thing for him to do.

I really think that you should tell at least one other person you trust about what he has done so you can get some support. And then not speak to him until after your holiday.

This kind of thing can be deeply unsettling and destabilising. If it feels like that for you after it's sunk in a bit then counselling would probably be really helpful.

Only take the DNA test if it's something you yourself want to know. It actually shouldn't make any different to him at this stage, you are the daughter he raised either way.

Mortimercat · 29/04/2023 16:56

SmallFerret · 29/04/2023 16:43

This has clearly tormented him for 40 years.
It clearly hasn't, as he can give no better reason for choosing to tell OP than his bullshit "but potential medical.genetic stiff" which obviously didn't torment him for 40 years, or he would have taken steps to address it, for the benefit of OP's health.
He didn't, so he didn't care, so it's not about medical stuff.

It might not have been his decision to stay quiet
He made the decision to stay quiet when OP's mum told him of the possibility BEFORE THEY GOT MARRIED. He could have insisted on a DNA test at that point, & walked away if he wanted to.
He chose not to test. he chose to marry, & he chose to stay quiet.

How can you possibly say it has not tormented him? I presume you are a female and if you are a mother, I think you can be fairly certain that your child is yours, bar any highly unusual hospital mix up. I think it is hard to comprehend how a man might feel, especially when the mother had hinted that he might or might not be the father.

Who is to say that the right response was to that? We didn’t have DNA testing 40+ years ago, so it was not as simple as taking a test, he chose to stand by OP’s mother.

As to picking the right moment, what was the right moment? There was never going to be a good time for this. I don’t understand “why now”. Why yesterday? Why the day before? Why five years before? None were good times because there are no good times for this,

ps I am not sure why my post has gone into italics but I am on a mobile and don’t know how to fix it.

YeOldeTrout · 29/04/2023 16:48

Ok, talk to me like I'm 5.

How did he wound OP with this suspicion?
Did he say he loves her less, or will love her less if she's not biologically his?
Did he tell OP she should condemn her mother?
Did he say it was OP's fault?
Did he say that's why he hated her mother?
Did he tell OP that he KNEW for sure she wasn't his & therefore he KNOWS she's been lied to?
Did he say he will stop caring about OP's children if they aren't his bio GKids?
Did he say he regrets raising her & regarding her as his daughter?

I agree that he shouldn't badger her about it, nag her or tell her what to do with the information. I'm 100% in support of OP stamping her feet, telling him off for the nagging & to take his over-excitement about the potential revelation, elsewhere. This whole situation is his problem, not hers.

it sounds like when excitement in his mind has calmed down (presumably weeks from now), that OP might get some sense out of him on the "Why Now" question. The "medical things" excuse is weird, I wouldn't be satisfied with that either, but could let it lie for now.

RandomMess · 29/04/2023 16:43

It's totally ridiculous that he waited you were on holiday to ambush you with this, I'm not surprised you are fuming! He could have waited a few weeks until you were back home.

I would block him for now whilst you come to terms with it and try enjoy your holiday.

Flowers
SmallFerret · 29/04/2023 16:43

This has clearly tormented him for 40 years.
It clearly hasn't, as he can give no better reason for choosing to tell OP than his bullshit "but potential medical.genetic stiff" which obviously didn't torment him for 40 years, or he would have taken steps to address it, for the benefit of OP's health.
He didn't, so he didn't care, so it's not about medical stuff.

It might not have been his decision to stay quiet
He made the decision to stay quiet when OP's mum told him of the possibility BEFORE THEY GOT MARRIED. He could have insisted on a DNA test at that point, & walked away if he wanted to.
He chose not to test. he chose to marry, & he chose to stay quiet.

SmallFerret · 29/04/2023 16:36

Nimbostratus100 · 29/04/2023 13:45

speaking as someone who once had to be traced by distant relatives and warned of potentially lethal genetic disease in the family, I can see his point

😂A 'point' so close to his heart that he did fuck-all about it for 4 decades?

SmallFerret · 29/04/2023 16:35

ho hum, you've had 40+ years of not having this info, which lack of information you obviously prefer. But what if you Preferred to know? How dare he deny you of this information if you actually prefer to know. So he can't win, he can't presume which knowledge status you prefer without giving you a choice.

The "win" here is retroactive. He can't have a "win" now, because he's just fucked up really badly.
He could have found out - as OP told us - at any point during OP's childhood, when having medical tests/check ups etc.

Had he done so, & found he was not OP's bio father, she could have been told kindly & appropriately, as a youngster, while her mum was still alive. Parents presenting a united front, telling OP that dad chose to stay & chose to love her as his own.

He chose not to do that.
That's fine & dandy, but now the opportunity has passed, he's changed his mind & was comfortable with wounding OP - his CHILD, no matter the genetic facts - in order to satisfy his selfishness.

WasIWasINot · 29/04/2023 16:34

Honestly if it was me I’d be telling him he’ll have to take it to the grave, and I wouldn’t agree to any test. Nothing.

I suspect this is about inheritance, there is literally no reason why someone has to drop this kind of bombshell on someone after 40 years. The whole “in case you need medical treatment” line is a load of bollocks.

And I’d be telling him that either he backs off or I would tell everyone. How dare he drop this on you now. This is not your secret to have to keep.

My dad is my dad, and if it transpired now that he might not be I wouldn’t want to know.

Genuinely I think that if you’re brought up by someone, if they’re your parent, then it really doesn’t mattter in the scheme of things. I would have no interest in any potential other siblings and what-not because my family are my family.

SmallFerret · 29/04/2023 16:28

Apparently my mother told him before the wedding that there was a very slim chance that baby might not be his.
So he went ahead with the wedding anyway, accepting this slim possibility.
It's so unfair for him to bring it up now.
He married your mum, knowing a child was on the way, & that made him your legal father.

I just don’t see the benefit of bringing any of this up now apart from him to clear his own head and possibly related to him telling his partner.
His head was already clear. He knew what he was doing. Your mum was upfront & honest with him. How dare he change his mind now, & bring you into it?
He doesn't need to tell his partner, & he certainly shouldn't have told you.

SmallFerret · 29/04/2023 16:24

He maintains it’s in case I ever needed something medically related highly unlikely.

Mendacious twat.
Your medical needs didn't worry him for 40 years.
What a stinking hypocrite.

SmallFerret · 29/04/2023 16:20

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 10:20

you have had some enormous news but seem very focussed on your holiday!

anyway, putting that aside - it would be that he thought it would bean opp for you to digest the news, talk to him, ask questions etc without normal life distractions

Amazingly, people are capable of holding more than one thought at a time.
Your post seems critical of OP - the exclamation point didn't soften the cutting nature of your opening sentence.

Why do you think OP shouldn't be annoyed/disappointed/distressed about this news spoiling her holiday? It's not her fault her DF chose to break this nasty news to her. If he were a better dad (bio or not) he'd have kept it to himself. What is the point of upsetting OP with it now, in her 40's?

His actions were selfish & cruel.
it would be that he thought it would bean opp for you to digest the news, talk to him, ask questions etc without normal life distractions
Nope.
Where & when he broke this news isn't the issue.
The issue is, that 40 years after having OP, he now chooses to hurt her with his suspicions. Even if they are true, she's not responsible for any alleged wrongdoing on her mother's part.

YeOldeTrout · 29/04/2023 16:20

Could you send him one message like...
"I agreed to have the test. I'll do that when I get back. Until then you need to talk about this to someone else because it is literally Not my problem and I am not remotely curious. I need to have a mental break from everyone else's worries now. That's why I am going to ignore your messages until I'm ready to do the test, which is a little while after I get back. I'm not mad at you I just can't take on your worries & problems. Take care" (or however you would usually sign off).

And literally block his messages. They can go into a black hole until you unblock him & let him know you're ready.

It sounds like this ignore-until strategy is an option for you. He is U to hassle you.

SmallFerret · 29/04/2023 16:13

I’m also obviously annoyed that I’ve been lied to my entire life but he also has basically banned me from discussing it with anyone outside of dh.

Let me get this straight.

DF wants you to take a DNA test - why? Is he going to disown you after 4 decades of being/acting as your dad if the test says you're not his bio child?

He also wants you to keep HIS shabby secret. Why? So he gets his own way (is he hoping for some kind of retroactive moral victory?), but he thinks you should be made to act like you are something shameful, & are not allowed to discuss your feelings about this awful bombshell your dad has chosen to land on you?

TomatoSandwiches · 29/04/2023 16:00

The only one being unfair is your father, he is a real piece of work deciding to do this on your much needed holiday and even after agreeing to the test is ignoring your boundaries and harassing you daily with phone calls.

He is selfish, rude and entitled.

I'd be telling all the siblings.

Lefteyetwitch · 29/04/2023 15:50

Nimbostratus100 · 29/04/2023 15:45

I think you are being unfair on him

40 years ago maybe he made the decision to take it to his grave, but things have changed, people get their DNA checked as a hobby these days, and the chances of it never coming out are zero. Anyone in your family if diagnosed with a genetic defect, or any one of your children ever do one of those silly ancestry things, and it will be public knowledge,

and anyway, it sounds like the chances are, you are his.

And the reason he couldn't have done this in 2 weeks?

billy1966 · 29/04/2023 15:46

What an awful man your father is.

You should inform your whole family what he has done.

Why are you following orders not to tell anyone?

He dodoesn'get to decide whom you speak to.

A man like that, so selfish, it won't be any great loss.

Step away OP, he sounds so selfish and awful.

Nimbostratus100 · 29/04/2023 15:45

I think you are being unfair on him

40 years ago maybe he made the decision to take it to his grave, but things have changed, people get their DNA checked as a hobby these days, and the chances of it never coming out are zero. Anyone in your family if diagnosed with a genetic defect, or any one of your children ever do one of those silly ancestry things, and it will be public knowledge,

and anyway, it sounds like the chances are, you are his.

mychel · 29/04/2023 15:38

I have asked why now and if his need is so great he should have insisted years ago, when my mother was around to sit down and have this conversation. The reason I’m showing anger towards him is the timing, after everything we have going on at home I was looking forward to a real rest. I just feel it could have been brought up so many times over the years. I have agreed to the test and I just want it over with tbh, how he has gone about this has fractured the relationship we did have.

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 29/04/2023 15:16

This must be very shocking news and I can understand your anger however I'm going to suggest an alternative view. You're saying his timing is appalling (it is) and that you'd have rather not have known about the doubts and that he's selfish...and on the face of things he is but I think you're disregarding his feelings.
This has clearly tormented him for 40 years. It might not have been his decision to stay quiet. Now your mum is dead he has had freedom to play it his way but he's debated if it would be a good or a bad thing. You talk about favourites. Maybe he knows that this doubt has subconsciously affected how he relates to you. Ultimately he hadca choice. The secret was becoming unbearable and he felt you both deserved the truth. He sounds an honest man as he's told you how he was tempted to 'steal' dna for testing but decided that would be unethical so didn't.
Regards why you should know he probably can't articulate. I think everyone should know who their biological parents are...and aren't!
He's chosen now because he wants to talk with you F2F. He's probably not considered how much you needed this break and that this is your 'holiday' and this is poor timing.
Ignoring your boundaries though is selfish. Tell him to leave you alone and that if he contacts you again you'll be off and they'll be no test.
I would give this time to settle and not make any hasty decisions. Also don't overlook your mothers part in this. They both did what they thought was right at the time. You're dad has likely felt for sometime (since your mum's passing?) that that wasn't the right action. He's tried to keep it in but he can't. His need is maybe greater than yours.

Coolblur · 29/04/2023 15:13

Have you ask him what difference it makes for him to know? He should have asked himself that. Surely it doesn't matter at this stage, he's your father regardless of whether he is biologically. Does he plan on your relationship changing if you're not actually blood relatives?

Maddy70 · 29/04/2023 15:12

I would refuse. Just say you don't want to. It doesn't matter to you if he's your biological dad or not

After all this time do you think he is OK? Sounds as if he could be having a mental health issue

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 15:11

Theunamedcat · 29/04/2023 15:03

All I'm getting is anger he is adding to her already heavy load just how much more does he want her to take? Middle of treatment during a much needed holiday after loads of stress SOUNDS PERFECT!

dick move

Yes so he sounds an absolute twat

he utter thoughtlessness won’t have come out of the blue to the OP.

I suspect that their relationship was pretty bleak before his behaviour now so my point was…. Op, you’re not related to this tool that you clearly dislike. Eventually that will be reason to celebrate

Theunamedcat · 29/04/2023 15:04

Personally I would say no I don't want to do this

Then buy an ancestry DNA kit and see if my family showed up

Also tell your siblings they should know what he is doing

Theunamedcat · 29/04/2023 15:03

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 12:16

Op do you like him? Close to him?

because it seems you can’t stand him

so presumably element of relief

All I'm getting is anger he is adding to her already heavy load just how much more does he want her to take? Middle of treatment during a much needed holiday after loads of stress SOUNDS PERFECT!

dick move

Swipe left for the next trending thread