Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Heartbroken and totally let down by education system

256 replies

Amatueuragonyaunt · 28/04/2023 22:56

I'm after advice (and a bit of a vent). Ever since the start of the COVID fiasco, my two children (then 5 and 8 years old) have been totally failed by the state sector. My daughter is bright, but was not being pushed and was losing self confidence because of a lack of feedback and attention, so we moved her to a selective independent school where she is now thriving. The finances were (and are) a stretch, so we left our DS in the state system with the plan to see how things went and then move him at the same age as we moved our daughter (10). However, his needs are at the other end of the spectrum. It became apparent to us during pandemic home learning that there was some issue going on, but it took a further year before the school took it seriously enough to commission an assessment and another year after that before we got the report. It turns out he has severe dyslexia. This came as a both a surprise and not because we had suspected something, but generally his school reports were good with just a few weaker areas. Anyway, fast forward a few months when a load of interventions have supposedly been put in place - we don't feel confident that he's making much progress and we're aware of other children in the class with severe behavioural issues which were taking up the TAs time in entirety (so no support for anyone else). As such, we brought forward our quest to go independent and arranged taster days at a local non-selective school with good SENCO provision. Our boy loved it. However - here's the rub - the school won't offer him a place because he is more than two years behind the other children in that class. Needless to say, he's feeling pretty despondent about it, but what I'm fuming about is how his current school let it get that bad and not even tell us. Everything that has been put in place for him has only come about because we forced the issue and, when we were doing it, we were made to feel like we were overreacting and we're even told that actually our son was a bit lazy. This was before the report came out. This is an 8 year old who has been turned down for entry at a non-selective school that we are prepared to pay for because he is too far behind his peers. How is it that we have to send him in taster days just to find out how bad things are? The fact it's all come to light in a way which has left our son utterly gutted is the final straw. We didn't see it coming so couldn't manage expectations. We now have a situation where one child is flying and getting tons of opportunities while the other is completely shafted and there seems to be nothing we can do about it except give the current school a rocket (and what difference will that make?). To say I am fuming is an understatement. Anyone had similar or have any words of comfort or advice?

PS - the current school is supposedly 'outstanding' according to Ofsted, but it's not worked at all for our kids.

OP posts:
diflasu · 29/04/2023 17:12

I don't think people get that if your child has learning difficulties then school is exhausting so then 'extra' school with a tutor is a massive ask.

This was absolutely an issue how tired they were from school - even now it can be and lack of study leave I do think is adversely affecting DS even now.

I suppose because I was doing it not a tutor it was more possible to little and often but with multiple children needing help it did frequently feel overwhelming but be end of primary they weren't behind anymore and were in strong position for secondary.

diflasu · 29/04/2023 17:05

what I'm fuming about is how his current school let it get that bad and not even tell us. Everything that has been put in place for him has only come about because we forced the issue

Over a decade ago this was our experience as well - only aware there could be issues because of diagnosis in my generation and kept being told it was all fine.

Luckily I could offer home support and MN primary board was fanatic for resource information.

there seems to be nothing we can do about it except give the current school a rocket (and what difference will that make?).

If you have money and little time I'd look at a tutor to support him otherwise -

https://www.soundfoundations.co.uk/

https://www.spelfabet.com.au/ is an Australia site and not really suitable for Uk style pronunciations but she good for resources and background info

Any maths problems - maths factor with some physical rods/numicon

What I wouldn't do is wait on the school to improve matters even with their interventions - I'd be looking to put in support outside school with hope he can catch up - and if he's really 2 years behind I'd expect it to take longer than that to catch up - so I'd be focused on trying to get him where he should be with a view to going private at secondary.

Also look at ways to bolster his confidence - groups/sports etc and keep interest with comics, audio books or https://www.barringtonstoke.co.uk/dyslexic-reluctant-readers/ style books or https://www.readingchest.co.uk/about-us

School are in a bad place at the minute resource wise - but even when they were in a better place we were fobbed off and our concerns dismissed.

We did move schools in end due to work relocation to a supposedly less desirable school that couldn't rely on parental support so much - smaller class sizes were a massive benefit but also we weren't snowed under with busy work homework and there was much less of an expectation we'd fill in gaps. I'm not sure if that would still be the case with all the funding cuts lately - but moving schools may be worth exploring.

Teaching dyslexic children to read and spell | Sound Foundations Books

Dancing Bears books pioneered synthetic phonics: easy-to-use books with exercises & proven success in teaching dyslexic children to read and spell.

https://www.soundfoundations.co.uk

PocketSand · 29/04/2023 16:35

@izzy2076

The trouble is that teaching staff - who don't read or understand section B of an EHCP - can't distinguish between who is the most needy at an individual level and who is the most disruptive in whole class sessions.

Sometimes the most disruptive are the least needy. And the 'quiet' (ie selectively mute) are the most needy but fly so far under the radar that they are considered 'fine' until it is too late and they fall out of education entirely.

DS1 was failed at primary. Went to specialist after pushy parents got an EHCP and went to tribunal for specialist placement. It was too late.

BusyMum47 · 29/04/2023 16:24

DelphiniumBlue · 29/04/2023 00:15

Yes, all of this.
And be aware that in many areas the criteria for getting an EHCP involve pages of evidence which take months to obtain ( ie asking for things to be tried for 6 months before moving to next step)and once they are written can take many more months/years to be processed .
I had meeting recently with the Ed Psych for a particular child who made a list of steps the school needed to follow ( in front of the parents) and all the steps required 1:1 input from an adult. If there had been a class TA then maybe they could have found time to implement strategies such as typing lessons, occupational therapy etc once they had the training to do that, but in most classes there is only the teacher, who can't do that stuff while teaching 29 other children something else. Their attitude was that until those steps have been implemented and tried out and no improvement seen, then we can't move on to the next step, recommending funding for additional support!
I work in a fantastic school with caring staff but we cannot supply 1:1 support for any but the most extreme cases. I hate saying cases, each one is a child who needs help. There are simply not enough adults to go round. We are struggling to provide enough adults to supervise SATs properly next week, we need additional adults to allow those children who need extra time and/or breaks to have that adjustment. Our budget is in deficit, we can't afford to get enough supply staff even if there were sufficient available... it's not the school who has let down your child but the government. Do lobby your MP about this.

This! This! This! ⬆️

Speaking as a fellow Primary School Teacher. It frustrates & upsets us more than you could imagine.

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 15:56

Coffeeandbourbons · 29/04/2023 15:49

I’m just saying, there just seems to be so much special needs around now compared to 20-30 years ago. It wasn’t the dark ages it was late 90s-early 2000s

i wonder what’s causing it that’s all, it’s worrying

What’s “causing it all” is an awareness

have you bothered to look in to the shockingly rapid increasing rates of adults being diagnosed as ND ie your peers!

whumpthereitis · 29/04/2023 15:54

Another76543 · 29/04/2023 12:42

Unfortunately the state system is failing a lot of children (not just because of funding, but also because of bad behaviour, and teachers having to spend time doing crowd control rather than teaching).

You mention that private school fees will be a financial stretch, so just bear in mind that, if the Labour Party get in, they have said they will remove charitable status and add VAT to fees, because apparently a decent education is a luxury……. (a whole other thread!)

A lot of promises are made in the run up to an election, but that doesn’t mean they’ll be kept. Labour can’t just remove their charitable status, it’s not their decision. That’s down to the charity commission. When there was a case heard about the charitable status of private schools, private schools won in court.

Phineyj · 29/04/2023 15:54

How is political discussion helpful to this OP? There are regular threads on here to discuss all that.

Start a thread discussing what's wrong with the education system today and you will get lots of takers.

Presumably OP would like practical help for her son now rather than a discussion of why we're all going to hell in a handcart!

Coffeeandbourbons · 29/04/2023 15:49

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 15:34

So about 200 children.

sorts be clear

your sample of 200
from decades ago
when you were a child

and you have extrapolated that because you don’t remember violence etc…. What?

I’m just saying, there just seems to be so much special needs around now compared to 20-30 years ago. It wasn’t the dark ages it was late 90s-early 2000s

i wonder what’s causing it that’s all, it’s worrying

SunnyEgg · 29/04/2023 15:39

Also did the school reports break down by meeting expectations etc

Did they all say he was meeting them?

RudsyFarmer · 29/04/2023 15:35

Amatueuragonyaunt · 28/04/2023 22:56

I'm after advice (and a bit of a vent). Ever since the start of the COVID fiasco, my two children (then 5 and 8 years old) have been totally failed by the state sector. My daughter is bright, but was not being pushed and was losing self confidence because of a lack of feedback and attention, so we moved her to a selective independent school where she is now thriving. The finances were (and are) a stretch, so we left our DS in the state system with the plan to see how things went and then move him at the same age as we moved our daughter (10). However, his needs are at the other end of the spectrum. It became apparent to us during pandemic home learning that there was some issue going on, but it took a further year before the school took it seriously enough to commission an assessment and another year after that before we got the report. It turns out he has severe dyslexia. This came as a both a surprise and not because we had suspected something, but generally his school reports were good with just a few weaker areas. Anyway, fast forward a few months when a load of interventions have supposedly been put in place - we don't feel confident that he's making much progress and we're aware of other children in the class with severe behavioural issues which were taking up the TAs time in entirety (so no support for anyone else). As such, we brought forward our quest to go independent and arranged taster days at a local non-selective school with good SENCO provision. Our boy loved it. However - here's the rub - the school won't offer him a place because he is more than two years behind the other children in that class. Needless to say, he's feeling pretty despondent about it, but what I'm fuming about is how his current school let it get that bad and not even tell us. Everything that has been put in place for him has only come about because we forced the issue and, when we were doing it, we were made to feel like we were overreacting and we're even told that actually our son was a bit lazy. This was before the report came out. This is an 8 year old who has been turned down for entry at a non-selective school that we are prepared to pay for because he is too far behind his peers. How is it that we have to send him in taster days just to find out how bad things are? The fact it's all come to light in a way which has left our son utterly gutted is the final straw. We didn't see it coming so couldn't manage expectations. We now have a situation where one child is flying and getting tons of opportunities while the other is completely shafted and there seems to be nothing we can do about it except give the current school a rocket (and what difference will that make?). To say I am fuming is an understatement. Anyone had similar or have any words of comfort or advice?

PS - the current school is supposedly 'outstanding' according to Ofsted, but it's not worked at all for our kids.

Could you pay for tutoring to catch him up?

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 15:34

So about 200 children.

sorts be clear

your sample of 200
from decades ago
when you were a child

and you have extrapolated that because you don’t remember violence etc…. What?

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 15:33

Coffeeandbourbons · 29/04/2023 14:54

Previously, these children might have been deemed difficult or naughty and placed in special schools.

No, I don’t really believe this. When I was growing up I knew many many many families through school and church, and lived in a large village where not much was hidden. Maybe around 80-100 families? So about 200 children. Out of those I knew one boy who had quite severe cerebral palsy, one with moderate learning difficulties (she’s now married with a job and lives mainly independently), and one child who was ‘odd’ and is now transgender autistic. I don’t remember any children being exceptionally violent, or anything like that. There must be a true rise in conditions but I wonder what is causing it, I hope people are trying to find out as well as just treating them if you see what I mean.

Referring back to what you remember as a child in terms of children and neuro diversity is ridiculous

the op has clarified her son is articulate and well behaved. So from his peers perspective, no issue.

Bamboozleme · 29/04/2023 15:28

Amatueuragonyaunt · 29/04/2023 10:52

He's 9 in a couple of weeks. I'm happy to agree to differ on the agency point. I'm not saying that just because he says no we won't do it. However, I don't want him to feel railroaded so will do my best to try and lead him to the decision we think is best for him!

Parents making educational choices on a half of their 8 year old is not railroading.

Another76543 · 29/04/2023 15:25

SnackSizeRaisin · 29/04/2023 14:39

A private education is a luxury. Hopefully a state education is decent, otherwise 95% of children are screwed.

Running state education into the ground but keeping private schools slightly cheaper to benefit the 5% who can afford them is obviously not the answer.

Bear in mind that if labour don't get in, the education and NHS and everything else will continue to get worse in coming years.

You only have to read threads like this, and other threads where teachers are saying they just can’t cope with conditions in the classroom any more, to realise that a private education is not a luxury for many families - their children are being failed by the state system, and they feel they have no choice. Just like the OP. It’s dreadful. Yes, they are lucky to have a choice when many others don’t, but someone needs to urgently tackle the problems in the state sector. I’m not convinced extra funding alone will sort it.

Someone needs to look at whether the “one size fits all” approach is the best one - do we need more specialist schools instead? Is the National Curriculum and OFSTED fit for purpose? Why is behaviour so bad in the classroom? Why are so many teachers leaving and not joining (it’s as much about conditions as pay). Is the current schools’ budget being used in the best possible way? There are some very highly paid people running academies for example - is that the best use of taxpayers’ money? I don’t know the answers.

The current government have failed to improve the state system, and it’s arguably now worse, but I fear that Labour’s obsession with the 6% privately educated is using energy and efforts which should be focused on the 94% in the state system. The estimated gains from taxing private schools is a tiny proportion of the overall education budget. We need more than that.

It’s easy to say that funding will solve everything, but the funding needs to come from somewhere, be that decreased spending elsewhere or increased taxes.

Since the 1980s, real terms education funding has doubled, and yet schools now can’t afford glue sticks. Why?

Re SEN provision, I’ve found these charts which show that over the last 15 years or so, the number of SEN children has actually fallen. The “high needs block” of the Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG), intended for special educational needs provision in state-funded schools has increased in real terms by almost 40% over the last 8 years or so. Admittedly the charts don’t seem to correlate with what teachers are saying is happening in the classroom, but I have no idea why.

I don’t know the answers, but I do think it’s a lot more complicated than a simple question of funding.

Heartbroken and totally let down by education system
Heartbroken and totally let down by education system
SunnyEgg · 29/04/2023 15:13

Hi op I can see you are feeling some shock around the recent diagnosis and new information

The private school sounds keen, even if it is a year below. Out of interest you posted they turned down your ds and won’t offer him a place did you just mean because it was t the right year?

Dyslexia can take a while to assess, I recall a pre prep getting into strife with paying parents as a few dc had been missed. The feedback was characteristically they’re doing very well (as is often wanted as feedback) but huge disappointment when some found out dyslexia was missed and no places offered at next school entry.

It can happen in small prep schools too.

The other element is prep schools can select out SEN anyway so they have lower extra needs. Was there an extra charge for support? I assume not

I think private can be great if it’s a good fit, so it may well work

Although I would question why reports had not flagged any issues in state. Private may well have their own take on this and I’d want to understand where both sectors are coming from.

Coffeeandbourbons · 29/04/2023 14:54

Previously, these children might have been deemed difficult or naughty and placed in special schools.

No, I don’t really believe this. When I was growing up I knew many many many families through school and church, and lived in a large village where not much was hidden. Maybe around 80-100 families? So about 200 children. Out of those I knew one boy who had quite severe cerebral palsy, one with moderate learning difficulties (she’s now married with a job and lives mainly independently), and one child who was ‘odd’ and is now transgender autistic. I don’t remember any children being exceptionally violent, or anything like that. There must be a true rise in conditions but I wonder what is causing it, I hope people are trying to find out as well as just treating them if you see what I mean.

ConsuelaHammock · 29/04/2023 14:46

Take the space in the year below and explain that it’s only until he catches up. Get a tutor to work with him in the meantime. Do you have the results of any NRIT or cat tests?

Spendonsend · 29/04/2023 14:40

Coffeeandbourbons · 29/04/2023 13:28

Yes but why? What’s happening to our kids? Is there no curiosity why so many of them have conditions?

I think there is curiosity, but its not just one thing. There are better survival rates for children with conditions which is one cause. Older parents is another cause.

There has been a baby boom (which has ended now) but there were just more children generally. Lots of schools expanded and took bulge classes but special schools were closed or didnt expand. So even if there was the exact same % of SEN as always, more were being put in mainstream as sen school places were a smaller % of overall school places.

Thats before you get to all the people who were actually failed by education before but it wasnt such a high stakes testing system so it didnt notice so much.

Ehcps were also extended to 25 years old with no extra funding. So suddenly lots of people who would have aged out the funds were retained within them.

SnackSizeRaisin · 29/04/2023 14:39

Another76543 · 29/04/2023 12:42

Unfortunately the state system is failing a lot of children (not just because of funding, but also because of bad behaviour, and teachers having to spend time doing crowd control rather than teaching).

You mention that private school fees will be a financial stretch, so just bear in mind that, if the Labour Party get in, they have said they will remove charitable status and add VAT to fees, because apparently a decent education is a luxury……. (a whole other thread!)

A private education is a luxury. Hopefully a state education is decent, otherwise 95% of children are screwed.

Running state education into the ground but keeping private schools slightly cheaper to benefit the 5% who can afford them is obviously not the answer.

Bear in mind that if labour don't get in, the education and NHS and everything else will continue to get worse in coming years.

Nightlystroll · 29/04/2023 14:25

Soontobe60 · 29/04/2023 09:50

I have 2 TAs in my class. Both full time. But I also have 1 child with very high needs and his EHCP provision is 1:1 support at all times, so that excludes one TA. I also have 4 children who attend a PRU 2 days a week - the 3 days they are in class they require the full attention of the remaining TA (plus the SENCo, learning mentor, DHT and HT when their behaviour deteriorates). In addition, I have a handful of children who speak no English, some with very little English, some who did absolutely nothing all throughout lockdown because their parent speaks no English. The rest of the children range in ability with a probably 4 year age span. On a daily basis it’s like juggling jelly!

It might be like juggling jelly but according to you, you have identified the problems that your learners have and presumably you're not recording in your reports that they're working at the level for their age. Because that's exactly what the op is concerned about. That the teacher of her child has been sending out good reports about her son when in reality he's two years behind his age.

As a teacher myself, I'd like to think that not only would I know if someone was two levels below what would be expected but that I'd also have informed the parents of what's happening. I'd think that's a pretty basic requirement.

Phineyj · 29/04/2023 13:59

Hi OP, I have a year 5 DC with SEN (not dyslexia) at a private school. It is routine for private schools to work a year ahead because part of their remit is to get children ready for competitive entrance exams that happen at the beginning of year 6.

So by offering your son a place in the year below he's at national age related expectations. He's done fantastically considering the dyslexia, the disruption and Covid etc! Can you reframe this for him?

The SENCO at the private sounds good. She spent an hour on the phone to you. I would take her advice seriously.

My DC's school have been great with her and they are a top 20 prep. They still manage to be inclusive of different DC. There are kind and supportive privates. There are less than brilliant state schools (I've taught in both sectors).

Regarding your son's self-esteem, what is he good at? My DC is bright but not at all academic. She has talent in some sports and loves acting and singing. We make a big fuss of her achievements in those (tbh we both are actually impressed.. I have two left feet and DH would probably rather shoot himself than take up am dram...)

SleepyRich · 29/04/2023 13:56

Coffeeandbourbons · 29/04/2023 13:28

Yes but why? What’s happening to our kids? Is there no curiosity why so many of them have conditions?

In recent years, there has been a significant increase in the recognition of SEN students in mainstream schools. Previously, these children might have been deemed difficult or naughty and placed in special schools. As rates of SEN identification continue to rise, the government is reevaluating its approach to providing support (see "Fit for the Future? Rethinking the Public Services Workforce" for more information).

The expectation is that, as the working population decreases in proportion to those unable to work due to disability or old age, public service standards may need to be lowered. This would involve relying more on lower-skilled and cheaper-to-train staff, such as nurses, paramedics, and ACPs taking leading roles in healthcare where previously Drs/GPs would have done so. In schools Teaching Assistants (TAs) or unqualified staff will take increasingly senior roles with more responsibility. It's very possible that the primary educator for a year group may eventually be an upskilled TA or someone with a similar background.

The trend of an increasingly frail and non-working population is challenging to reverse, as advancements in healthcare have led to longer lifespans. People are surviving serious health conditions, managing chronic illnesses more effectively, and engaging in fewer harmful behaviors such as smoking. There are numerous theories regarding the rise in SEN children unable to join the workforce, including factors such as pollution, diet, reduced vaccination rates, older parents, breakdown of family structures, and sedentary lifestyles with increased exposure to technology (i.e. more time spent watching tv not learning to interact/socialise/cope with being bored instead of constant entertainment. It's likely that each of these factors has a small, cumulative impact, making the situation difficult to reverse as society will struggle to revert.

One potential solution is to encourage an influx of working-age immigrants to the UK. However, this presents its own set of difficulties, as highly skilled UK workers are increasingly leaving the country permanently. Attracting skilled workers to the UK will become more difficult as living standards fail to keep pace with other Western nations. This ongoing cycle could lead to a continued loss of essential professionals such as teachers, doctors, nurses, and entrepreneurs who seek a more comfortable life abroad, whilst living standards in developing nations overtake that of the UK meaning those residents will no longer seek to work in the UK.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 29/04/2023 13:47

At 8 years old there's no such thing as being 'behind' it's an artificially constructed barrier to keep your son out.

I agree with this. You have a problem with the new school, and I would try a different one.

Losingtheplot2016 · 29/04/2023 13:41

Same Same!! I feel really bloody angry about state education. I feel like I'm paying for its failings. It's a massive 'one size fits all' and if that's not you then tough.

We've moved our daughter - moderate dyslexia - to a private school at the start of yr 8. She is now a totally different person. Enjoying school !

She is still exhausted from being in school though

I don't think people get that if your child has learning difficulties then school is exhausting so then 'extra' school with a tutor is a massive ask.

Radical I know - can you get a tutor for a morning when they should be in school and then send them in later!!

izzy2076 · 29/04/2023 13:41

Coffeeandbourbons · 29/04/2023 13:28

Yes but why? What’s happening to our kids? Is there no curiosity why so many of them have conditions?

I think people are much much more aware of neurodiversity. Children who may have been seen as having weak literacy previously are being diagnosed with dyslexia if their parents can afford the assessment.

Lots and lots of people are currently being diagnosed with adhd when previously they would have been seen as a 'bit scatty.'

I'm aware of how difficult it can be to secure a diagnosis for children, how rigorous and long it can be to get an ASD assessment for example. But there are private experts who can be paid to secure an assessment demanding reasonable adjustments very quickly and we end up with far more children requiring adjustments than schools can cope with.