Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Heartbroken and totally let down by education system

256 replies

Amatueuragonyaunt · 28/04/2023 22:56

I'm after advice (and a bit of a vent). Ever since the start of the COVID fiasco, my two children (then 5 and 8 years old) have been totally failed by the state sector. My daughter is bright, but was not being pushed and was losing self confidence because of a lack of feedback and attention, so we moved her to a selective independent school where she is now thriving. The finances were (and are) a stretch, so we left our DS in the state system with the plan to see how things went and then move him at the same age as we moved our daughter (10). However, his needs are at the other end of the spectrum. It became apparent to us during pandemic home learning that there was some issue going on, but it took a further year before the school took it seriously enough to commission an assessment and another year after that before we got the report. It turns out he has severe dyslexia. This came as a both a surprise and not because we had suspected something, but generally his school reports were good with just a few weaker areas. Anyway, fast forward a few months when a load of interventions have supposedly been put in place - we don't feel confident that he's making much progress and we're aware of other children in the class with severe behavioural issues which were taking up the TAs time in entirety (so no support for anyone else). As such, we brought forward our quest to go independent and arranged taster days at a local non-selective school with good SENCO provision. Our boy loved it. However - here's the rub - the school won't offer him a place because he is more than two years behind the other children in that class. Needless to say, he's feeling pretty despondent about it, but what I'm fuming about is how his current school let it get that bad and not even tell us. Everything that has been put in place for him has only come about because we forced the issue and, when we were doing it, we were made to feel like we were overreacting and we're even told that actually our son was a bit lazy. This was before the report came out. This is an 8 year old who has been turned down for entry at a non-selective school that we are prepared to pay for because he is too far behind his peers. How is it that we have to send him in taster days just to find out how bad things are? The fact it's all come to light in a way which has left our son utterly gutted is the final straw. We didn't see it coming so couldn't manage expectations. We now have a situation where one child is flying and getting tons of opportunities while the other is completely shafted and there seems to be nothing we can do about it except give the current school a rocket (and what difference will that make?). To say I am fuming is an understatement. Anyone had similar or have any words of comfort or advice?

PS - the current school is supposedly 'outstanding' according to Ofsted, but it's not worked at all for our kids.

OP posts:
Supergirl1958 · 30/04/2023 19:32

Hellothere54 · 28/04/2023 23:39

It’s almost like

  1. schools are massively underfunded
  2. there are not enough TAs to support children with extra needs,
  3. there are not enough special school places so those with behavioural needs are disrupting classes and taking up teachers and TAs time,
  4. Finance for SEND and CAMHS have been slashed so children have more mental health difficulties
all these things mean that children are falling through the cracks every day. I have a new 9yo child in my class that can’t access reception level work and I have no other adult in my class. I am trying to teach him to count to 10 and to sounds out basic phonics and at the same time teach fractions and parenthesis to the other children in the class - who are also at various levels of understanding. It’s ridiculous - children are suffering, but no one in the govt appears to care.

This right here is exactly it and the main reason teachers are currently striking!!

Its heartbreaking.

those of you complaining about teacher strikes, read this thread!!

tumpymummy · 30/04/2023 19:26

I work in a school (not a teacher). Hellothere54 has said it all and has hit the nail on the head. This is why teachers are striking!

NameforMN · 30/04/2023 18:43

I second what the previous poster says. DS moved from mainstream primary to a specialist secondary setting. It's the best thing we've done. He has Dyslexia and a language disorder and was treated appallingly in his primary school. He's due to pass all of his GCSES next year which I could never have dreamed of before.

SourDoe · 30/04/2023 18:40

We have been in a similar situation. I have to say provision for dyslexic children in mainstream settings is (despite the best efforts of teachers) barely exists.

Have you considered a dyslexia specialist school? DC1 attends one and it has been transformative, although they are hard to come by and often independent. You can get funding through EHCP although it usually involves a fight in the courts, which is what we did but absolutely worth it.

DC2 is also ND (but not dyslexic) with above average cognition. He also had similar experience to your child where he began to slide backwards in mainstream, despite being academic. We tried a local private school but I have to say it was a waste of time, they didn’t offer him any suitable support and so now he attends an independent specialist school which is still aspirational for the children but offers a much more flexible approach to help optimise their learning.

Both are making progress in their settings. The idea of specialist schools can be a bit off putting to some but if you can find a good mid-range school for high functioning children then the results can be remarkable.

rcd · 30/04/2023 18:15

I agree with everything in this post. The situation is very difficult in state school's.

Hulashaker · 30/04/2023 17:58

I honestly feel like your child could be in my child's class. We have had nothing but issues since reception, I have been in countless times trying to get support and nothing. Then home learning happened and I noticed the dyslexia, I brought it up with the class teacher and they just said yeah sounds like it, but nothing we'd do for age 7 so not point. I went to see SEN, they assessed and said highly dyslexic in literacy and they'd support- this leaves much to the imagination. They have two badly behaved children on the class so all the time is spent on them and my child is completely overlooked. I am waiting till year 6 to pay for the assessment as I have read that if they aren't done within x period then high schools need another in order to put things in place and we can't afford to spent £800 twice

Coffeeandbourbons · 30/04/2023 15:47

I agree ‘working towards’ and the terminology they use can be really confusing. It’s ordinary meaning would be ‘nearly there’ rather than ‘years behind’. I wonder if now they worry about offending parents so were told to use soapy language that doesn’t benefit the kids

loftconversi0n · 30/04/2023 15:35

@Coffeeandbourbons Tbey kept telling us he was working towards .... with little extra detail. Tbey talked a lot about how popular he was and a lovely boy and fitted well in the school and with the routine but everything was 'working towards' but with a positive slant. When the reality was that he was quite far behind

Coffeeandbourbons · 30/04/2023 15:12

Thats really strange yes. Did they lie at parents evenings and in reports and just say he was doing fine?

loftconversi0n · 30/04/2023 15:10

@Coffeeandbourbons and then maybe at the very least they should have told us!!! We thought he was doing just fine for the first 2 years!

Coffeeandbourbons · 30/04/2023 15:09

loftconversi0n · 30/04/2023 15:06

@Coffeeandbourbons what do you mean how could they? They should have identified that he was already behind and put a system in place to help him to catch up. Some sort of intervention. It was too little too late when they finally started to try so do something in yr2

What system though? Sounds like he needed one on one tuition, they don’t have the resources for that

loftconversi0n · 30/04/2023 15:06

@Coffeeandbourbons what do you mean how could they? They should have identified that he was already behind and put a system in place to help him to catch up. Some sort of intervention. It was too little too late when they finally started to try so do something in yr2

fridaytwattery · 29/04/2023 21:16

I'm glad a plan is coming through now @Amatueuragonyaunt to help your son.

As a primary teacher I want you to know I wish there was more I could do to help children like your DS. There is SEN in my extended family (ASD, ADHD and Dyslexia) so I can understand how it can impact the person and their sense of self.

I do try my best to support (coloured paper and display screen, dyslexia font, take-up/processing time, preferred seating and working partner, visual prompts/supports) but within my class I have 3 diagnosed ASD and 2 on the pathway, 2 suspected ADHD, 1 EAL, 3 with dyslexia, 3 with suspected dyscalculia (not the same 3), a number of children with SS involvement due to home life issues. Any behaviour that is disrupting the class has to be dealt with first, otherwise no-one can learn and this can significantly impact teaching time if no TA is available to support the child having a meltdown. I also have some very able students whose parents will rightly expect that I extend and challenge their learning too.

I frequently end my teaching day knowing I haven't been able to give everyone the best opportunity to reach their academic potential. But my day isn't just teaching academics: it's talking through friendship issues, home life worries, period poverty, making sure some have had breakfast or a break time snack/drink, listening to their funny stories (some kids just want to talk to someone and feel heard), or just being there for them when they are not feeling well. I feel I wear many 'hats' and Teacher is just one of them. I love my job but I come home most days exhausted with not much left of myself to give my own family.

Coffeeandbourbons · 29/04/2023 19:44

It did all start with really bad glue ear which was fixed in reception but the school did fuck all to ensure he caught up

How could they? What would you expect them to do?

Timeturnerplease · 29/04/2023 19:42

PocketSand · 29/04/2023 16:35

@izzy2076

The trouble is that teaching staff - who don't read or understand section B of an EHCP - can't distinguish between who is the most needy at an individual level and who is the most disruptive in whole class sessions.

Sometimes the most disruptive are the least needy. And the 'quiet' (ie selectively mute) are the most needy but fly so far under the radar that they are considered 'fine' until it is too late and they fall out of education entirely.

DS1 was failed at primary. Went to specialist after pushy parents got an EHCP and went to tribunal for specialist placement. It was too late.

Unfortunately the most disruptive need dealing with before you can even think of supporting the most needy, I have found out this year. A poor boy in my class spent most of last year hiding under a table thanks to two behaviourally disruptive boys in his class. I’ve only been able to begin to help him according to his EHCP this year when my saintly TA managed to start calming those two disruptive boys down while I was teaching.

Newrumpus · 29/04/2023 19:36

GrandIllusion · 29/04/2023 04:55

I don't believe them.

If that private school was benevolent and not results driven they would take your son and work with him to the best of his ability.

At 8 years old there's no such thing as being 'behind' it's an artificially constructed barrier to keep your son out.

Find a better solution which will nurture and boost your son's confidence.

I agree with this. This school doesn’t sound like it has as good an SEN facility and you think.

loftconversi0n · 29/04/2023 19:15

I empathise completely. When my son was in yr2 we realised he was at least a year behind. Could barely read, couldn't do any maths and writing was ineligible. The school kept telling us he was working towards, working towards and was a delight with lots of friends. We didn't realise until we saw some of the other work of other students in his year. Moved him to a private school and now he is thriving . Said he used to put his hand up and no one would come to him. It did all start with really bad glue ear which was fixed in reception but the school did fuck all to ensure he caught up. Glad we moved him. Can see definite improvement. He also has a maths tutor and reading tutor each week. I am hoping by the time secodary school comes round, he will at least have caught up

Sherrystrull · 29/04/2023 19:03

PocketSand · 29/04/2023 16:35

@izzy2076

The trouble is that teaching staff - who don't read or understand section B of an EHCP - can't distinguish between who is the most needy at an individual level and who is the most disruptive in whole class sessions.

Sometimes the most disruptive are the least needy. And the 'quiet' (ie selectively mute) are the most needy but fly so far under the radar that they are considered 'fine' until it is too late and they fall out of education entirely.

DS1 was failed at primary. Went to specialist after pushy parents got an EHCP and went to tribunal for specialist placement. It was too late.

What absolutely rubbish. Teachers are professionals used to juggling multiple children with different needs. Just because a child is quiet doesn't mean they get ignored.

Amatueuragonyaunt · 29/04/2023 18:13

I've checked out the Sound Foundations site and it looks really good - thank you for the recommendation. I've ordered some of the books and will try and work through them with him. I like the structure and the way it monitors progress. This is one of the things I find really hard about implementing the things the school have sent home - it's hard to see what difference it's making as it doesn't come with targets to know when we've done enough or the ability to have eyes on the wider context. We have also spoken with a specialist dyslexia tutor who has offered an hour a week on a Friday afternoon, either in the school setting or at her home within school hours (assuming the school agree) which helps avoid the very real exhaustion issue of piling on more studying after school - I can then keep my bits to the weekends. So with this and with him having agreed to the taster days in the year below, a plan is starting to fall into place. Hurrah!

OP posts:
PocketSand · 29/04/2023 17:43

@izzy2076 who do you think is saying the child is 'fine'? Even GOSH writing directly to the school had no effect. School is a such a short time. Just ignore the problem. Let PIP and ESA provide the funding when school fails. So shortsighted personally and financially.

Charley50 · 29/04/2023 17:43

When you say 'severe dyslexia' do you mean he has a 'spiky profile' e.g. some high scores and some low scores? Or does he have mainly low scores (below 84)?

Personally at home I would focus on his strengths and not push too much on the academic side. I would read to him every evening though and let him see the words as you're reading. Only ask him to read when he is ready to, and only to read things that he is interested in and are accessible to whatever his current reading levels are. Find a good dyslexia tutor who can make learning fun, rather than you trying to help him and him getting upset. It is learning to read that is key. Things like poor spelling can be compensated for with technology.

It is being able to read which makes the other subjects accessible at secondary level. If he cannot get reading fluency, using electronic reader when he's at secondary level and having that as his normal way of working will help.

CookieDoughKid · 29/04/2023 17:32

I've read all your posts here and understand the disappointment. Moving on, don't waste a minute further fighting the state school system, you will get no where. There are hundreds of parents just like you but unfortunately they dont have the funds to solve it. You do.. Seize the private school year below offer with both hands and run with it. Its times like now that you put your foot down and make your son go to private school. End of. Then support him there.

Fwiw, both mine go to outstanding selective grammars and both mine are fairly bright. I'm not joking when I say even in my school arena there are failures and the school can't pick up the outliers. They just can't. State education in UK is a shambles tbh and on thin ice.

izzy2076 · 29/04/2023 17:30

@PocketSand I agree with you. I would hope the SENco would have a summary of this information attached to the child's name on the register. With EHCPs being so long, they are often read then filed rather than referred to frequently therefore it's important that the info goes on a one page profile that is approved the the child and parents.

diflasu · 29/04/2023 17:19

They did offer him a place in the year below. We would have taken this option, but when we presented it to our son, quiet tears started and he buried his head on my shoulder and wouldn't speak. He has former and existing classmates either at or joining the school in September and is worried about what they would think.

I missed this - honestly I do this and keep a close eye on how he gets on in next year.

manchestermom5 · 29/04/2023 17:19

I am surprised the teacher didn't pick anything for someone who is 2 years behind. Is it possible for you to hire a tutor and give full support at home, and prepare him for the next academic year.