Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Heartbroken and totally let down by education system

256 replies

Amatueuragonyaunt · 28/04/2023 22:56

I'm after advice (and a bit of a vent). Ever since the start of the COVID fiasco, my two children (then 5 and 8 years old) have been totally failed by the state sector. My daughter is bright, but was not being pushed and was losing self confidence because of a lack of feedback and attention, so we moved her to a selective independent school where she is now thriving. The finances were (and are) a stretch, so we left our DS in the state system with the plan to see how things went and then move him at the same age as we moved our daughter (10). However, his needs are at the other end of the spectrum. It became apparent to us during pandemic home learning that there was some issue going on, but it took a further year before the school took it seriously enough to commission an assessment and another year after that before we got the report. It turns out he has severe dyslexia. This came as a both a surprise and not because we had suspected something, but generally his school reports were good with just a few weaker areas. Anyway, fast forward a few months when a load of interventions have supposedly been put in place - we don't feel confident that he's making much progress and we're aware of other children in the class with severe behavioural issues which were taking up the TAs time in entirety (so no support for anyone else). As such, we brought forward our quest to go independent and arranged taster days at a local non-selective school with good SENCO provision. Our boy loved it. However - here's the rub - the school won't offer him a place because he is more than two years behind the other children in that class. Needless to say, he's feeling pretty despondent about it, but what I'm fuming about is how his current school let it get that bad and not even tell us. Everything that has been put in place for him has only come about because we forced the issue and, when we were doing it, we were made to feel like we were overreacting and we're even told that actually our son was a bit lazy. This was before the report came out. This is an 8 year old who has been turned down for entry at a non-selective school that we are prepared to pay for because he is too far behind his peers. How is it that we have to send him in taster days just to find out how bad things are? The fact it's all come to light in a way which has left our son utterly gutted is the final straw. We didn't see it coming so couldn't manage expectations. We now have a situation where one child is flying and getting tons of opportunities while the other is completely shafted and there seems to be nothing we can do about it except give the current school a rocket (and what difference will that make?). To say I am fuming is an understatement. Anyone had similar or have any words of comfort or advice?

PS - the current school is supposedly 'outstanding' according to Ofsted, but it's not worked at all for our kids.

OP posts:
Amatueuragonyaunt · 29/04/2023 07:10

Thanks to everyone for your responses. In answer to some of the questions:

  1. Money - we don't have endless resources. Going independent only became a choice in the last year or so because of a change in job. Affording it is/will be hand to mouth, but we feel that if we can make it happen we need to.
  2. Why didn't we know he was behind? We did. It became very apparent to us in lockdown he had struggled more than we would have expected. However, we were told by the school that it was a lockdown/personality/not to be worried about things. We were therefore led to believe a few minor interventions would put him back on track and that he was a couple of months, rather than years, behind. I could have researched the national curriculum and tried to understand age-related expectations, etc but, call me lazy, stupid, or both, the teachers already know all this so I would have expected them to be frank in the face of the questions we were asking. When the initial interventions didn't work and we felt like we weren't getting reliable feedback we got a private specialist dyslexic tutor. Only after this, when she confirmed our concerns (albeit not a formal diagnosis) did we persuade the school to refer for a proper assessment. That was when we were made to feel like we were just being pushy parents with a lazy child. After this conversation, I did feel like I was perhaps fussing about nothing and, in spite of my gut feeling, half expected the report to come back saying nothing was wrong. I was naive, perhaps, but certainly not paying no attention.
  3. We have tried working with him at home, but he fights us, tries avoidance tactics, lots and lots of deflection, tears, tantrums. He finds schoolwork hard and wants home to be a refuge. It's not through a lack of willingness to do work with him ourselves, but we don't feel equipped to provide the specialist input he needs. It's a very fine balance to strike between encouraging him to focus and work hard, without it damaging his self-esteem or the more emotionally supportive side of home life. I don't want to force him - (a) you actually can't make a child do academic work when they refuse and (b) I want home to be a safe space for him. In school he is quiet, polite and tries really hard. I totally take the point that schools are broken for a whole range of reasons and it may not be their fault, but I do find the constant criticism of parents difficult too - the assumption that we haven't fought for him or tried to help is just not correct. Schools are there to teach the academic side of things. I am here to wipe tears, provide decent meals, boost them up, arrange a social life... Yes, supporting academic studies is part of that, but I am not a teacher and not equipped to compensate for his SEN and being two years behind without significant support myself.
  4. ECHP - we don't have one. We've been told by the dyslexia tutor (who also does work for the council) the LA won't consider putting this in place until a child is at least six years behind his expected level. We are not prepared to just wait until things are worse.
  5. Tutoring - yes we are looking into this, particularly given the challenges of trying to work with our son ourselves.
  6. The independent school - they were complimentary about how articulate, polite and hardworking he is. They did offer him a place in the year below. We would have taken this option, but when we presented it to our son, quiet tears started and he buried his head on my shoulder and wouldn't speak. He has former and existing classmates either at or joining the school in September and is worried about what they would think. The SENCO spent over an hour on the phone to us after the taster day so it didn't feel dismissive, despite being gutting. We were really impressed with her and the school have quite a lot of SEN children already. The provision does seem excellent, which is why we wanted him to go there, but although they see potential, he's too far behind for them to catch him up in time for year 6 with the resources they have.
  7. TA support - our child is one of the children they are supposed to be supporting. However, there are two other children - one who can't talk and needs constant 1:1 and another who until very recently was aggressive and violent in class and towards the teacher- who commandeer all of the time.

Sorry this is so long.

OP posts:
Oblomov23 · 29/04/2023 07:01

I'm sorry but I too can't grasp how you didn't know he was 2 years behind. So take responsibility for that. Now you will have to do 2 years of double effort. Hire a tutor. And fight to get school to do more. But mainly this will come down to you. Look up the dyslexia way of teaching, and fo it yourself : spend 1 hour every afternoon helping him. For 2 years. Maybe for the rest of his school life. No one is going to do it for you. It's on your head only.

QuintanaRoo · 29/04/2023 06:44

When Dd was 7yo she was a year behind at state primary. We paid for a private diagnostic and sure enough she had dyslexia (but mild). We moved her to a state primary with smaller class sizes (we are very rural so fairly easy). Some private tutoring. went to a terrible state secondary so needed some tutoring just before GCSEs.

Anyway she’s just got a 1st class degree in Architecture …..so don’t think the future has to be bleak. It doesn’t.

electriclight · 29/04/2023 06:36

Very few mainstream state schools are able to pay for a dyslexia diagnosis. In our area they cost £800. Instead, where we suspect dyslexia, we support and adapt as if they did have a diagnosis.

If you suspected dyslexia why didn't you have a private diagnosis? If you didn't, why be so cross that school didn't either? We are not experts but generalists. If your son did not present with the classic traits but instead, say, has a poor working memory and sequential skills, this could be missed. Many people get to university or adulthood before securing a diagnosis.

He will not be the only child in the class with additional needs. You mention the behavioural issues but there will be other children with dyslexia too, safeguarding issues, medical issues, SEN. This is the nature of mainstream schools, as in life.

They have now put adjustments in place but you are unlikely to see the progress you seem to expect after just 'a few months.' There are no magic bullets but small steps of progress.

How good is the SENCO and SEN support at the private school really if your son is being turned away? If a child with dyslexia is turned away for being two years behind, I can't even imagine why they need a SENCO. They are results driven. Two years behind the private school cohort does not necessarily mean he's two years behind at his current school. Not every private school will be like this. Find one that will want him and support him.

The only thing that surprises me is that you didn't know that he was struggling at school. If he is not working at the expected level for his age and you genuinely didn't know then that's poor.

WordtoYoMumma · 29/04/2023 06:30

Unfortunately the private school system is horribly elitist and unfair. They don't want your son to ruin their impeccable records of pupil achievement - and private schools can do whatever they like. You have one child who has benefitted from the EXACT same unfair system that is discriminating against your other child.

The private school have the same attitude to your son as you do to the children with equally valid and difficult additional needs in your son's current class who "take up all the TA time".

The education system is in complete crisis. I'm sorry that your son has been failed by the system, he is one of thousands of children in the same boat - or worse because many parents can't just throw money at the problem.

If you've got money to spend on private school, use it to get your son a private dyslexia tutor.

Dilemma19 · 29/04/2023 06:30

SparklyBlackKitten · 29/04/2023 04:50

"the school won't offer him a place because he is more than two years behind the other children in that class."

But that makes sense no? For them to say no. And even for your kid. Imagine being in a class where everybody is more than 2 years ahead of you in everything. Talk about soul crushing

But what I dont understand is that you blame his former school for not having flagged he was so behind, but how is it that you never picked up on that? Wherever i live you can see what your kid is supposed to be able to do at a certain age. And with homework it would become very obvious too right. So you know exactly when they are behind.

So how come you don't put some blame on yourself as well instead of pointing fingers at school. ... plus you seem to have a bit of extra cash. Why didn't you get your son a tutor before??

This was my question you. Given op has an older child, how did she not know roughly where he should be? Why is it entirely up to school? 2years is a massive amount of time to be behind so how did you not notice for 2 years?

Oblomov23 · 29/04/2023 06:18

You'd be better to get this moved ti SN section to get very good advice. Dyslexia is hard, and most schools fail dc with it. You need to wake up and smell the coffee,

I was failed by primary for ds1, but I'm a totally different way. They refused to accept he needed help and didn't put anything in place. You are going to have to start fighting, hard. Email Senco. Politely demand that things are put in place.

Hire a dyslexia tutor. Our lovely town Facebook group, has one that advertisers. She is lovely and all who have used her said she made a big difference. (Two of my friends are using her for Year 9 children).

If you don't attack in now, it coukd/probably will get worse. He'll slip more and more behind. Then by the time you get to Year 10 - start of GCSE's, he might be seriously struggling.

Biscuitandacuppa · 29/04/2023 05:13

Hi my dd had a similar experience in primary. It was only because of home schooling in lockdown that I realised she was massively struggling with reading and spelling. School denied she had any issues and just said that verbally she was fine and was a day dreamer!

My LEA don’t fund assessments so I paid privately for a dyslexia assessment and unsurprisingly she is dyslexic. She is also very intelligent and had switched off from school as she thought she was stupid so the diagnosis was a help for her self confidence.

I would recommend taking your ds for a visual stress test from a specialist optometrist. Having coloured lenses really helped to improve my dd’s reading speed and reduced her mistakes. Since we started 3 years ago her reading speed has improved from 70 words per minute with 8 mistakes to 122 words per minute with zero mistakes. She also has poor visual convergence so has coloured varifocal glasses with a prism. The glasses help the words to stop moving and blurring on the page (common in dyslexics).
The assessment has to be repeated yearly as the brain adapts to the colours and it starts to be less effective. However the glasses are far better than coloured paper or overlays as she can read off the board/computer etc

The school paid for a licence for IDL which is a spellling and reading programme and this did help her to improve her spelling and she did this at home instead of reading homework. She completed the free dance mat course for touch typing and had her own chrome book in class at all times.

I act as a TA at home for homework, I help her organise her work and I am always there when she is doing it. She obviously does the work but I am there to discuss ideas, and she uses a laptop for most of her homework.

She is now in year 7 at a faith school, it is a smaller supportive environment and she is doing amazingly well. She has caught up on her reading, but is still spelling at an 8 year old level. The laptop helps with that as spell check picks up mistakes. However her grades are really good and it looks like she will be top set in most subjects next year.

I hope some of the things we have tried will be helpful for you. I had to push lots and sort things out myself as dd wasn’t a behavioural issue in class they simply didn’t pick up there was an issue. The primary were very apologetic afterwards and did try catch up groups but to be honest I think the glasses, technology and looking at ways of chunking down work at home and strategies to help (I’ll read out homework etc) made the biggest difference.

CoozudBoyuPuak · 29/04/2023 05:09

Another possibility might be to ask them if they will admit him into the yeargroup below his own age cohort. Is he summer born by any chance? That might close the gap enough for them to cope.

But pp who said it might not actually the right school does have a point. The non-selective indie around our way isn't really well set-up for learning difficulties. They specialise in the "nice but dim" and generally very sporty and/or creative offspring of the wealthy who can't pass the challenging entry tests for the competitive academically selective indie schools, but generally don't have specific additional needs beyond being not that bright. If that is a similar target market then it's probably not the right place for your DS, who may actually be exceptionally bright and doing a huge amount of extra work to have been doing as well as he has in the context of his additional challenges. A dyslexia-focussed specialist school may have a much better way to release his full potential.

GrandIllusion · 29/04/2023 04:55

I don't believe them.

If that private school was benevolent and not results driven they would take your son and work with him to the best of his ability.

At 8 years old there's no such thing as being 'behind' it's an artificially constructed barrier to keep your son out.

Find a better solution which will nurture and boost your son's confidence.

SparklyBlackKitten · 29/04/2023 04:50

"the school won't offer him a place because he is more than two years behind the other children in that class."

But that makes sense no? For them to say no. And even for your kid. Imagine being in a class where everybody is more than 2 years ahead of you in everything. Talk about soul crushing

But what I dont understand is that you blame his former school for not having flagged he was so behind, but how is it that you never picked up on that? Wherever i live you can see what your kid is supposed to be able to do at a certain age. And with homework it would become very obvious too right. So you know exactly when they are behind.

So how come you don't put some blame on yourself as well instead of pointing fingers at school. ... plus you seem to have a bit of extra cash. Why didn't you get your son a tutor before??

SurvivingJust1 · 29/04/2023 04:47

I'd also add do you really want that particular school?
they clearly they don't want your son or any other child that remotely needs differentiated learning or an extra bit of effort. Sounds harsh but they clearly don't know what to do when they're not perfect carbon copies of middle class children.

What suggests that if you get him working at an age appropriate level and thus into the independent that he would continue that trajectory of progress. They are literally telling you they cant deal with mild SEN like dyslexia.

Perhaps looks at more Inclusive provision with staff who are prepared to teach to the individual child.

SurvivingJust1 · 29/04/2023 04:38

In our school we can 'suspect' these sorts of issues eg dyslexia even in reception but the local authority has made it such that we can not even put chn in the waiting list for assessment until ks2. Did they not assess him internally as below or well below in literacy on end of year reports?
The reason sen provision is great for chn in the independent sector is they go private for assessments and are allowed to quickly.
Ĺet alone the sendco at your state school probably had other needs that were 'worse' than you son, for want of a better expression and I'm sorry that sounds so heartbreaking in relation to your son.

By all means meet the sendco and class teacher to find out what they will be doing now supposedly he has an ehcp and therefore funding (otherwise who is funding his extra work outside if what they class teacher has to provide for the class). I can't remember from the OP but do you have an ehcp with funded hours? The adults in class are probably due to other children's funded hours, plus a little class based time. Your sendco is probably going to have to collate evidence from other agencies and spend a long time applying/fighting the local authority (who interestingly approve and set how many hours your child will need and know how stretched their budget is)
If you do not have one I would write your own with some support from sendco as that will move things quicker.
Sometimes you can blame the system and the funding from the government and the schools hands are genuinely tied.

From experience, his previous class teachers were probably well aware there was an issue but had to wait until he was outside the remit of 'just a bit behind' and that 'everything had been tried internally' before they could move foresrd....sounds like a full 24 months of internally paperwork proving he needed extra support, got the support and still had no change (remember winter 2021 when lots of schools were blighted by abscesses and therefore interventions might nit have been done as LSAs were covering other areas well that would have added weeks on the timeline)

Apologies for the long delay but I'm sick of schools baring the brunt. You clearly have some extra money - I just never get why people won't just do private assessments,do the state ones and complain its taken too long. Advocate for your son and spend some money. It is not the headteachers fault the system is underfunded but I'm sure they will apologise and show you what they're doing as teachers everywhere are doing. I think it's really obvious when they nhs has its budget removed but not so in the education sector)

Seashor · 29/04/2023 04:38

I teach and have a child who is severely dyslexic. I knew that there was absolutely no way he would get any support at secondary school and bit the bullet and went private. You need a school with a dyslexic unit not just the nearest private school. We had to move for this.

I have a mixed year class of 30. Some are EAL, some have varying SEN, many are from dysfunction homes, some have hearing and visual problems and then there is me! On my own, exhausted, frustrated and overwhelmed. The classroom is no where near what is was when I started teaching.

When I eventually got a Dr’s appointment, she wasn’t sure so sent me to a specialist. That doesn’t happen anymore in education; you’re on your own with absolutely no specialist support. The classroom is also a merry go round of teachers in and quickly out of the school, leaving whilst they can. I’ll be on that merry go round this year.

parietal · 29/04/2023 04:28

there are some specialist dyslexia schools - have you looked for them?

CoozudBoyuPuak · 29/04/2023 04:17

You are not at all unreasonable to feel so let down.

Keep communication open with the indie school and ask them if they will reassess for entry a year later. Throw the fees you would have paid for that year into specialist dyslexia tutoring and occupational therapy to support your DS to learn key skills to recognise and manage his additional challenges. With the right support like this, I should think it will be quite likely that he will catch up sufficiently that they are happy to admit him second time around.

greenspaces4peace · 29/04/2023 04:05

i wouldn't be surprised though if the private school primary children are working a year ahead.

Nightlystroll · 29/04/2023 03:25

Hellothere54 · 28/04/2023 23:39

It’s almost like

  1. schools are massively underfunded
  2. there are not enough TAs to support children with extra needs,
  3. there are not enough special school places so those with behavioural needs are disrupting classes and taking up teachers and TAs time,
  4. Finance for SEND and CAMHS have been slashed so children have more mental health difficulties
all these things mean that children are falling through the cracks every day. I have a new 9yo child in my class that can’t access reception level work and I have no other adult in my class. I am trying to teach him to count to 10 and to sounds out basic phonics and at the same time teach fractions and parenthesis to the other children in the class - who are also at various levels of understanding. It’s ridiculous - children are suffering, but no one in the govt appears to care.

But surely, even if the school didn't have the money to diagnose and support, the teacher would have picked up there was a problem and were falling 2 years behind rather than sending out positive reports.

generally his school reports were good with just a few weaker areas.

You have managed to diagnose that a child is behind in their age level. I guess you're not sending out reports to their parents saying that everything is good. And, unlike you, the teacher of the op's child does have TAs in the class so isn't a solo adult.

Is it ever the fault of the teacher/school and not the govt?

2chocolateoranges · 29/04/2023 01:46

Hellothere54 · 28/04/2023 23:39

It’s almost like

  1. schools are massively underfunded
  2. there are not enough TAs to support children with extra needs,
  3. there are not enough special school places so those with behavioural needs are disrupting classes and taking up teachers and TAs time,
  4. Finance for SEND and CAMHS have been slashed so children have more mental health difficulties
all these things mean that children are falling through the cracks every day. I have a new 9yo child in my class that can’t access reception level work and I have no other adult in my class. I am trying to teach him to count to 10 and to sounds out basic phonics and at the same time teach fractions and parenthesis to the other children in the class - who are also at various levels of understanding. It’s ridiculous - children are suffering, but no one in the govt appears to care.

Yes
yes
yes
yes

all so true. Unfortunately all children are suffering. My children re older and some of their friends have never sat exams and they are 18 and have now been thrown into university exams not knowing what to,do, how to study me what support to look for.

The pandemic have a lot to answer for!

greenspaces4peace · 29/04/2023 01:38

would the private school consider taking him out of cohort? placing him1 year behind his peers.

ZZpop · 29/04/2023 00:47

"we're aware of other children in the class with severe behavioural issues which were taking up the TAs time in entirety (so no support for anyone else)."

TAs are usually funded for particular children and are not class TAs.

JimmyGrimble · 29/04/2023 00:43

There isn’t really a meaningful test for dyslexia that can done before the age of seven. School budgets are so tight that SALT and EP access are extremely limited (two children per term at our school). The system is broken and there aren’t enough resources.

MillieOns · 29/04/2023 00:38

YANBU but your DC is experiencing exactly the same poor education opportunities as every other child in the UK. The majority of parents can’t afford to pay to send their DC to private school.

Newjobformoremoney · 29/04/2023 00:33

HI OP

My personal story was the school I was at missed the fact that I couldn’t read or write at 9. At 10 I got moved to a specialist school (complex ND and was at the time categorised as having “learning difficulties” due to all my issues) and was reading at a 13 level by the age of 11. The first book I ever read was by John Grisham.

The point of my story is that you can quickly catch up given the right understanding of your kids need. Finding someone understands dyslexia is key. I would use the money for a tutor and put pressure on the current school and look at moving him to an indie in a years time.

NeatCompactSleeper · 29/04/2023 00:23

Also it's a shame so many pay-to-learn schools won't accept children who have fallen behind, and desperately need the teaching the parents are willing to pay for.

It makes no sense and smacks of the school putting 'results' before children.