Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Furious with ex over taking ds to concert - should I say something?

260 replies

pinotnow · 28/04/2023 19:39

DS likes a band who have never toured in the UK. Tickets went on sale for two dates today. By the time I looked after work I could only find tickets costing upwards of £200 each - we'd need 2. This was completely out of the question. Ds was also looking and he found the same. Also, I realised that it would be difficult for us to get there anyway as we are 2 hours from London so it would be extremely tight in a school night - it's a Friday and ds will be Y10 and doors open at 6.30pm.

DS is at his dad's tonight and has just messaged to say ex has got him tickets. I am livid. Ex pays no CM as his income is too low. He is definitely not a high earner but had a large inheritance a year ago and may therefore have funds, but none come dc's way. We have been apart 10 years and he has never paid anything and buys nothing for the dc ever, even when he came into his inheritance. To give an example, ds recently asked him for some trousers when staying there as he had none and ex refused as 'you have plenty of clothes at your mum's.'

DC are with ex 4 nights per fortnight and he pays for nothing but their food when there - and even then they come home saying they are starving and complaining there are no snacks there.

Ex has not run this concert by me and has presumably spent about £500 on tickets. He's never spent anything like this before on either child, not in 10 years. Meanwhile I'm paying out constantly for trips, clothes, prom, phones, social life...the list goes on, all on a teacher's wage. Also saving for dc's uni and to give ex £10 000 of marital assets when ds turns 21. Ex is also quite likely to have a gig on the day in question and then what? It'll be on me to get ds there and I don't think I can.

I'm so cross and really want to confront him and tell him how wrong this is. AIBU to think if he has money of this kind spare he should be contributing and this is a piss take. I really want to tell him this. Should I?

OP posts:
Isthisexpected · 28/04/2023 21:20

You're absolutely entitled to tell your son whilst your pleased for him re the tickets, his Dad will have to get him there and back.

KTheGrey · 28/04/2023 21:19

@EllandRd 's view that your children are property owned by their father is adorable 😍 (irony).

But in answer to your question - yes, you should say everything, and on here, not to your ex. When you have got past the justifiable anger that you feel about your manipulative ex's behaviour, you can start thinking about the pros and cons of the situation.

As a teacher, I have never believed the odd day of school missed does much harm. Data indicates the magic number for attendance is 95%.

You can then weigh up getting your ex to waste the money on the tickets against making your son very happy.

As regards your other son, that is something worth having a word with your ex about. He absolutely should be treating your other son to something of equal value, and if not, hand him the cash.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 28/04/2023 21:19

Who is using the 2nd ticket?

Georgeandzippyzoo · 28/04/2023 21:17

EllandRd · 28/04/2023 19:53

None of your business and stop looking for a fight. What he does with his child is nothing to do with you.

But in the OP it starts it's probably gonna be down to mum to get him there, so actually it has everything to do with her.
If he was doing it on his own time different matter.

poetryandwine · 28/04/2023 21:15

OP, we are on your side but you have a real problem that I am not sure you are seeing.

If exH has parental rights, he can take DS out of school himself. As PPs have said, even apart from this consideration, are you sure that attempting to prevent DS leaving school early for what he sees as a major event (and, sadly, the more so as the tickets are from his deadbeat dad) is worth the cost to your relationship with him? Don’t kid yourself, that cost will be huge.

You and your DC unquestionably have legitimate issues with exH but, presuming he is organising transport etc, it is hard to see the purchase of these tickets as one of them. I would expect your other DC to absorb this, also. Hopefully their turn will come, and they already have the cricket (although the aftermath has been bad, it sounds like there was some bonding).

Writing as an academic I assure you that many students successfully put themselves through uni. I have the greatest respect and sympathy for all other aspects of your post. Your DC understand you are their rock.

A question for MNetters: is there any way the exH inheritance can made relevant to CM?

mainsfed · 28/04/2023 21:09

pinotnow · 28/04/2023 20:02

What a stupid comment. Definitely comes from someone who doesn't have to deal with an ex.

I wouldn’t let some of these comments get to you, MRA frequent these boards a lot.

Isthatyourname · 28/04/2023 21:08

I don’t understand other posters comments - YANBU at all!!!! What sort of man doesn’t pay any maintenance or anything for his kids but splashes out on a concert for one of them! I’d be furious too

MaltedCow · 28/04/2023 21:08

@CorvusPurpureus has the best advice here. Understand why you'd be annoyed with this set up.

CorvusPurpureus · 28/04/2023 21:06

Ah yeah, I too have a live one of these.

  1. nod along politely 'oh you & dad are off to see Lynyrd Skynrd are you? Sounds fun.'

  2. do not facilitate - up to ex to collect ds, take him & bring him back. If that falls through, channel your inner Windsor Davies 'oh dear, how sad, never mind'.

  3. let it gooooo re missed school. It's genuinely not going to be a big deal, he's hardly going to make a habit of it. You do NOT want to be the 'bad guy' here - just let ex crack on.

  4. if other dc says 'oi this isn't fair' - your line is 'mmmm this is all between you & your df.' Don't either attempt to ameliorate things OR to stir it - leave it to ex to deal with that one.

  5. Disney-ing but no uni contribution - trust me, they'll clock that & draw their own conclusions.

Basically, detach. Detach detach.

Yes, the ex is an irritating twat who could have spent that money on actual day to day expenses, or uniform, or put it aside for uni etc. But he won't BECAUSE he is a twat.

You can't win that battle...but you don't need to. Because your kids are not stupid. They will see what he's up to, & they'll see what you do, day in day out, year in year out.

Fuck him, the showboating muppet. Let him crack on.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 28/04/2023 21:05

EllandRd · 28/04/2023 19:53

None of your business and stop looking for a fight. What he does with his child is nothing to do with you.

What he does with THEIR child is certainly something to do with her.

Whatabouterry · 28/04/2023 21:04

Is this a KPop band? If so I managed to get two tickets today for around £80 each. It may not have cost hundreds. Apologies if it’s not though.

revealmyjackpot · 28/04/2023 21:04

I'm afraid it's a 'suck it up' situation,@pinotnow. My ex husband has paid £0 since we split up. Every now and then, he swoops in and does the whole "I'm so marvellous" thing. I take it as a bonus for the children.

I don't quite see why you are saving for university. If your earnings are relatively low, they will get a full maintenance loan (mine all do). They have all managed to live within the loan, albeit not lavishly. They live with me in the holidays, which I regard as my contribution. We have all long since ceased to imagine that their father will do anything other than the occasional gesture.

underneaththeash · 28/04/2023 21:03

let DS go, he’ll enjoy it.
let the benefits office know that he’s come into an inheritance and is no longer entitled to them.

Erex · 28/04/2023 21:03

The posters saying YABU, "pick your battles" and "nothing to do with you" etc. clearly have no experience of a Disney dad.
I had one, and it's really, genuinely astounding that people are telling you he's done nothing wrong. Yes, because having been on the receiving end as a child, not being fed enough (my dad had enough money but strict diet he imposed on house guests too) and not being provided for is absolutely fine as long as mum is there to pick up the pieces and dad suddenly magics up some cash for a lavish treat.
Spoiler: The last few years of being completely NC with my dad have been fantastic and I wish I'd done it sooner.

MrsTerryPratchett · 28/04/2023 21:01

Ex is also quite likely to have a gig on the day in question and then what? It'll be on me to get ds there and I don't think I can.

My exH was a musician. He is always unreasonable. Just as a rule. You have my sympathy.

And yes, buying tickets for one when you have ignored every need and want for years is dickish.

Summerfun54321 · 28/04/2023 20:59

He sounds awful but you are the one who had kids with him. Taking something away from your child isn't going to change that or improve your situation.

Willmafrockfit · 28/04/2023 20:56

pinotnow · 28/04/2023 19:45

But he's only spent it on one child? The other benefits not at all.

what an idiot he is

babyproblems · 28/04/2023 20:54

Ignore the first comment - fairly sure it’s just a troll.
Your anger is totally justified- he’s a fucking twat isn’t he clearly. I’d let your son enjoy this though.. he’ll be hounding him for more after this and then let’s see whether Dad steps up and starts offering to help more!!! You’re not being unreasonable imo to expect fair maintenance and you’ve clearly done all the parenting whilst he’s not done his share. Maybe your son will wonder why he can have concert tickets but not XWZ after? And he’ll see him for what he is. Good luck to you. Do something lovely for yourself when they go to the concert xxxxx

FlowersEverywherePlease · 28/04/2023 20:54

Indoorcatmum · 28/04/2023 20:07

Wow, I am really surprised at the responses on here.

The fact that he won't purchase basics like clothes but will splash out on tickets with zero thought to the actual practicalities of it must be frustrating at best.

You have had to do everything for the children and yet he can do a big gesture to look good.

I would be upset if I were you and I would also put it all on his dad.

If your ex cant take him to the concert, that is on him. Don't take responsibility for it.

Tell your DS you are very happy for him and the arrangements are to be between him and his dad.

That's fucking petty.

Theunamedcat · 28/04/2023 20:53

pinotnow · 28/04/2023 19:39

DS likes a band who have never toured in the UK. Tickets went on sale for two dates today. By the time I looked after work I could only find tickets costing upwards of £200 each - we'd need 2. This was completely out of the question. Ds was also looking and he found the same. Also, I realised that it would be difficult for us to get there anyway as we are 2 hours from London so it would be extremely tight in a school night - it's a Friday and ds will be Y10 and doors open at 6.30pm.

DS is at his dad's tonight and has just messaged to say ex has got him tickets. I am livid. Ex pays no CM as his income is too low. He is definitely not a high earner but had a large inheritance a year ago and may therefore have funds, but none come dc's way. We have been apart 10 years and he has never paid anything and buys nothing for the dc ever, even when he came into his inheritance. To give an example, ds recently asked him for some trousers when staying there as he had none and ex refused as 'you have plenty of clothes at your mum's.'

DC are with ex 4 nights per fortnight and he pays for nothing but their food when there - and even then they come home saying they are starving and complaining there are no snacks there.

Ex has not run this concert by me and has presumably spent about £500 on tickets. He's never spent anything like this before on either child, not in 10 years. Meanwhile I'm paying out constantly for trips, clothes, prom, phones, social life...the list goes on, all on a teacher's wage. Also saving for dc's uni and to give ex £10 000 of marital assets when ds turns 21. Ex is also quite likely to have a gig on the day in question and then what? It'll be on me to get ds there and I don't think I can.

I'm so cross and really want to confront him and tell him how wrong this is. AIBU to think if he has money of this kind spare he should be contributing and this is a piss take. I really want to tell him this. Should I?

DO NOTHING seriously say that's nice give no other reaction then when he tries to push it off onto you...say no this is your dad's treat he takes you

SteakExpectations · 28/04/2023 20:53

I do think that it’s different if you cannot get the time off work to take DS.

My DS (same age) has an artist that he adores and we’re taking time off work and school later this year to see them live.

I think that £500 is an insane amount of money to spend on gig tickets, but I think so long as DS’s dad can take him then I think you should just keep it upbeat and positive and encourage them to have a good time. I think it’s also probably worth mentioning to your ex that it’s great that he is able to take DS as even if tickets weren’t so expensive, you won’t have be able to take him due to timings with finishing work, so that it’s clear that he either goes with his dad or not at all.

Wishitsnows · 28/04/2023 20:53

He sounds like a complete and utter bellend. What sort of man contributes nothing over the years to raise their child?! Luckily you child will no doubt see through him but will obviously not want to miss out on the concert. I don’t understand the type of man who relies complain a woman financing their children being raised and think buying an occasional present makes them amazing.

FlowersEverywherePlease · 28/04/2023 20:53

PeaceLilyCactus · 28/04/2023 20:04

Why bother emailing him about anything if he does nothing for them and gives you no maintenance? I tried to control my ex and force him to be a good father and it doesn’t work. Nothing I said made one bit of bloody difference. I don’t tell him anything now as it’s completely unnecessary.

Your ex is a dick but you’d be wasting energy if you argue with him over this one. I initially thought you meant he was taking your child but if he’s bought you and the child tickets then that’s surely a better situation?

I totally get why you’re annoyed but you need to rethink it; you’re getting to take your child to a concert they really want to go and see, and will make happy memories with them, and the tickets cost you nothing.

This. 100%

FlowersEverywherePlease · 28/04/2023 20:50

So a lifetime of debt and a difficult time (potentially) at uni, but it's all good because he took one dc to one concert one time"

You are hard work.
No one said "it's all good"
But you need to learn to pick your battles op!

Ducksurprise · 28/04/2023 20:49

UrsulaBelle · 28/04/2023 20:14

He absolutely won’t be missing school.

Be careful not to become the bad guy in your DS’s eyes. At his age he won’t be seeing the bigger picture. The more of a deadbeat dad your ex is, the harder it is for your DC. They’ll quite possibly be very keen to have any sign that their dad actually does care about them. Speaking from experience here.

A million times this.

If you have to take him then you get to enjoy the experience, he will remember that long after he has forgotten who paid. Missing a couple of hours school won't ruin him.