Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour wants tree cut down

191 replies

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 18:22

Hello,

I'd appreciate some thoughts on a dispute with my neighbour.

I have a silver birch in my garden that is next to the boundary.

My neighbour wants us to cut this down because they don't like the mess caused by falling seeds/leaves and because of the risk the roots may cause their newly laid (and presumably very expensive) patio which is right next to the boundary.

For reference we are in a conservation area and the removal of the tree would require planning permission as the diameter is over 7.5cm at a height of 1.5m (though only just). The tree trunk is thus relatively slender and the height is roughly that of a two story house but the canopy is not large.

Unfortunately, the conversion got quite heated/ugly (and ended up with them throwing their sweepings over the fence).

I'll admit I don't want to lose the tree as it is really lovely, but having a look on google birches do have shallow roots that can cause problems to patios.

So where I am at is that I'm loathe to cut down the tree but equally I'm conscious about potential damage to the neighbours property that I might become liable for (the fact you have to sweep up leaves I don't believe to be relevant).

It's also probably worth mentioning that if the roots were a problem I'm unsure why this wasn't raised by the professionals who installed the patio.

As a final point they said they had to declare the tree on their house insurance so potentially the motivation here is the impact on the premium (the tree was in situ when they bought the property).

I don't want to fall out with neighbours (though that ship might have sailed) so what next?

I looked at the council website and they don't engage re: private tree disputes.

So I'm a bit unsure of what to do next and am I BU by not agreeing to cut down the tree.

Has anybody been in a similar situation?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Missingmyusername · 28/04/2023 19:40

If you ever wish to sell, you’ll have to declare a dispute to buyers.
The tree is 1.7m? Doesn’t seem huge, is it really the mess or is it the shade it throws?

For an easy life I would say they can get rid of the tree at their expense, including taking the tree away.

Then get a conifer in. Joke!

Iwasafool · 28/04/2023 19:39

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 19:37

It's not causing any damage.

They want it removed in cases it causes damage in the future.

I'm not sure trespass is an issue if there is no damage but happy to be corrected.

Have a look at the RHS site, they say the neighbours can cut the roots back.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 28/04/2023 19:38

I wouldn’t be rushing to cut a healthy tree down but I would ensure that the branches aren’t protruding over their fence.

JennyForeigner · 28/04/2023 19:38

We had a neighbour who built an extension and then demanded we fell a little birch. Then he demanded we fell all trees on our boundary, then he put in overlooking windows in his extension without planning permission, then we caught him in the tree starting to hack it down without permission, then he started demanding we lower a fence which is our boundary. Then the council told us they wouldn't enforce removing the windows specifically because we had the option to mitigate oversight with 'vegetation'.

Twats are twats, and our neighbour wasn't going to leave us alone until we made it very clear we would be reporting any issues. We are raising the fence and planting more trees.

Iwasafool · 28/04/2023 19:38

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 19:36

3 meters.

The proximity isn't ideal (we didn't plant it).

It sounds like a very young tree, the council have just planted some silver birch on a site near me and they sound bigger than your tree. Could you move the tree? The ones that have been planted her are doing well six weeks after planting and are now covered in leaves.

ActDottie · 28/04/2023 19:38

Not your problem :) just ignore them

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 19:37

BrighteyesBonnie · 28/04/2023 19:35

Well prepare for a legal battle. If you’re sure you will win, crack on but I can’t see you winning if the tree is trespassing their land and causing damage. I can’t see the law saying this is okay.

It's not causing any damage.

They want it removed in cases it causes damage in the future.

I'm not sure trespass is an issue if there is no damage but happy to be corrected.

OP posts:
Littleworkaholic · 28/04/2023 19:36

oioimatey · 28/04/2023 19:34

Out of curiosity, how far away from the trunk is their house, do you think?

Honestly, this makes me just hate people. If the roots damage their newly laid patio then they should have thought about that before having the work done.

I'd also consider having a camera on your lovely tree; it's not that uncommon for trees under dispute to be drilled into and poisoned. Sadly this has happened to a beautiful tree near me.

Try and get a TPO if you can 😂

See this makes me hate people. A massive tree that can grow to 50 foot is planted 9 foot from someone’s house. And you couldn’t even be bothered reading rhe ops posts.

Iwasafool · 28/04/2023 19:36

oioimatey · 28/04/2023 19:34

Out of curiosity, how far away from the trunk is their house, do you think?

Honestly, this makes me just hate people. If the roots damage their newly laid patio then they should have thought about that before having the work done.

I'd also consider having a camera on your lovely tree; it's not that uncommon for trees under dispute to be drilled into and poisoned. Sadly this has happened to a beautiful tree near me.

Try and get a TPO if you can 😂

It is their land though, I just looked at the RHS site and it says you can cut back the roots but you will be responsible if it damages the tree so it is complicated.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 19:36

oioimatey · 28/04/2023 19:34

Out of curiosity, how far away from the trunk is their house, do you think?

Honestly, this makes me just hate people. If the roots damage their newly laid patio then they should have thought about that before having the work done.

I'd also consider having a camera on your lovely tree; it's not that uncommon for trees under dispute to be drilled into and poisoned. Sadly this has happened to a beautiful tree near me.

Try and get a TPO if you can 😂

3 meters.

The proximity isn't ideal (we didn't plant it).

OP posts:
BrighteyesBonnie · 28/04/2023 19:35

Well prepare for a legal battle. If you’re sure you will win, crack on but I can’t see you winning if the tree is trespassing their land and causing damage. I can’t see the law saying this is okay.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 19:35

Roselilly36 · 28/04/2023 19:34

Do you have legal cover on your home insurance OP? If so give them a call, just for advice.

Oh that's an idea I hadn't thought of - thank you.

OP posts:
oioimatey · 28/04/2023 19:34

Out of curiosity, how far away from the trunk is their house, do you think?

Honestly, this makes me just hate people. If the roots damage their newly laid patio then they should have thought about that before having the work done.

I'd also consider having a camera on your lovely tree; it's not that uncommon for trees under dispute to be drilled into and poisoned. Sadly this has happened to a beautiful tree near me.

Try and get a TPO if you can 😂

Roselilly36 · 28/04/2023 19:34

Do you have legal cover on your home insurance OP? If so give them a call, just for advice.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 19:30

Littleworkaholic · 28/04/2023 19:21

The thing is this is the sort of thing that folks dig their heels in over and it ends up in extensive legal costs and sad faces in the daily mail.

they clearly aren’t going to let it go. So are you, if not. Then dig in for big bills and a civil suit. The fact you will have a formal neighbours dispute is the least of your issues.

my personal opinion is that if something on my property is causing a neighbour an issue, I will remove it if it is indeed my problem and this tree, nine foot from their house is an issue, especially as trees get bigger, it’s going to be a significant problem, not just for them but for you when you come to sell when that tree comes up in a survey so close to your houses. It’s subsidence city.

I'll admit this is my concern.

I don't want this to escalate but I'm also unwilling to cut down a lovely tree for no good reason.

I'm trying to be pragmatic about it but I'll admit their attitude (especially the pettiness of throwing the seeds over the fence) made me more inclined to dig my heels in - which I am trying to resist doing - hence trying to get an independent perspective here.

OP posts:
Pocketfullofdogtreats · 28/04/2023 19:30

Neighbour's trees having to be declared on your house insurance? That seems weird. My neighbour has trees all along his boundary but we've never been asked about them. The closest is about a metre from the side of our house.
Keep your lovely tree. Trees are valuable in all kinds of ways.

Littleworkaholic · 28/04/2023 19:29

Oh Himalayans grow massive, like 50 foot or more, and it’s clearly a young tree. I never understand why folks plant trees which will grow massive so close to a property. The neighbour is right, that’s a problem that needs dealing with now.

Iwasafool · 28/04/2023 19:28

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 18:30

Yes my understanding is that if the tree did cause damage they could choose to sue and the fact they have raised this (and did nothing potentially) would be in their favour.

I've heard, but don't know if it is true, that they could start legal proceedings if the roots are "trespassing" and potentially causing damage. Not sure what happens or if they can make you take it down but neighbour disputes are a real problem.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 19:25

EmotionalSupportWyrm · 28/04/2023 19:18

you need to look at this @HimalyanSilverBirch re the calculation of the radius for roots. It might be worth your while getting a proper tree survey done.

https://www.woodlandtrust.org.uk/blog/2021/04/root-protection-areas/#:~:text=The%20British%20Standard%20that%20defines,to%20maintain%20the%20tree%27s%20viability.

That's useful - thank you

OP posts:
HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 19:24

TizerorFizz · 28/04/2023 19:15

They are allowed to return any leaves or twigs from the tree that are on their land I’m afraid. They belong to you. However if it’s 3m away from a house, that’s close if the foundations have not been designed to take a tree. It might be slender now but it won’t stay that way. Have you checked what size it will be in 10-15 years? You know you are liable so you are taking a risk.

Is it possible for you to replant the tree elsewhere in a less contentious position? I might be pragmatic about this. These trees are not expensive and you might even choose a smaller tree for a small garden. Would this be acceptable 3m from a house? I don’t think so.

Your picture is a different species.

Mine is a Himalayan silver birch.

This picture is the most similar in terms of size (mine is about a third smaller re:the canopy) and obviously just one tree.

Neighbour wants tree cut down
OP posts:
parietal · 28/04/2023 19:23

Keep tree. Ignore neighbour

Timesawastin · 28/04/2023 19:22

RudsyFarmer · 28/04/2023 18:37

On these threads people don’t like trees on boundaries but I’m going to agree with your feelings here.

The tree came before the patio. Silver birches are not known to be big trees and I don’t think it’s going to cause any problems whatsoever aside from obviously annoying your neighbours. I like to always fall out with neighbours as pretty much all of them end up being a massive PITA and wanting to constantly talk about fences or r trees or don’t want to talk but want to be anti social and play music day and night and do their drug dealing outside the house.

So my suggestion is to ignore them and enjoy your tree. In fact plant mother one just to really annoy them.

'Silver birches are not known to be big trees'? Excuse me, WHAT? Ours is a 60 foot monster which has to be kept under strict control by frequent surgery.

stbrandonsboat · 28/04/2023 19:22

I'd get a camera because the neighbour sounds determined enough to go round and have it felled in your absence. Make sure your garden is inaccessible as well if that's possible.

Littleworkaholic · 28/04/2023 19:21

The thing is this is the sort of thing that folks dig their heels in over and it ends up in extensive legal costs and sad faces in the daily mail.

they clearly aren’t going to let it go. So are you, if not. Then dig in for big bills and a civil suit. The fact you will have a formal neighbours dispute is the least of your issues.

my personal opinion is that if something on my property is causing a neighbour an issue, I will remove it if it is indeed my problem and this tree, nine foot from their house is an issue, especially as trees get bigger, it’s going to be a significant problem, not just for them but for you when you come to sell when that tree comes up in a survey so close to your houses. It’s subsidence city.

ohtowinthelottery · 28/04/2023 19:21

We've got 3 Silver Birch trees - 2 on the boundary at the back which overhang neighbours garden (the trees pre-date the building of neighbour's house) and one at the front bordering the pavement. Never had any complaints from neighbours at the back (there's been 2 lots). The one at the front has caused a slight crack in the tarmac on the pavement but I can't imagine it would have lifted patio slabs. It's been there 30 years.