Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour wants tree cut down

191 replies

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 18:22

Hello,

I'd appreciate some thoughts on a dispute with my neighbour.

I have a silver birch in my garden that is next to the boundary.

My neighbour wants us to cut this down because they don't like the mess caused by falling seeds/leaves and because of the risk the roots may cause their newly laid (and presumably very expensive) patio which is right next to the boundary.

For reference we are in a conservation area and the removal of the tree would require planning permission as the diameter is over 7.5cm at a height of 1.5m (though only just). The tree trunk is thus relatively slender and the height is roughly that of a two story house but the canopy is not large.

Unfortunately, the conversion got quite heated/ugly (and ended up with them throwing their sweepings over the fence).

I'll admit I don't want to lose the tree as it is really lovely, but having a look on google birches do have shallow roots that can cause problems to patios.

So where I am at is that I'm loathe to cut down the tree but equally I'm conscious about potential damage to the neighbours property that I might become liable for (the fact you have to sweep up leaves I don't believe to be relevant).

It's also probably worth mentioning that if the roots were a problem I'm unsure why this wasn't raised by the professionals who installed the patio.

As a final point they said they had to declare the tree on their house insurance so potentially the motivation here is the impact on the premium (the tree was in situ when they bought the property).

I don't want to fall out with neighbours (though that ship might have sailed) so what next?

I looked at the council website and they don't engage re: private tree disputes.

So I'm a bit unsure of what to do next and am I BU by not agreeing to cut down the tree.

Has anybody been in a similar situation?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Raffleyourdoughnut · 28/04/2023 21:48

@HimalyanSilverBirch I'm a planning officer. Generally to fell a conservation area tree it's needs to be one of the three D's dead dying or dangerous. The planting of a replacement tree of a similar species is usually required if the fallen tree is native.

Your council will sent out an arboriculturist to check the health of the tree as part of your application. Your will likely need a arboriculturist/tree surgeon) tree survey with your application for planning to even look at it (it's part of the application validation process).

Littleworkaholic · 28/04/2023 21:34

Bloody hell. So it’s going to grow to over 20 foot foot tall and 12 foot wide and it’s nine foot from his house.

honestly I hope he takes you to court. How utterly selfish of you.

Treecreature · 28/04/2023 21:31

As a side note... if you were building next to the tree you would have to abide by the guidance in BS5837 (trees in relation to construction). This gives guidance about how much ground you need to preserve around a tree to ensure it has enough of a root system for structural stability and nutrient uptake - this is based in the diameter of the stem. if the tree is just over 75mm - let's call it 80 to make the maths easy it would have a root protection area of 0.9m in all directions from the stem. If the tree is 3.0m from the boundary, trenching down and installing a root barrier on the boundary is unlikely to have any significant negative effect on the tree, and may alleviate your neighbours worries about root damage to the patio.

magamammam · 28/04/2023 21:19

This is the tree. Same species

https://www.trees-online.co.uk/Silver-Birch-Snow-Queen.html

Neighbour wants tree cut down
RandomMess · 28/04/2023 21:14

Silver Birch trees are the thing I'm most allergic too 🙄 was very glad to move away from the Woking area with its plentiful SB areas

Treecreature · 28/04/2023 21:11

Ooh that's easy to solve. Put in a conservation app and apply for removal. On the reasons state your neighbour hates trees and they want it removed as they don't like mess. The legal mechanism for a CA app means the app can only be approved, or denied AND the tree gets a Tree Preservation Order. Such a crap reason will piss off the Tree Officer, there's no way they'd give permission and boom there you go, TPO and tree saved. "Sorry neighbour old buddy- I tried my best...'

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 21:11

*haven't seen the tree so I'm going to ask you a question.

You've said it's really small. This type of tree has shallow roots.

Can you move it?

Just a suggestion don't bite my head off!*

Not planning on biting anyone!

I came here for advice/perspectives so happy to listen :-)

The tree is unlikely to survive being moved.

I'd consider this option if it were viable but apparently it's expensive to do and likely to fail.

OP posts:
ELCismyspiritnana · 28/04/2023 21:09

FlowersEverywherePlease · 28/04/2023 21:03

This is interesting
We have a HUGE ash tree in our neighbours garden that keeps the sun from our garden it's so huge.
They refuse to remove it.
Should I put this request in writing?

No, check the council website and see if you are in a conservation area, if so, nothing you can do. If not, you can ask nicely but it's totally up to them unless it is dangerous, dead, or causing damage.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 21:09

CaroleSinger · 28/04/2023 21:03

My neighbour has a birch tree next to the boundary. I hate it. Every day the insides of my windows are coated in seeds. They get in my bath, my bed, my food. It's an absolute menace and I want it cut down. My neighbour seems oblivious with the plague her tree inflicts on other people. I'd poison the bloody thing with copper nails if I could get near enough. Just a perspective from someone like your neighbour here. Not everyone loves your birch tree.

My neighbour would certainly appreciate your perspective.

The seeds are only shed for a few weeks a year though. It's not every day all year round and given the tree canopy is small it's far from a deluge. The amount they tipped over the fence from todays sweepings would fit inside a crisp packet.

I am conscious though of not wanting to BU hence posting here so I appreciate you giving your opinion.

I'm just not convinced seeds a few weeks a year justifies cutting down an established pretty tree.

OP posts:
FlowersEverywherePlease · 28/04/2023 21:08

CaroleSinger · 28/04/2023 21:03

My neighbour has a birch tree next to the boundary. I hate it. Every day the insides of my windows are coated in seeds. They get in my bath, my bed, my food. It's an absolute menace and I want it cut down. My neighbour seems oblivious with the plague her tree inflicts on other people. I'd poison the bloody thing with copper nails if I could get near enough. Just a perspective from someone like your neighbour here. Not everyone loves your birch tree.

Do you think copper nails work?

ELCismyspiritnana · 28/04/2023 21:07

So glad someone se has advised calling the tree people at the council. They are ime very helpful and knowledgeable. I would also forcthe sake of £100 or so get a tree surgeon to assess the trees health and potential for damage just for your own piece of mind. We need more trees, and a neighbours dislike of droppings is irrelevant.

I worked in property maintenance and the number of people who but houses in leafy tree full areas who then campaign to remove any trace of them is disgusting. I would be VERY firm in refusal and make it very clear the council have been consulted and will know exactly where to go should anything happen to the tree. Mention the I stallion of a ring doorbell to cover any poisonings.

You won't find a compromise with people like this, you gave to be firm and immovable that its tough tits and the tree is going nowhere.

HalloweenGhost · 28/04/2023 21:06

Noontimes · 28/04/2023 21:04

Silver birches are such beautiful trees. It would be criminal to chop one down. How shallow must your neighbours be not to be able to see the beauty in a tree ffs?

I have two and I wish at least one was a cherry :-)

Word to the wise to anyone interested in trees don't ever get a monkey puzzle! The leaves are like knives and tree surgeons hate them 😂

HalloweenGhost · 28/04/2023 21:05

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 21:03

Sadly I don't think placating is an option other than cutting down the tree.

I haven't seen the tree so I'm going to ask you a question.

You've said it's really small. This type of tree has shallow roots.

Can you move it?

Just a suggestion don't bite my head off!

Noontimes · 28/04/2023 21:04

Silver birches are such beautiful trees. It would be criminal to chop one down. How shallow must your neighbours be not to be able to see the beauty in a tree ffs?

FlowersEverywherePlease · 28/04/2023 21:03

This is interesting
We have a HUGE ash tree in our neighbours garden that keeps the sun from our garden it's so huge.
They refuse to remove it.
Should I put this request in writing?

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 21:03

Sadly I don't think placating is an option other than cutting down the tree.

OP posts:
CaroleSinger · 28/04/2023 21:03

My neighbour has a birch tree next to the boundary. I hate it. Every day the insides of my windows are coated in seeds. They get in my bath, my bed, my food. It's an absolute menace and I want it cut down. My neighbour seems oblivious with the plague her tree inflicts on other people. I'd poison the bloody thing with copper nails if I could get near enough. Just a perspective from someone like your neighbour here. Not everyone loves your birch tree.

HalloweenGhost · 28/04/2023 21:01

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 21:00

As posted above there's nothing really to trim. The canopy is really small.

If I could find a compromise I really would.

Perhaps not, but you are trying to placate your neighbours, so I am referring to a future plan of an annual trim in the early spring.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 21:00

HalloweenGhost · 28/04/2023 20:54

Ah, silver birch. My great hay-fever foe. Really annoying tree in that respect, and I have two in my garden, boo hoo.

These trees live only 30-40 years, but they do grow pretty fast, and then easily drop branches big and small in wind.

(Ours have a tpo on them so can only be removed with permission. )

Anyway @HimalyanSilverBirch my advice would be to trim it often, annually in the early spring to keep it small, which will keep it stronger, and will keep the root reach smaller.

People who wait 6,7 years before getting the tree surgeon out and then asking him to lop the top half off are doing the tree or themselves no favours. The tree has grown its big roots in that time anyway, and a huge chop makes it go into shock and throw up huge vertical new branches even faster.

If you want to keep the tree tell the neighbour you're happy to have it trimmed annually to keep the roots in check.

As posted above there's nothing really to trim. The canopy is really small.

If I could find a compromise I really would.

OP posts:
HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 20:59

FlutterbButterfly · 28/04/2023 20:53

7.5cm in diameter/1.5m in height? That tree is tiny @HimalyanSilverBirch, I'm guessing those measurements are wrong,

To clarify that's not the tree dimensions.

That's the specifications for a tree needing planing to be felled - if it's truck is over 7.5cm at a height of 1.5m.

At 1.5m the trunk is over this diameter but not by much.

OP posts:
HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 20:56

Rosscameasdoody · 28/04/2023 20:41

The tree is relatively small and it was there when they bought the house, and their surveyor and the landscaper who did their patio didn’t raise it as an issue. They sound very rude, so I would go with the conservation area explanation - once the tree is established you can’t cut it down because it’s subject to a preservation order. You can offer to cut overhanging branches and from the sound of it, they’re just petty enough to keep throwing the sweepings over your fence, which you’ll just have to deal with. Let them get on with it, it’s your tree - don’t be bullied into cutting it down.

I did (calmly) explain I couldn't cut down the tree (even if I wanted to) as it would need planning permission and to get permission I'd need reasonable grounds.

That went down like a lead ballon.

I then said if the tree is cut down anyone responsible risks being subject to a hefty fine.

That resulted in them losing the plot and accusing them of planning to cut down the tree (ironic as their last shouty words were "that tree is coming down" with an accompanying pointy finger).

I said no, I was explaining I did not want to be fined which is why I was stating the issue of the planning permission.

It was really hard to remain civil (but I did) and I'll admit trying hard not to pull this face Hmm when they told me to look at the seeds on the ground and justify why that was acceptable (for reference we have to sweep leaves on our drive from another - nice - neighbours tree and just accept it for what it is - you know that thing called nature).

The truth is they didn't want a conversation. They just wanted me to say yes I'll cut down the tree and I didn't want to commit to that.

Anyway I think contacting the council is a good next step and getting some advice (and potentially they might agree to speak with neighbours).

OP posts:
Chocolatefreak · 28/04/2023 20:54

Your neighbours sound like idiots. It's ia shame that a patio built after a tree has been planted, and becomes established, gets priority. For conservation it should be the other way around - protect the tree, not the patio!

When we moved into our house (not the UK) our neighbours proudly informed us they's chopped down loads of trees in their back garden that used to overshadow our house. it's actually been so hot the last few years those trees would have provided very welcome shade...have your neighbours considered that?

HalloweenGhost · 28/04/2023 20:54

Ah, silver birch. My great hay-fever foe. Really annoying tree in that respect, and I have two in my garden, boo hoo.

These trees live only 30-40 years, but they do grow pretty fast, and then easily drop branches big and small in wind.

(Ours have a tpo on them so can only be removed with permission. )

Anyway @HimalyanSilverBirch my advice would be to trim it often, annually in the early spring to keep it small, which will keep it stronger, and will keep the root reach smaller.

People who wait 6,7 years before getting the tree surgeon out and then asking him to lop the top half off are doing the tree or themselves no favours. The tree has grown its big roots in that time anyway, and a huge chop makes it go into shock and throw up huge vertical new branches even faster.

If you want to keep the tree tell the neighbour you're happy to have it trimmed annually to keep the roots in check.

FlutterbButterfly · 28/04/2023 20:53

7.5cm in diameter/1.5m in height? That tree is tiny @HimalyanSilverBirch, I'm guessing those measurements are wrong,

TheHateIsNotGood · 28/04/2023 20:49

Thanks for the explanation OP - seems your tree is fine (for now) the real problem (in the UK) is paving over outside spaces. It's rife in my little town; for unknown reasons, except for "low maintenance garden" explanations.

Just as top and trim urban trees within seasons is important - my main thing is to lift at least 1 slab a year and grow plants in that space instead.

It really helps the water table and curtails overloading our archaic water infrastucture system too.