Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour wants tree cut down

191 replies

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 18:22

Hello,

I'd appreciate some thoughts on a dispute with my neighbour.

I have a silver birch in my garden that is next to the boundary.

My neighbour wants us to cut this down because they don't like the mess caused by falling seeds/leaves and because of the risk the roots may cause their newly laid (and presumably very expensive) patio which is right next to the boundary.

For reference we are in a conservation area and the removal of the tree would require planning permission as the diameter is over 7.5cm at a height of 1.5m (though only just). The tree trunk is thus relatively slender and the height is roughly that of a two story house but the canopy is not large.

Unfortunately, the conversion got quite heated/ugly (and ended up with them throwing their sweepings over the fence).

I'll admit I don't want to lose the tree as it is really lovely, but having a look on google birches do have shallow roots that can cause problems to patios.

So where I am at is that I'm loathe to cut down the tree but equally I'm conscious about potential damage to the neighbours property that I might become liable for (the fact you have to sweep up leaves I don't believe to be relevant).

It's also probably worth mentioning that if the roots were a problem I'm unsure why this wasn't raised by the professionals who installed the patio.

As a final point they said they had to declare the tree on their house insurance so potentially the motivation here is the impact on the premium (the tree was in situ when they bought the property).

I don't want to fall out with neighbours (though that ship might have sailed) so what next?

I looked at the council website and they don't engage re: private tree disputes.

So I'm a bit unsure of what to do next and am I BU by not agreeing to cut down the tree.

Has anybody been in a similar situation?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
TheGaffer · 29/04/2023 11:30

Your neighbours sound unpleasant however they have probably been stewing about the tree for quite a while getting themselves more and more riled up about it. I do have some sympathy…our neighbour has 3 silver birch planted right on the boundary, one of which is probably only about 1.5 meters from our garage. The leaves and falling (small) branches are a total nuisance and I rage inwardly every time I walk past them! We’ve not fallen out about it though but I do think it is very selfish to plant trees so close to boundary like that. It limits what we can do in our own garden. Yes the trees were there when we bought, but the house is perfect in every other way and in an hard to buy area and so we can live with it. But it does wind me up something awful.

stillherenow · 29/04/2023 10:35

My neighbours behind me asked me to cut down my trees at the back as their branches were intertwining with their (newly planted ) trees.

In my experience it’s best to be firm but pleasant with neighbours, they’ll just move onto the next thing they want you to change if you give into this.

if you’re really worried maybe asked a surveyor to have a look and write a report and give it to them to shut them up.

stillherenow · 29/04/2023 10:30

I really don’t think the roots will be a problem. Yours isn’t a huge variety and I specifically asked my surveyor about my massive silver birch and he said the roots weren’t a problem at all. I just measured how far mine is from the house and it’s exactly 3m. It’s much much taller than my house and yes it does shed but tough luck. We all put up with inconveniences caused by neighbours and shedding trees is really not a big one!

JennyForeigner · 29/04/2023 06:55

Honestly, what happened to being adults making adult choices?

It's as though people are arm-twisted into choosing a particular house, spending their money on it and waiting a year to move in. Then they set about bullying and hectoring the people around them to change how they live. And don't get me started on the 'not in my back yard nor a kilometre radius of it' selfishness of wanting to replace anything green with concrete.

Bottom line is that you can't placate bullies OP, and you don't have to be on good terms with them. It's good you tried.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 29/04/2023 01:03

I think the problem with that idea (though I thank you for it) is that they are relatively new to the property and not moving any time soon (neither are we).

I'm not sure I can legitimately prevaricate for 10/20 years 😀.

OP posts:
DelphiniumBlue · 29/04/2023 00:56

MsGrumpytrousers · 29/04/2023 00:45

One option that I don't think anyone has suggested is to tell them that yes you'll get the tree cut down but first you'll have to apply for permission from the council. And then don't do it. Just be always about to get around to it.

Or you could apply to the council for permission to cut it down and if they approve, ignore it and go on prevaricating, and if they don't – which they may well not, if there's no good reason, which there isn't – than that also solves the problem.

The tree is protected for a reason: the laws recognise the value of trees in our environment, and protect them from being cut down for stupid reasons, like seeds falling on people's nasty patios.

Good idea.
But when they ask what's happening you can say you thought they were doing the application, and in fact what you need is an aboraculturalist ( sorry can't spell that!) report. Which you commission but they pay for. Money upfront. Then you can get the report, (it would be helpful to have professional advice), and consider whether you want to abide by it's findings. You may find you agree to move the tree ( at their expense, obviously).

MsGrumpytrousers · 29/04/2023 00:45

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 21:03

Sadly I don't think placating is an option other than cutting down the tree.

One option that I don't think anyone has suggested is to tell them that yes you'll get the tree cut down but first you'll have to apply for permission from the council. And then don't do it. Just be always about to get around to it.

Or you could apply to the council for permission to cut it down and if they approve, ignore it and go on prevaricating, and if they don't – which they may well not, if there's no good reason, which there isn't – than that also solves the problem.

The tree is protected for a reason: the laws recognise the value of trees in our environment, and protect them from being cut down for stupid reasons, like seeds falling on people's nasty patios.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 23:58

YouCould · 28/04/2023 23:50

I find my birch trees quite messy trees but mine have bigger canopy's than yours. They shed lots of twigs and catkins and, in autumn shed leaves like you would expect. I wouldn't expect your small canopy tree to have shed much at this time of year.

It's definitely shedding catkins but given the size of the tree it's not a huge amount (as I posted earlier the amount thrown over the fence you could put in a crisp packet).

OP posts:
YouCould · 28/04/2023 23:50

I find my birch trees quite messy trees but mine have bigger canopy's than yours. They shed lots of twigs and catkins and, in autumn shed leaves like you would expect. I wouldn't expect your small canopy tree to have shed much at this time of year.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 23:44

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/04/2023 23:29

How do they even know it’s there? 1.5 meters is tiny.

As posted previously this is not the size of the tree. This is referring to the requirement for planning permission to fell.

The tree is the height of a 2 story house but with a slim canopy of circa 1.5m.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 28/04/2023 23:29

How do they even know it’s there? 1.5 meters is tiny.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 23:25

YouCould · 28/04/2023 23:05

"Sorry please see earlier post about 7.5cm at 1.5 metres"
"That is not the size of the tree"

I understood what you had said earlier it was the ratio of trunk size to height to canary that sounded odd but I guess it's just got a slim canopy

I would still not want it 3m from my house. It's still way too close. It's the roots I'd be worried about. Either damage directly from the roots or damage caused by the roots slurping up all the water in the ground.

Yes this is the dilemma.

They have 3 issues.

2 of which I think are invalid re: sweeping up seeds and home insurance given the tree was there when they moved in.

The issue of proximity re: potential damage I'm much more sympathetic to and I'm trying not to let how they approached the issue lead me to make poor decisions in response.

Hence posting for some perspective.

The tree is very slim but looks healthy to me.

I simply don't think it's roots are going to be of sufficient heft to cause any damage given the size of the tree.

But I'm not an expert.

It just seems very sad to cut down a healthy tree if it's not causing any issues (which currently it's not and given its maturity it's not going to grow significantly bigger).

Re: the patio as this is new if the roots were a problem surely it's installation would have literally uncovered the issue. Which leaves me to think that isn't the driver here.

They were very annoyed about the seeds and sweeping and if that's the main concern them cutting down a tree to save them time for a few weeks a year doesn't seem reasonable.

So getting an independent view (council) seems like the best route to follow.

I don't want this to escalate but neither do I want to be bullied nor do I want to be unreasonable.

OP posts:
Abitofalark · 28/04/2023 23:22

To be pragmatic and give you peace of mind, you could decide either to move the tree or remove it altogether and plant a replacement further away from the boundary and the neighbour's property.

Alternatively, based on my experience of years-long dealing with a neighbour's tree causing subsidence, and fear of potential risk from the growth and proximity of my own TPO tree (involving more than one firm of structural engineers, insurance companies and loss assessors, the council Tree Officer, the planning inspector, uncle Tom Cobbley and all) the best course would be to commission a report from an arboriculturalist, that is a specialist with knowledge of trees and their interactions with ground and buildings based on the science and latest research findings; assessment of risk from and to the tree, and the correct techniques available for managing or minimising growth and invasive roots to your neighbour's property. Armed with this expert knowledge and report giving you confidence in your position vis a vis the neighbours and your obligations and potential liabilities, you can make an informed decision as to the best course of action and approach the council accordingly for any necessary permission.

In my case, at the end of this long and gruelling process - three years of trial and error during which I wrote countless letters, underwent lengthy monitoring and inspections, wrangled with and changed loss assessors and structural engineers until I found the right ones, I learnt that the Tree Officer at my council didn't actually have much knowledge and recommended the wrong technique which would have caused more growth, not less. In the end, finding the right engineers and arboriculturalist solved everything: I succeeded in winning a planning appeal against the council's decision and was subsequently able to carry out repairs and manage the tree correctly using the proper techniques and ultimately have peace of mind and be able to sell the house without a problem.

Bovrilla · 28/04/2023 23:17

I'm sure it is a nice patio. Strikes me they don't really understand much about y'know...gardening. Or nature. I bet they have it all sterile neat and tidy expecting outdoors and nature to somehow be like their house.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 23:11

Bovrilla · 28/04/2023 23:03

I'd love the issue of an actual tree

As it is, my idiot neighbours planted leylandii years back, too close to the border. As a result we couldn't fence to our property line.

Leylandii have almost no benefits to native wildlife.

Ash and silver birch do. We need to have more trees, not fewer. We live in the most nature deprived country in Europe.

Do your neighbours have plastic grass too OP?!!

They don't have any grass.

Their whole garden is patio (it's like a small courtyard).

To be fair they must have spent £££ on the patio - it's a really nice job.

OP posts:
YouCould · 28/04/2023 23:05

"Sorry please see earlier post about 7.5cm at 1.5 metres"
"That is not the size of the tree"

I understood what you had said earlier it was the ratio of trunk size to height to canary that sounded odd but I guess it's just got a slim canopy

I would still not want it 3m from my house. It's still way too close. It's the roots I'd be worried about. Either damage directly from the roots or damage caused by the roots slurping up all the water in the ground.

Bovrilla · 28/04/2023 23:03

I'd love the issue of an actual tree

As it is, my idiot neighbours planted leylandii years back, too close to the border. As a result we couldn't fence to our property line.

Leylandii have almost no benefits to native wildlife.

Ash and silver birch do. We need to have more trees, not fewer. We live in the most nature deprived country in Europe.

Do your neighbours have plastic grass too OP?!!

Bovrilla · 28/04/2023 23:00

FlowersEverywherePlease · 28/04/2023 21:48

ThIs is the size of our neighbour's tree.

@FlowersEverywherePlease was it there when you moved in?

Ash aren't that fast growing.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 22:52

My tree's dimensions exceed this but not by much.

By which I mean trunk dimensions at 1.5m.

The height of the tree is as tall as a 2 story house but the canopy is circa 1.5m in circumference and starts 3/4 of the way up the tree.

OP posts:
HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 22:49

YouCould · 28/04/2023 22:34

You trees dimensions sound a bit odd. Is it healthy?

I really wouldn't want a silver birch growing so close to my house even a smaller variety. I love silver birches and I've got three massive ones at the ed of my garden. We've all got big gardens and I planted mine well away from the boundaries. I think the previous owner of your house was pretty shitty and stupid to plant it where they have. You neighbour seems a bit daft to approach you about this after building his patio but I can understand why they chose a patio as grass won't thrive so close to the tree.

Are you sure it's 75mm at 1.5 metres?

Is it possible to prune it, I know you can't at this time of year but it might help.

If I could I think I'd see if it was possible to cut it down. I know you didn't plant it but it's the wrong tree in the wrong place even if it's a slow growing variety.

Sorry please see earlier post about 7.5cm at 1.5 metres.

That is not the size of the tree.

It's the dimension of the trunk at a height of 1.5m for you to need planning to fell a tree in a conservation area.

My tree's dimensions exceed this but not by much.

OP posts:
HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 22:46

YouCould · 28/04/2023 22:34

You trees dimensions sound a bit odd. Is it healthy?

I really wouldn't want a silver birch growing so close to my house even a smaller variety. I love silver birches and I've got three massive ones at the ed of my garden. We've all got big gardens and I planted mine well away from the boundaries. I think the previous owner of your house was pretty shitty and stupid to plant it where they have. You neighbour seems a bit daft to approach you about this after building his patio but I can understand why they chose a patio as grass won't thrive so close to the tree.

Are you sure it's 75mm at 1.5 metres?

Is it possible to prune it, I know you can't at this time of year but it might help.

If I could I think I'd see if it was possible to cut it down. I know you didn't plant it but it's the wrong tree in the wrong place even if it's a slow growing variety.

I'm not a gardener so bear in mind that caveat but it looks perfectly healthy to me.

I appreciate the location of the tree isn't good, but we are where we are.

It would be so much easier if I could post a picture but I can't do that without including neighbours house and I think that's an invasion of their privacy and their house is distinctive if you know the village (in a good way, it's a pretty property). After all you only have my viewpoint here so I don't think it's fair to potentially identify them when they have no rebuttal.

I think the key is to speak to the council and take it from there.

They are independent and tree experts so I assume they will flag any issues with tree health and wider implications.

I don't really want to cut down the tree but I also don't want to be unreasonable and fundamentally if I'm advised that the tree is problematic by an independent party then I'll take on board their advice and act in line with that.

OP posts:
YouCould · 28/04/2023 22:34

You trees dimensions sound a bit odd. Is it healthy?

I really wouldn't want a silver birch growing so close to my house even a smaller variety. I love silver birches and I've got three massive ones at the ed of my garden. We've all got big gardens and I planted mine well away from the boundaries. I think the previous owner of your house was pretty shitty and stupid to plant it where they have. You neighbour seems a bit daft to approach you about this after building his patio but I can understand why they chose a patio as grass won't thrive so close to the tree.

Are you sure it's 75mm at 1.5 metres?

Is it possible to prune it, I know you can't at this time of year but it might help.

If I could I think I'd see if it was possible to cut it down. I know you didn't plant it but it's the wrong tree in the wrong place even if it's a slow growing variety.

HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 21:56

Raffleyourdoughnut · 28/04/2023 21:48

@HimalyanSilverBirch I'm a planning officer. Generally to fell a conservation area tree it's needs to be one of the three D's dead dying or dangerous. The planting of a replacement tree of a similar species is usually required if the fallen tree is native.

Your council will sent out an arboriculturist to check the health of the tree as part of your application. Your will likely need a arboriculturist/tree surgeon) tree survey with your application for planning to even look at it (it's part of the application validation process).

Thanks very much for your advice.

The tree definitely isn't dead, dying or dangerous in my opinion.

OP posts:
HimalyanSilverBirch · 28/04/2023 21:55

Littleworkaholic · 28/04/2023 21:34

Bloody hell. So it’s going to grow to over 20 foot foot tall and 12 foot wide and it’s nine foot from his house.

honestly I hope he takes you to court. How utterly selfish of you.

Well I did asked for opinions so thanks for your candor I guess 😂.

For reference however, the tree is at least 15 years old and thus mature I believe (and won't grow much if any taller).

It's height is equivalent to a 2 story house.

However for reasons I don't claim to understand the canopy is tiny compared to that in the picture and only starts 3/4 of the way up the tree.

I posted a picture earlier as an example.

If the tree was the size of the picture below and likely to/be allowed to grow to that size I'd agree that the neighbour would have a fair point.

However, I'm very happy to keep up maintaining the tree and managing the size precisely because it's so close to the boundary (which I made clear).

As I stated earlier there really isn't anything to meaningfully prune.

Those pictures are not representative of the tree in this case.

OP posts:
FlowersEverywherePlease · 28/04/2023 21:48

Littleworkaholic · 28/04/2023 21:34

Bloody hell. So it’s going to grow to over 20 foot foot tall and 12 foot wide and it’s nine foot from his house.

honestly I hope he takes you to court. How utterly selfish of you.

ThIs is the size of our neighbour's tree.

Swipe left for the next trending thread