Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think that women are really cruel?

291 replies

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 12:42

I just think that every stage of my life has been destroyed by women.

As a child, it was the adult women that were around me that were the cruellest.

School, the girls were so cruel. I got on with the boys.
college, the same
work, the same.

I just started a new job (remote)and we have been in training for two months. As there is a lot of training.

The way the job works is that we have four managers while we are training. They all do shifts as managers with us. Then when we complete training , we are assigned one full time managers.

During the training, the two female managers only messaged me and called me to tell me what I was doing wrong. They kept telling me I was doing things wrong. They were nasty and cruel to me. The two male managers were different, they were really supportive of me, as I had just started in the job. They said to ask them any questions etc.

When I finished training, I prayed that I would get one of the male managers, which I did. He is very nice and supportive.

Now, a month into the job, we have been told that we will all be assigned a quality coach. Which will be one of three people. The quality coaches are two men and a woman. I've dealt with the two men before and they are lovely, supportive and kind. The woman is a bully and just enjoys having power over people.

Again I prayed to get one of the men, but I got the woman this time. She has been making my life a misery. She is supposed to be supportive and helpful to me, but she has been really abusive to me and she is awful. She enjoys knocking people down. One of my. Other team mates also has her, and also says that she is abusing her really badly. Like as quality coach her job is meant to be supporting and helping you. But she just tells you that you are shit and useless.

My other team mates that have the male quality coaches, say that they are so kind and supportive to them , and are really helpful.

I just wonder, what is this? Why do women always seem to enjoy knocking people down and being cruel?

OP posts:
ReginaPhalange1989 · 28/04/2023 15:03

I think that you need to look up the definition of the word 'cruel'

People telling you their opinion isn't cruel.
People disagreeing with your perspective isn't cruel.
People giving you feedback at work isn't cruel.

I mean this respectfully to you, I am not trying to invalidate your experiences that you have had with other women. Some people are lovely, some are arseholes, that's just life.

I am saying this as I am a highly sensitive person, I pick up on peoples body language, tone of voice, and can often misinterpret how people act towards me.
But I have never once jumped to the conclusion that how I have interpreted something is necessarily right.
From your responses on this thread I feel like you can be quite defensive, and argumentative, and also seem to claim people are being personally cruel to you. I think that a bit of self reflection is needed here. I understand that you feel like you've been bullied / mistreated by women in your life time, and your reaction to this is to claim "all women are cruel". It is hard in life to not take everything personally, but there's a reason the saying is to "take offence". Offence isn't given, your emotional reactions to any given situation are your own reactions, in which you do have control over. What you deem as cruel or bullying may not be taken in the same way as another person experiencing the same situation.

I also sense a slight bit of victim mentality in your posts, and you're projecting your bad experiences onto all women.

Self care, and self growth are really important factors in life, inspecting your feelings and reactions to certain situations can help you learn so much about yourself, and enable you to understand that someone who is blunt to you is not cruel. Women can be strong, blunt, passionate and boss ass bitches, it doesn't mean that they have to be super kind and 'people please' constantly, that's just the patriarchal view of what women should be, and isn't accurate in this day and age.

And I am a mental health professional, and I must agree that you could find talking to one of us very beneficial, as it could help to change your mindset to have a more positive view, or help you to understand how you interact with people, and what affect that has on your relationships.

WinterofOurDiscountTentz · 28/04/2023 15:02

So you see You can't win. Even though I know they intended to call me crazy, if I call them out on it, one of them will say "so you're calling people with mental health issues crazy"

You DON'T know that though. You imagine that they are calling you crazy, when they are not. You "call them out" ie you are mean and rude to them, and then when they ask you why are you so rudely calling people with mental health issues crazy, you whine that they are all cruel gaslighting bullies and it proves your point!

Nobody called you crazy. You did call others crazy. You said that having MH issues is being crazy/unstable etc. You said that mentioning possible MH issues is bullying.

The rudeness, "cruelty" is coming from you. But you are the perpetual victim, so you can't see it. Or won't.

JusthereforXmas · 28/04/2023 15:02

In general I do feel get along with boys better (say as co-workers) as theres less drama with men and things often feel 'easier' (just look at planning a stag do vs. hen do lol) HOWEVER every best friend I have had has been a girl.

Usually I will have 1 close girlfriend in a group and the majority of the rest of our shared circle is usually men.

Its unlikely I would be part of a large gaggle of just girls as I find when lots of women get together fights/cattiness tend to break out through clashes of personality especially in contained spaces like work/school.

Yes women seem a tad more prone to drama when they feel they don't 'match' personality with each other but nobody is bad based on their genitals though.

Those women might all be perfectly fine one on one and I have no rule that I can only be friends with one girl that just seem to be how cards tend to fall for me. At the same time I have met some AWFUL men in my life too.

If you can't ever find ANY women you get along with its likely a reflection of you not 'all of womankind'.

SallyWD · 28/04/2023 15:02

I've come across plenty of really nasty women in my time and also some genuinely good and kind men so I certainly don't believe the "women are lovely, men are bastards narrative!".
However, you seem to be taking things to the other extreme. Yes SOME women are awful but you seem to think most are! The women I work with now are so incredibly kind and supportive. I've made really good friends with female colleagues over the years. There are many wonderful women out there!

Ilovepugs2017 · 28/04/2023 15:00

Imo I think it’s unfair to say women are cruel. Not ALL women are. Some can be bitchy yes.

MissLucyLiu · 28/04/2023 15:00

I speak to therapist myself post a really bad long term relationship. Even after I recovered I use her to help with my career. There is absolutely nothing wrong with needing to get some help. People on here are not being cruel to tell to to get some help. They are trying to help you.

Deadpalm · 28/04/2023 14:59

This is what I would describe as the pinnacle of female cruelty.

People will stop taking you seriously if you keep these exaggerations up. I have to say that the eay it's going, if you weren't recognisable long term pister, I would think you are just winding people up.

Megapint · 28/04/2023 14:58

I don't know what you've experienced at work so I can't comment on that. I do have a question for you tho, and I ask this in good faith not to be a dick. Why do you choose mumsnet to come for advice if you think the posters here are so nasty & bullying?.

Jacketandbeans · 28/04/2023 14:58

WinterofOurDiscountTentz · 28/04/2023 14:40

Only a professional doctor can tell someone that they need mental health assistance

Come on, you know that's not true.

You calling women in need of mental health support "crazy" is quite mean, isn't it? Cruel, you would say. Why are you being cruel to other women?

Oh my god this is severe gas lighting.

ttcat37 · 28/04/2023 14:58

I haven’t found this at all actually OP. I find that women are far more genuine, trustworthy and kind than men, especially in the work place.

SummerWinterSummerWinter · 28/04/2023 14:58

Are you interacting with these women differently to how you interact with the men? Are you expecting different things from them?

Sorry that you've met so many shit people - but if it's more than just you being unlucky, the common denominator in all these interactions with you. Maybe need to work through (probably with a qualified professional) to understand how you go through interactions and communicate and how these things keep happening.

Yes - women can be cunts. I worked for a woman who was an absolute twat and bullied me. I also worked with several women who were incredibly kind and went above and beyond to reassure me and lift me up. Ditto with men.

WinterofOurDiscountTentz · 28/04/2023 14:58

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 14:42

Oh my god. The extreme gaslighting on here.

No. People who have mental health issues are certainly not crazy.

But when ten women on a thread tell one woman that she has mental health issues and needs to seek professional help, believe me they are not doing it out of kindness. They are doing it to call the other woman insane/imbalanced/unstable.

If you are not a doctor/ a mental health professional, you have no right to say it to anyone.

It is the way they say it. It is extremely severe bullying .

I've seen it happen to other women on mumsnet.

You have absolutely summed up your issue here.

If ten people tell you that you need mental health support, it doesn't occur to you for a minute that you might need mental health support. You instead see it as "extremely severe bullying".
If a thousand people said it, what would you say to that?
If a dr said it, you would call the dr a bully as well. Cruel and awful, the same as everyone you have ever met.

It isn't bullying of any kind. Random people saying things you do not like are not bullies. You have a persecution complex, you cannot understand normal human interaction.

LifeExperience · 28/04/2023 14:58

The bullying on this thread is mostly coming from you, OP.

DancedByTheLightOfTheMoon · 28/04/2023 14:57

"One doesn't have to operate with great malice to do great harm. The absence of empathy and understanding are sufficient" .

lightinthebox · 28/04/2023 14:57

From your OP

*As a child, it was the adult women that were around me that were the cruellest.

School, the girls were so cruel. I got on with the boys.
college, the same
work, the same.*

Take out the trigger of mental health. It could benefit you greatly to sit down with someone and talk in depth about past experiences. It seems to be something that causes you distress, simply talking about it can help rather than seeking help on an anonymous forum.

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 14:55

OhmygodDont · 28/04/2023 14:46

For a women to succeed in a big company she has to be better than the men there. So yes women at work do have to be more competitive with their peers to prove their worth if they want to move up the ranks. Men get there by being men and being friends with the men and men men men basically.

A very sadly huge amount of men at work who are nice or kind to you, wouldn’t give you a second glance to even say hello to in the street if you stopped working in the same company. They use women for their own gains still again, they will flirt with you, so you think they are great and even you then sing their praises you possibly work harder too. Don’t want to let Mr tommas down. But his eying you up like a piece of meat either sexually or for his own work gain too.

Women are just blunt about what they want require and need and how your failing, she can’t flirt with you to get that same advantage unless your both bi/lesbians that isn’t going to work.

It is an interesting point about men. Men have been kinder to me at work. But as you said "are they only kinder for their own benefit".

Though a couple of the men that I work with, are happily married and I can't see what they gain from being kind to me. They just seem to be kind men

OP posts:
Whichwhatnow · 28/04/2023 14:55

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 14:36

Are you a doctor? Are you a mental health professional? Then why on earth would say that to anyone. So bizarre. Really utterly weird.

OP I don't think anyone is telling you that you definitely have mental health issues. As you say, only a mental health professional can tell you that. But if you won't talk to a mental health professional how will you know? People are just saying that it might be worth having that conversation.

Btw, there is no shame in seeking mental health support. I have mental health issues. Many people do. To be honest, for you to call people like me crazy/insane/imbalanced/unstable (all descriptions you have used) is in itself pretty cruel...

Mamamess · 28/04/2023 14:52

FishHaveFeelings · 28/04/2023 14:33

@Mamamess

Really wise advice. A lot of what you said resonated with me. Thanks for sharing your insight. And OP if that makes even the slightest bit of sense to you, think on it

ah thank you, I’m glad the post came across how I intended to

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 28/04/2023 14:52

Another reason your noticing the female cruelty which other posters have touched on -

We still live in a patriarchy and many women are fighting for the scraps which can result in trampling over others

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 14:51

WinterofOurDiscountTentz · 28/04/2023 14:40

Only a professional doctor can tell someone that they need mental health assistance

Come on, you know that's not true.

You calling women in need of mental health support "crazy" is quite mean, isn't it? Cruel, you would say. Why are you being cruel to other women?

Oh my god the utter gaslighting. It's shocking.
This is what I would describe as the pinnacle of female cruelty.

I never mentioned mental health issues.

10+ women came on here and said that I had mental health issues.

I said it's offensive to say that to a stranger on the internet that you've never met. And that they are using it in this instance to call me unstable.and to knock me down

Someone then says "so you are calling people with mental health issues crazy"?

So you see You can't win. Even though I know they intended to call me crazy, if I call them out on it, one of them will say "so you're calling people with mental health issues crazy".

That is female cruelty right there. You just can't win

OP posts:
tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 28/04/2023 14:50

OP why would you start a thread asking why all women are cruel and straight away accuse posters who point out perhaps how you interact could be a contributing factor, of being cruel?

> aware by your standards I'm being cruel Confused <

I've met lots of women over the years who have been horrible at times but reasons why could be -

By the nature of my social and working life I've interacted with many more women thsn men,

Female relationships can become close and intimate quite quickly meaning if things go a bit wrong things you've shared can make you vulnerable,

To think of a few reasons.

If I then consider the cruel things I've experienced from men (sexually assaulted age 11, again at 16, cat called, groped, graphic details of a sexual activity shared around a pub, photos taken of me by a man's friend during sex with him without my consent or knowledge) these have had far more lasting damage

usernother · 28/04/2023 14:49

OP I think you sound paranoid and you should get these feelings sorted out or you're going to spend your life being miserable

SmallFerret · 28/04/2023 14:48

Yes I think there is a particular psychological cruelty in women. Where they like to knock other women down.

You're being illogical.

Men are just as likely to knock other men down.
In fact, often more likely. It's all that testosterone. You know testosterone's not 'the sex hormone' that most people think it is, right?
It's actually 'the status & competition' hormone.

But never mind the science.
Just look at the world around you, & its messages. See any action film - they are all predicated on The Hero pitted against ... other men. See also war, politics, big business ... all men, competing with each other & vying for advantage at the other's expense.

JulieHoney · 28/04/2023 14:46

Your definition of cruel is quite a stretch. “Not pandering to you” isn’t what being cruel is.

Disagreeing isn’t cruel. Criticising your work isn’t cruel. Telling you your black and white thinking is unhealthy isn’t cruel. Even not wanting to be your workmate isn’t cruel.

You’re actively looking to take offence on this thread, which gives the casual reader the impression you do this in other areas of your life as well.

Women aren’t generally cruel. There are the odd few arseholes, sure, but as a cohort we aren’t cruel. I think you’re seeing exactly what you expect to see rather than what is there.

That sort of thinking hurts only you, OP. Changing your mindset would change your experience of other people.

lightinthebox · 28/04/2023 14:46

I strongly disagree.

If someone had a broken arm you'd tell them to go to A and E, no, they're not a doctor but it's simple advice.

Seeking help for past childhood experiences that are negatively affecting a person is nothing to be ashamed of.

It's not thinking someone is crazy, it's genuine empathy. Im sorry you see MH support in such a negative light.