Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think that women are really cruel?

291 replies

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 12:42

I just think that every stage of my life has been destroyed by women.

As a child, it was the adult women that were around me that were the cruellest.

School, the girls were so cruel. I got on with the boys.
college, the same
work, the same.

I just started a new job (remote)and we have been in training for two months. As there is a lot of training.

The way the job works is that we have four managers while we are training. They all do shifts as managers with us. Then when we complete training , we are assigned one full time managers.

During the training, the two female managers only messaged me and called me to tell me what I was doing wrong. They kept telling me I was doing things wrong. They were nasty and cruel to me. The two male managers were different, they were really supportive of me, as I had just started in the job. They said to ask them any questions etc.

When I finished training, I prayed that I would get one of the male managers, which I did. He is very nice and supportive.

Now, a month into the job, we have been told that we will all be assigned a quality coach. Which will be one of three people. The quality coaches are two men and a woman. I've dealt with the two men before and they are lovely, supportive and kind. The woman is a bully and just enjoys having power over people.

Again I prayed to get one of the men, but I got the woman this time. She has been making my life a misery. She is supposed to be supportive and helpful to me, but she has been really abusive to me and she is awful. She enjoys knocking people down. One of my. Other team mates also has her, and also says that she is abusing her really badly. Like as quality coach her job is meant to be supporting and helping you. But she just tells you that you are shit and useless.

My other team mates that have the male quality coaches, say that they are so kind and supportive to them , and are really helpful.

I just wonder, what is this? Why do women always seem to enjoy knocking people down and being cruel?

OP posts:
Jacketandbeans · 28/04/2023 17:23

FishHaveFeelings · 28/04/2023 17:15

Hmmmm, I think men and women psychologically abuse in very different ways. Women really know which buttons to press to emotionally hurt each other.

I think you're right, it comes from emotional intelligence and knowing how to hurt.
You don't really get the male equivalent of the AIBU pile ins and take downs. If you do please show me where because I'd love to witness it!

FishHaveFeelings · 28/04/2023 17:15

Watchkeys · 28/04/2023 17:03

But noone can do psychology bullying as well as women and girls

Apart from abusive men. They're pretty good at it.

Hmmmm, I think men and women psychologically abuse in very different ways. Women really know which buttons to press to emotionally hurt each other.

Jacketandbeans · 28/04/2023 17:14

Watchkeys · 28/04/2023 17:03

But noone can do psychology bullying as well as women and girls

Apart from abusive men. They're pretty good at it.

There are obviously psychologically abusive men too, but it's just my experience, and I'm referring mostly to groups rather than domestic situations.

Watchkeys · 28/04/2023 17:03

But noone can do psychology bullying as well as women and girls

Apart from abusive men. They're pretty good at it.

Jacketandbeans · 28/04/2023 17:02

Psychological*

Jacketandbeans · 28/04/2023 17:02

I agree with you OP, but you won't get much agreement here, a very feminist space, and as everyone knows, there plenty of vipers here!

I have some fantastic female friends, they are like sisters, my closest friends are women. I also have plenty of male friends. But noone can do psychology bullying as well as women and girls. I purposely avoid ending up in only female friendship groups, it usually gets complicated and catty in my experience. Maybe I've just been unlucky but I'm pretty old now and have formed my own opinions.

BiscuitsBiscuitsEverywhere · 28/04/2023 17:00

Of course some women can be cruel. And some men can be cruel. It is wildly inaccurate to suggest that women "always seem to enjoy knocking people down and being cruel." That is a huge generalisation that cannot possibly be supported with evidence.

Chickenkeev · 28/04/2023 16:39

SmallFerret · 28/04/2023 16:36

You are doing it again OP.

The same damaged (not a critiscism - somebody in your young life damaged you, It's not your fault) thinking that proclaims "all women are cruel" has just proclaimed "no therapist will work for me."

You have met TWO therapists in you life, out of millions.

The first time I tried to disclose my CSA to a health professional, I felt her response was sarcastic. Whether it was, or whether I was misinterpreting due to my own triggers & skewed impressions, is moot - the point is that, oike you, I did not go back to see her.

So it was years before I finally accessed the thorough, expert MH help I needed. I found a therapist who suited me, who challenged or showed compassion in equal measures ... & my life slowly improved, as I learned to recognise behaviour traits, & avoid abusive people. Some of those traits were my own. It's very common for adults who were abused as children to seek out, or be sought out, by people who continue the abuse in subtle, or different ways. The survivor is often too mired in muddled thinking patterns to spot it for herself. Therapy helps her do just that.

When a chilkd;s early life is blighted by abuse, that child will gravitate toward more abuse as an adult - not consciously, but because it feels like home, & they mistake it for love. Often, "we do what we know - not what we want."

You responded positively to @sparepantsandtoothbrush's post, & what a result that it led you to think about the film Good Will Hunting.
I don't know why, but that post kind of got something through to me. Maybe I am a bit defensive about getting mental health help.
Give yourself some self-care OP.
Look on it the same as you would for any physical health discomfort - you have an issue, you see a medical professional.
Or even as a personal fitness goal - you'd like to be fitter/run a marathon/build some muscle, so you go to a gym, work with a trainer. MH improves when we actively exercise healthy thinking patterns - & we ALL needs help in seeing the wood for the trees about what's healthy, & how to maintain it, at some stage in our lives.

Thanks for this. Food for thought!

SmallFerret · 28/04/2023 16:36

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 16:24

But I also don't think that therapy is any good.

Therapists are just human beings like ourselves.

I went to two therapists when I was younger. One man, one woman.

The first man. I told him my life story . And he sighed and said "that is going to be a lot of work for me". He wasn't kind so I didn't go back.

The second therapist I went to. I told her my life story. She burst into tears. And cried for about ten minutes. I ended up comforting her.

You are doing it again OP.

The same damaged (not a critiscism - somebody in your young life damaged you, It's not your fault) thinking that proclaims "all women are cruel" has just proclaimed "no therapist will work for me."

You have met TWO therapists in you life, out of millions.

The first time I tried to disclose my CSA to a health professional, I felt her response was sarcastic. Whether it was, or whether I was misinterpreting due to my own triggers & skewed impressions, is moot - the point is that, oike you, I did not go back to see her.

So it was years before I finally accessed the thorough, expert MH help I needed. I found a therapist who suited me, who challenged or showed compassion in equal measures ... & my life slowly improved, as I learned to recognise behaviour traits, & avoid abusive people. Some of those traits were my own. It's very common for adults who were abused as children to seek out, or be sought out, by people who continue the abuse in subtle, or different ways. The survivor is often too mired in muddled thinking patterns to spot it for herself. Therapy helps her do just that.

When a chilkd;s early life is blighted by abuse, that child will gravitate toward more abuse as an adult - not consciously, but because it feels like home, & they mistake it for love. Often, "we do what we know - not what we want."

You responded positively to @sparepantsandtoothbrush's post, & what a result that it led you to think about the film Good Will Hunting.
I don't know why, but that post kind of got something through to me. Maybe I am a bit defensive about getting mental health help.
Give yourself some self-care OP.
Look on it the same as you would for any physical health discomfort - you have an issue, you see a medical professional.
Or even as a personal fitness goal - you'd like to be fitter/run a marathon/build some muscle, so you go to a gym, work with a trainer. MH improves when we actively exercise healthy thinking patterns - & we ALL needs help in seeing the wood for the trees about what's healthy, & how to maintain it, at some stage in our lives.

Grumpy34 · 28/04/2023 16:36

That has not been my life experience at all. You have some real issues if you think you can blame all your problems on one gender. YABU.

Mirabai · 28/04/2023 16:35

Advising someone with clear mental health issues to seek appropriate support is not gaslighting. Gaslighting is trying to convince someone with good mental health that they have mental health problems.

trisfreya · 28/04/2023 16:34

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 14:51

Oh my god the utter gaslighting. It's shocking.
This is what I would describe as the pinnacle of female cruelty.

I never mentioned mental health issues.

10+ women came on here and said that I had mental health issues.

I said it's offensive to say that to a stranger on the internet that you've never met. And that they are using it in this instance to call me unstable.and to knock me down

Someone then says "so you are calling people with mental health issues crazy"?

So you see You can't win. Even though I know they intended to call me crazy, if I call them out on it, one of them will say "so you're calling people with mental health issues crazy".

That is female cruelty right there. You just can't win

10+ women came on here and said that I had mental health issues.

I said it's offensive to say that to a stranger on the internet that you've never met. And that they are using it in this instance to call me unstable.and to knock me down

People are responding to what you write, that's all

what would you tell you? Do you think what you've written is 'normal' ?

CuriousMoo · 28/04/2023 16:30

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 16:24

But I also don't think that therapy is any good.

Therapists are just human beings like ourselves.

I went to two therapists when I was younger. One man, one woman.

The first man. I told him my life story . And he sighed and said "that is going to be a lot of work for me". He wasn't kind so I didn't go back.

The second therapist I went to. I told her my life story. She burst into tears. And cried for about ten minutes. I ended up comforting her.

Sorry you've encountered two terrible therapists.

That doesn't mean that therapy is no good though.

I've seen a few different therapists, mostly NHS, and none were like you describe. Mine were supportive and helpful.

And yes, therapists are people too. That's why they have extensive therapy themselves, before they begin working with clients.

Watchkeys · 28/04/2023 16:30

The fact that you don't think therapy is any good doesn't mean that therapy isn't any good. The fact that you think that advice on a forum to seek mental health support is bad advice doesn't mean that it's bad advice. The fact that you think that the statement 'women are cruel' might be true doesn't mean it's true.

You seem to state your feelings as facts that can be applied to anybody... or as if we should 'know' that you think counselling is a bad idea, or that we should 'know' you don't want mental health support.

Why do you do that, when there is so much evidence to say that therapy is a good idea, and there are so many threads where people take advice and seek mental health support, and there are so many people who are women, so they can't possibly all be cruel? Why does your mind choose those paths to go down?

JulieHoney · 28/04/2023 16:29

If I wanted to do it I would do it by my own choice

A stranger on the internet telling me to do it, is not going to make me do it

@Mooshamoo I think the hope of most people posting is that if almost everyone is united in saying "this is not a healthy way of seeing the world", you might wonder if "hey, all those women might have a point. Maybe some help would improve my (currently unhappy) situation."

Rather than "you mean women are proving my point that women are horrible and cruel."

I've been the bitterly unhappy person with a heightened perceive slights and hurts.
It sucked.
I wish I'd known what I saw wasn't what was actually happening much earlier. I thought my mindset was normal. It took people outside to point out no, that's skewed. And I got counselling. And I'm much happier now.

Chickenkeev · 28/04/2023 16:28

What do you want exactly? You're on a majority female site, with a majority of female posters, and when they comment (quite rationally) you say all women are bitches. Grand stuff, take yourself off to reddit of somewhere.

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 16:24

But I also don't think that therapy is any good.

Therapists are just human beings like ourselves.

I went to two therapists when I was younger. One man, one woman.

The first man. I told him my life story . And he sighed and said "that is going to be a lot of work for me". He wasn't kind so I didn't go back.

The second therapist I went to. I told her my life story. She burst into tears. And cried for about ten minutes. I ended up comforting her.

OP posts:
ThreeblackCats · 28/04/2023 16:21

I came here to say exactly what @FrenchFancie has said. But your somewhat nasty response to her words of wisdom tells me that the reason people are cruel to you is because of you.

She (Frenchfancie) was not cruel. She is correct. You are the reason people are nasty to you. I guess you’ll think I’m just being cruel op, but you need to have an attitude adjustment.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 28/04/2023 16:17

*Xyxygy
*
I was speaking from life experience and yes, when I've had a negative interaction it's often involved asssult, abuse or sexual humiliation.

Way more damaging. And definitely cruel

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 16:13

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 28/04/2023 16:02

I was thinking about a study that I read about children who suffered psychological abuse. It affected them for their whole lives and it badly impacted many areas of their lives. Sexual abuse is of course more harmful, but psychological abuse is also abuse, and it has many negative effects on people

You do realise you were one of those children OP? You must realise that that abuse you suffered is impacting the way you're viewing relationships with pretty much everyone in your life. This is why some posters have told you you need some help with your mental health.

Thank you for saying that politely.

I don't know why, but that post kind of got something through to me. Maybe I am a bit defensive about getting mental health help.

It made me think of the scene in Good will hunting.

Have you seen that movie. Where robin Williams the therapist, is talking to Matt Damon (who had been an abused chid).

Robin williams is saying that Matt needs help. Matt Damon is saying he is fine and is telling robin Williams to fuck off .

Robin Williams keeps saying to Matt Damon that it is not his fault that he was abused as a child.

And Matt Damon eventually breaks down and cries.

OP posts:
ASGIRC · 28/04/2023 16:12

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 13:20

Again, you are proving my point , by being cruel.

Well done.

I think Ive figured out the problem OP.

Its not that people are cruel to you... Its that you perceive cruelty in ANY criticism and opinion that isnt your own.

And no, this is not being cruel.

Like a PP said, "if you meet an asshole, it is likely that person is an asshole, but if everyone you meet is an asshole, you might be the asshole".

Im not saying you are an asshole, exactly. Im saying you might be too sensitive for your own good.

In my experience, women are not cruel. I have met a couple of HORRIBLE women, just like I have met a couple of horrible men, but by and large, no, there is no particular cruelty inherent to women. Most raise themselves up and are supportive of other women.

If this is not your experience, you need to take a good hard look at yourself.

WinterofOurDiscountTentz · 28/04/2023 16:12

Suggesting to someone that they seek therapy on an online forum is not helpful in any way shape or form

Of course it is. Just because you have no intention of doing it does not mean its not helpful advice.

Every post you make confirms just how much you need to speak to a professional.

EasterBreak · 28/04/2023 16:10

I agree op

Mooshamoo · 28/04/2023 16:07

JulieHoney · 28/04/2023 16:00

If you think suggesting you seek counselling is cruel, you have a deeply skewed understanding of mental health issues.

You are posting aggressively and offensively to people who disagree with you and are positioning yourself as a victim. That so many posters can see what an unhealthy mindset that is doesn't mean they are being unkind or calling you crazy. It means they can see you need some support to have a healthier and better life. And they suggest you ask for that support.

There is no shame in needing or seeking counselling or therapy. I've had years of it myself and it has dramatically improved my life. I was one of those suggesting you get counselling because I know how much it can help.

Your problem is you, OP. That's hard to hear but the good news is you have the power to improve your situation.

If you were right and so many women are cruel, that would be an unfixable problem. But it's either your mindset or trauma informing your experience, and help is available for both.

I wish you could see that, and I wish you well. But I doubt you'll listen.

Suggesting to someone that they seek therapy on an online forum is not helpful in any way shape or form.

First of all: All of us are aware of the mental health supports out there. I am well aware of the telephone supports, the online supports, the counsellors, the therapists that are out there.

They have been there for years.

If I wanted to do it I would do it by my own choice.

A stranger on the internet telling me to do it, is not going to make me do it.

The same way if I said to someone else on the internet - "you should get therapy. "

It's not going to make her get therapy is it?

OP posts:
WinterofOurDiscountTentz · 28/04/2023 16:03

More so that I've noticed particular traits of cruelty in women. That are particular to women

There aren't. Women are just judged more harshly than men are for the exact same things.

Swipe left for the next trending thread