Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like this about having another child?

216 replies

WhatAreTheseOddFeelings · 28/04/2023 11:34

I know that I want another child. I’m an only child and I’ve always wanted more than one. I have a nearly 2 year old and I absolutely love being a mum.

The current plan is to try for another baby when he’s in school so he would probably be 5 or 6. The idea with this is that I will get to spend all of his first 5 years with him, giving him all of me and being able to do all of the activities and toddler/pre-school classes without having to factor in another child. Then when he’s at school and we have another one I can do the same with them during school hours.

The odd thoughts/feelings I am having right now are:
Panicking about getting pregnant now - Around the time my period is due (and more so if it is late) I start panicking that I am pregnant. I don’t believe in abortion so that would never be an option for me so I know that if I were to end up being pregnant sooner than planned I would be having that baby. Now I don’t doubt that I would love and enjoy my second child no matter when they come along but the thought of being pregnant again sooner than planned makes me feel sad. I don’t want either child to miss out on opportunities to do all the fun baby and little kid things with me. I want my child to be our only focus until he starts school so that I can fully enjoy being his mummy and doing all of the fun things we do now. I don’t want him to have to share our attention right now.

But then the other thought I’m having is what if this thought/feeling doesn’t change when he starts school? I know I will miss him whilst he is there and I don’t want the new baby to be seen as a replacement. But then how long is too long to wait? What if I don’t think he is ready to share the attention until year 1 or year 2? He would then be 7, 8 or 9 by the time the next baby comes.

I feel less worried about the next baby in the sense that all they will know is having a big brother so they won’t have that feeling of being replaced/ignored/left out ect. in the same way as a child who has been an only child previously.

The thing is that I know I want another child. I’m pretty positive that that won’t change. So what are these feelings about and what do I do??

OP posts:
DeflatedAgain · 30/04/2023 19:01

It's a pretty big age gap OP.

I was 8 nearly 9 when my brother was born and we didn't speak at all growing up.

Obviously a bit older, but you might not get pregnant in the timeframe you want!

Try to relax and enjoy time with your LO. Another one will come along when the time is right and you'll make it work.

JMSA · 30/04/2023 18:52

Oh, and I have a 5 year gap between my eldest and middle. It's not great - just too big a gap really.
The 3 year gap between middle and youngest was perfect, and they grew up really close until the dreaded teens hit.

Caneloalvarez · 30/04/2023 18:52

hi @WhatAreTheseOddFeelings do you suffer from anxiety / ocd at all? I know a couple of people have mentioned that your thought processes are odd but I can relate totally. I would agree that planning to this degree is coming from an anxious / perfectionist mind. I have one DC and also have a history of anxiety. I was actually anxious to have a smaller gap due to my age and also because I thought that siblings closer in age would get on better. But sadly here I am just after my 2nd MMC with the gap getting bigger and bigger. As an anxious person I have found the process of going from nearly getting my 'perfect' plan to then readjusting and re-planning very draining and sad. I know everyone would find this hard and sad (not just someone with ocd type thinking) but it seems to add a complicated layer. In theory it is fine to have a plan but I really wouldn't worry so much about whether the gap is 'perfect'. People like us need to be reminded that life cannot be planned in this way and we need to make peace with that.

As an anxious brain I have also had panics and fears that I MIGHT be pregnant when I really didn't want to be e.g. when my DC was younger than a year old, or too soon after MC when I didn't feel ready... And then have equally been panicking at the thought of not being able to have the second DC when I planned to. I think these crazy thoughts are just the product of an anxious mind and we need to remember that hopefully things will work out one way or another (maybe not in the exact way we plan!)

Also really appreciate those mentioning that longer gaps actually work well as I was feeling a bit down about people pointing out the negatives! :)

Fundays12 · 30/04/2023 18:46

I have nearly a 5 year age gap between my first and second child. It's not a great gap at all. They have nothing in common and my oldest is and still can be quite jealous towards my middle child. He was used to having me and his dad to himself for years and found it difficult to adjust to having a sibling after so many years. They are now 11 and 6. It's constant different activities and interests so we often have one parent taking dc1 somewhere and the other taking DC2 and Dc3. They go to bed at different times, don't play together and I honestly think it did dc1 more harm than good being an only child for so long as we also gave him loads of one to one attention. That's not always the case if they have a lot of other kids around them and are used to sharing you and dad but it's something to consider.

Dc3 came along as a surprise. There is a 2.5 year gap between him and dc2. It's a great gap. It was hard work when they were very small but they play together loads now, giggle all the time together and have similar interests. They are the best of friends and seek each other out at lunchtime in school too have a cuddle.

You will love your second child just as much as your first. Anxiety is natural but it's worth considering a huge gap has negatives as well as positives.

mrlistersgelfbride · 30/04/2023 18:41

Are you sure you want another child? It seems like it's a stressful matter for you. It doesn't need to be this planned if you do. There are pros and cons to every and any age gap.
I've agonised over this too until I realised I was worrying about something that did not yet exist and was not necessarily needed, so I'm enjoying DD as she is. She's 5 and v likely to be an only now. I'm happier now than when I was flip flopping every day over having a 2nd.

Tumbleweed101 · 30/04/2023 18:38

I have four children and a variety of age gaps. My favorite gap was the 2yr gap between my first and second.

humblesims · 30/04/2023 18:34

I havent read the full thread.
You are over thinking and second guessing.
If you wait until your first child goes to school and then produce a sibling then there is the danger of the first child being upset that the 'new' one is at home enjoying your wonderful mum things.
I'm being a bit flippant but there is no perfect time to have another child.
My own experience is two children, two and a half years apart which for us was perfect. The second child just adds to the family and if they have a year or two together before the oldest starts school then they have time to create a strong sibling bond. Yes! they can enjoy a relationship almost as important as yours!
They grow together and being close in age they start doing the same things as they get to be older children.
It's just my two penneth.

JMSA · 30/04/2023 18:31

I mean this in a nice way, but you should have the second child to take the intensity off the first. I mean, he's two, and you are already thinking about missing him at school 😬
Relax and don't overthink it.

Katherine1985 · 30/04/2023 18:30

jaychops · 28/04/2023 11:40

All I can say is from my experience, I thought I could never love another child as much as I did my first. But your heart just doubles and you are full of love. If a second one arrives sooner, you won't be on your own with your first but you will get to see the bond develop between them and your first grow as a big sibling. It's the best thing in the world (in my eyes).

This describes the process I went through

I knew I wanted a second, but with a reasonable age gap, just like you OP. But the 5 years gap I envisioned suddenly turned into 4. I panicked at first, but it was amazing, and just right for us

GirlsAndPenguins · 30/04/2023 18:29

I’ve just had my second. My first was turned 3, 3 days before baby was born!
personally I wanted them to be close in age so that they may have similar interests or when they are older we can do days out that suit both of them.
So a few things. My daughter had her 30 hours just after the baby was born, so she is in nursery 4 days a week and we have one day together where I take her to football. Come September though (she will be 3.5) she starts the nursery attached to her primary school. She will then go 5 days a week. For me this in important as it will mean that she knows everyone and the routines before reception. I wouldn’t want her to go to reception with children that all knew each other from nursery and feel left out. I’ve also known children that didn’t go to the nursery struggle with the transition to reception.
The reason I’m saying this is because you may find that they are in some form of education before 5. Even reception starts at 4.
I was worried about my daughter being jealous but she hasn’t been at all. She tells everyone her sister is her best friend. Constantly asking to hug and kiss her. She will ask for her sister to pick her up from nursery. She loves showing her off, makes me wait at preschool so that all the staff can see her 😂. Honestly the bond is already amazing and it makes us all melt!
She gets plenty of attention (more than the baby when she’s around!) gets taken to football and swimming lessons. The swimming is just the two of us as Dad has the baby.
Do what suits you but I was worried about jealousy and I now see I had no reason as my daughter says ‘my baby sister is my best friend’ x

Peakypolly · 30/04/2023 18:28

I had a very similar timeframe in mind. DC2 arrived 44 months after DC1. I would not worry about your eldest feeling pushed out. My eldest already felt they were deprived not having a sibling as most of their friends already did.
However, I have to agree with other posters; you can't plan things too finely. Unplanned DC3 arrived 22 months after number two... and all is well.

Breezycheesetrees · 30/04/2023 18:28

Nuevabegin · 30/04/2023 09:15

I don’t really understand the constant comments re having all that time to focus on your first dc without having to deal with a second child . Tbh I think children benefit more from playing and being around siblings close in age than parents playing with them as children are on their level .
Of course attachment to the parent is so important but honestly this hyper focus on all the time together without the “distraction “ of another child is a bit odd and all sounds too intense tbh. I have three dcs relatively close , they are older now and they have a fantastic relationship with each other . The first two years are essential for attachment so pouring all that time in then but honestly they benefit so much from each other .

Totally, and a 5-6 year old who's got used to having all the focus and special attention is going to really fucking hate a baby coming along and spoiling it all...

Luckyduc · 30/04/2023 18:27

I'm an only child....why do you want another child? Thats maybe what you need to ask yourself.
Cause waiting 5 years or more fir baby number 2... the age gap is massive and I can assure youu that your 2 kids will be in completely different paths ....they won't play with the same toys, won't lioe the same cartoons, won't be in the same section of softplay... won't have that much in common. So I'm guessing the second baby isn't a play friend for the first.
Also....you could do all the messy play, groups and so on with both of them at the same place if you had a baby now.

anotherscroller · 30/04/2023 18:17

orangegato · 28/04/2023 11:41

Stop having a perfect image of what you need your life to be like just roll with it. You can’t be in control of everything.

This

wingingit1987 · 30/04/2023 18:16

I personally think that the 5 year age gap is too much for me. My mum had that between me and each of my siblings and it wasn’t til we were in our late teens/twenties that we did much together. Mine are 8,6,4,2 and 4 months. Already things like days out can be tricky at the 8 year old won’t have the same interests as my 4 or 2 year old. Luckily, he can pair up with my 6 year old and go off and play.

that being said, I know a lot of mums with bigger gaps who enjoy it.

Imisssleep2 · 30/04/2023 18:12

I would say i felt the same and had the same doubts as you when my son was that age, he is 2years 7 months now and the change i have seen in him in independence is mind blowing, and they start to want to play and socialise with other children more now too. I dont know what it is like round you but our routine during the week is:
Every other monday playgroup which he cant do after he turns 3
Tuesday a different playgroup that also stops once 3
Wednesday messyplay
Thursday preschool, morning only thatvhe loves
Friday free/recharging for the weekend.

So once he turns 3 we will only be able to still do preschool and messyplay, and he really does love school and as we both work full time he will go to pre school mornings mon to friday come January and i think he will be ready for that interaction with kids his own age and i will still have him in the afternoons to do things, it will also prepare him for school nursery more.

There is a reason alot of people have a 3 year age gap in the uk, if you have too big a gap i think you will lose the friend/ companship for your kids you may be seeking by having two, but that may just be me.

We are trying for our second now after much debating in my head for me, i do feel it is right for us, but just see how you feel but you may feel very differently in 6 months time

Beccy1990 · 30/04/2023 18:10

If your not worried about your fertility and that it might take a while for you to fall pregnant I’d start trying for a new baby once your little one starts reception. Then even if you fall pregnant straight away it’s still 9 months until the baby comes.
This means your older child will of been in school 9 months already so won’t feel like they’ve been sent to school and been replaced with the new baby. Plus that gives you a minimum of 9 months to get your oldest one settled in case there is any teething problems in school.

Chocolateisnice · 30/04/2023 15:07

Stop overthinking!!! Just live in the moment and take each day as it comes.

CongratsOnTheCats · 30/04/2023 15:06

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/04/2023 09:39

Why have another baby op? Sound like even just the idea is causing you a lot of stress! Why not just chill out and be happy as you are? 😊

She says she wants another child.

THEDEACON · 30/04/2023 13:58

I was an only child for 6 yeary sibling and I aren't close and I resented the baby sister trailing after me through teens I'd never recommend that age gap

Dracuuule · 30/04/2023 13:53

I agree with the overthinking. Any age gap is going to have good points and bad points.
I had a two year age gap and I feel it's made life so much easier for me.
My dc played together all the time, shared a bedroom and it was easy taking them to the cinema, museums, soft play, playgrounds and so on. I could even chuck them both into the garden together to play together.
The first couple of years were tough but worth it later.

DangerousAlchemy · 30/04/2023 11:09

You're definitely overthinking this OP! We have almost 4 year age gap as I had a miscarriage in between. You can't always map out a perfect future. My friend had a 7 year gap and whilst the older one was great with a newborn baby they are now 15 & 7 & it really isn't working well atm as they have absolutely nothing in common, don't play together at all & don't want to do the same activities/days out. Once her eldest is 18 & off to Uni or college she'll have an 11 year old still at home, effectively an only child for another 7 years before they are off to Uni etc. If you definitely want another child I wouldn't wait 6 years before trying to conceive - it could take you years to get pregnant & you could end up with a 10 year gap or something.

Elaina87 · 30/04/2023 10:52

I had similar thoughts around an age gap, and just felt I'd cope better when my eldest was at school. She's 4, 5 in July and I'm about to have my second any day now. I got pregnant just before she started full time school. You're definitely letting your mind run away with you. A smaller age gap would be nice as theyd probably be closer, so either way there are pros and cons. Its hard to have feelings for a future child and at the moment all you can think is how it will affect your son, I've been the same. But both children will be loved and it will all work out whatever the age gap.

Sunshine275 · 30/04/2023 10:24

Theres nearly 3 years between my two it was ideal for me, by the time I had baby I got free funding for the 3 year old so so she had her own time to develop in a nursery setting while I got time with the baby. We had the first 3 years of toddler groups etc. She’s nearly 7 now and doesn’t remember any of it, all I know is for me it works and my kids are close enough in age to now play the same things together but also I got individual time with both they needed.

SaveMeFromForearms · 30/04/2023 09:39

Mumof1hopingfor2nd · 30/04/2023 09:26

I was a little bit like you OP
I was a young mum 20 when I fell pregnant and I ended up single my sole focus became my DC I was determined he would be my world...I worked but in my head it was only to provide him with a better quality of living not for myself!
I never went out with friends hen do's engagements girls holidays despite the fact I was so lucky and had a lot of offers of childcare I only used them for work cover I didn't need anyone I had my DC

He was a handful by anyone's standards and we didn't know it at the time but he has Autism ADHD Tourettes and Epilepsy by the time he was 3 I couldn't go anywhere or do anything because he was used to me being there for him and only him! My mental health declined and I went to therapy! My therapist said something which has stuck with me since
' you have made it the responsibility of a 3 year old to make you happy, content and fulfilled how is that fair to them?'
I was like no I haven't she Repeated back to me what I'd said
He's my whole world's my sole focus if he is happy I am happy he's the reason I get up each day and I heard it from a different perspective and it hurt! I realised I had potentially unintentionally damaged him! As when things were hard I sort of blamed him I was like I've given you everything I had and still you can't behave or be like the other kids etc!
Now I'm not saying this is you but I'm sharing because this is extreme we think we are doing right by them making them the sole focus but it's almost too much.
From then I changed things it was hard but I did it and then obviously we had a lot of diagnosis when they started school and it helped massively but I coped because I'd started to reclaim my life!
I then met my new partner when DC was 7 when DC was 9 we decided to try for a baby thought it would be easy I wasn't trying when I fell with DC so it would be easy right...WRONG
We tried for a year nothing so we had tests all normal no reason secondary infertility is a thing I didn't know about
My DC is now coming up too 12 and I am finally pregnant I have had 2 miscarriages and still in the early stages with this one but hopeful!
You can't always plan life even with the best intentions obviously we all have choices where we can choose to try and prevent situations but I feel ATM from your post that your worrys are interfering with your life and taking enjoyment from your DC worrying about the next one coming earlier than planned
Maybe just relax but please please stop making him centre of your world have time to be you, to be a friend, to be a wife/partner
It's better in the long run and he won't hate you mecand my DC have an amazing relationship now and they are beyond excited for their sibling despite a 12 year age gap

This is a really smart post, thanks for sharing your story. You sound like a great mum.