Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like this about having another child?

216 replies

WhatAreTheseOddFeelings · 28/04/2023 11:34

I know that I want another child. I’m an only child and I’ve always wanted more than one. I have a nearly 2 year old and I absolutely love being a mum.

The current plan is to try for another baby when he’s in school so he would probably be 5 or 6. The idea with this is that I will get to spend all of his first 5 years with him, giving him all of me and being able to do all of the activities and toddler/pre-school classes without having to factor in another child. Then when he’s at school and we have another one I can do the same with them during school hours.

The odd thoughts/feelings I am having right now are:
Panicking about getting pregnant now - Around the time my period is due (and more so if it is late) I start panicking that I am pregnant. I don’t believe in abortion so that would never be an option for me so I know that if I were to end up being pregnant sooner than planned I would be having that baby. Now I don’t doubt that I would love and enjoy my second child no matter when they come along but the thought of being pregnant again sooner than planned makes me feel sad. I don’t want either child to miss out on opportunities to do all the fun baby and little kid things with me. I want my child to be our only focus until he starts school so that I can fully enjoy being his mummy and doing all of the fun things we do now. I don’t want him to have to share our attention right now.

But then the other thought I’m having is what if this thought/feeling doesn’t change when he starts school? I know I will miss him whilst he is there and I don’t want the new baby to be seen as a replacement. But then how long is too long to wait? What if I don’t think he is ready to share the attention until year 1 or year 2? He would then be 7, 8 or 9 by the time the next baby comes.

I feel less worried about the next baby in the sense that all they will know is having a big brother so they won’t have that feeling of being replaced/ignored/left out ect. in the same way as a child who has been an only child previously.

The thing is that I know I want another child. I’m pretty positive that that won’t change. So what are these feelings about and what do I do??

OP posts:
toobusymummy · 01/05/2023 19:15

Samlewis96 · 01/05/2023 17:44

Presume you weren't working and needing to pay for childcare with them all being so close in age

Actually I was working, Like I said, I had a plan.....

Bugbabe1970 · 01/05/2023 19:04

Good grief - you are really overthinking this!
older kids don’t miss out on anything just because siblings come along!

Daisyb1080 · 01/05/2023 18:56

You are overthinking this

Greymalkin12 · 01/05/2023 18:14

I decided to plan a three year age gap, and my child is nearly five having had four miscarriages and a baby loss and no immediate prospect of another child. Some things are out of our control and to some extent we have to go with the flow.

Angelil · 01/05/2023 18:13

For very similar reasons to you, we went for a 4-year age gap. I didn’t want two in nappies and childcare simultaneously and as we travel frequently (both sets of (grand)parents live abroad) I really needed one who was old enough to walk beside me with their own little suitcase, listen to instructions in crowded places, sit in their own plane/train seat etc before having another.
So my eldest is now 4.5 and his baby brother is 9wo. He LOVES his baby brother and I get to devote my maternity leave to my youngest just as I did with the eldest. I think it’s a great age gap personally and in terms of my age it has also worked well (I was 32 when I had the eldest and 36 with the youngest).

Winnipeg23 · 01/05/2023 18:10

After reading your post I just thought...wow...talk about overthinking it! And that comes from someone who definitely thinks things through but that takes it to a whole other level🤣
Anyway I'd say have them close together and they grow up together and u can do similar aged stuff together. That's my tuppence worth. But I think most comments made to your post were really good and helpful. Hopefully all that helps!
Best wishes with the family ❤️

Lamaitresse · 01/05/2023 18:00

We started ttc when dc1 was 1. It took 6 years to have dc2, with lots of losses on the way.
YABU to think that you can control life to that extent. Also I wish so much that we had less of an age gap - they are at such different stages and are always fighting.
If you are lucky enough to be blessed with a dc2 just be grateful, whatever age gap you have.

Harls1969 · 01/05/2023 17:52

Just over 4 years between my two and they've always had a great relationship. I was 10 (and a half!) when my sister was born and 15 when my brother was born. We are also very close. So an age gap doesn't necessarily mean they won't get on. I think there will always be good and bad sides to having them close together or with a few years between, but if you definitely don't want another baby in the next couple of years, you might want to use more reliable contraception 😀

wentworthinmate · 01/05/2023 17:49

Thats too much of an age gap for me personally.

Samlewis96 · 01/05/2023 17:44

toobusymummy · 01/05/2023 15:07

I had a plan....that went right out the window when I realised it wasn't going to be as easy as I thought it was! Then I had another plan, but that one went right out the widow when I realised that I was an IVF rockstar and had an easy (ish) time of it. Then the next plan went out the window when the old tickerty-tock told me I wasn't done at 2. Oh, and there was the 'I hate toddler groups, I'd rather stick needles in my eyes' that I hadn't expected AT ALL so that felt like a complete grind. I could give you a whole books worth of arguments why your original plan (wait till number 1 goes to school) has a heap of drawbacks and potential unwanted effects on number 1 - and there's this other books where you've hit the baby jackpot and got it completely right. I had one and two 16-months apart - it was AMAZING, watching them interact together and getting time to see them grow and bond before oldest had to go off to school. three came along when two had just turned 3 so they got a tiny bit of time together but then I got to spend time with three (although the schedule was different as we had school run to do). Anyway my point is, it would seem that you're getting yourself worked up about the 'next steps' which could well have an effect on enjoying these ones. If you're on birth control you're taking steps to make sure your plan works out, and if for some reason you get pregnant anyway before then well... it was meant to be and you'll be fine!

Presume you weren't working and needing to pay for childcare with them all being so close in age

Samlewis96 · 01/05/2023 17:42

clarehhh · 30/04/2023 19:32

The gap will mean they are hardly siblings. They will have such different needs. Much better to go gor smaller gap so they can play together otherwise elder one will have to accommodate smaller one and their needs and resent them too much. Think about having a toddler and a teenager, recipe for trouble.

I had a toddler and a teenager. Plus one inbetween What's the big deal with that? At least the teenager was doing her own stuff and I wasn't paying all my wages out on childcare like when you have two preschoolers

ChaosOnTheCoast · 01/05/2023 17:37

All sounds way too intense for everyone.

Samlewis96 · 01/05/2023 17:35

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 28/04/2023 12:31

Personally, I wouldn't have wanted a brother who was 5 of more years younger than me. It's too big an age gap, you can't really engage on the same level with someone that much younger than you, play with each other etc.

My brother is 3 years younger than me, and that seems pretty much perfect to me. It was enough of a gap that I could do the protective older brother, and that I could use him as an excuse to play with "Little kids toys", but we were close enough in age that we like playing some of the same games together and he didn't completely do my nut in.

I see some of my friends who are the eldest of 3 or 4, and they're almost always closest to the sibling that they're closest in age to.

Doesn't always work like that. I have a brother 2 years 2 months younger and one 12 years younger. Didn't play with my first brother at all as a child despite the close age gap. Ironically the 2 boys always got on very well despite age difference ( nearly 10 years) and still do. My daughters are 3 years 3 months spart. Fought like cat and dog constantly. Now they both married they have nothing much to do with each other. My son is 9 years younger than DD2 (now 19) and they get on much better. Ironically both DDs only have the one child each

toobusymummy · 01/05/2023 15:07

I had a plan....that went right out the window when I realised it wasn't going to be as easy as I thought it was! Then I had another plan, but that one went right out the widow when I realised that I was an IVF rockstar and had an easy (ish) time of it. Then the next plan went out the window when the old tickerty-tock told me I wasn't done at 2. Oh, and there was the 'I hate toddler groups, I'd rather stick needles in my eyes' that I hadn't expected AT ALL so that felt like a complete grind. I could give you a whole books worth of arguments why your original plan (wait till number 1 goes to school) has a heap of drawbacks and potential unwanted effects on number 1 - and there's this other books where you've hit the baby jackpot and got it completely right. I had one and two 16-months apart - it was AMAZING, watching them interact together and getting time to see them grow and bond before oldest had to go off to school. three came along when two had just turned 3 so they got a tiny bit of time together but then I got to spend time with three (although the schedule was different as we had school run to do). Anyway my point is, it would seem that you're getting yourself worked up about the 'next steps' which could well have an effect on enjoying these ones. If you're on birth control you're taking steps to make sure your plan works out, and if for some reason you get pregnant anyway before then well... it was meant to be and you'll be fine!

IAmTheWalrus85 · 01/05/2023 12:49

I think there’s no right or wrong when it comes to sibling age gaps. They’ve all got pros and cons - and also all involve individual humans with individual personalities.

But the one thing I can close to guarantee you is that whenever you do have a second one, you will adore them and you won’t see them as an intruder/interloper into your relationship with DS1.

SophieinParis · 01/05/2023 12:41

kikisparks · 01/05/2023 07:24

How do you know toddler groups with mummy are not that fun? What a strange comment.

And a sibling isn’t guaranteed to be a constant playmate you can cuddle up with.

I do know what @Mumsday is getting at. I have 4 children: some close together in age and some not. I love playing with them and avoiding playing with them is not why i had them close together. BUT playing with mummy or daddy is not in any way the same experience as playing with a close in age sibling. My children live in their own imaginary world. They play together from before breakfast until after dinner. They are never lonely. Of course I do the odd bit of crafting, painting, baking, Lego with them. But that’s always the filler in until a sibling gets home or finishes homework etc.

Of course bigger age gaps do play together and my children who are further apart do hang out together and love each other, but a 10 and a 5 year old do
not play in quite the same way. They aren’t friends in the sense that my closer in age ones are. They don’t gossip about mutual acquaintances or play games based on the books they both read, or start a baking project or write a story or a playscript together, or make up a dance routine. It is more a case of bigger one placating the little one and looking after them and doing funny things for them etc.
If possible I really do advocate a smaller age gap. As I said I have both big and small gaps and whilst the bigger gap is much nicer for me, the smaller gap is nice for the children.

katienana · 01/05/2023 09:57

My gap is 3.5 years, they are now 10 and 7. It's working well now as they like going to see the same films at the cinema, gaming together, play lots together. When ds2 was born ds1 was doing 3x 5hr nursery sessions a week so that gave me time one on one with the baby. The rest of the time we would go to the park, soft play, playgroup which was all stimulating for the baby as well as the pre schooler. The baby used to watch his big brother intently and definitely benefitted from having him around. Big brother was old enough to understand when baby needed to be fed etc and was very sweet with him.
When the older one started school the younger was 18 months and it was definitely easier to do the school run than I can imagine with a newborn (why do they always poo when you're about to leave the house?!)

Mumof2girls2121 · 01/05/2023 09:32

I have an 8 year age gap.
they DDs get on very well, activities are a occasionally a nightmare finding things for them both to do! Also starting school runs at seperate schools will be hard, for infants and seniors!
I wish I’d had them closer together so I don’t have to do toddler and pre teen tantrums at same time 😩
you’ll be surprised how your second one will make you feel, I was worried I wouldn’t like her! And I love her just as much as the first!

Dingdong90 · 01/05/2023 07:33

I've got a 5 year age gap, my eldest was in year 1 when I had my youngest and honestly, I wish I hadn't waited so long. 5 years of attention then suddenly having to share it was quite a shock to my eldest, although she loved having a baby sister, she did complain that she wasn't getting enough attention because up until then ,she was quite spoiled for attention from us

kikisparks · 01/05/2023 07:24

Mumsday · 30/04/2023 09:23

What about changing the way you’re looking at it?

If you wait until your first child starts school before you try again, you’re assuming that he will benefit from all that mummy time with you one on one.

But what about how much he’d benefit from the fun and companionship of having a sibling for those years? Toddler groups with mummy are really not that fun - having a constant play mate who makes you giggle and you can cuddle up with definitely is.

I also think what you’re planning is a tricky age gap. Your first DC will have just gone through a big transition (starting school) and then he will have a new sibling after being on his own for 5-6 years. Tricky times.

I got pregnant with my DC2 when my first was 2, so there’s a 2.9 year age gap. Seeing the relationship they built together before my first started school and how they played together was one of the great joys of my life. They slept in the same bed and absolutely adored each other.

How do you know toddler groups with mummy are not that fun? What a strange comment.

And a sibling isn’t guaranteed to be a constant playmate you can cuddle up with.

erakakitzi · 01/05/2023 07:15

I wouldn’t wait for 5-6 years! Me & my sister are 6 years apart and even though we never had problems when we were kids and now we are very close as adults, I wish we had less of a gap. We had pretty much nothing in common till I finish uni. When we were kids she stopped playing when I started playing, when I was in high school she was off to uni and when I was partying in uni she was getting closer to 30 so she stopped. I have two kids of my own now 2.3 months apart. At first it was a shock for me cause I was obsessed with my older son so I felt I missing out but eventually it balances out. He was jealous for a month or so in the beginning but he is fine. And to be frank he ll never remember a life without a sibling. The longer you wait, the harder will be for the older I feel to adjust from only child to sharing. And don’t forget you older will always have firsts as primary school kid, as a teenager etc. So it s a matter if you want more than 1.

autienotnaughtym · 01/05/2023 06:55

My dd have a two year gap and are very close/always played together. I had a six year gap and my sisters never played with me/made my life a misery. I felt like an only child .

squidwid · 01/05/2023 06:02

I had twins and they have me and also each other. I did every toddler class. It's difficult to have 2 or more kids at any age (you and your first born's age).

If you have two close, you are done faster with the baby phase, nappies etc.

Twins were financially difficult but I'm smug now they are in school and my friends' babies are still in nappies.

I found pre school and babyhood hard for various reasons. Lack of government support for childcare, it's all down to you and babies and pre schoolers have a lot of needs.

I love my life now they are in school, we have the best weekends and holidays.

Smile good luck.

Zonder · 01/05/2023 05:53

I have less than 2 years between my two and there have been so many positives. They have always been really close, even more so now that they're both teens.

Firstly, I enjoyed playing with my first and when the second came along it was even nicer. We just did things as a three until dh got home/ weekends when we did things as a four.

Secondly even quite young my two wanted to do stuff with other children. We did baby and toddler groups, made friends and did play dates so it turned out that it wasn't always me they wanted to play with anyway.

It's good for them to share your love and attention. It doesn't mean they only get half each and lose out.

Mumoftrois · 01/05/2023 05:22

I have loved being a mum to my daughter, only daughter for the first 6 years of her life. We got to do so much as a family of 3. We got pregnant (with twins) when she was 5. I always knew I wanted more than 1 child. And I am so glad I waited until she was the age she was. She went through a bit of an anxious unknown when I was pregnant, and I seriously started to wonder what I have do her and if I had ruined our little family. 5 months later the twins are here and it is the absolute best age gap. Shelves them so much and understands when they need me and then I make sure we do nice things together whilst they sleep, or sort childcare for the 2 and we go out just the 2 of us. And whilst she’s at school, swimming, going to clubs, friends, doing everything she always has done I have quality time with the twins. (Until I go back to work and this will be a whole new juggling act 😂).

I was in your situation, I just got some really good birth control (implant) and started trying when she got into reception at school.

Swipe left for the next trending thread