Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that home schooling is as much for the privileged as private school?

184 replies

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:14

I see a lot of private school bashing on here, which I guess is fair enough, as it's something that benefits a tiny minority and seems to be something a lot of wanky politicians do. Not so much home schooling, though, which to me is also a thing that only 'rich' people can access. Private school is seen as for toffs, right wing, bad, whereas home schooling is seen as radical, left wing, and generally not judged as much? AIBU that both options are reserved for the highly privileged who can afford to do such things / make huge sacrifices for a radical alternative option to state schooling?

OP posts:
Mammalamma · 28/04/2023 15:46

CurlewKate · 28/04/2023 14:47

In order to home school you basically need to be able to survive on one income. That's it. I know that you are financially privileged if you can do that-but not nearly as financially privileged as you need to be to afford private school.

I work full time as does DH, we home educate both of our children

VikingLady · 28/04/2023 15:32

I home ed my kids because they cannot cope with school. Even if they were given a place in a special school, they couldn't cope - their issues preclude it utterly. Plus there is no actual education goes on in our local special school. It's purely crowd control; essentially a storage area for out of control kids.

DH was on £16k when we started. No family help. No car, no holidays. I fed us from food schemes (That Bread and Butter Thing is brilliant if you need it) and having the time to shop clearance at the end of the day. The adults in the house lived mainly off value bread and rice. I'm very good at mending things including clothes. I made our treats.

No, it's not a fucking privilege. It's a necessity.

The people I really despise are the smug bastards who say "oh, I'd do anything for my kids, but I couldn't spend all day with them" [tinkly laugh] or "oh I'd love to, but we can't afford it" as they tell me about their second foreign holiday this year, then drive home in a new car. Their kids in new Next or Boden. Yes you could, you just don't want to.

Not a privilege.

DyslexicPoster · 28/04/2023 15:21

For many in the SEN community home schooling is the only option and I know plenty of mums living on UC in their council house home schooling a violent child with pda who has been expelled. So I guess it's your view point as you might see that as privileged if your living in squat / crack den I guess.

However I think really you need to understand that you don't need to be uber rich to access private education ( I have two kids in private sen schools paid for by my LA. I'm not rich, I'm a carer right now, but I do know my rights so I have privilege that I can read and understand law hence my kids aren't being home schooled) our Private village school takes in kids from inner London on full bursaries so on speech day you see the 4x4 porches and the mum with a brown paper primark bag packing the kids boarding kit up. All chuffing along together fine, in the rwal world theres not the resentment. Most of the kids are from abroad, boarding.

It's simple to think that everyone who home educates is a hippy that is minted so no need for a job and every child in the private sector is a toff but the reality is you will find a fair share of kids born into and living in poverty with parents who have no chance to ever escape that poverty. Harsh but true. In the despair and hopeless some people can get a break. You can live in poverty but still aspire, research bursaries and get out of state. However anyone who enveys my situation is bloody stupid. One Of my children will never live independently. One was utterly shitted on from height on by state schooling so much so I could prove in tribunal at the Royal courts of Justice no where else but a private school meet his SEN needs. People could look my children and feel jelous ( unlikely unless you covet a non verbal child with asd and severe language disorders) but I look at the kids going to the local state and feel utter despair that isn't my two. Comparison is the thef of joy n all that jazz. Take my kids independent schooling, but wit it comes severe learning difficulties. Feel jelous of the tower hamlet kid getting a 25k a year private school place, so go live in her high rise tiny flat.

FatGirlSwim · 28/04/2023 14:59

I’m a single parent. But work minimal hours whether they’re in school or not due to their SN. It is actually easier for me to work when they are home Ed. The to and fro from school and the dealing with the meltdowns due to the stress of school is harder than home Ed, which I can work around (I work from home).

FatGirlSwim · 28/04/2023 14:57

My children aren’t illiterate. Ds went into school ahead of his peers in most areas. I didn’t unschool but neither did I follow the school curriculum.

However, the peers of his who did unschool and were completely child led, aren’t illiterate either. They do read and write, they just did so later than their schooled peers.

With hindsight I wish I had leaned more to unschooling in the primary years.

SleepyMathematician · 28/04/2023 14:54

CurlewKate · 28/04/2023 14:47

In order to home school you basically need to be able to survive on one income. That's it. I know that you are financially privileged if you can do that-but not nearly as financially privileged as you need to be to afford private school.

No this isn’t true. Well, it will be for some families but certainly not all.
I homeschooled (out of desperation). DH worked in the day and I worked in the evenings and on Saturdays. It was tough and we sacrificed a lot for many years. Every penny we earnt that we had spare went on the DC. I didn’t buy myself a single item of clothing for about ten years.
It was worth it. They both loved it and did really well out of it. But we definitely weren’t rich (DH a was a minimum wage earner), by any standards.

Cinderellasfeatherduster · 28/04/2023 14:50

We also have the advantage that we are both self employed and by secondary will be able to involve DS with our work, so we wouldn’t have to give up everything to home educate.

CurlewKate · 28/04/2023 14:47

In order to home school you basically need to be able to survive on one income. That's it. I know that you are financially privileged if you can do that-but not nearly as financially privileged as you need to be to afford private school.

palygold · 28/04/2023 14:35

No one in the workplace is going to prejudice your kid for going to a private school. They might get judged by a few self important reverse-snobs, but they are easy to ignore.

True

And they wouldn't know in a lot of situations, unless you tell them or they make a guess because of your accent (has happened on occasion to me).

Mammalamma · 28/04/2023 14:32

I home educate both my children due to them both being failed catastrophically by the schooling system. Both my children suffered so much at school due to their needs not being met. They became shadows of themselves and I wasn’t prepared to put them through more trauma. We don’t home school, we home educate as there is nothing like school in our lives.

We are no where near privileged and we aren’t well off by any description. Me an DH both work full time and we go without an awful lot.

I’m sure there are lots of people who will make snap judgments for our choices but until they have been in a similar situation then it will be hard for them to understand. I would like to point out however, my children are far from illiterate (as a previous poster likes to make out)

the education system doesn’t work for so many children. The system should mould around the child and their needs. Instead, the child has to mould around the system in the hopes of getting by and not drowning. Just because a child is in school does not mean they are receiving a fulfilling education

TheSnowyOwl · 28/04/2023 14:29

I only know people who home educate because of SEN and an independent school isn’t an alternative because they wouldn’t take the children. I also don’t think the children concerned get the same level of academic education and a fair bit of it is being left to their own devices to learn compared to a school setting. However, it’s a happier environment and more suitable for them than mainstream school where the inability to fit in meant they weren’t getting the level of academic education they could have been either.

Some people wfh around the home schooling because it’s not affordable. However, when neither state nor private schools are an option, there isn’t any choice.

Nachobowls · 28/04/2023 14:24

I home educate (not homeschool) dd because she wasn’t given a place in a sen school when she wouldn’t cope in mainstream, I’m far from rich in fact the opposite!

Cinderellasfeatherduster · 28/04/2023 14:19

Although in fairness the majority of the homeschoolers here are the anti-establishment anti-vaxxer variety. I’d always planned to home school ds but couldn’t get on with the groups locally. He’s fine at a lovely primary now but we may have to look at home schooling for secondary as he is ASD. We’re not rich and I’m already making financial/career plans in case that’s the route we have to go down.

Cinderellasfeatherduster · 28/04/2023 14:17

Not at all. You’d change you’re mind if you visited the home schooling groups here. Not one ‘wealthy’ person.

happyumwelt · 28/04/2023 14:15

Two of my three dc are homeschooled - they are autistic and were drowning in school, especially dd, who became suicidal. They went to a mainstream (independent) primary school and did very well, but the social pressures of secondary were too much. I think it is possible to do it well without being particularly well off, but it does make it much easier - we pay for multiple hours of one to one tutoring, music lessons and sports coaching. I was also financially able to take an extended break from work in order to facilitate it all (am self employed and we can manage easily without my earnings). It would be much more difficult for me if I had no choice but to work or if we had to teach them ourselves.

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 14:00

Christ, off the back of this thread I googled the name I used on mumsnet that I used to use when I was home educating all those years ago (I’ve re registered many times over the years on here).

First hit was a thread I started in the home ed section in 2010 taking about people making shitty comments about ds being home educated. I was in such a low place because of it.

I honestly don’t know if I can go back to taking that shit all the time 13 years on. It was exhausting and demoralising.

wherediditgo80 · 28/04/2023 12:51

I must admit, my presumption on home schooled was from conspiracy theory say-on-the-toilet anti vax parents to keep them 'Away from the system' however there was a great thread here earlier in the year, maybe in AMA? About what it actually entails when you do it properly - not just sat indoors all day trying to replace being a teacher. It sounded ideal tbh, especially as we have a DD who is probably going to struggle in a school system.

But it did make me realise that not only do you need to be able to survive on one income (or one full and one part time) you also need money for all the activities, the tutors, the outings. We couldnt afford that.

But we COULD afford, at a push, private school (in primary years anyway).

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 12:38

I home educated my first child until he was ten (he’s now a young adult doing a degree apprenticeship). He wasn’t ready for school in so many ways when he was young. He went to nursery at 3 and it led to a catastrophic start for him. It was just awful. We took him out to home educate him half way through reception. He went to school at 10 as we moved across the county and asked if he wanted to try school. He did and it was fine at that point.

My 9 year old is at school. Started nursery at 3 and a half and loved it. Loves school. It suits her. She was a very different child to ds.

My youngest is 3 in August. I’ve not applied for a nursery place as she is very similar to how ds was and being and August born child, I wouldn’t have been sending her so soon anyway. I am probably going to home ed her but won’t decide properly for another year or so. I’ve found all the local home ed groups in preparation.

I am not religious. I am not a crusty mum who lets her children walk round asda with bare feet and thinks it’s fine that they still can’t read at 10.

With ds I followed an online curriculum. We went to lots of home ed groups. He did lots of “after school” activities.

The only drawback when he went to school was that he was ahead of his peers academically. He’s not gifted or very bright - you can just get though a lot one on one and children learn a hell of a lot when they can pick their own projects. He also missed thee social aspect of home ed, which makes me laugh seeing as most people act like home educated children are locked in the house 24/7.

If I do home educate my youngest, it won’t be something I have entered into lightly.

And christ, the constant criticism and judgment you get as a home educator isn’t something I would actually chose to subject myself to. People can be so, so rude and nasty. I just want to do the best I can for dd. And if that’s home ed, I will again, take all the shitty comments on the chin.

I privileged to be able to have the choice. But I chose to be a SAHM. We are not well off, dh supports us all on £37k (my adult son is still at home but has a good job and pays some rent). But that’s a lifestyle choice we made and we live within our means and moved to a very cheap are to do so.

Anyway, I’d best start growing that thick skin again. I see attitudes haven’t changed in eleven years since I last home educated. I’d better get ready for the harsh judgment to start.

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/04/2023 12:23

I think there are similarities and differences.

As PPs have mentioned I think a large subset of homeschoolers do so because their children struggle in mainstream education due to emotional, health or learning difficulties or neurodiversity or because they have particular beliefs or ways of living (including but not limited to religion) which are not compatible with mainstream education.

That said, it is a fairly privileged position for one person in a partnership to be able to abandon their job to focus purely on educating their children. I privately educate my child so I'm in no position to throw accusations of privilege around but its not something all families can do.

isittheholidaysyet · 28/04/2023 12:17

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:37

I think I meant privileged because you'd need to be able to afford to give up work and potential career advancement, pension contributions etc, as well as pay for things, activities, extra tutoring etc. I don't judge home school people I envy them. I suppose I also envy private school people if I'm honest about it

Yeah. I don't have a pension or any hope of career advancement. I would say those things are for the privileged.

But I do the best I can for my kids.

isittheholidaysyet · 28/04/2023 12:15

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:39

If for example you had to give up a 35k job to home school then home schooling is costing you 35k a year, no? Which you could technically use to pay the fees?

There is no way I would ever earn that much though.

I was a SAHP because there is no way I could earn enough to pay for nursery/childcare.

Yes giving it up would be a sacrifice, but so would spending it on private school.

jeaux90 · 28/04/2023 12:03

I'm a single mum and use a private all girls school for my daughter. I couldn't homeschool because I'm a lone parent.

It's a reasonable cost, lots of parents both work, mainly in law, medical, tech etc

The reason why many of us strain to pay private is because the state school system is absolutely shit for ND kids. My DD14 has ASD and ADHD. Academically she's good but really really struggled at state primary with 30 kids in a class and the noise levels.

Her school has two classes a year 12 in a class and she is thriving.

This is not about privilege. Sometimes treating everyone the same is the most unfair thing you can do.

I definitely might have considered home school/online schooling if I could have or thought it the best thing for my child.

FatGirlSwim · 28/04/2023 12:03

I think there is far more judgement of home educating families than there is of people who send their children to private school.

There’s a massive assumption that children will be learning and will access education just because they attend a school.

I have home educated at various times. I couldn’t afford private school.

I have sacrificed work, but atm all my children attend school and I still can’t manage many hours at work due to their needs (reduced timetables, inability to cope with wraparound care, separation anxiety, autism)

blackpearwhitelilies · 28/04/2023 12:01

I had to home-ed my children because they both have special needs which were ignored by the school. Then they became the targets of bullies and one attempted suicide. We couldn’t afford private education and no alternatives were offered. Call me an over-privileged ‘crustie’ if you want to, but what else could we have done?

cannaecookrisotto · 28/04/2023 11:59

I don't agree.

My friend homeschools due to her DD not coping at school. She's not privileged in any way, spends her days homeschooling and evenings working.

Homeschooling must be very hard going. If I was rich enough and came into that "privileged" bracket of which you speak, I would pay a full time tutor.