Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that home schooling is as much for the privileged as private school?

184 replies

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:14

I see a lot of private school bashing on here, which I guess is fair enough, as it's something that benefits a tiny minority and seems to be something a lot of wanky politicians do. Not so much home schooling, though, which to me is also a thing that only 'rich' people can access. Private school is seen as for toffs, right wing, bad, whereas home schooling is seen as radical, left wing, and generally not judged as much? AIBU that both options are reserved for the highly privileged who can afford to do such things / make huge sacrifices for a radical alternative option to state schooling?

OP posts:
Cuboidapple · 28/04/2023 18:59

Noteification · 28/04/2023 18:52

No, stay at home mothers have been undervalued and negatively judged for a long time. But now the government really have declared war on them.
Being a stay at home mother should be a respected and valid choice for women. The household hours match, why does it matter who is earning them? All that matters is that mothers aren't home with their children, seemingly. I can't think of another explanation.

Yes I agree with you . It’s totally wrong to remove the choice

Noteification · 28/04/2023 18:52

Cuboidapple · 28/04/2023 18:44

Seems like they really don’t want anyone at home do they

No, stay at home mothers have been undervalued and negatively judged for a long time. But now the government really have declared war on them.
Being a stay at home mother should be a respected and valid choice for women. The household hours match, why does it matter who is earning them? All that matters is that mothers aren't home with their children, seemingly. I can't think of another explanation.

Cuboidapple · 28/04/2023 18:44

Noteification · 28/04/2023 18:39

You'd think so. M at home parents are women and this does take choice away, it is supposed to. I wish the papers would take it up with some uproar and a u turn. But I don't think anyone cares how it negatively impacts working class mothers and their children.
My husband often works over 40 hours a week, gets pretty much all the hours he can. But that isn't good enough, we both have to work less hours. I miss tax credits.

Seems like they really don’t want anyone at home do they

Noteification · 28/04/2023 18:39

Cuboidapple · 28/04/2023 18:15

That’s absurd isn’t it!!!!! Surely if the combined household hours are the same it doesn’t matter !!!! It enables choice for couples too with childcare etc

You'd think so. M at home parents are women and this does take choice away, it is supposed to. I wish the papers would take it up with some uproar and a u turn. But I don't think anyone cares how it negatively impacts working class mothers and their children.
My husband often works over 40 hours a week, gets pretty much all the hours he can. But that isn't good enough, we both have to work less hours. I miss tax credits.

Cuboidapple · 28/04/2023 18:15

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 17:25

There was a thread here on it a few weeks ago.

There was so much vitriol that people could claim UC with only one half of a couple working full time.

But if both worked part time, it was fine.

That’s absurd isn’t it!!!!! Surely if the combined household hours are the same it doesn’t matter !!!! It enables choice for couples too with childcare etc

Wenfy · 28/04/2023 18:09

The filthy rich very often ‘homeschool’ by paying in tutors - results in decent enough exam results they get their pick of universities & then jobs.

Dibblydoodahdah · 28/04/2023 17:55

@alyceflowers I sent mine to private when I earned about £38k. Almost all of my salary went on the fees.

Giselletheunicorn · 28/04/2023 17:51

I’m my experience many who choose to home school do so out of desperation

I would echo this. Everyone I know who homeschools has a child with SEND that cannot manage in mainstream and cannot access a place in a SEND school due to lack of places. Particularly kids on autistic spectrum. And they are all families who have seen their household incomes cut in half due to one parent having to give up work to school the kid(s). Very much a 'needs must' situation and not remotely privileged.

WeBuiltThisCity · 28/04/2023 17:50

Round here home Ed is truely very mixed, from parents really struggling as single parents to manage SEN and surivive on benefit and low paid p/t work to those on huge incomes with tutors. Personally I’d say it’s the group with the most variance on social factors, or economic factors. They are far far away from being a homogeneous group. It’s like linking Eton to a sinking comprehensive to try to group them .

WeBuiltThisCity · 28/04/2023 17:48

I have five children. So private school wise that could be 40k per term. I don’t earn that on a year…. So I’d say no… they aren’t comparable

alyceflowers · 28/04/2023 17:43

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 17:31

I'm not saying home school families are rich, but I don't think people working 2 full time wages with with kids at private school is rich either, because of how much it costs. Both are choosing to educate differently but on MN you generally see that private school families get flamed but I think I'm reading the wrong threads bc home schooled families on this thread looks like they feel judged as well, which isn't the case in my social circles. I'm not in a position to do either due to if I give up work I won't be able to go back after ten or more years and we couldn't afford fees but maybe could with a bursary. But then I was overthinking as lots on here (and in RL) judge private school families.

Spending a lot of money doesn't make you 'not rich' - it just means you are rich and spend a lot of money.
People who earn £100k plus are high earners, they are in the very top earning percentiles - even if they spend a big chunk on school fees (or holidays or a huge mortgage) it doesn't change that.

depre · 28/04/2023 17:38

I home ed DD but I'm not rich. We get tax credits and disability benefits and muddle our way through. School was damaging her mental health so I took her out.

Hesma · 28/04/2023 17:36

Most people I know who homeschool do so because their children were not coping in mainstream school.

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 17:31

Createausername1970 · 28/04/2023 17:21

I home schooled out of desperation due to un met needs at school. We aren't privileged or rich. Just parents seeing their child heading for a crisis and trying to do the best for them.

I'm not saying home school families are rich, but I don't think people working 2 full time wages with with kids at private school is rich either, because of how much it costs. Both are choosing to educate differently but on MN you generally see that private school families get flamed but I think I'm reading the wrong threads bc home schooled families on this thread looks like they feel judged as well, which isn't the case in my social circles. I'm not in a position to do either due to if I give up work I won't be able to go back after ten or more years and we couldn't afford fees but maybe could with a bursary. But then I was overthinking as lots on here (and in RL) judge private school families.

OP posts:
katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 17:25

Cuboidapple · 28/04/2023 16:47

Why would they do that ? Surely it matter what the household working hours are and whether that’s one partner or both is irrelevant otherwise they are unfairly taking away choices from people that can severely impact their family life

There was a thread here on it a few weeks ago.

There was so much vitriol that people could claim UC with only one half of a couple working full time.

But if both worked part time, it was fine.

Createausername1970 · 28/04/2023 17:21

I home schooled out of desperation due to un met needs at school. We aren't privileged or rich. Just parents seeing their child heading for a crisis and trying to do the best for them.

Cuboidapple · 28/04/2023 16:47

Noteification · 28/04/2023 16:29

We're a low income home educating family. A little stressed about proposed UC changes to make it so each person in a couple has to work 18 hours , instead of one working 36 hours. It'll cost the government more in childcare.... but as long as we're making it harder for stay at home mothers.
Figuring out a plan, but my husband will likely reduce his hours and share a larger chunk of the educating. But home education is very important to us, so we will have to make it work.
Most of the people who I know who home educate are pretty well off. Pretty sure we are the poorest home educators I know. But we also do more academically than most people we know. If you can afford private school at all, I would consider you well off. We couldn't afford it at all.

Why would they do that ? Surely it matter what the household working hours are and whether that’s one partner or both is irrelevant otherwise they are unfairly taking away choices from people that can severely impact their family life

alyceflowers · 28/04/2023 16:46

I home educate one of my own children and know a lot of home educators and would say most are in the working class or lower middle class categories - certainly haven't met any I would consider priviledged and definitely not in the 'private school' category!

Some home ed families can have one parent permanently at home, either a single parent on benefits or being able to live off one partners wage or having one parent as a registered carer for a disabled child.
Most families still have both parents working though to some extent - for example doing cleaning jobs early morning, parents working opposite shifts, working from home, mobile hair/beauty services where they can take a child with them.

Lots of families find themselves essentially forced into pretty impoverished situations because their children with SEN can't attend school as there is such a lack of support.

Noteification · 28/04/2023 16:29

We're a low income home educating family. A little stressed about proposed UC changes to make it so each person in a couple has to work 18 hours , instead of one working 36 hours. It'll cost the government more in childcare.... but as long as we're making it harder for stay at home mothers.
Figuring out a plan, but my husband will likely reduce his hours and share a larger chunk of the educating. But home education is very important to us, so we will have to make it work.
Most of the people who I know who home educate are pretty well off. Pretty sure we are the poorest home educators I know. But we also do more academically than most people we know. If you can afford private school at all, I would consider you well off. We couldn't afford it at all.

Spendonsend · 28/04/2023 16:22

I think its probably my circle, but nealy everyone I know that home schooled was forced into it by lack of sen provision and have suffered financially, losing jobs etc and didnt feel at all privileged. They just felt massively let down and denied the human right to education.

Netcam · 28/04/2023 16:13

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:37

I think I meant privileged because you'd need to be able to afford to give up work and potential career advancement, pension contributions etc, as well as pay for things, activities, extra tutoring etc. I don't judge home school people I envy them. I suppose I also envy private school people if I'm honest about it

It's not always that simple. I couldn't afford to give up work/ potential career advancement / pension contributions but when it felt like the only option for my DS when he refused to go to primary.

A few years later with 2 young homeschooled DSs in tow, my marriage failed and I found myself a single parent trying to manage it all.

I had to be creative since I had given up my career when the kids were young too. I retrained doing an online masters degree, worked part time evenings and weekends when the kids were with their dad, or got babysitters.

I continued to homeschool as the kids were part of an established community by the time I broke up with my ex and didn't want to disrupt their lives further.

It has been exhausting but they are now 16 and 18 and I am almost at the end of my home ed journey.

DS1(18) did really well with his GCSEs, which I had to pay for privately, and after nearly 2 years at 6th form he should be off to uni soon. DS2(16) has already done 5 of his GCSEs, grades so far are 4 x 9s and 1 x A. Has 3 more exams to do this summer and then he's off to 6th form to do 4 A levels.

I don't know if it was the right decision, for me it was a massive sacrifice. But it seemed like the right thing to do at the time. Most home ed parents have a mix of ups and downs, as do those whose kids go to school.

But I certainly wouldn't call it a privilege, there is no way I could have afforded private school, we just lived quite simply. Money went on the activities they wanted to do, but a lot is organised cheaply among home ed families. Tutors have only been used minimally for a couple of subjects near exams, but mostly, like others have found, GCSE textbooks have sufficed.

I am fortunate that I eventually remarried and things became easier then. But I had 5 years as a single, part time working, home ed parent. And believe me, I did not feel privileged.

Threebeanburrito · 28/04/2023 16:12

I know someone who homeschools and they are the stereotypical hippie/vegan type. (They also don't vaccinate and homeschool probably consists of learning about yoga and chemtrails.) I understand that it's not always like this.

I agree it's a privilege to be able to stay at home with your children and have no school runs/work. But I don't think people who homeschool are the same level of rich as people who can afford private school. In theory you could home school with one parent working and the other staying home, and survive cheaply on the one income.

Dibblydoodahdah · 28/04/2023 16:05

@CurlewKate loads of families with kids at private school use one salary for fees and the other for other household expenses. I was one of them. I did think sometimes about giving up work and home schooling. We would have been in the same position financially.

Capitulatingpanda · 28/04/2023 16:02

I home ed and me and DH both work. We're not well off at all, no holidays or money left at the end of the month. It might be the home ed groups we go to but most families we meet are in similar position, barely holding on financially and there are a lot of families where both parents are working.
I feel like people are reverse snobby about private school but absolutely vicious and judgmental about home ed, some seem to see it as akin to child abuse.

CurlewKate · 28/04/2023 15:59

In order to home school IN MOST CASES you basically need to be able to manage on one income.
Fixed it.