Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that home schooling is as much for the privileged as private school?

184 replies

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:14

I see a lot of private school bashing on here, which I guess is fair enough, as it's something that benefits a tiny minority and seems to be something a lot of wanky politicians do. Not so much home schooling, though, which to me is also a thing that only 'rich' people can access. Private school is seen as for toffs, right wing, bad, whereas home schooling is seen as radical, left wing, and generally not judged as much? AIBU that both options are reserved for the highly privileged who can afford to do such things / make huge sacrifices for a radical alternative option to state schooling?

OP posts:
GrouchyKiwi · 28/04/2023 20:11

We home educate. It means we have one salary, which on its own is a good one, but obviously has to go further than if I had a job too.

Most of the people I know who home ed do it on much, much lower household incomes than we have.

So in my experience YABU.

lunaloveroo · 28/04/2023 20:04

I don't think that the majority of children who are homeschooled are privileged. I think there are many different reasons. I've met lots of children through work who are homeschooled and it's mostly due to schools not meeting their needs. These families are usually on their knees.

The rich ones who homeschool probably pay for private tuition and access to expensive activities. Then there are children whose parents make a lifestyle choice because they want an alternative to the education system, but usually aren't rich, just make sacrifices due to their way of life.

Easterbunnywashere · 28/04/2023 20:02

There are a huge variety of homeschoolers for a whole spectrum of reasons. I was largely home educated myself due to sickness as a child but went on to gain an BSc, MSc and PhD. Homeschooled kids are far from illiterate!

I homeschooled my own DCs, one due to SEN and the other because they were gifted and not being stretched at school. Both did better being HS than they ever would have done at the local school.

I have also been an HS teacher myself and taught a lot of different children. Some have never been to school, others found it didn't work for them, and then there is the private school crowd who use state primary, then homeschool from 11 to cram for private scholarship places at 13. These HS children often do much better than their contemporaries from either state or private preps because the one-to-one time puts them ahead academically. The money saved on private fees pays for tutors and they gain in the long-run from scholarship places.

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 20:00

Only one of the home educators that I knew at the time, I meant.

PadPad · 28/04/2023 19:58

Homeschooling, after school tuition, music lessons, elite sports coaching, high level musical theatre etc

Pretty much all of these require serious man hours, dedication and cash from parents than can run into thousands per year.

Definitely not normally the kids with 2 siblings and whose mum is working nightshift and Dad is working 2 jobs to pay the rent.

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 19:56

homeeddingwitch · 28/04/2023 19:52

I’ve home educated for years and know loads of other home educators and know no-one who has ever had any contact with SS.
The LA contact you each year though for a summary of what you’re doing.

I contacted the LA myself with ds. A really nice man came round once a year to the house (I know you don’t have to do that but I did), looked at ds work - he had no choice, ds would thrust projects at him, have a cup of tea and would then bugger off again for 12 months.

I was the only one in all the home educators to engage with the LA, but I pick my battles and for the sake of half an hour and a cup of tea every 12 months, that was one battle I couldn’t be arsed with.

Plus, like I said, I was covering all bases as I knew we would be reported to SS by family.

homeeddingwitch · 28/04/2023 19:52

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 19:47

It’s another reason why I don’t think I can do it again with my youngest. No matter if SS just call you for a chat and say they won’t be taking it further, it still causes huge amounts of stress and worry.

I’ve home educated for years and know loads of other home educators and know no-one who has ever had any contact with SS.
The LA contact you each year though for a summary of what you’re doing.

curious79 · 28/04/2023 19:47

I know two homeschoolers. One has a daughter who is suffering extreme anxiety and social issues. The other has a daughter with SEN issues. It wouldn't be their choice otherwise

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 19:47

Thesearmsofmine · 28/04/2023 19:41

Yes this happened to a friend of mine. It was her neighbours who reported her. I’ve read about schools doing it too when a parent deregisters even when they have no previous concerns about a child.

It’s another reason why I don’t think I can do it again with my youngest. No matter if SS just call you for a chat and say they won’t be taking it further, it still causes huge amounts of stress and worry.

Noteification · 28/04/2023 19:43

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 18:59

Me neither.

But that doesn’t go down well on MN. I’ve been ripped apart on here for chosing to be a stay at home mother. It’s my choice and me and my family are all happy. But i’m constantly told dh will leave me, I’ll be left destitute in old age.

It’s always so negative.

It is so depressing.
I wish it were respected and valued. It really is an important role. I don't know why it is undervalued and disrespected

homeeddingwitch · 28/04/2023 19:41

HettyMeg · 28/04/2023 19:25

Personally the only situation I see homeschooling working is if the child has sensory or other issues that means the parent feels they are incompatible with mainstream school. Otherwise how will they learn to interact with others? Private school can be little better though, I went to uni with a girl who had gone to an all girls school and had never spoken to a boy other than her cousin at the age of 18...

That’s the only situation you see home ed working? I’m astounded by your naivety. What do you think we do all day?!

Thesearmsofmine · 28/04/2023 19:41

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 19:36

repeted to SS twice by the same person who just didn’t believe in home ed. SS just called both times and that was it, we were registered with the LA and they visited once a year. I did that to cover my back as I knew certain family members would report us.

SS didn’t even contact the LA in the end, they were satisfied it was malicious.

Yes this happened to a friend of mine. It was her neighbours who reported her. I’ve read about schools doing it too when a parent deregisters even when they have no previous concerns about a child.

homeeddingwitch · 28/04/2023 19:39

Minimalme · 28/04/2023 19:16

I don't judge either. However, I don't have concerns about a privately educated child, whereas I do about some home educated children.

One example is a child who dropped out of school due to MH reasons. Rather than work to get her back in, the parents have basically allowed the child to stay at home while they go out to work. No homeschooling happening and child loosing any peer context and development.

In contrast, my youngest ds started school refusing after Covid. We moved him to a new school and dh literally carried him in and kept doing it until he gave in.

Wow.

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 19:38

HettyMeg · 28/04/2023 19:25

Personally the only situation I see homeschooling working is if the child has sensory or other issues that means the parent feels they are incompatible with mainstream school. Otherwise how will they learn to interact with others? Private school can be little better though, I went to uni with a girl who had gone to an all girls school and had never spoken to a boy other than her cousin at the age of 18...

That is such a blinkered view. Do your children only speak to other children at school?

homeeddingwitch · 28/04/2023 19:37

What a naive assumption!
And how easy it is to slap the word privileged’ on a whole diverse group of people.
I home educate my DC and I can tell you that having met a HUGE amount of home ed families over the last few years, that financially privileged is not something you would say about them IF you had met them.
The vast majority are making it work in extremely creative ways. Many are single parents, many have SEN kids who have been spectacularly failed by the education system, many work two jobs to get by, some work evenings to be with their kids in the day, some sacrifice being on the property ladder and rent tiny homes to get by, lots don’t even own a car just as examples.

I’m tired of justifying my education choices to the world, I’m tired of being called a ‘crusty’ because I chose a different path to the mainstream. And since when did being a hippy or being crusty equate to being privileged?!

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 19:36

repeted to SS twice by the same person who just didn’t believe in home ed. SS just called both times and that was it, we were registered with the LA and they visited once a year. I did that to cover my back as I knew certain family members would report us.

SS didn’t even contact the LA in the end, they were satisfied it was malicious.

Noteification · 28/04/2023 19:34

HettyMeg · 28/04/2023 19:25

Personally the only situation I see homeschooling working is if the child has sensory or other issues that means the parent feels they are incompatible with mainstream school. Otherwise how will they learn to interact with others? Private school can be little better though, I went to uni with a girl who had gone to an all girls school and had never spoken to a boy other than her cousin at the age of 18...

Mine interacts with others every other month for 20 minutes when we go to do our bulk shop of freeze dried caviar. We do our home ed meets there, boys and girls, they all dress in their finest for the outing, it is great. Kids often walk back to the car together and sometimes will exchange a peanut for a casew amongst themselves.. Amazing interactions, though if one child gets the yoghurt crystallised ginger there's no interactions there, can't blame 'em.

ChristineCricket · 28/04/2023 19:34

HettyMeg · 28/04/2023 19:25

Personally the only situation I see homeschooling working is if the child has sensory or other issues that means the parent feels they are incompatible with mainstream school. Otherwise how will they learn to interact with others? Private school can be little better though, I went to uni with a girl who had gone to an all girls school and had never spoken to a boy other than her cousin at the age of 18...

I don’t home school but I’m offended on their behalf. Most home schooler make a lot of effort to mix, go to groups etc.

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 19:34

Thesearmsofmine · 28/04/2023 19:19

I home ed through choice.
We aren’t wealthy at all and even if I was working FT we wouldn’t be able to afford private school fees(let alone the other expenses that come along with that). As for sacrifices, we live in a cheap area and don’t have holidays abroad, for some that might be a huge sacrifice but tbh it doesn’t feel like one to me.

As for judgement, people often judge home educators harshly. It’s not uncommon to be reported to SS, nobody is going to report you to SS for sending dc to private school.
Also you have strangers who will randomly ask your children maths questions in an attempt to test them or simply make assumptions about you and your family, depending on the person it is they will assume that you are antivax/hippy/lazy/vegan/that you hated school/that you don’t discipline your kids/that you hot house your kids/that your kids will be illiterate and on and on.

Ah yes, the performing monkey thing.

Ds was very often quizzed by family and friends. Quite randomly. “Can you read this?” “What is 4x8?” while sitting at lunch.

He ended up playing dumb in the end and telling them he couldn’t read. Or if they wrote down a maths question he would say, “mum, what are these funny squiggles, I don’t know what they are!”

He was as jaded as me by it all by the time he was 8.

And we were reported to SS twice.

Dibblydoodahdah · 28/04/2023 19:33

@HettyMeg not all private schools are single sex and not all state schools are co-ed.

HettyMeg · 28/04/2023 19:25

Personally the only situation I see homeschooling working is if the child has sensory or other issues that means the parent feels they are incompatible with mainstream school. Otherwise how will they learn to interact with others? Private school can be little better though, I went to uni with a girl who had gone to an all girls school and had never spoken to a boy other than her cousin at the age of 18...

Thesearmsofmine · 28/04/2023 19:19

I home ed through choice.
We aren’t wealthy at all and even if I was working FT we wouldn’t be able to afford private school fees(let alone the other expenses that come along with that). As for sacrifices, we live in a cheap area and don’t have holidays abroad, for some that might be a huge sacrifice but tbh it doesn’t feel like one to me.

As for judgement, people often judge home educators harshly. It’s not uncommon to be reported to SS, nobody is going to report you to SS for sending dc to private school.
Also you have strangers who will randomly ask your children maths questions in an attempt to test them or simply make assumptions about you and your family, depending on the person it is they will assume that you are antivax/hippy/lazy/vegan/that you hated school/that you don’t discipline your kids/that you hot house your kids/that your kids will be illiterate and on and on.

Minimalme · 28/04/2023 19:16

I don't judge either. However, I don't have concerns about a privately educated child, whereas I do about some home educated children.

One example is a child who dropped out of school due to MH reasons. Rather than work to get her back in, the parents have basically allowed the child to stay at home while they go out to work. No homeschooling happening and child loosing any peer context and development.

In contrast, my youngest ds started school refusing after Covid. We moved him to a new school and dh literally carried him in and kept doing it until he gave in.

ChristineCricket · 28/04/2023 19:06

I’m a stay at home mum, but don’t get any benefits. I thinks it’s fine to make that choice if you can afford it.

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 18:59

Noteification · 28/04/2023 18:52

No, stay at home mothers have been undervalued and negatively judged for a long time. But now the government really have declared war on them.
Being a stay at home mother should be a respected and valid choice for women. The household hours match, why does it matter who is earning them? All that matters is that mothers aren't home with their children, seemingly. I can't think of another explanation.

Me neither.

But that doesn’t go down well on MN. I’ve been ripped apart on here for chosing to be a stay at home mother. It’s my choice and me and my family are all happy. But i’m constantly told dh will leave me, I’ll be left destitute in old age.

It’s always so negative.