Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that home schooling is as much for the privileged as private school?

184 replies

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:14

I see a lot of private school bashing on here, which I guess is fair enough, as it's something that benefits a tiny minority and seems to be something a lot of wanky politicians do. Not so much home schooling, though, which to me is also a thing that only 'rich' people can access. Private school is seen as for toffs, right wing, bad, whereas home schooling is seen as radical, left wing, and generally not judged as much? AIBU that both options are reserved for the highly privileged who can afford to do such things / make huge sacrifices for a radical alternative option to state schooling?

OP posts:
homeeddingwitch · 28/04/2023 23:26

daretodenim · 28/04/2023 22:26

The people who take their kids out of school because they're not adequately supported, have my full support. It's a failure that these kids are in such a situation.

But the smug homeschoolers, who post sun-dappled photos of their little 6 year old cherub (singular - that's important) learning Mandarin, Arabic AND French in private classes on their Insta/blog with some comment about how schooling deprives children of the opportunity to learn properly and teachers aren't as good as they/their tutors are just pisses me off. I've unfollowed people because of this. There's usually also comments dotted in about how great a parent they are, because they prioritise their child's education. The implication that working parents don't rings clear.

They have trips to museums and galleries and the whole shabang. And as such, they're usually based on a major city (London included).

There are also comments about how much they sacrifice to provide their child with the best, how they can't afford holidays, but that's ok, because they care about their child more.

They do not seem to get the inherent privilege of being able to live in London, afford for one parent to not work/barely work or both work part time, pat for private tutors and pay for all the many excursions. PLUS the amount of time available to invest in preparing/sourcing worksheets that are "suitable" (no twinkl), making learning materials etc. who the hell has time for all that?

I think it's quite telling that this type of hone schooler always has one child. Once you have children with multiple interests and competing schedules, you don't have time to make "Waldorf-esque" special materials.

This group of kids is being hothoused as much as in any private school, it's just in a more individualised manner.

And then, after a few years of one on one private tuition we're told that their child is far more intelligent - they're "gifted" - than their peers. No, they're not. They've just had private tutors and pushy parents who've made it their life's work to demonstrate how special their child is. All the rest of us can't understand and/or are jealous, because we've not got such a special child and we've dumped our kids at the learning factory school, because we don't care about them as much as they care about theirs.

I wish I was making this up.

The majority of homeschoolers these days don't appear to be like this. But I think this little group are relevant to OP's OP.

Like I said, Unfollowed!

I love it when a generalization is made about an entire group of people based on one person’s Instagram account.
I do not recognise this person at all and according to nearly every comment on this thread nor does anyone else…

HazeyjaneIII · 28/04/2023 22:37

I don't know...the only families I know who homeschool, do so because their child has been so utterly failed by the education system, that they have no choice.
They have all had to make huge sacrifices and struggle to make ends meet, but have done so to provide the best education they can for their children.
It doesn't seem like much of a privileged position to me.

daretodenim · 28/04/2023 22:26

The people who take their kids out of school because they're not adequately supported, have my full support. It's a failure that these kids are in such a situation.

But the smug homeschoolers, who post sun-dappled photos of their little 6 year old cherub (singular - that's important) learning Mandarin, Arabic AND French in private classes on their Insta/blog with some comment about how schooling deprives children of the opportunity to learn properly and teachers aren't as good as they/their tutors are just pisses me off. I've unfollowed people because of this. There's usually also comments dotted in about how great a parent they are, because they prioritise their child's education. The implication that working parents don't rings clear.

They have trips to museums and galleries and the whole shabang. And as such, they're usually based on a major city (London included).

There are also comments about how much they sacrifice to provide their child with the best, how they can't afford holidays, but that's ok, because they care about their child more.

They do not seem to get the inherent privilege of being able to live in London, afford for one parent to not work/barely work or both work part time, pat for private tutors and pay for all the many excursions. PLUS the amount of time available to invest in preparing/sourcing worksheets that are "suitable" (no twinkl), making learning materials etc. who the hell has time for all that?

I think it's quite telling that this type of hone schooler always has one child. Once you have children with multiple interests and competing schedules, you don't have time to make "Waldorf-esque" special materials.

This group of kids is being hothoused as much as in any private school, it's just in a more individualised manner.

And then, after a few years of one on one private tuition we're told that their child is far more intelligent - they're "gifted" - than their peers. No, they're not. They've just had private tutors and pushy parents who've made it their life's work to demonstrate how special their child is. All the rest of us can't understand and/or are jealous, because we've not got such a special child and we've dumped our kids at the learning factory school, because we don't care about them as much as they care about theirs.

I wish I was making this up.

The majority of homeschoolers these days don't appear to be like this. But I think this little group are relevant to OP's OP.

Like I said, Unfollowed!

SenseiOfDuty · 28/04/2023 22:19

It's a privilege to have a child that can access education. My DC1 wouldn't survive in school, even specialist.

I've no pension, no savings, and I rely on handouts from my parents. The LA Ed Psych and the SEN Advice Charity in the region both agree home ed is best for DC1.

I buy my clothes from supermarkets and charity shops. Don't have a passport, don't have a career any more.

But DC1 is happy. Which is important really, isn't it. They aren't being destroyed and they're learning to regulate themselves.

eduwot · 28/04/2023 22:11

That might be the case for some, but when your child doesn't fit in mainstream school and there isn't a specialist school place available that will meet their needs, you don't have an option. There are many, many children who are home ed in this position. I feel irritated that people believe it is a privilege. You don't have a bloody clue. Try surviving on a single income, or attempting to work and home school your child/children. Such a fucking privilege.

FlyingPandas · 28/04/2023 22:05

I know various families who have home educated - almost all have DC who could either not cope in school due to SEN, or have medical issues that could not be managed in school. All of them say that no-one would choose to home educate a child if there was any other realistic choice and that it is unbelievably, grindingly, soul-crushingly hard. I don't think the majority of home educators or children who are home educated are privileged in the slightest.

ZenNudist · 28/04/2023 21:59

Inmyonesie · 28/04/2023 11:21

I’m my experience many who choose to home school do so out of desperation. School can be very traumatic for kids and it becomes the only option. Certainly was in my case. So no, it is not always for the privileged, but for the desperate.

I've known the middle class SAHM crowd who homeschool their dc with fabulous visits to museums and with travel and forest school and lots of paid for activities and groups of likeminded wealthy mums. That's your private school equivalent and their dc have switched into private school off the back of homeschooling.

I've also known those who take their dc out of school due to SEN and bullying and with no alternative home school usually without the fabulous activities that you need money for and with less of a home school network as the middle class groups are hostile. It's definitely desperation that's driving it.

People usually see happier children as a result and that's seen as worth it. My friends in this position traded giving up on academic attainment and switching to something vocational at early secondary level.

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 21:55

LindorDoubleChoc · 28/04/2023 21:27

"I think home schooled kids do better in general, from what I've seen".

What do you mean by this OP ^?

I've never met a home schooled child or home schooling family so I'm completely ignorant on the subject. Is there general evidence anywhere to say they "do better"?

There was a thread yesterday about the school strikes where people were sharing just how bad things were in school.

No continuity of teachers, no TAs, huge class sizes, classrooms being more like crowd control than teaching.

Its easy to see how a lot of home educated children do better when they are usually one on one.

Ds is still in touch with his home educated friends from childhood. The ones who stayed home educated until 16 did so much “better” academically than the few like ds who went to school. I know that’s anecdotal, but it’s something you hear a lot.

They also had so much more time to indulge their passions in music, sport, volunteering etc.

When ds went to school at 10, a lot of things he loved fell to the wayside as there just didn’t seem to be the time anymore. I know children in school do music, sports etc. But home education gives so much more flexibility for timings, lessons and practice, travelling to competitions.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 28/04/2023 21:53

Inmyonesie · 28/04/2023 11:21

I’m my experience many who choose to home school do so out of desperation. School can be very traumatic for kids and it becomes the only option. Certainly was in my case. So no, it is not always for the privileged, but for the desperate.

Was about to say exactly this.
The parents I know who have gone onto 'home school' have done so because they had no option due to their child's needs being unable to be met through state education (Inc mainstream AND send Schools)

Equalitea · 28/04/2023 21:50

LindorDoubleChoc · 28/04/2023 21:27

"I think home schooled kids do better in general, from what I've seen".

What do you mean by this OP ^?

I've never met a home schooled child or home schooling family so I'm completely ignorant on the subject. Is there general evidence anywhere to say they "do better"?

I’m so surprised by this, that you don’t know any, I know quite a few home schoolers.

I’ve never heard that they do better.

I did my alevels 20+ years ago with a girl who was home schooled, I often wonder what she is upto now!

Equalitea · 28/04/2023 21:48

I know quite a few parents who home school (one of my children went to a special school) and I would say that the vast majority are on benefits. At or not much above the poverty line.

Beezknees · 28/04/2023 21:46

YANBU. I'm a single mum working full time, I need to work to pay bills so wouldn't have the time to home school. I'm not clever enough either, I didn't do well at school myself and did not do A levels or a degree.

LindorDoubleChoc · 28/04/2023 21:27

"I think home schooled kids do better in general, from what I've seen".

What do you mean by this OP ^?

I've never met a home schooled child or home schooling family so I'm completely ignorant on the subject. Is there general evidence anywhere to say they "do better"?

depre · 28/04/2023 21:11

The privilege for us would be if there was a school that was suitable for DD.

Doobydoo · 28/04/2023 20:53

We home ed. Our eldest chose to go to secondary. Our 2nd left primary at 7 and is now 16 and never wanted to return to school. One of us has worked the other been at home. It has been tough financially. We home edded for many reasons,none of them because our children have extra needs that weren't being met.I have met many many home edders who do so for many different reasons and have different approaches and finances.

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 20:47

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 28/04/2023 20:31

You have every right to make your choice of schooling for your children but your attitude to those who make other choices is staggeringly judgmental. You do not know and should not assume you do, what motivates people. How much have you investigated home schooling? Or do you simply believe that anyone who doesn’t think like you is wrong? Oh dear.

Is this aimed at me? I think what motivates people is that they want to do the best for their children, and that they make the best choices based on the resources they have available.

I think home schooled kids do better in general, from what I've seen, and I've also heard lovely things about a local private school from the teachers there who have kids the same age as mine. I'd love to choose either home school or private school for my DS who is struggling with peers / bullying / large classes but I can't sacrifice my career for home school and we don't have the income for private.

My OP was about how it seems to me that HS and PS both are for the privileged, and that the extent of that privilege is either the possibility for families to survive on one income or, in the case of PS, to basically spend the whole of one decent wage a year on the fees. Seems like if you had enough money to choose PS (but not silly amounts) then the lifestyles in terms of disposable income would be the same?

I know lots of home school families and only one private school one, and she's a teacher, but here on MN private schools are bashed a lot. It occurred to me that you could have 2 families with the same income, one sending kid to private school with both parents working, and one home schooling with one parent not working, and they could be exactly the same in terms of privilege.

I'm talking privilege like, being able to buy a house, have a degree, have children at all, drive a car, etc. Not huge mansion / inheritance.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 28/04/2023 20:37

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:37

I think I meant privileged because you'd need to be able to afford to give up work and potential career advancement, pension contributions etc, as well as pay for things, activities, extra tutoring etc. I don't judge home school people I envy them. I suppose I also envy private school people if I'm honest about it

Lots of families survive on one salary. One half because the working parent earns so much they don't need to work, and one side because the non working parent can't out-earn childcare costs.

Al the people I know who home school absolutely couldn't afford private, make sacrifices to have one parent at home and are doing so out of desperation.

Mammalamma · 28/04/2023 20:37

PadPad · 28/04/2023 19:58

Homeschooling, after school tuition, music lessons, elite sports coaching, high level musical theatre etc

Pretty much all of these require serious man hours, dedication and cash from parents than can run into thousands per year.

Definitely not normally the kids with 2 siblings and whose mum is working nightshift and Dad is working 2 jobs to pay the rent.

We home educate, have never been wealthy, both work full time and, whilst it does need dedication and a lot of time, it doesn’t necessarily cost as much as you seem to think it does.

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 20:33

Cuboidapple · 28/04/2023 20:26

Yes we found the same although admitting to the other home educators I knew at the time that I allowed a home visit and have work samples meant we became outcasts in the groups and ended up no longer attending such was the bad atmosphere. Apparently those who let the LA in or have work samples then make it harder for the other home educators who know their rights and the limits the LA have ..

I had the same experience. I soon learned to keep my mouth shut about it after I was told I was making it harder for everyone else.

The LA weren’t the boogeymen that the other home educators I met feared. Cup of tea, a chat, literally ticking some boxes on a sheet of paper, and then that was it.

The man who used to visit us was always very enthusiastic about the work ds showed him and asked him questions about it. It was fine.

Mammalamma · 28/04/2023 20:32

HettyMeg · 28/04/2023 19:25

Personally the only situation I see homeschooling working is if the child has sensory or other issues that means the parent feels they are incompatible with mainstream school. Otherwise how will they learn to interact with others? Private school can be little better though, I went to uni with a girl who had gone to an all girls school and had never spoken to a boy other than her cousin at the age of 18...

Do your children only interact with others at school? Of course not! Just because a child doesn’t attend school it doesn’t mean they will suddenly become a recluse, devoid of all socialisation opportunities 🙄

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 28/04/2023 20:31

You have every right to make your choice of schooling for your children but your attitude to those who make other choices is staggeringly judgmental. You do not know and should not assume you do, what motivates people. How much have you investigated home schooling? Or do you simply believe that anyone who doesn’t think like you is wrong? Oh dear.

katyperryseyelid · 28/04/2023 20:29

Stuf · 28/04/2023 20:19

I found the LA home Ed point of contact to be supportive and experienced.

Yes, the guy who used to come to see us was good.

In fact, when we were moving across the country and ds was going to try school he was super helpful with that too and gave me loads of really good advice.

Cuboidapple · 28/04/2023 20:26

Stuf · 28/04/2023 20:19

I found the LA home Ed point of contact to be supportive and experienced.

Yes we found the same although admitting to the other home educators I knew at the time that I allowed a home visit and have work samples meant we became outcasts in the groups and ended up no longer attending such was the bad atmosphere. Apparently those who let the LA in or have work samples then make it harder for the other home educators who know their rights and the limits the LA have ..

Stuf · 28/04/2023 20:19

I found the LA home Ed point of contact to be supportive and experienced.

Stuf · 28/04/2023 20:15

The fee paying schools near me are 14k plus per annum per child. We couldn’t afford this.

Home Ed for one child costs us £200 in activities/classes/memberships a month term time, so about 2k per annum. We forgo lots of things to cover the cost of home educating but at the same time understand we are privileged to be able to do this. We are also lucky to have grandparents and home educators and opportunities close by. We felt we had no choice as school wasn’t meeting his needs and my son was deeply unhappy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread