Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that home schooling is as much for the privileged as private school?

184 replies

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:14

I see a lot of private school bashing on here, which I guess is fair enough, as it's something that benefits a tiny minority and seems to be something a lot of wanky politicians do. Not so much home schooling, though, which to me is also a thing that only 'rich' people can access. Private school is seen as for toffs, right wing, bad, whereas home schooling is seen as radical, left wing, and generally not judged as much? AIBU that both options are reserved for the highly privileged who can afford to do such things / make huge sacrifices for a radical alternative option to state schooling?

OP posts:
GroovyHedgehog · 30/04/2023 09:36

My friend home schools her two children. She didn't enjoy school herself as a child and so made the decision from the day they were born that she would home educate them.
I can't see what value she is adding to their lives at all. Being kept at home because mum didn't get on with the world and struggled to make friendships and forge a career.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 30/04/2023 08:52

Home education is perhaps a first choice for some, but definitely a desperate final destination for most. And yes, it can definitely be crushingly hard, depending on why one's DC is not able to access mainstream schooling.
I've a DC who is teetering on the brink of not being able to access mainstream education as they get older and acadrmic expectations increase.
It's like watching a slow motion car crash unfold, with a mixture of SEN, sup-par SEN support due to lack of funding and the impact of an unforeseen life event taking a huge toll on MH.
Working in education, I am in a good place to advocate for DC, and I have a positive relationship with agencies involved, but it is hard. I spend hours every week in correspondence with school, LA and external agencies and providers, filling in forms, engaging with plans, contributing to reviews, weekly updates, meetings, providing parent voice statements on repeat, just to keep DC in school, because despite how hard it is for them, they love many aspects of going to school and desperately want to remain in the system. SEN diagnosis makes accessing classroom based learning at ARE nigh on impossible though.
I would not wish this on anyone.
If DC crashes out of mainstream education, it'll be down to me to give up work to home educate, despite me earning more, as DP doesn't have the skills set. It's something I am very scared of at the moment and am basing some serious work-related contingency planning around.

homeeddingwitch · 29/04/2023 18:59

HalloweenGhost · 29/04/2023 11:29

I think if people would just not judge others full stop the world would be a nicer place.

Homeschoolers are not rich. They home school because they think it's better for their child. Many are teachers by profession, many are not.

It frustrates me how everything is a race to the bottom.

Couldn’t agree more. It’s so easy to slap a ‘privileged’ label on others without actually knowing anything about them at all.
So many assumptions.
And yes it sometimes feels, especially on here, that it’s a race to the bottom.

Equalitea · 29/04/2023 16:36

FatGirlSwim · 29/04/2023 10:16

EOTAS is totally cut in most areas due to funding issues. LA should provide it but they don’t.

It is a fight to access and usually crap.

I know a few people who have good EOTAS packages, however it has meant a fight of a few years via tribunals. I don’t think any LA have ever given them willingly.

Sceptre86 · 29/04/2023 13:13

Not every child fits the school mould. Quieter kids are often ignored in favour of the louder or more challenging children Without TAs teachers cannot give 30 kids equal or even adequate attention. Often homeschooling is a last resort ad a result of a child being failed. There are parents who decide on it from the get go and from that point of view perhaps they are privileged. In that they can live off one salary.

Homeschooling set ups really do vary some people go for a similar length of day to school whereas others may be more child led etc. It just varies. I wouldn't bash someone for homeschooling rather I think they know their kid better than I do.

I'd consider it.

FatGirlSwim · 29/04/2023 11:50

I don’t think home Ed is ‘soul crushingly hard’ - I find it easier than school. It isn’t easy either. There are pros and cons to both, no option is perfect. In my experience.

I definitely don’t agree that ‘nobody would home educate by choice’ though.

Wellfedandfedup · 29/04/2023 11:37

What I mean, is that it's still considered normal

Wellfedandfedup · 29/04/2023 11:37

YABU. Home education, ime, is judged more than independent school. It maybe for the privileged but it's still school.

HalloweenGhost · 29/04/2023 11:29

I think if people would just not judge others full stop the world would be a nicer place.

Homeschoolers are not rich. They home school because they think it's better for their child. Many are teachers by profession, many are not.

It frustrates me how everything is a race to the bottom.

depre · 29/04/2023 11:08

Our home ed isn't curriculum based and we are not aiming for exams, just better mental health. We haven't done yoga or chemtrails yet but great ideas Smile

JazbayGrapes · 29/04/2023 11:05

I know someone who homeschools and they are the stereotypical hippie/vegan type. (They also don't vaccinate and homeschool probably consists of learning about yoga and chemtrails.) I understand that it's not always like this.

And what are hippies, vegans and antivaxxers supposed to do?

FatGirlSwim · 29/04/2023 11:03

I prefer home Ed over EOTAS for us, as it puts my child in control and enables them to learn in the way that suits them. EOTAS isn’t something I’d want although it would mean not paying for exam entry etc.

EOTAS also wouldn’t solve the problem of my work. But neither does school, for us.

FatGirlSwim · 29/04/2023 11:00

lifeturnsonadime · 29/04/2023 10:23

It really shouldn't be crap.

It should provide funding for everything your child needs for a full time education to meet their age and ability if you can demonstrate that no school can meet need and the education should take place 'other than in school'.

If you are prepared to fight , all the way to tribunal if necessary, lack of funding is NOT a reason for an LA to refuse provision although they will almost always cite this as a reason not to make it in the first place.

A lot of people give up because fighting that, on top of having a SEN child is very difficult and the outlay for private reports that are sometimes needed can put it out of reach.

But it does exist.

I know.

Unfortunately when parents fight they can be accused of exaggerating their child’s needs. It can lead to FII allegations and so parents are scared.

Also, it shouldn’t be crap. But it usually is.

Createausername1970 · 29/04/2023 10:52

HettyMeg · 28/04/2023 19:25

Personally the only situation I see homeschooling working is if the child has sensory or other issues that means the parent feels they are incompatible with mainstream school. Otherwise how will they learn to interact with others? Private school can be little better though, I went to uni with a girl who had gone to an all girls school and had never spoken to a boy other than her cousin at the age of 18...

Personally, I think you don't know what you are talking about and spouting nonsense you have picked up along the way from others who also don't know what they are talking about.

My DS had much more positive and rewarding social interactions when he was homeschooled. They were shorter and more manageable and consisted of positive interactions with people he wanted to see and who wanted to see him. Being forced to spend most of your time with others, for no other reason than they happen to have been born in the same year as you, doesn't always make for a happy existence. And that applies whether you are SEN or not. Positive social interactions can take place anywhere and everywhere, not just in a school playground.

I feel blessed to have home schooled DS. It was a truly happy time and he benefited immensely.

lifeturnsonadime · 29/04/2023 10:23

FatGirlSwim · 29/04/2023 10:16

EOTAS is totally cut in most areas due to funding issues. LA should provide it but they don’t.

It is a fight to access and usually crap.

It really shouldn't be crap.

It should provide funding for everything your child needs for a full time education to meet their age and ability if you can demonstrate that no school can meet need and the education should take place 'other than in school'.

If you are prepared to fight , all the way to tribunal if necessary, lack of funding is NOT a reason for an LA to refuse provision although they will almost always cite this as a reason not to make it in the first place.

A lot of people give up because fighting that, on top of having a SEN child is very difficult and the outlay for private reports that are sometimes needed can put it out of reach.

But it does exist.

FatGirlSwim · 29/04/2023 10:16

Equalitea · 29/04/2023 06:07

Have you thought about EOTAS?

EOTAS is totally cut in most areas due to funding issues. LA should provide it but they don’t.

It is a fight to access and usually crap.

Cuboidapple · 29/04/2023 09:38

lifeturnsonadime · 29/04/2023 09:33

I echo the sentiment of several posters upthread.

For many who are home educating, to be able to have a suitable school place would be the privilege.

The right to education is a human right, that so many SEN and disabled children are forced into education at home is a national disgrace.

And then with UC making stupid rules to take choice away it makes the situation even worse 😞
Total household hours worked shouldn’t have to be split if it doesn’t suit family circumstances and one parent is needed at home

lifeturnsonadime · 29/04/2023 09:33

I echo the sentiment of several posters upthread.

For many who are home educating, to be able to have a suitable school place would be the privilege.

The right to education is a human right, that so many SEN and disabled children are forced into education at home is a national disgrace.

happyumwelt · 29/04/2023 07:19

My dd is doing significantly better academically now she is home educated - she was so anxious at school and put so much energy into masking (she is autistic - diagnosed shortly after leaving school in year 7) that she struggled to focus on her work. Now, at 13, she is working at GCSE level in all the subjects she has continued with. And that is just the academic side of things - the bottom line is that she is much more content, confident, relaxed and no longer self harming and feeling suicidal.

She interacts with peers at three musical activities that she does each week and this is (more than) enough for her. A lot of fuss seems to be made about how a child not going to school means they miss out on developing vital social skills, but school is not a natural social environment and these skills develop through real world interactions. Additionally, autistic children are often on the fringes (or completely left out) of the social environment at school, which can cause enormous anxiety and distress and doesn't help them at all.

I think I may sound a little bit like the smug parents described above - although I would never broadcast my life on instagram - but home ed has been an incredibly positive step for our family. It is hard going at time - I can't really work and get very little time to myself - but it is worth it for much happier dc.

dottiedodah · 29/04/2023 06:59

Dd did music lessons at a Saturday school loved it

dottiedodah · 29/04/2023 06:58

Mrsleonferrell I could have written this! Altogether my dc are very different. Dd struggled and school was hard for her.she was much happier at home .ds was almost made for school,loved it !we are not privileged at all.i was a sahm for a while and it was hard as you say.problems started for us at secondary, big gap between dc .so could leave dd while collecting ds. Most people I know were also desperate for help .none forthcoming sadly from council for us either

Snugglemonkey · 29/04/2023 06:50

BeardieWeirdie · 28/04/2023 11:18

My child goes to state school. I don’t like the inequalities that private schools entrench but at least the parents using them value education. The crusties home-schooling/neglecting their kids, depriving them of opportunities on the basis that mummy didn’t like school very much 30 years ago - I absolutely judge!

I do not think this is fair. I would not homeschool, however I do have friends who do and they spend an enormous amount of resources on their children's education.

Three dc, all do climbing and swimming. One fences, one rides horses, one does ballet. They all play an instrument, learn Spanish and Chinese. The 12 year old does some kind of boating or yachting or smth. They are always trying stuff outdoors, they do seasonal things, skiing, snowboarding etc then switch to hiking, paddle boarding etc. It always sounds so adventurous.

Netcam · 29/04/2023 06:37

daretodenim · 28/04/2023 22:26

The people who take their kids out of school because they're not adequately supported, have my full support. It's a failure that these kids are in such a situation.

But the smug homeschoolers, who post sun-dappled photos of their little 6 year old cherub (singular - that's important) learning Mandarin, Arabic AND French in private classes on their Insta/blog with some comment about how schooling deprives children of the opportunity to learn properly and teachers aren't as good as they/their tutors are just pisses me off. I've unfollowed people because of this. There's usually also comments dotted in about how great a parent they are, because they prioritise their child's education. The implication that working parents don't rings clear.

They have trips to museums and galleries and the whole shabang. And as such, they're usually based on a major city (London included).

There are also comments about how much they sacrifice to provide their child with the best, how they can't afford holidays, but that's ok, because they care about their child more.

They do not seem to get the inherent privilege of being able to live in London, afford for one parent to not work/barely work or both work part time, pat for private tutors and pay for all the many excursions. PLUS the amount of time available to invest in preparing/sourcing worksheets that are "suitable" (no twinkl), making learning materials etc. who the hell has time for all that?

I think it's quite telling that this type of hone schooler always has one child. Once you have children with multiple interests and competing schedules, you don't have time to make "Waldorf-esque" special materials.

This group of kids is being hothoused as much as in any private school, it's just in a more individualised manner.

And then, after a few years of one on one private tuition we're told that their child is far more intelligent - they're "gifted" - than their peers. No, they're not. They've just had private tutors and pushy parents who've made it their life's work to demonstrate how special their child is. All the rest of us can't understand and/or are jealous, because we've not got such a special child and we've dumped our kids at the learning factory school, because we don't care about them as much as they care about theirs.

I wish I was making this up.

The majority of homeschoolers these days don't appear to be like this. But I think this little group are relevant to OP's OP.

Like I said, Unfollowed!

I have home educated for the past 16 years and met a large number of home Ed parents over the years. I have never met someone who resembles what you've described.

Yes, people do take their kids to (usually) free museums sometimes and occasionally use a tutor for a subject they need help with. But so do parents with kids in school.

DS1 did Mandarin GCSE, it was one of the hardest things in my life, we learned together with textbooks over many years and I found a local Chinese person to do an exchange with for language practice.

He has also found since going to 6th form that if anything he is the opposite of being hothoused, he has found he has very good self study skills which help with A level revision as he had to do all that on his own for GCSEs. We are not in London by the way.

Equalitea · 29/04/2023 06:11

PadPad · 28/04/2023 19:58

Homeschooling, after school tuition, music lessons, elite sports coaching, high level musical theatre etc

Pretty much all of these require serious man hours, dedication and cash from parents than can run into thousands per year.

Definitely not normally the kids with 2 siblings and whose mum is working nightshift and Dad is working 2 jobs to pay the rent.

Many of these families have to sacrifice a wage. Their standard of living reduces. Some have to move from mortgage to renting.

You are right though, it’s such a huge and massive commitment for some families to feel forced into!

Equalitea · 29/04/2023 06:07

SenseiOfDuty · 28/04/2023 22:19

It's a privilege to have a child that can access education. My DC1 wouldn't survive in school, even specialist.

I've no pension, no savings, and I rely on handouts from my parents. The LA Ed Psych and the SEN Advice Charity in the region both agree home ed is best for DC1.

I buy my clothes from supermarkets and charity shops. Don't have a passport, don't have a career any more.

But DC1 is happy. Which is important really, isn't it. They aren't being destroyed and they're learning to regulate themselves.

Have you thought about EOTAS?