Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that home schooling is as much for the privileged as private school?

184 replies

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:14

I see a lot of private school bashing on here, which I guess is fair enough, as it's something that benefits a tiny minority and seems to be something a lot of wanky politicians do. Not so much home schooling, though, which to me is also a thing that only 'rich' people can access. Private school is seen as for toffs, right wing, bad, whereas home schooling is seen as radical, left wing, and generally not judged as much? AIBU that both options are reserved for the highly privileged who can afford to do such things / make huge sacrifices for a radical alternative option to state schooling?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JazbayGrapes · 03/05/2023 16:57

My friend home schools her two children. She didn't enjoy school herself as a child and so made the decision from the day they were born that she would home educate them.
I can't see what value she is adding to their lives at all. Being kept at home because mum didn't get on with the world and struggled to make friendships and forge a career.

That's a very legit reason to home educate. Give your children a better life quality and opportunities you didn't have yourself.

EnaSharplesStout · 30/04/2023 23:08

Clarabell77 · 30/04/2023 11:47

@EnaSharplesStout

So sorry to read this about your son and I hope he is in a much better place now. I don’t think people understand the challenges some children have in attending mainstream school - I didn’t until my son started.

@Clarabell77 thank you. He is like a totally different child now. He has friends and he is making steady progress educationally.

mondaytosunday · 30/04/2023 22:23

I don't think of home schoolers like that. I know I could never do it - no patience!

pompomdaisy · 30/04/2023 22:05

My daughter is homeschooled. She had to be as she developed panic disorder. I'm sure ignorant ill informed people may look at us and judge.

If you're going to judge people then I'm happy to have that discussion with you. Otherwise shut the F U!

Citygirl007 · 30/04/2023 21:59

Ah yes, the £69 a week for 24/7 care is such a win, isn't it? 🙄

Huop · 30/04/2023 21:48

I've sacrificed a career to be a f/t carer to my SN child whose needs were not met in school. I can afford to home educate him only because we are claiming benefits due to his disability and me being his carer. That is absolutely not a privileged position to be in and anyone who thinks it is, is certainly welcome to try living in the pittance I receive for 24/7 caring - it is far below minimum wage. And anyone who complains about not having the choice to home ed because they are working full time - well they have the same "choice" I did, I handed in my resignation one day and that option is there for anyone else.

FatGirlSwim · 30/04/2023 21:43

groovyhedgehog has it occurred to you that school might have traumatised your friend and been the reason for her struggles?

FatGirlSwim · 30/04/2023 21:42

GroovyHedgehog · 30/04/2023 09:36

My friend home schools her two children. She didn't enjoy school herself as a child and so made the decision from the day they were born that she would home educate them.
I can't see what value she is adding to their lives at all. Being kept at home because mum didn't get on with the world and struggled to make friendships and forge a career.

Who needs enemies?

She may be giving her children the opportunity to learn and socialise in the way that suits them?

Citygirl007 · 30/04/2023 21:21

Hmmm, I'm probably able to answer your question well.
Prior to kids I was on 6 figure salary, husband about half of that.

Child 1 came along - clingy, scared of everything, very curious and bright. Diagnosed at 4 with ASD/ADHD/dyspraxia etc.
He was meant to go to prep school, who swiftly decided that actually they don't want him bc he is autistic. They returned deposit paid 3 years ago, all without seeing him.
He attended mainstream for a term, where he was barely in for 3 hours. Then he stoped going altogether. He disclosed recently he was abused there. I then went through 4 SEN tribunals over 2 years, winning all of them, yet LA failed to provide any education.
Eventually he had tutor for 10 hrs a week but after a while they took it away because it was expensive. 3 social service referrals completely malicious. It became clear they will bully us to home ed, whether we like it or not.
Age 9, child is indeed illiterate, but not fkr lack of trying. He won't do any activities or leave my side. It's 24/7 job, where husband and I escaped out together three times in 10 years, after the bedtime. And no, he won't stay with anyone, even with close family.

Child 2 started private school just as lockdown hit. He developed what we think was Long Covid, because for 2 years he was so tired he lasted 3 hours before needing a nap. School accomodated half day timetable for a term before making it clear he needs to be in full time. So, paid two teems of fees to exit school. He has luckily recovered back last summer and now does about 10 clubs a week, inc swimming, acting, french, scouts etc. He is ahead of math and also illiterate, because our behavioral optometrist thinks he is heavily dyslexic.

We didn't bother with school for child 3. He is very advanced academically (self taught, barely 5).
Struggles with understanding instructions, we think autistic/ADHD.

I can only tell you that home ed is a very very hard choice. Would I want to be sitting in my cosy office I had to give up? Absolutely.
Would I want to be able to afford house that I could have bought on my 6 figure salary? Totally.
Would I send them to prep school? Yes, it's totally worth it, if you have a 'normal' child. It doesn't compare with state at all. Would I send them to state? No, it's shitty, let's be honest. No one can effectively teach in classes of 30. Funding is rubbish.
also being a foreigner I find the attendance nonsense and school starting age quite ridiculous.
Am I privileged? I grew up with nothing on former Eastern Europe. Despite shitty education I did very well in my 20s/30s because of hard graft.
I just have to do what's best for our kids.

FloatingBean · 30/04/2023 15:30

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 30/04/2023 11:30

Ena Flowers
Starseeker, if one's DC is able to attend school, either in mainstream or in a specialist setting with an EHCP, that's great, and what many who have ended up home-schooling reluctantly giving up work and financial security would wish for their own DC more than anything. They can't afford to either, but it ceases to be a 'choice' and the cards fall where they may.

Rather than EHE have you looked at EOTAS? You might have to appeal, many do, but that way the LA remain responsible and parents cannot be compelled to facilitate or deliver the provision.

depre · 30/04/2023 14:57

Starseeking · 30/04/2023 10:40

As a full-time working single parent, the choice to homeschool my DC is not open to me, as I wouldn't be able to pay my bills if I stopped working.

Absolutely it's a privilege to be able to make the homeschooling choice for your DC, but not one I would judge.

There is nothing privileged about being on the bones of your arse waiting for the next benefit payment to hit the bank so you can afford to buy food. There is no choice involved.

Mammalamma · 30/04/2023 14:28

Starseeking · 30/04/2023 10:40

As a full-time working single parent, the choice to homeschool my DC is not open to me, as I wouldn't be able to pay my bills if I stopped working.

Absolutely it's a privilege to be able to make the homeschooling choice for your DC, but not one I would judge.

But often it’s not a choice, it’s a necessity. Parents either have to give up jobs, change work or change working hours. It ceases to be a choice when there is no other way. I’ve seen many parents give up their careers in order to home educate and they will take on evening work or work from home doing any job they can. They sure as hell wouldn’t see themselves privileged.
I would move heaven and earth for my kids just like any parent would. Sometimes you get stuck in such a desperate situation that you do whatever you can.

kitsuneghost · 30/04/2023 12:37

Depends what you mean by home school? There are different levels
Some privileged, some not so, some make sacrifices, some work really hard to make it work.

The workshy family that mistakes not sending their kids to school as homeschooling

The career couple that 1 gives up their job

The career couple that both WFH and do shifts teaching and working.

The high flyers that hire a private tutor.

PartyPartyYeah · 30/04/2023 11:57

I have 2 out of school because the system failed them, I hardly feel privileged that my neurodivergent children aren't able to access same opportunities!

Clarabell77 · 30/04/2023 11:47

@EnaSharplesStout

So sorry to read this about your son and I hope he is in a much better place now. I don’t think people understand the challenges some children have in attending mainstream school - I didn’t until my son started.

Clarabell77 · 30/04/2023 11:44

I would never have given home schooling a thought in terms of an alternative to state school (couldn’t afford private and don’t really believe in it in principle), however, it is something I’ve wondered about since my DS8 started school. He is autistic and just finishing his 3rd year in mainstream (we deferred entry) and it has been difficult. He finds the whole environment overwhelming, doesn’t sit in a group, has a desk on his own, is taken out regularly by an ASN assistant and has a quiet room if he needs it (I think he spends a lot of time in there). There have been a lot of incidents where we’ve been called and sometimes had to go to the school to speak to him or bring him home. The local authority have refused twice now to give him a specialist place, even though the school he’s currently and an educational psychologist supported it. I don’t think I could give up work completely but to home school we would probably both need to reduce our hours and potentially would need to downsize, and most definitely have to reduce our spending. It doesn’t need to be done in normal school hours and I could potentially get family to support it, as they already help with after school childcare, but I think it would be hard and it’s not something I’d particularly want to do. However, due to his circumstances it’s still not something I would rule out and we are definitely not a family who would or could go private.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 30/04/2023 11:30

Ena Flowers
Starseeker, if one's DC is able to attend school, either in mainstream or in a specialist setting with an EHCP, that's great, and what many who have ended up home-schooling reluctantly giving up work and financial security would wish for their own DC more than anything. They can't afford to either, but it ceases to be a 'choice' and the cards fall where they may.

EnaSharplesStout · 30/04/2023 11:12

HomeskoolorPrivate · 28/04/2023 11:37

I think I meant privileged because you'd need to be able to afford to give up work and potential career advancement, pension contributions etc, as well as pay for things, activities, extra tutoring etc. I don't judge home school people I envy them. I suppose I also envy private school people if I'm honest about it

I home Ed my son who has autism (pda), severe ADHD and dyslexia. He was totally failed by the school system.

I can’t ‘afford to give up pension contributions’- I’m just forced to because of the situation. I didn’t sit down and think ‘oh it’s ok, my wife earns enough money, I have a private pension etc’, - I gave up any future financial stability so my 7 year old wouldn’t work out any more ways to kill himself.

alyceflowers · 30/04/2023 11:04

Starseeking · 30/04/2023 11:00

I say that with having one DC who has an autism diagnosis, and attends a specialist school due to it.

I don't think either of my DC would appreciate us having nowhere to live as I'd start to edge towards bankruptcy after a year of no job, given that's the level of savings I have, and the bank currently owns the majority of my house (no benefits are paid by the government towards mortgages, I believe).

I don't have the privilege of choosing to homeschool, I couldn't, no matter the circumstances.

If your child couldn't attend school, you aren't allowed to just leave them alone when you go to work - so unfortunately it isn't always a choice.

You are lucky to have the privilege of a suitable school place for your child.

Piony · 30/04/2023 11:02

It's not a privilege if it's borne of desperation. If your child is suicidal and unable to leave the house, the choice to work full time - or indeed work at all for some - suddenly gets taken away. A parent who needed to work to pay the bills can overnight become one who's unable to work, even though the bills needed paying. That's not privilege.

If homeschooling were a lifestyle choice for all who made it, rather than the only option left for desperate families of unwell children, I'd agree with you.

Starseeking · 30/04/2023 11:00

I say that with having one DC who has an autism diagnosis, and attends a specialist school due to it.

I don't think either of my DC would appreciate us having nowhere to live as I'd start to edge towards bankruptcy after a year of no job, given that's the level of savings I have, and the bank currently owns the majority of my house (no benefits are paid by the government towards mortgages, I believe).

I don't have the privilege of choosing to homeschool, I couldn't, no matter the circumstances.

alyceflowers · 30/04/2023 10:51

Starseeking · 30/04/2023 10:40

As a full-time working single parent, the choice to homeschool my DC is not open to me, as I wouldn't be able to pay my bills if I stopped working.

Absolutely it's a privilege to be able to make the homeschooling choice for your DC, but not one I would judge.

You say that, but if your child couldn't go to school you wouldn't have a choice.

Starseeking · 30/04/2023 10:40

As a full-time working single parent, the choice to homeschool my DC is not open to me, as I wouldn't be able to pay my bills if I stopped working.

Absolutely it's a privilege to be able to make the homeschooling choice for your DC, but not one I would judge.

Cuboidapple · 30/04/2023 09:42

FatGirlSwim · 29/04/2023 11:00

I know.

Unfortunately when parents fight they can be accused of exaggerating their child’s needs. It can lead to FII allegations and so parents are scared.

Also, it shouldn’t be crap. But it usually is.

This happened to us. It was horrendous

SoShallINever · 30/04/2023 09:38

The quality of home schooling varies so much and can be as expensive or inexpensive as you like. I know one family where the mother gave up her medical career (GP) to ensure her DC's (SEN) needs were met at home. I'm guessing that cost well over £100k per year.
On the other hand I've met families that the state have given up on (parents in and out of prison, DC excluded from school after school) who are also trying to home school. I imagine the latter don't have high quality learning experiences.
I also know of families that have banded together to home ed on a shared basis so that one family teaches the first half of the week and the second family does the latter half. It allows them to earn a part time salary.