Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS Doctors refused evacuation from Sudan by British Government - DISGUSTING!

304 replies

Raggletagglegypsy · 28/04/2023 08:55

Shameful and shocking that NHS doctors should be turned away from evacuation flights from Sudan, simply because they have British residency, but are not British nationals. Just watching Newsnight on catchup and I was so enraged that I couldn't keep watching. I really hope that this matter has been put right since Newsnight aired yesterday. A medic who served the British people at Manchester Royal Infirmary through the pandemic was escorted out of the airport where he had arrived for evacuation, wanting to return to his work as a registrar. There are apparently over 20 doctors known to be in a similar position (having visited families for Eid - many with young children). The doctor who was interviewed described the situation as "disappointing" - I would use stronger vocabulary.
WE SHOULD ALL BE RAISING THIS WITH OUR MPs TODAY!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Camablanca · 28/04/2023 12:18

Theluggage15 · 28/04/2023 12:08

It’s all about feelingz these days. Actual facts seem beyond most media and public. Taking a job in the NHS because you don’t want to work in the country that trained you doesn’t make you special.

Even ChatGPT can do a better job than most 'journalists'. It's wrong half the time but they're no better. At least it isn't emotive

loislovesstewie · 28/04/2023 12:16

The government advice is also that it's still possible to get a ferry from Port Sudan but not to try to get to Egypt as the queues leaving are too long. I would suggest that chaos is likely to ensue shortly. If British nationals aren't out then people will complain about that.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 28/04/2023 12:10

You do understand OP that it's not up to Britain who they evacuate? The Sudanese have set terms as to who can be evacuated. Those with foreign passports (in Sudan). To break these terms would put the whole ceasefire and safe passage agreement in jeopardy. Sudanese nationals without travel documents are being blocked at checkpoints by the Sudanese army not turned away by british forces.

"I work for the NHS" surprisingly doesn't have as much meaning in Sudan than it seems to have in the UK.

Againstmachine · 28/04/2023 12:10

Theluggage15 · 28/04/2023 12:08

It’s all about feelingz these days. Actual facts seem beyond most media and public. Taking a job in the NHS because you don’t want to work in the country that trained you doesn’t make you special.

And seeing as Sudan is about to become a warzone wouldn't it make sense for these doctors to SERVE and help their family's and citizens of Sudan.

Theluggage15 · 28/04/2023 12:08

It’s all about feelingz these days. Actual facts seem beyond most media and public. Taking a job in the NHS because you don’t want to work in the country that trained you doesn’t make you special.

OrwellianTimes · 28/04/2023 12:06

TheOtherHotstepper · 28/04/2023 09:07

Good enough to work in our crumbling NHS, so presumably have clearance to work here, but not good enough to be rescued from a war zone.

Is this what we have become?

Yup ☹️

ScribblingPixie · 28/04/2023 12:04

Intergalacticcatharsis · 28/04/2023 11:58

I am all for free speech but what would be good is if there were a responsibility on journalists and publishers to actually have to state the law below these kind of emotive articles they publish.

Totally agree. I noticed on Twitter that a 'context' box was added under a BBC article (on a different subject) which gave readers the chance to add the facts. Great idea, and shaming for them that they need it.

Intergalacticcatharsis · 28/04/2023 11:58

I am all for free speech but what would be good is if there were a responsibility on journalists and publishers to actually have to state the law below these kind of emotive articles they publish.

Camablanca · 28/04/2023 11:43

PollyThePixie · 28/04/2023 11:33

So when people talk about someone serving in the military what does it mean in your world given they’re doing paid jobs.

That's a colloquial term specific to that job. Maybe from the days of 'military service' (related to conscription)? There are numerous other special words such as 'service record', 'service length' etc.

Similar terms are also used in the civil service (SERVICE), an umbrella for varied professions from HMRC top brass to driving instructors. They are 'employees of the Crown', but that's all.

What you are asking is the emotional loading of the term 'to serve', meaning that somebody deserves special consideration. Given that the dictionary definition of 'serve' is simply to carry out duties on behalf of another party.

To which my reply was I would extend said consideration to those who had gone out of their way, towards their own detriment. Giving the example of voluntary service.

Quveas · 28/04/2023 11:39

Raggletagglegypsy · 28/04/2023 10:55

@Againstmachine Actually, when it comes to this evacuation process, I think I would place someone with British residency, who normally lives and works here, above a Sudanese dual national, British passport-holder, who does not normally live and work in Britain.

At what point are you and others going to realise that your opinion is not only wrong but DANGEROUS. Under international law we have the right to be allowed to safe passage to evacuate our own citizens. Reciprocal agreements with other countries enable us to also lend aid and assistance to citizens of partner countries if we are able to do so. Sudan is not a member of any of those agreements. And even if it was we cannot remove a citizen of that country from that country with impunity. This person is a citizen of Sudan. And he has done himself no favours by going to the press because he has now highlighted the fact that there is an "ask" of the British government to remove citizens of Sudan from Sudan - something that paints a target on our troops and planes if the people armed to the teeth choose to take it that way. Which they have every right to do, much as you may dislike them and what they stand for - it is their country and their citizens. The defintion of "repatriate" is "to bring/send someone back to their own country". It is not to take people, no matter how "worthy" the reason, from their own country and take them somewhere else, even with their agreement.

What you and others are arguing is putting our troops and other British citizens at greater risk than they already are. And the kerfuffle that this person has kicked up will have been seen in Sudan as well, so they now know who he is, that he is attempting to leave the country; and that probably others will be doing the same thing. You don't think they will now be watching for them? That puts them all at greater risk too.

I am sorry for all the people - especially the Sudanese people - who are caught up in this tragedy. But that does not justify throwing caution to the wind and putting people at greater risk by trampling over international law. If we cannot be trusted to abide by those laws, then we have no right to expect others to. And we cannot pick and choose the laws we like when it suits our emotional responses. Until, and unless, the UN intervenes in Sudan, we have no authority to remove Sudanese citizens for any reason, or to otherwise protect them.

ScribblingPixie · 28/04/2023 11:36

Luckily, I can't imagine what it's like to come from a war-torn country where a visit to family back home is a risky activity that needs to be thought through and balanced between benefit and possible disaster. But I don't think people should shout about the shitty Tory government and the sanctified NHS as if that nullify both those risks taken and those demanded of British soldiers in order to help them. Doctors visiting family aren't more 'worthy' of saving than taxi drivers visiting family. Those news reports seem politically motivated to me.

PollyThePixie · 28/04/2023 11:33

Camablanca · 28/04/2023 10:35

Again, use of emotive language used to obscure practical questions.
'Serve' - so they're not doing paid jobs? Maybe it's a better life than in Sudan, so it's actually benefitting them? I use 'serve' to mean at one's own expense.
'Adopted' them? How do you know that they're not here for the short term. Would you also feel the same for an investment banker, ballet dancer or anybody else here for the same amount of time?

It's common for doctors to complete short-term training, residency etc in various countries. They then move on. 'Short-term' could mean a few years.

The way you put it they have given up everything to come to the UK, built lives families etc etc. Them being DOCTORS doesn't make that true.

So when people talk about someone serving in the military what does it mean in your world given they’re doing paid jobs.

Papernotplastic · 28/04/2023 11:32

’I saw the incredible job the French military were doing in helping evacuate all nationalities via Djibouti. That used to be us before insular dickheadery became the norm.’

True.

ArcticSkewer · 28/04/2023 11:30

darjeelingrose · 28/04/2023 11:18

Actually dual citizenship in itself is a bit of a misnomer. As @DogInATent says, it's international law that you do not have more rights than your fellow citizens in a country where you are a citizen through having another passport. You don't have the rights of the country plus other rights. On the other hand, in the UK, you are not a lesser citizen either. So a British person who is also Sudanese, is not less British than a British person who is not Sudanese. Not in the eyes of the law anyway. In the eyes of some posters, they are.

You do have less rights now as you can be stripped of UK citizenship and deported to a country you might never even have visited, if you have dual citizenship. There have been some quite sad examples of this.

Camablanca · 28/04/2023 11:25

darjeelingrose · 28/04/2023 11:18

Actually dual citizenship in itself is a bit of a misnomer. As @DogInATent says, it's international law that you do not have more rights than your fellow citizens in a country where you are a citizen through having another passport. You don't have the rights of the country plus other rights. On the other hand, in the UK, you are not a lesser citizen either. So a British person who is also Sudanese, is not less British than a British person who is not Sudanese. Not in the eyes of the law anyway. In the eyes of some posters, they are.

Exactly. But it's a gray area and as @Intergalacticcatharsis 'exceptions' are made in the case of repatriation.

The most 'clear-cut' would be a dual national (or otherwise) married to a British national, ordinarily resident in the UK. Residency exceptions may be for permanent residents (ILR).

The thing about 'dual nationals' is that should they get out of the country on their own steam they can walk into any of the countries of their nationality and live as a citizen, be entitled to benefits etc. That's a bit different from 'consular help' to get them out in the first place.

darjeelingrose · 28/04/2023 11:18

Actually dual citizenship in itself is a bit of a misnomer. As @DogInATent says, it's international law that you do not have more rights than your fellow citizens in a country where you are a citizen through having another passport. You don't have the rights of the country plus other rights. On the other hand, in the UK, you are not a lesser citizen either. So a British person who is also Sudanese, is not less British than a British person who is not Sudanese. Not in the eyes of the law anyway. In the eyes of some posters, they are.

Camablanca · 28/04/2023 11:17

DogInATent · 28/04/2023 11:06

Ah, but then on the other thread people were complaining that this is racist too! There were a number of reports of dual national holders trying to get out despite being Sudanese but haven't lived in the UK for years.

If you have dual citizenship you do not get consular/embassy services whilst in the country you also hold nationality of. It's not racist or xenophobic, it's international law.

Did you mean to quote @AgainstMachine?

As the thread demonstrated 'international law' means nothing to people claiming that things should be done (or otherwise) because they're 'morally right'. Hence why as in the quoted post, and also the premise of this entire thread (as I recall the article was about Sudanese doctors)

Intergalacticcatharsis · 28/04/2023 11:17

If you have dual citizenship you do not get consular/embassy services whilst in the country you also hold nationality of. It's not racist or xenophobic, it's international law.

And it is on the website, in black and white. But they do make exceptions. Which again is stated.

“As a British national, you can receive our assistance even if you do not normally live in the UK. However we cannot help British nationals (overseas) of Chinese ethnic origin travelling or living in China, Hong Kong or the Macao Special Administrative Regions.”

So there are exceptions… people need to understand what their legal rights are depending on their exact circumstances before travelling.
The government does make exceptions in certain instances, especially with dual national holders and residents. But it is not a legal right. So it is always going to be emotive.
And if they set a precedent then they end up having to make similar exceptions in the future. Because the press and public put pressure.

But this whole doctor thing can be easily spun the other way into a sort of NHS is collapsing, UK desperate for medical workers, shopping in unstable regions for them, stealing their doctors when they desperately need some in a crisis. Anyone with any medical experience welcome back to the UK as heroes however tenuous your ties….

DogInATent · 28/04/2023 11:06

Ah, but then on the other thread people were complaining that this is racist too! There were a number of reports of dual national holders trying to get out despite being Sudanese but haven't lived in the UK for years.

If you have dual citizenship you do not get consular/embassy services whilst in the country you also hold nationality of. It's not racist or xenophobic, it's international law.

Againstmachine · 28/04/2023 11:01

Raggletagglegypsy · 28/04/2023 10:55

@Againstmachine Actually, when it comes to this evacuation process, I think I would place someone with British residency, who normally lives and works here, above a Sudanese dual national, British passport-holder, who does not normally live and work in Britain.

Nope the Government has a duty to citizens ahead of any other nationalities, it's part of being a citizen.

To expect them to put Sudanese citizens ahead is plain stupid.

Camablanca · 28/04/2023 11:00

Raggletagglegypsy · 28/04/2023 10:55

@Againstmachine Actually, when it comes to this evacuation process, I think I would place someone with British residency, who normally lives and works here, above a Sudanese dual national, British passport-holder, who does not normally live and work in Britain.

Ah, but then on the other thread people were complaining that this is racist too! There were a number of reports of dual national holders trying to get out despite being Sudanese but haven't lived in the UK for years.

It's very complex. There's too much that meets the eye to be 'disgusted' as a knee jerk reaction.

I will also say it's a question of size. Sudan doesn't have that many, so evacuating everyone is fine. Again taking Malaysia as an example - there are so many Malaysians resident here for such a small country (more than, say Thai or Vietnamese) it would take several planes.

**Malaysia is a safe country, but just for arguments sake.,

StorminaStarmug · 28/04/2023 10:58

Againstmachine · 28/04/2023 10:50

They dot serve, they do jobs well paid bloody jobs.

You repatriate British citizens first, they are Sudanese citizens who made stupid decisions to actually go there.

Your post is full of how doctors are better than anyone because they 'serve' so you do place them above others that is clear.

Doctors are public servants. They do serve. Fact. The thread is not about how much they are paid. Although they are not paid enough or the British ones wouldn't all be going abroad, would they?

I don't think doctors are superior beings. If you read my post I said I am bothered by humans in general and that is part of my concern about not repatriating doctors domiciled in the UK. We need them to keep other humans alive. Literally. I don't care what passport they have.

Raggletagglegypsy · 28/04/2023 10:55

@Againstmachine Actually, when it comes to this evacuation process, I think I would place someone with British residency, who normally lives and works here, above a Sudanese dual national, British passport-holder, who does not normally live and work in Britain.

OP posts:
Camablanca · 28/04/2023 10:53

Againstmachine · 28/04/2023 10:50

They dot serve, they do jobs well paid bloody jobs.

You repatriate British citizens first, they are Sudanese citizens who made stupid decisions to actually go there.

Your post is full of how doctors are better than anyone because they 'serve' so you do place them above others that is clear.

Exactly this!
It's a job. Like the IT people, project managers all foreign have come to the UK for a job.

Now if you think doctors are underpaid etc that's a diff story but it has nothing to do with having repatriation rights over others of the same visa. Nope. You're indirectly implying that those who don't work for the NHS are rightfully turned away.

Swipe left for the next trending thread