Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people have inflated view of our healthcare system?

181 replies

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:10

I've had treatment abroad twice and I wouldn't hesitate to get elective treatment abroad again this was the EU. The staff spoke perfect English there was an ICU in the hospital. I was offered pre op sedation because i was anxious ,I had my own private room , I was nursed with one other patient and there was 2 nurses on shift so 1:1 ratio my pain was perfectly managed. In comparison over here ive been expected to have gynaecological procedures with no pain relief. I had great protein filled meals with fish plenty of vegetables great for healing. (High carb slop offered here.)

I had dressings changed , post op care wirh docfor and I stayed 4 weeks to ensure everything was healing well. I keep hearing people say they would never get treatment abroad you will die etc they treat the UK as some holy grail of healthcare. People who go abroad are stupid etc.I have been left in pain multiple times in our health care system. My DD when she fell ill in Singapore had a team of doctors waiting for her at the hospital.
Preparing to be flamed but AIBU to think our healthcare system isn't that great? Many people haven't actually experienced care abroad so assume ours must naturally be the best?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Remaker · 28/04/2023 03:50

I’m in Australia and I am often shocked by the posts on healthcare in the UK. In particular having to grovel and beg to actually see a dr in the first place. Here if you want an GP appointment you just make one and go. Same with hospital- you go to A&E (and it’s free). My DS was sick this week, went to A&E, waited about 4 hrs, triaged, admitted and had surgery the following morning (on a public holiday) to remove his appendix. Stayed in hospital for 3 nights, had a private room for 2 nights and shared with one other teenage boy the other night. Cost to us $0.

I was recently diagnosed with bowel cancer and my surgeon was going through the various prognosis statistics. He pointed out (I assume because DH is English) that the UK has the lowest survival rate from bowel cancer of any developed country - 20% lower survival rate than Australia!

Tests such as colonoscopies and endoscopies are always done under sedation here, I find it barbaric that they aren’t in the UK and I wonder if that contributes to poorer outcomes as people are just too scared to have the tests!

Fererr · 28/04/2023 03:29

In 2010 NHS care scored highly on international tables and satisfaction levels were much higher. Then Tories got in, spending dropped significantly and not surprisingly quality of care.

“Health spending per person, adjusted for demographic change, NHS spending grew at 2% a year under the Conservatives from 1979 to 1997; at 5.7% a year under Labour from 1997 to 2010; at -0.07% from 2010 to 2015; and at -0.03% from 2015 to 2021. In other words, even Margaret Thatcher, who declared there’s no such thing as society, increased NHS funding at a higher rate than the Conservatives in the 2010s. David Cameron declared he wanted to create a “big society”, and he and George Osborne reduced NHS funding per person. Cameron also said that there would be no more top-down reorganisation of the NHS and then, with his health secretary Andrew Lansley, did exactly that. It marked what Chris Ham, former head of the King’s Fund, described as the political failure that led to the decline of the NHS.

Other European countries have taken a different approach. If the UK had increased its healthcare expenditure from 2010 to 2019 as much as France did, we would have increased our current spend by 21%, and by 39% if we had matched Germany. The NHS needs more money. It would help in filling the 150,000 vacant full-time posts. Paying doctors and nurses appropriately would help. But we do need reform as well.”

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/apr/24/labour-wes-streeting-nhs-britain-europe?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

Labour’s Wes Streeting is half right about how to fix the NHS | Michael Marmot

Yes, reform is necessary. But without increases in spending as well, Britain will continue to be the sick man of Europe, says epidemiologist Michael Marmot

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/apr/24/labour-wes-streeting-nhs-britain-europe?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

Silverrocks · 28/04/2023 03:20

It's not a controversial view, plenty of people realise the NHS is currently shit. I'd say most like the premise of free at point of use healthcare but acknowledge its not really working at the moment.

evuscha · 28/04/2023 03:00

@Phoebo it honestly is like in the TV shows 😀 I had an amazing experience going to ER (A&E) as well, I was seen within 30 minutes, had a private room as well and multiple doctors and nurses tending to me and giving me all necessary treatments on the spot. Was given food and drinks as well. The hospital I went to is very clean looks recently renovated too so overall felt pretty luxurious compared to Europe.
And the other thing I appreciated was the short waiting times - whenever my DD was sick the pediatrician would fit her in on the same day, same with my GP and referral to a specialist would typically happen within a few days, a week tops.
Also other thing worth noting, there’s a lot of money in the US for research so all top notch specialists experimental treatments etc seem to be there. I know quite a few people in Europe fundraising for a treatment only available in the US (like for rare conditions or cancer).
I was a SAHM and me & DD had a very good insurance through my DH’s job, there were generally no or very low copays at appointments (like $5).
I have a very vague understanding of what it’s like for people with lower level or no insurance (and it probably also differs by state) but I suspect this is where it gets tricky and people often have to set up GoFundMe for their treatments.
So yeah I guess a compromise would be nice, NHS could absolutely do with more funding and people should expect some level of copays but there should be measures in place to ensure low income people can still access adequate care.

Nightlystroll · 28/04/2023 02:58

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:25

Many will say because its free we should be grateful for anything. I'm actually shocked by the quality of care here vs abroad nothing to do with the staff who are hard working it's the ratios.

Are the staff working hard? My mum had an emergency admission into hospital with a seizure and I sat with her for 20 odd hours through a&e, amu and onto a ward. Some staff worked consistently. Some staff chatted. The nurses in light blue and white, were being asked to do everything. The nurses in dark blue sat at computer screens, chatting. I asked one of these dark blue nurses for a bedpan for my mum and that I would sort her out. He had his chin resting on his hands and just stared at me. The man doing the tea trolley intervened and said that I needed help. And the nurse gave a vague smile and said when he had a nurse free, he'd send one over. He stayed seated where he was, with 4 other hcps. My mum wet herself.

Phoebo · 28/04/2023 02:47

evuscha · 28/04/2023 02:16

@Emotionalstorm I can confirm after living in the US the quality of care is absolutely superior to anything I’ve ever experienced in EU/UK. My prenatal experience and giving birth was also absolutely top notch, I had my own room for 4 days after c-section and was given nutritious meals 5 times a day. Expensive though if you don’t have a very good insurance, for that reason I still like the European model better. I don’t know enough about the options in the US for low income people Obamacare etc., they exist but I don’t know the details.

I've always wondered when watching TV shows as it always looks good! I don't think I've ever seen anyone in a non-private room. The only thing that is sad/scary is if you one of the ones that doesn't have health insurance

Phoebo · 28/04/2023 02:45

I was extremely impressed with Turkey when I went in 2009 and DH sliced his leg open and needed stitches. Sometimes I think people underestimate how good it is in other countries

evuscha · 28/04/2023 02:16

@Emotionalstorm I can confirm after living in the US the quality of care is absolutely superior to anything I’ve ever experienced in EU/UK. My prenatal experience and giving birth was also absolutely top notch, I had my own room for 4 days after c-section and was given nutritious meals 5 times a day. Expensive though if you don’t have a very good insurance, for that reason I still like the European model better. I don’t know enough about the options in the US for low income people Obamacare etc., they exist but I don’t know the details.

Emotionalstorm · 28/04/2023 01:55

Best healthcare I have ever seen is in the US. My parents went there for treatment. Clean hospitals, lots of staff around, no waiting, the rooms were like hotels and had a wine list. I would be thrilled if we followed the US model.

Divorcedalongtime · 28/04/2023 01:16

I have lived in three different countries and they all tell their people the same propaganda that their heath service s the best in the world and their school system is great and their steel is the most sought after, lol.
yes overrated

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 01:14

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 01:03

That was what we were billed by the hospital for DD unless you think I should ask them to pay more? So yes it was cheap. I also had a procedure which was cheaper to pay over there vs paying private here. I think people will have to get their heads around paying for healthcare as the current system is not sustainable.

First, we do pay for healthcare. Second, the system is sustainable it’s just been cut to the bone. Third, most of the country doesn’t have the money to pay more for healthcare not now when an extra 85% of homeless people died on the streets, when 45 people a DAY die due to no heat in their homes, when millions cannot even afford food to eat and are dependent on food banks. You think the desperately poor are going to go to a doctor or A&E if there is a co-pay? No, the excess death rate will go up even more than it has already.

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 01:03

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 00:57

Paeds isn’t that low and your DD was the patient, not her grandmother. Singapore doesn’t allow dual citizenship. I’m just asking is your DD a citizen of Singapore? Because it doesn’t make sense to say it’s so cheap to get healthcare abroad outside the U.K. when the price you paid for your DD wasn’t the price a foreigner from abroad would pay for their DD.

That was what we were billed by the hospital for DD unless you think I should ask them to pay more? So yes it was cheap. I also had a procedure which was cheaper to pay over there vs paying private here. I think people will have to get their heads around paying for healthcare as the current system is not sustainable.

OP posts:
ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 00:57

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:49

Grandma is a citizen this was around 8 years ago. You are quoting the adult rates Peads is a lot lower it was 20 sgd and she had excellent care.

Paeds isn’t that low and your DD was the patient, not her grandmother. Singapore doesn’t allow dual citizenship. I’m just asking is your DD a citizen of Singapore? Because it doesn’t make sense to say it’s so cheap to get healthcare abroad outside the U.K. when the price you paid for your DD wasn’t the price a foreigner from abroad would pay for their DD.

poetryandwine · 28/04/2023 00:54

PS We worked in America for 15 years and participated in a brilliant Health Maintenance Organisation centred around a large university medical centre. For participants it worked a lot like a much better version of the NHS, with small copays. It was funded by employers, with state and federal governments funding the participation of the poor and elderly. Nonprofit. In fact, much like the French system and much the best medical care I’ve ever had

PeloMom · 28/04/2023 00:49

While UK’s healthcare system may not be the best is far from being the worst. I’ve lived in 5 different countries and unfortunately have had health issues in another 4-5 countries and I’d say UK is somewhere in the middle (at least was 6-7 yrs ago when I last had to use it). Which country are you referring to if I may ask (it’s always nice to know in which country health care is great).

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:49

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 00:45

So how did your DD pay the going rate for a citizen then? This says it’s about Sing$29 to $68 to see a consultant if you’re a citizen, but Sing$131 to $148 for a nonresident.

You do realise Singaporeans pay more out of pocket for their healthcare than even the Americans do?

https://www.sgh.com.sg/patient-care/visiting-specialist/charges-payments-singapore-general-hospital

Grandma is a citizen this was around 8 years ago. You are quoting the adult rates Peads is a lot lower it was 20 sgd and she had excellent care.

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 28/04/2023 00:47

I agree with you,@Paperbagsaremine and it is very sad.

Before the pandemic DH had life saving surgery on the NHS followed by almost a week of brilliant care on the HDU - he was stuck there because of bedblocking.

But nursing care when he moved to the ward was awful. I saw the contrast. Sepsis set in. So DH became critically ill and required a lot more attention than if they had just treated him properly in the first place. My blood still boils recalling it.

And everything is worse now.

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 00:45

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:29

Singapore it cost 20 Singapore dollars £10 at the time for assessment and treatment of our DD. No waiting required DHs mum is a citizen, I think the vast majority of people could afford £10 for treatment there's a reluctance to pay for any healthcare here.

So how did your DD pay the going rate for a citizen then? This says it’s about Sing$29 to $68 to see a consultant if you’re a citizen, but Sing$131 to $148 for a nonresident.

You do realise Singaporeans pay more out of pocket for their healthcare than even the Americans do?

https://www.sgh.com.sg/patient-care/visiting-specialist/charges-payments-singapore-general-hospital

Charges & Payments - Singapore General Hospital

https://www.sgh.com.sg/patient-care/visiting-specialist/charges-payments-singapore-general-hospital

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:40

FangedFrisbee · 28/04/2023 00:30

@Runaway0 ok then you go off to turkey and pay for your elective surgeries you need. No doubt you'll be back when you get some god awful raging infection like I've seen before, and then you'll be desperate for our 'shitty health care system' to fix you for free. If you choose to go abroad for surgery and get complications you should have to pay to have it fixed here.

I haven't had treatment in Turkey , I don't believe their medical system is regulated enough. I've been to an EU country and Singapore. I also stay for the full recovery period so any complications are picked up and treated before I go home. So many people fly home much too early. I have NEVER asked for NHS care related to my elective procedures. Turkey isn't regulated like the UK but other countries are.

OP posts:
Paperbagsaremine · 28/04/2023 00:33

I guess understandably people are worried that politicians (who have been known to cock stuff up) might just make everything worse if they try e.g. to change us over to the German system - that somehow they might contrive to get us the chunky insurance payments but with not a noticeably improved standard of healthcare, because their buddies creamed off a big portion of the money. Particularly after all the PPE procurement scandals and various others (just pick up ANY edition of Private Eye...).

It annoys me though that any suggestion of change is interpreted as "they want us to have the US system only worse so ALL THE POOR PEOPLE DIE" - you could have MP Chris Sensible of Saneshire saying"The French system is better, let's switch to that" and they'd immediately be drowned out by accusations of links with Big American Health Business and a desire to only stuff the pockets of the rich, even if there was 0 evidence of that.

There's been so much incompetence, mismanagement and corruption that the trust needed for positive change isn't there.

gettingoldisshit · 28/04/2023 00:32

And i am an ex hcp who worked in the NHS! The decline in standards is shocking!

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 00:32

The system is great, it’s just that you get what you pay for and the government has grossly underfunded the NHS for over a decade. That great care you got, it cost more money. You can’t get good quality on a shoestring budget. Numerous studies have debunked the government propaganda that the NHS is inefficient before anyone says they are not undefended they’re just a bunch of wasters. The NHS is actually more efficient in terms of resources and spending its funds compared to clinical outcomes than the vast majority of healthcare systems in the OECD.

gettingoldisshit · 28/04/2023 00:31

Op I completely agree! I had elective surgery abroad last year and got so many hysterical comments about the " hospitals/doctors abroad". The hospital was absolutely spotless and the care I received second to none! I would rather go there for surgery than take my chances on an understaffed NHS ward!

FangedFrisbee · 28/04/2023 00:30

@Runaway0 ok then you go off to turkey and pay for your elective surgeries you need. No doubt you'll be back when you get some god awful raging infection like I've seen before, and then you'll be desperate for our 'shitty health care system' to fix you for free. If you choose to go abroad for surgery and get complications you should have to pay to have it fixed here.

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:29

AlphabetSue · 28/04/2023 00:24

Yes, you’re treated as a customer who has choices and needs care.

In the UK it’s often as though you’re lucky to have what you’re given, if it’s anything at all. And good luck figuring out the pathway to accessing it. Obviously there’s issues with being a customer (can you afford it?) but when the UK has broken down so far then it doesn’t matter if it’s free at the point of service, when you can’t access that service.

Singapore it cost 20 Singapore dollars £10 at the time for assessment and treatment of our DD. No waiting required DHs mum is a citizen, I think the vast majority of people could afford £10 for treatment there's a reluctance to pay for any healthcare here.

OP posts: