Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people have inflated view of our healthcare system?

181 replies

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:10

I've had treatment abroad twice and I wouldn't hesitate to get elective treatment abroad again this was the EU. The staff spoke perfect English there was an ICU in the hospital. I was offered pre op sedation because i was anxious ,I had my own private room , I was nursed with one other patient and there was 2 nurses on shift so 1:1 ratio my pain was perfectly managed. In comparison over here ive been expected to have gynaecological procedures with no pain relief. I had great protein filled meals with fish plenty of vegetables great for healing. (High carb slop offered here.)

I had dressings changed , post op care wirh docfor and I stayed 4 weeks to ensure everything was healing well. I keep hearing people say they would never get treatment abroad you will die etc they treat the UK as some holy grail of healthcare. People who go abroad are stupid etc.I have been left in pain multiple times in our health care system. My DD when she fell ill in Singapore had a team of doctors waiting for her at the hospital.
Preparing to be flamed but AIBU to think our healthcare system isn't that great? Many people haven't actually experienced care abroad so assume ours must naturally be the best?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Florissant · 28/04/2023 06:53

I’ve also never paid hardly anything for it.

So what you're saying is that you paid a lot for it?

Florissant · 28/04/2023 06:51

BagelAndMarmite · 28/04/2023 06:06

'Free' at the point of use.
We pay for our health care system through taxation.

Nope. People who don't pay taxes still receive free healthcare. Taxpayers pay for some of the NHS's costs and the government makes up the balance through borrowing.

yakkyok · 28/04/2023 06:51

I think the thing to bear in mind is that the NHS is massively underfunded and a lot of money gets wasted managing people’s unrealistic expectations and time wasting.

It happens on both sides, very inefficient & so much time wasting.

Florissant · 28/04/2023 06:50

FangedFrisbee · 28/04/2023 00:27

Ooh goody good goody another nhs bashing thread! Can't wait!

I agree.

Dorisbonson · 28/04/2023 06:48

The % of a GDP we spend on the NHS is about the same as most European countries spend on healthcare, less than Japan and Italy which have older populations but on a par with France and Germany. There is no reason why the NHS is so bad other than poor management.

Museya15 · 28/04/2023 06:32

The healthcare would be the exact same in this country if we paid for our procedures, the way you did in another country. Staff ratio would be one nurse two or three patients. Bit of a non story really

evuscha · 28/04/2023 06:10

Neurodiversitydoctor · 28/04/2023 06:06

I’m glad to hear that. I didn’t even think about it being a thing back in 2019 (I wasn’t offered it and not sure if people with higher risk of DS were offered it or still had to pay for it) but now that is a routine thing in my second pregnancy it’s just nice to have that extra peace of mind.

evuscha · 28/04/2023 06:07

Neurodiversitydoctor · 28/04/2023 06:02

I completely agree, a European system is what is needed. I was quoting US stats because the PP was talking about how good maternity care was there.

We were in Greece this Summer when one of our party became unwell, the care she recieved was supperior to what you would get here, although no wine list !

Wine list is obviously a nice touch but not mandatory! 😀

BagelAndMarmite · 28/04/2023 06:06

'Free' at the point of use.
We pay for our health care system through taxation.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 28/04/2023 06:06

Looks like NIPT was introduced in 2021

phescreening.blog.gov.uk/2021/04/26/new-operational-guidance-for-nipt-screening-within-the-nhs/

Neurodiversitydoctor · 28/04/2023 06:02

evuscha · 28/04/2023 05:49

If you want to speak strictly maternal/infant mortality rates and take the US out of it, UK still performs very below average compared to the rest of Europe, so there’s that.

Glad you had a stress free pregnancy, I did too when I was in the UK, so I can’t compare to what care I would receive if anything was wrong. However from what I hear from UK-based friends it’s really not that great. First of all noone will even see you before 8 weeks so if you’re having a miscarriage, tough luck. If you’re cramping and want a peace of kind, you can’t easily get an ultrasound unless you go private. A friend was denied amnio in NHS because the genetic disorder that she and her DH are both carriers of “is not even that bad” (so she has to pay £2.5k going private). Not sure if NIPT is routinely offered in the UK - it wasn’t to me in 2019 - it is in the US and some EU countries that I know (if you want it).

I think everyone will agree that the big issue for NHS is the funding (and lack of staff). And it doesn’t have to be privatized like the US but there are many models around Europe that just work better.

I completely agree, a European system is what is needed. I was quoting US stats because the PP was talking about how good maternity care was there.

We were in Greece this Summer when one of our party became unwell, the care she recieved was supperior to what you would get here, although no wine list !

MayThe4th · 28/04/2023 06:00

People’s opinion is going to depend on their own experiences.

I am literally alive now because of the NHS. I spent Sunday night in a&e and the chaos and discontent that the media keep talking about just wasn’t there. I didn’t spend any more time there this time than I have done in the past, in fact it was quicker than times before the pandemic.

The NHS needs an overhaul but not just because of funding but also because people expect it to cover everything, and that’s just not sustainable.

Countries in Europe have a significantly higher tax, in the US the health service will benefit you depending on how much money you have and what your medical insurance is prepared to pay for.

And paying for treatment abroad is not comparable to having treatment on the NHS because you’re a paying customer, of course you’re going to get decent treatment, they want more like you.

evuscha · 28/04/2023 05:59

Caspianberg · 28/04/2023 05:50

I live Central Europe. Had a baby 3 years ago. Your under a Gynaecology consultant the whole way, Midwife’s here are only for after birth. Had scans or check ups every 4 weeks. 36-40 weeks, weekly. Private room, 1 week stay is standard. Midwife then assigned, and can visit you every day at home for 6 weeks if you want them ( mine came every day 1 week, then twice new week, then weekly as I didn’t need more) - From 36week check until birth and all after stuff was peak start 2020 covid and nothing was reduced. All baby checks the first year done monthly. Maternal physio for muscles after provided as standard. Cost €0

I have a few friends in Central Europe and that’s what I hear as well. And Central European countries actually score really well in maternal/infant mortality rates.

Caspianberg · 28/04/2023 05:50

I live Central Europe. Had a baby 3 years ago. Your under a Gynaecology consultant the whole way, Midwife’s here are only for after birth. Had scans or check ups every 4 weeks. 36-40 weeks, weekly. Private room, 1 week stay is standard. Midwife then assigned, and can visit you every day at home for 6 weeks if you want them ( mine came every day 1 week, then twice new week, then weekly as I didn’t need more) - From 36week check until birth and all after stuff was peak start 2020 covid and nothing was reduced. All baby checks the first year done monthly. Maternal physio for muscles after provided as standard. Cost €0

evuscha · 28/04/2023 05:49

If you want to speak strictly maternal/infant mortality rates and take the US out of it, UK still performs very below average compared to the rest of Europe, so there’s that.

Glad you had a stress free pregnancy, I did too when I was in the UK, so I can’t compare to what care I would receive if anything was wrong. However from what I hear from UK-based friends it’s really not that great. First of all noone will even see you before 8 weeks so if you’re having a miscarriage, tough luck. If you’re cramping and want a peace of kind, you can’t easily get an ultrasound unless you go private. A friend was denied amnio in NHS because the genetic disorder that she and her DH are both carriers of “is not even that bad” (so she has to pay £2.5k going private). Not sure if NIPT is routinely offered in the UK - it wasn’t to me in 2019 - it is in the US and some EU countries that I know (if you want it).

I think everyone will agree that the big issue for NHS is the funding (and lack of staff). And it doesn’t have to be privatized like the US but there are many models around Europe that just work better.

Eviebeans · 28/04/2023 05:48

Firstly I have to say that I have never received health care in another country.
however on 14th April this year I phoned my gp surgery and got an appointment to see the nurse practitioner that morning. I was referred on a two week wait. I had an appointment at hospital yesterday. I have been told that I’ll have the procedure in 4 to 6 weeks probably sooner. I saw a member of the dermatology team who had a trainee with her and also the consultant. My appointment lasted 20 minutes. Although I am very well aware of the situation with the NHS - lack of funding, staff needing pay increases, low morale etc I didn’t feel that I was being treated by a service that is on its knees. But that is due to the efforts of the staff.

happyumwelt · 28/04/2023 05:43

Our 5 year cancer survival rates are among the lowest in the developed world (they may even be the lowest - I can't remember), which I think is shocking. This is because of the quality of treatment and care, not because British people are subject to more aggressive cancers.

Quick google and found this:

https://news.cancerresearchuk.org/2019/09/11/measuring-up-how-does-the-uk-compare-internationally-on-cancer-survival/

It's from 2019, so I expect it is probably even worse now, with so many people missed during covid.

Measuring up: How does the UK compare internationally on cancer survival?

New survival figures have revealed some encouraging trends around the world. But they also highlight how much progress still needs to be made in the UK.

https://news.cancerresearchuk.org/2019/09/11/measuring-up-how-does-the-uk-compare-internationally-on-cancer-survival

Neurodiversitydoctor · 28/04/2023 05:36

Also having a baby (particularly your second if still under 35) doesn't need vast numbers of check ups. I had a total of 5 for my DD ( booking, 12 week scan, 20 week scan, 28 weeks and 36 weeks) in 2006. Made for a lovely relaxed pregnancy.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 28/04/2023 05:33

I have worked in the NHS for 23 years and I know it is in no way perfect. However you can't compare the whole NHS to private health care in the US, you have to compare it to the health care that most people can acsess.

evuscha · 28/04/2023 05:23

Neurodiversitydoctor · 28/04/2023 05:13

The maternal and infant mortality rates in the states are higher than any other developed country. That is how I measure the maternity services not wine lists !

That is to do with access to care though, not quality of care, and I do acknowledge that is an issue with privatized healthcare.
I had one pregnancy in the UK and one in the US and while it wasn’t bad in the UK, the thoroughness of checkups and screening was better in the US from my experience. But, as I said, I do have good health insurance. It probably isn’t as good or there’s more copay for people with lower tiered health insurance.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 28/04/2023 05:13

evuscha · 28/04/2023 02:16

@Emotionalstorm I can confirm after living in the US the quality of care is absolutely superior to anything I’ve ever experienced in EU/UK. My prenatal experience and giving birth was also absolutely top notch, I had my own room for 4 days after c-section and was given nutritious meals 5 times a day. Expensive though if you don’t have a very good insurance, for that reason I still like the European model better. I don’t know enough about the options in the US for low income people Obamacare etc., they exist but I don’t know the details.

The maternal and infant mortality rates in the states are higher than any other developed country. That is how I measure the maternity services not wine lists !

wingingit1987 · 28/04/2023 04:37

I think the thing to bear in mind is that the NHS is massively underfunded and a lot of money gets wasted managing people’s unrealistic expectations and time wasting. I’ve worked in the NHS for 18 years now and it never ceases to amaze me how many services are misused.

Ellie450 · 28/04/2023 04:33

@evuscha My experience with US healthcare has been the same. No messing around, very little waiting, and absolutely phenomenal care. I’ve also never paid hardly anything for it.

Since the system is flush with money they do have the advantage in research, treatments, specialists, staffing, etc. Thankfully they’re also really benevolent about sharing their knowledge and findings with other countries. It’s easy to forget how much was pioneered in the US.

Murdoch1949 · 28/04/2023 04:29

I have no problem with people paying for treatment abroad, as long as there is no subsequent cost to the NHS. You have had good treatment in Singapore and another unnamed EU country, and did not return to the UK for 4 weeks. You were lucky, and no issues arose after your surgery, that does not always happen.

dreamonlucid · 28/04/2023 04:03

Can I ask which EU country?

Just as a side note I lived in Singapore and this amazing system you talk about missed cervical cell changes and resulted in a very good friend of mine becoming addicted to strong painkillers.

It was the NHS screening that saved me when I came back 4 years later.