Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people have inflated view of our healthcare system?

181 replies

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:10

I've had treatment abroad twice and I wouldn't hesitate to get elective treatment abroad again this was the EU. The staff spoke perfect English there was an ICU in the hospital. I was offered pre op sedation because i was anxious ,I had my own private room , I was nursed with one other patient and there was 2 nurses on shift so 1:1 ratio my pain was perfectly managed. In comparison over here ive been expected to have gynaecological procedures with no pain relief. I had great protein filled meals with fish plenty of vegetables great for healing. (High carb slop offered here.)

I had dressings changed , post op care wirh docfor and I stayed 4 weeks to ensure everything was healing well. I keep hearing people say they would never get treatment abroad you will die etc they treat the UK as some holy grail of healthcare. People who go abroad are stupid etc.I have been left in pain multiple times in our health care system. My DD when she fell ill in Singapore had a team of doctors waiting for her at the hospital.
Preparing to be flamed but AIBU to think our healthcare system isn't that great? Many people haven't actually experienced care abroad so assume ours must naturally be the best?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Howpo · 28/04/2023 08:52

wombridgewalkabout · 28/04/2023 08:18

Leaving the EU has led to this latest crisis, not Covid

Look, I have had a chronic health condition for 30 years and can tell you that problems in the NHS well precede Brexit!

Brexit may well be your hobby horse but it is beyond simplistic to think that is one single cause to the current dire state of the NHS. There are many causes which have come together at this time to create the rather failing system we have now.

People are dying in our NHS system who don’t need to. People are suffering badly who don’t need to. People are spending literally years unable to work as they wait for operations. It’s utterly awful.

And you still get ideological numpties like those in this thread saying, ‘ another NHS bashing thread I see’ because they don’t want to face up to the problems, and they confuse being acerbic with argument.

As i said "latest crisis" the NHS wasn't great before, i doubt anyone would deny this.

1000s of Dr's Nurses and AHPs left the NHS after Brexit and perhaps more importantly, many more EU workers left Adult Social Care and no one from the EU comes here to work in the NHS anymore, a huge loss.

so we take HCPs or try too, from developing countries and have lowered their qualifications to come here as well.

These are facts, you may not like it, maybe you voted to Leave the EU, i don't know.

This is why, waiting lists lists have doubled since 2019 and why they are increasing, despite CV having abated.

LookItsMeAgain · 28/04/2023 08:52

The NHS model of healthcare - i.e. free at the point of delivery, is and will always be the pinnacle of what a good healthcare system should be. Free to anyone and everyone who needs it, when they need it.

It is held in very high esteem but unfortunately, the British Government hasn't realised what a gem they have had in their hands all this time and have let it decay and get to a point where the Minister for Health takes a Nurses Union to the High Court to stop them from going on strike. How about paying the nurses (yes, those citizens that the British public clapped for during the lock downs) a decent wage so that they can live without having to resort to going to food banks and then they, oh, might not need to strike in the first place!

We have what I will call a mongrel version of it in Ireland and we also have private healthcare for anyone who can afford to pay for it.

I can see the UK going a very similar two tier system where people who have money can 'jump the queue' and get healthcare because they have the money.

Reality25 · 28/04/2023 08:52

Put it this way, would you prefer a private system in exchange for getting approximately 50% of your combined income tax and national insurance and employer national insurance back?

Because that's how much the NHS costs to society.

Even as a basic rate taxpayer it costs me over £6000 a year, i.e. more than average health insurance cost in the US.

And in return I get shockingly poor treatment relative to the US.

I'm not even a high earner FFS.

SweetSakura · 28/04/2023 08:51

squigglesquirrel · 28/04/2023 08:49

There’s some glorification of the US system on this thread, ignoring the role that insurance companies have to play.

I have a rare condition. It took a while to get the right diagnosis and treatment on the NHS. But I’m in various online support groups and the people who have most trouble are usually those in America as insurance often won’t fund the right tests or medication.

Same. It's absolutely sobering reading about the battles people with my condition have in the US - even wealthy people with very good insurance cover.

squigglesquirrel · 28/04/2023 08:49

There’s some glorification of the US system on this thread, ignoring the role that insurance companies have to play.

I have a rare condition. It took a while to get the right diagnosis and treatment on the NHS. But I’m in various online support groups and the people who have most trouble are usually those in America as insurance often won’t fund the right tests or medication.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 28/04/2023 08:46

We (as a country) need to pay more for healthcare if we want outcomes and experiences to be as good as other countries. How we do that is ideological (eg NHS, German model, US model). But the poor outcomes and experiences are because we simply do not pay enough in.

Testina · 28/04/2023 08:41

“I keep hearing people say they would never get treatment abroad you will die etc “

I suspect that the people you hear saying that aren’t talking about the same countries and the same procedures that you have experienced.

The hell do you keep hearing people say they wouldn’t want healthcare in Singapore 🙄🤣

SweetSakura · 28/04/2023 08:41

OdeToBarney · 28/04/2023 08:39

Not all the time. The money they spend on lawyers is quite phenomenal. I know, I've seen the contracts. Albeit a few years ago now.

Agreed. And let's be clear, there are just as many "fucking idiots" (nice) in the private sector. And there are some phenomenally good civil servants doing amazing work and this is a lazy trope.

OdeToBarney · 28/04/2023 08:39

Madamecastafiore · 28/04/2023 08:11

Because that's gone so well in the past hasn't it? Serco, G4S etc - they're all doing an excellent job aren't they?

Because you've got fucking idiot civil servants or NHS employees negotiating and drawing up contracts.

Not all the time. The money they spend on lawyers is quite phenomenal. I know, I've seen the contracts. Albeit a few years ago now.

ShoesoftheWorld · 28/04/2023 08:36

My contribution also includes compulsory social care insurance, which we've seen in action fairly recently in my MIL's last couple of years - it covered the care she needed and she was able from her reasonable-but-not-huge pension to pay for a supported living flat with all meals and have plenty left over for discretionary spending.

Lapland123 · 28/04/2023 08:35

a major part of current crisis is staffing.
You realise there won’t magically be more staff, don’t you?
Though at least the private business healthcare model you are promoting would get nowhere without staff and would boost pay for HCP which the government are currently denying. I would not like to work in the system but I’d be happy with the 45% pay erosion for doctors being reversed and believe I would be much better paid as a vital person in a business model. A lot of the ‘project managers’ would go. More money to nurses, other frontline clinical staff.

SweetSakura · 28/04/2023 08:35

I have to say my experience recently has been amazing. I have been diagnosed with a serious neurological condition. I saw my specialist (who is an internationally respected expert) within a couple of weeks. Had the diagnostic tests two weeks later. Since then I get regular calls from a specialist nurse and can message her on an app that contains lots of useful information sharing tools.

When I had a query last week she called me within an hour of getting my message and the specialist saw me 2 days later and came up with a new treatment plan.

And I compare that with those with my condition in the US - often even previously wealthy people with decent jobs and insurance end up in dire financial circumstances because the cost of the drugs is so high. Or their insurers refuse treatments that my specialist would prescribe without blinking if I needed them . The stress of the financial burden makes our condition worse , and you see them going in a horrible downward spiral.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 28/04/2023 08:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Do you ever stop to think that the number of similar posts points to a widespread problem that is causing misery and sometimes permanent disability or death, and that maybe - just maybe- this matters to people?

Lapland123 · 28/04/2023 08:30

Howpo · 28/04/2023 08:13

Just so we can blow apart the myth we spend a lot on health or we match europe or its down to bad management.

  • This analysis examines how health care spending in the UK compares with EU countries in the decade preceding the pandemic.
  • Average day-to-day health spending in the UK between 2010 and 2019 was £3,005 per person – 18% below the EU14 average of £3,655.
  • If UK spending per person had matched the EU14 average, then the UK would have spent an average of £227bn a year on health between 2010 and 2019 – £40bn higher than actual average annual spending during this period (£187bn).
  • Matching spending per head to France or Germany would have led to an additional £40bn and £73bn (21% to 39% increase respectively) of total health spending each year in the UK.
  • Over the past decade, the UK had a lower level of capital investment in health care compared with the EU14 countries for which data are available. Between 2010 and 2019, average health capital investment in the UK was £5.8bn a year. If the UK had matched other EU14 countries’ average investment in health capital (as a share of GDP), the UK would have invested £33bn more between 2010 and 2019 (around 55% higher than actual investment during that period).
-

And this!

Lapland123 · 28/04/2023 08:28

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 00:32

The system is great, it’s just that you get what you pay for and the government has grossly underfunded the NHS for over a decade. That great care you got, it cost more money. You can’t get good quality on a shoestring budget. Numerous studies have debunked the government propaganda that the NHS is inefficient before anyone says they are not undefended they’re just a bunch of wasters. The NHS is actually more efficient in terms of resources and spending its funds compared to clinical outcomes than the vast majority of healthcare systems in the OECD.

This

ShoesoftheWorld · 28/04/2023 08:28

I'm in an EU country with statutory health insurance paid for as a % of income and it's definitely not all private rooms and wine lists, and you have to use your initiative a bit (GP will happily refer to specialists for most things and you can choose one but have to look around and sometimes ring around to see where appts are available) but if you need treatment you get it, within a reasonable and safe timeframe. A 6-month wait for psychotherapy can happen but is considered unacceptable, and once you get it you get an absolute minimum of 25 sessions. If you have an acute problem you can go straight to a GP or specialist (ENT with an ear infection, orthopaedist with neck or back pain, gynae with mid-cycle bleeding etc) and generally be seen the same day or same week at least, although you may have to wait an hour or two in the practice. Same for an ill child except you go straight to their paediatrician. I pay 500 or 600 a month (because I work for myself I also pay the employer's half of the statutory insurance contribution) and some years I'm sure I don't 'use' all I pay in, but it's worth it to know I'm helping keeping a system run for everyone.

CareBearScare123 · 28/04/2023 08:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 08:21

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Oh yes, there it is. Suck it up and don't moan. The NHS is afterall doing you a huge favour by treating you....

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 08:20

Oblomov23 · 28/04/2023 08:19

I'm having problems now. I fell over and hurt my back beginning February. Had xray, 8 week wait for ultrasound. Then referred to msk. Can't get a mri until been seen by MSK consultant to authorise it. 13 week wait minimum for MSK appointment. I'm at 3 months now. That'll be 6 months then, after falling over then? How can anyone think that's ok?

This is the sort of thing I am talking about. If you complain you are seen as ungrateful for not appreciating your "free" healthcare.

CareBearScare123 · 28/04/2023 08:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Oblomov23 · 28/04/2023 08:19

I'm having problems now. I fell over and hurt my back beginning February. Had xray, 8 week wait for ultrasound. Then referred to msk. Can't get a mri until been seen by MSK consultant to authorise it. 13 week wait minimum for MSK appointment. I'm at 3 months now. That'll be 6 months then, after falling over then? How can anyone think that's ok?

Florissante · 28/04/2023 08:18

People would have to pay premiums, like in Europe

Number 1 on the list of Things That Will Never Happen.

wombridgewalkabout · 28/04/2023 08:18

Leaving the EU has led to this latest crisis, not Covid

Look, I have had a chronic health condition for 30 years and can tell you that problems in the NHS well precede Brexit!

Brexit may well be your hobby horse but it is beyond simplistic to think that is one single cause to the current dire state of the NHS. There are many causes which have come together at this time to create the rather failing system we have now.

People are dying in our NHS system who don’t need to. People are suffering badly who don’t need to. People are spending literally years unable to work as they wait for operations. It’s utterly awful.

And you still get ideological numpties like those in this thread saying, ‘ another NHS bashing thread I see’ because they don’t want to face up to the problems, and they confuse being acerbic with argument.

Howpo · 28/04/2023 08:14

TodayInahurry · 28/04/2023 08:12

I have private health insurance, you get your own room in private hospitals, the staff are generally pleasant and you get good treatment. The NHS is a disaster the government throws £billions at it, badly managed, obsessed with current fads and squanders cash.

the UK needs to adopt medical systems in line with France, Germany etc rather than keep the NHS alive. People would have to pay premiums, like in Europe

Lucky you.

Typical Tory response!

Howpo · 28/04/2023 08:13

Just so we can blow apart the myth we spend a lot on health or we match europe or its down to bad management.

  • This analysis examines how health care spending in the UK compares with EU countries in the decade preceding the pandemic.
  • Average day-to-day health spending in the UK between 2010 and 2019 was £3,005 per person – 18% below the EU14 average of £3,655.
  • If UK spending per person had matched the EU14 average, then the UK would have spent an average of £227bn a year on health between 2010 and 2019 – £40bn higher than actual average annual spending during this period (£187bn).
  • Matching spending per head to France or Germany would have led to an additional £40bn and £73bn (21% to 39% increase respectively) of total health spending each year in the UK.
  • Over the past decade, the UK had a lower level of capital investment in health care compared with the EU14 countries for which data are available. Between 2010 and 2019, average health capital investment in the UK was £5.8bn a year. If the UK had matched other EU14 countries’ average investment in health capital (as a share of GDP), the UK would have invested £33bn more between 2010 and 2019 (around 55% higher than actual investment during that period).
-
Swipe left for the next trending thread