Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people have inflated view of our healthcare system?

181 replies

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:10

I've had treatment abroad twice and I wouldn't hesitate to get elective treatment abroad again this was the EU. The staff spoke perfect English there was an ICU in the hospital. I was offered pre op sedation because i was anxious ,I had my own private room , I was nursed with one other patient and there was 2 nurses on shift so 1:1 ratio my pain was perfectly managed. In comparison over here ive been expected to have gynaecological procedures with no pain relief. I had great protein filled meals with fish plenty of vegetables great for healing. (High carb slop offered here.)

I had dressings changed , post op care wirh docfor and I stayed 4 weeks to ensure everything was healing well. I keep hearing people say they would never get treatment abroad you will die etc they treat the UK as some holy grail of healthcare. People who go abroad are stupid etc.I have been left in pain multiple times in our health care system. My DD when she fell ill in Singapore had a team of doctors waiting for her at the hospital.
Preparing to be flamed but AIBU to think our healthcare system isn't that great? Many people haven't actually experienced care abroad so assume ours must naturally be the best?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 12:08

Btw, I don't want private healthcare. I want an actual NHS that works and treats people as they should be treated. That's not going to happen by holding your ears and just repeating "everything is fine. everything is great."when people are complaining.

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 12:06

fiftiesmum · 28/04/2023 11:58

It isn't failing but the government are gaslighting people into thinking it is as they want people to go private. There have always been waiting lists and people have always moaned about the food (preferring to send out for McDonald's or kfc).
Just remember to read the small print of your insurance policy - they are beginning to refuse expensive treatments (including cancer) and not renew if you have claimed.
This government wants you to transfer to private as they are incapable of running anything.
God help you if you are poor, disabled, old or chronically sick

You don't think it's failing when people are being made to sit for 30 hrs in A&E waiting to be seen? Or not getting tested for cancer? Or waiting 3 years for a hip replacement so they have zero quality of life in the meantime? Or can't gt a nurse to look after their child for 20 mins so they can eat for the first time in two days? Or can't get MH support? Or can't see a GP for love or money? Or can't get an ambulance for their gran who has been lying on a pub floor for 7 hours?

This isn't the goverment. This is real people sharing their experiences. You are gaslighting people into thinking they somehow have it wrong and they ought to put up with this because the NHS is doing just fine and people are just making a mountain out of a molehill and should just be grateful for the wonderful NHS.

fiftiesmum · 28/04/2023 11:58

It isn't failing but the government are gaslighting people into thinking it is as they want people to go private. There have always been waiting lists and people have always moaned about the food (preferring to send out for McDonald's or kfc).
Just remember to read the small print of your insurance policy - they are beginning to refuse expensive treatments (including cancer) and not renew if you have claimed.
This government wants you to transfer to private as they are incapable of running anything.
God help you if you are poor, disabled, old or chronically sick

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 11:34

Howpo · 28/04/2023 11:16

You and others are saying the NHS is wasteful and poorly managed etc but where is your evidence for this?

Btw anecdotal doesn't count.

When efficiency is compared to other health systems, the NHS does well, does more for less... but its on outcomes that it fails and thats down to lower staff numbers and less equipment.

But why has the UK allowed the NHS to fail?

Put simply, those in power don't use it, they see it as one of the last 1940s and 50s "socialist constructs" and want it gone, they cannot of course voice this publicly so dismantle the NHS bit by bit, as they also do with education.

what i really don't get is why Labour are not using this to put a clear divide between them and the Tories, they appear to be letting the Tory party control the narrative or maybe they want it gone too?

The 1940s is a widely different era for healthcare there wasn't many effective treatments for life limiting conditions. People died a lot quicker, smaller population less advanced age. It's a victim of its own success. If we want a brilliant healthcare system we will have to pay more in taxes and copay. It's going two tier already I rarely see the NHS anymore and I'm assuming a lot of people with disposable income are the same. We need to pay staff competitive wages in line with other Western countries.

A&E I saw a queue of elderly people on trolleys in corridors horrific to see and something I thought I would not see in 2023. Because its free they should be grateful ?

OP posts:
Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 11:18

Howpo · 28/04/2023 11:16

You and others are saying the NHS is wasteful and poorly managed etc but where is your evidence for this?

Btw anecdotal doesn't count.

When efficiency is compared to other health systems, the NHS does well, does more for less... but its on outcomes that it fails and thats down to lower staff numbers and less equipment.

But why has the UK allowed the NHS to fail?

Put simply, those in power don't use it, they see it as one of the last 1940s and 50s "socialist constructs" and want it gone, they cannot of course voice this publicly so dismantle the NHS bit by bit, as they also do with education.

what i really don't get is why Labour are not using this to put a clear divide between them and the Tories, they appear to be letting the Tory party control the narrative or maybe they want it gone too?

Or, conversly, if it was efficient and successful why is it failing?

Howpo · 28/04/2023 11:16

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 10:36

No, that's not what I am saying. I am saying a lot of the NHS is wasteful and inefficient. And in an attempt to plaster over the cracks they are bringing in inefficient privatised services which doesn't fix anything because the root cause is not being addressed.

You and others are saying the NHS is wasteful and poorly managed etc but where is your evidence for this?

Btw anecdotal doesn't count.

When efficiency is compared to other health systems, the NHS does well, does more for less... but its on outcomes that it fails and thats down to lower staff numbers and less equipment.

But why has the UK allowed the NHS to fail?

Put simply, those in power don't use it, they see it as one of the last 1940s and 50s "socialist constructs" and want it gone, they cannot of course voice this publicly so dismantle the NHS bit by bit, as they also do with education.

what i really don't get is why Labour are not using this to put a clear divide between them and the Tories, they appear to be letting the Tory party control the narrative or maybe they want it gone too?

Starchipenterprise · 28/04/2023 11:02

I have received excellent emergency NHS care, not flawless but still excellent and long term too. Top of the class for that kind of care. I appreciate primary care is struggling in the UK. However I don't see how you can compare the care I had from the NHS with elective care in another country. I would never choose elective care in another country that did not have access to an ITU - even in the UK I would ensure there was adequate local provision.

As others have said it's not the staff that are the problem. It's the structure and consistency of management and funding.

EvelynSalt · 28/04/2023 10:59

Perhaps if hospital departments were accountable for their own budgets which were directly linked to KPIs and performance (including patient feedback stats), the poorly managed ones might show some improvement.

The NHS is a beast, inevitably some hospitals, some departments, some trusts will be run badly. But that can only change, surely, if they are held accountable and people are rewarded for good performance (and sacked for poor performance)?

To add to the anecdotes on this thread, I had every major milestone and test missed by the maternity team that cared for me. The response was to get someone senior to help me out, which was nice, but doesn't resolve the issue of administrative or performance related incompetence. That team just carries on treating other patients who risk the same issues.

I guess what I'm asking, as someone who is admittedly a total layman, is would a privatised business culture, without the privatisation, at least improve things to a basic level more consistently?

CareBearScare123 · 28/04/2023 10:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 10:36

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 09:41

Yes it is slightly different, you were saying the NHS is wasteful and inefficient and that the privatised bits fix that in pockets. They don’t the privatised bits fix low quality care in pockets, but they are the hugely wasteful and inefficient bits that are then dragging down the quality of care in the rest of the NHS.

No, that's not what I am saying. I am saying a lot of the NHS is wasteful and inefficient. And in an attempt to plaster over the cracks they are bringing in inefficient privatised services which doesn't fix anything because the root cause is not being addressed.

CareBearScare123 · 28/04/2023 10:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Annabel073 · 28/04/2023 10:02

I think a big contribution to this is doctors often reluctant to do diagnostic test (probably for cost reasons) unless you fit neatly into the typically presenting cancer patient.

Also poor awareness among GPs leading to mis- or delayed diagnosis. Primary care needs a complete overhaul with a much greater focus on continuing education for GPs.

Sidking · 28/04/2023 10:01

Haven't rtft just got up to the cancer stats and I can quite believe it.

My dad was diagnosed with cancer in an awkward place (somewhere in his sinuses, so hard to reach), had radiotherapy (and maybe chemo I can't remember my memory is terrible) about 3 years ago. When he had finished the treatment plan they signed him off saying he's now fine, but they never bothered to rescan him.

Of course he wasn't fine, cancer wasn't completely gone and about 18 months ago they found out it had grown back, because it's come back in a fairly short space of time they said his options are limited. He's had all the chemo they're willing to give for now and that's it, that's his lot.

It's not gone, but it's shrunk again, they say if it comes back (as it's sinuses he gets symptomatic at a certain point) within 9 months there's nothing they will do, if it's after that point they will consider more chemo. They won't consider surgery because of the placement though I'm sure it's not impossible, we can do microscopic surgery now!

ChillLil · 28/04/2023 09:59

I have had a breast issue for some time. No lump that I can find but the texture inside is completely different to my other breast.
I called the gp and was asked by the receptionist if I needed to be seen or would a telephone appointment suffice. I said surely they can't examine my breast over the phone so why take up a telephone appointment when I'll ultimately need to be examined anyway.
So they gave me an appointment with a nurse who did not robustly examine my breast, she just felt it lightly and prescribed ibuprofen gel which I questioned because there isn't pain so much as a sensation. She insisted I use it for 7 days, so I did.
No change.
So I called again, same attempts to avoid a face to face appointment by reception and eventually convinced them I needed to be seen.
Another appointment with same nurse who didn't recall seeing me. Same half hearted examination. Agreed to refer me to breast clinic.
I've now had a letter several weeks later, and I could cry. Its next week but it's a hospital telephone appointment. This will be the 3rd appointment and there is no way I don't need a mammogram. That cannot be done over the phone.
All these attempts to fob me off could actually kill me.

The funding issue won't be solved with more money if the NHS continues to be run by idiots.
My breast feels worse and is bigger. I'm scared but nobody gives a shit.

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 09:54

And switching systems costs money. Billions of £££. I’d rather any extra billions go to delivering healthcare, not think tank reports and then a slew of government contracts to de-nationalise some or all of our healthcare.

We are terrible at it anyway. Denationalisation has failed on every service we have privatised- our rail system is utter shit and expensive, our water system is aging and pumping sewage so we literally have rivers and oceans of poo, our gas/electric is a third higher than in mainland Europe and the war in Ukraine affected them too plus the whole system is aging due to no investment into upkeep, our telecommunications - 4/5G sucks anywhere outside London again down to private companies prioritising profit over network maintenance and upgrades.

Howpo · 28/04/2023 09:50

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 09:35

That's not different to what I am saying though. Yes they are inefficient economically, but they are there to plug holes, fix cracks, rather than actually addressing the full thing.

Like any organisation, if its properly staffed, tends to be run more efficiently.

I asked my DD what makes your ward run smoothly, she replied when fully staffed but thats a rarity, so things get missed, people don't get the care required, patients come back in & so it goes on.

Private companies are there to make profit, they will exploit the NHS to make more money... look at the report into the Priory Group published recently.

Frabbits · 28/04/2023 09:45

The NHS, when it works, is a treasure everyone should fight tooth and nail for. Having experienced the absolute shitshow that is the US healthcare system it's obvious that any country with asperations to true social equality has to have a system where anyone and everyone can access healthcare without having to worry about the cost of it.

The problem is, of course, that we have had 13 years of the tories fucking the NHS up just as they have fucked everything else up.

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 09:43

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 09:30

But you do know that the choices aren't a faltering NHS OR a US private health care system right? There's an inbetween.

Yes. But given that the NHS was the #1 healthcare system in the world for decades prior to being sucked dry by the Tory government who’s goal is to privatise it and line their pockets, it’s not the system that is the issue. There is no need to overhaul and switch to another system. All that is needed is to properly fund the system we have.

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 09:41

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 09:35

That's not different to what I am saying though. Yes they are inefficient economically, but they are there to plug holes, fix cracks, rather than actually addressing the full thing.

Yes it is slightly different, you were saying the NHS is wasteful and inefficient and that the privatised bits fix that in pockets. They don’t the privatised bits fix low quality care in pockets, but they are the hugely wasteful and inefficient bits that are then dragging down the quality of care in the rest of the NHS.

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 09:39

Lapland123 · 28/04/2023 08:35

a major part of current crisis is staffing.
You realise there won’t magically be more staff, don’t you?
Though at least the private business healthcare model you are promoting would get nowhere without staff and would boost pay for HCP which the government are currently denying. I would not like to work in the system but I’d be happy with the 45% pay erosion for doctors being reversed and believe I would be much better paid as a vital person in a business model. A lot of the ‘project managers’ would go. More money to nurses, other frontline clinical staff.

The pay erosion suffered by doctors is the same pay erosion all workers have suffered due to the U.K. getting poorer as a country. When analysed by industry, the pay erosion suffered by NHS workers has been less than workers in other industries. I don’t think you’d get a pay boost under a private business model, or if you did it would not even offset the much higher out of pocket cost of professional liability insurance that would come with it.

mondaytosunday · 28/04/2023 09:38

The treatment my father got in a shiny new hospital in Spain after a stroke was terrible. The treatment he got at a London hospital after we flew him home was exemplary.
My experience has generally been very positive. My family lives in America and paying for insurance is their main consideration when changing jobs, and the cost is unbelievable even with good insurance.
Other than Spain and US I have no other experience of healthcare, I think if you are paying then you will get better care.

yoga4meinthemorning · 28/04/2023 09:37

The country is being run by the rich who use private medical care.

They will let the nhs rot.

Turkey is going to do so well from nhs refugees in the years to come.

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 09:35

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 09:33

You have it backwards, the privatised bits have the biggest waste of money. Yeah they function ok in terms of performance but the price tag includes far too much profit.

That's not different to what I am saying though. Yes they are inefficient economically, but they are there to plug holes, fix cracks, rather than actually addressing the full thing.

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 09:34

Howpo · 28/04/2023 08:13

Just so we can blow apart the myth we spend a lot on health or we match europe or its down to bad management.

  • This analysis examines how health care spending in the UK compares with EU countries in the decade preceding the pandemic.
  • Average day-to-day health spending in the UK between 2010 and 2019 was £3,005 per person – 18% below the EU14 average of £3,655.
  • If UK spending per person had matched the EU14 average, then the UK would have spent an average of £227bn a year on health between 2010 and 2019 – £40bn higher than actual average annual spending during this period (£187bn).
  • Matching spending per head to France or Germany would have led to an additional £40bn and £73bn (21% to 39% increase respectively) of total health spending each year in the UK.
  • Over the past decade, the UK had a lower level of capital investment in health care compared with the EU14 countries for which data are available. Between 2010 and 2019, average health capital investment in the UK was £5.8bn a year. If the UK had matched other EU14 countries’ average investment in health capital (as a share of GDP), the UK would have invested £33bn more between 2010 and 2019 (around 55% higher than actual investment during that period).
-

Thank you howpo. These are the figures people need to see.

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 09:33

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 08:08

The issue with this sort of thing is it's all sticking plasters. The NHS is hugely wasteful and disfunctional and then pockets are changed or privatised to fix those pockets, but it's just putting plaster on plaster on plaster rather than treating the wound. The whole thing needs to be pulled apart and reorganised, but that is likely such a daunting task it will never happen.

The other thing is the lack of accountability. People are made to feel like because it's "free" they should just be grateful with whatever care they get and shouldn't even dare complain if it's subpar and really impacting their wellbing. When actually we are all paying for the NHS, quite a lot as well.

You have it backwards, the privatised bits have the biggest waste of money. Yeah they function ok in terms of performance but the price tag includes far too much profit.