Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people have inflated view of our healthcare system?

181 replies

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 00:10

I've had treatment abroad twice and I wouldn't hesitate to get elective treatment abroad again this was the EU. The staff spoke perfect English there was an ICU in the hospital. I was offered pre op sedation because i was anxious ,I had my own private room , I was nursed with one other patient and there was 2 nurses on shift so 1:1 ratio my pain was perfectly managed. In comparison over here ive been expected to have gynaecological procedures with no pain relief. I had great protein filled meals with fish plenty of vegetables great for healing. (High carb slop offered here.)

I had dressings changed , post op care wirh docfor and I stayed 4 weeks to ensure everything was healing well. I keep hearing people say they would never get treatment abroad you will die etc they treat the UK as some holy grail of healthcare. People who go abroad are stupid etc.I have been left in pain multiple times in our health care system. My DD when she fell ill in Singapore had a team of doctors waiting for her at the hospital.
Preparing to be flamed but AIBU to think our healthcare system isn't that great? Many people haven't actually experienced care abroad so assume ours must naturally be the best?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
SweetSakura · 04/05/2023 16:19

Burgoo · 29/04/2023 11:58

No. If anything people bash it much more than is reasonable.

The money is there in many cases though the actual staff aren't available. Why? Because people abuse our nurses, demand more and more from the service and misuse it.

I have worked in the NHS for decades - at one point my average "did not attend" rate was 25 HOURS a month. TWENTY FIVE HOURS of non-attendance. I worked in outpatients so I couldn't just randomly book someone else into those slots. We have wait lists going into years and yet people don't respect or appreciate what is being offered. It is terribly demoralising and I often think "why are you wasting our time?"

There is also a huge issue with bureaucratic BS which doesn't help. We have to document EVERY TINY THING to the point that we spend upward of 60% of our working days on documenting things, in case someone complains.

Then there are so many issues with the way things are joined up. I had a medical complication not long back and went to A&E. I was told I needed to see a specialist and I had to go back to my GP to get a referral to that specialist. A specialist that was literally OVER THE CORRIDOR! I asked why they couldn't just send the referral over themselves but got told that it has to go through the GP because of commissioning. So it was a few weeks for a GP appointment just to ask them to refer on. Then multiple weeks before I got a specialist appointment.

I used to love the job when we could assess and treat complex conditions. It sound be seamless. If I have a problem with a patient I should be able to call another department and say "hey could you pop down at some point and review this case please?" and it just happens. Instead we have to do a formal referral, that gets triaged, then it gets put on a list blah blah blah. It is a never ending shitshow. Back in the "good ol days" we could have a ten minute chat with a colleague from another area and have no hassle. Its now a nightmare because of funding issues.

I always bang on about this but we need a few things here:

  1. People need to take MUCH more responsibility for their health. I recently got told I was overweight. I know that can lead to diabetes, heart disease etc. What did I do? Lost 8kg by dieting and exercising (and NOT lying to myself about what I am eating).
  2. Realise all the additional extras chip away at what is offered. Carers assessments? More money directed from clinical care. Equality officers. Same. Satisfaction questionnaires? Ditto. Patient outreach groups. Argh.
  3. If people DNA appointments there should be a charge. I don't buy that people can't let us know in advance for a huge majority of situations. They are lazy and it isn't okay.
  4. We need to get away from treatment to prevention. This means taking ownership and active steps to avoid getting ill. For example, I have a friend who works in psychiatry. People arrive having a poor diet, poor sleep hygiene, using alcohol to excess, sitting indoors and not socialising... these should be addressed before they even hit my colleagues office!

There is also a tendency (and it is a BIG issue) of people demanding to get diagnosis when it will not have any benefit for them and/or help for conditions that simply aren't all that severe. I've often had patients say they want an assessment because they are "curious" about whether they have a condition. CURIOUS! No. If you want to get assessed to satiate your curiosity you can pay for it, privately. At £1000 a pop.

I get very passionate about this. The NHS is misused and abused to a massive degree. It was NOT set up as a catch all for every social and health-care ill. Originally it was for actual health issues - now it is a monolith that is expected to take responsibility for everyone's (often poor) life choices.

I was with you till you got to point 4...

People who are distressed for whatever reason understandably get into bad and unhelpful habits and find it hard to get out of them. So of course that's how they present.

And "curiosity" over a niggling condition could save a patient's life. I kept going backwards and forwards to GPs who took your same dismissive tone about my health worries.... Eventually,. thankfully, a switched on optician spotted my ptosis and twigged that I might have Myasthenia Gravis. Thanks to the lack of "curiousity" from GPs I missed a chance for an early diagnosis, with better treatment options. It also meant that in all those years without diagnosis (including the pandemic years) if I had had an emergency health situation I may have been treated in a way that made me much iller or was fatal. So I struggle to forgive the GPs who didn't want to investigate further into what was making me ill. They left me hugely vulnerable for years

Coffeelotsofcoffee · 04/05/2023 06:44

I had fertility treatment in the czech Republic. After many failed ivf cycles here.
Absolutely amazing care and professionalism. Oh and it worked too

JaneorEleven · 04/05/2023 06:13

ChopperC110P · 28/04/2023 09:29

That happened to a friend of mine in the US. She died after hitting her cap.
she was 34.

I get that people die here too when the NHS refuses them treatment, but I’d rather there be a nationwide policy decided by doctors that applies to everyone instead of what you have in the US where whether you get treatment is up to some insurance company employee who’s job security is literally based on how much money he/she can save the company.

The ACA (Affordable care act or Obamacare) has stopped Lifetime limits on insurance policies. https://www.hhs.gov/healthcare/about-the-aca/benefit-limits/index.html

HHS logo

Lifetime & Annual Limits

The current law prohibits health plans from putting annual and lifetime dollar limits on most benefits you receive.

https://www.hhs.gov/healthcare/about-the-aca/benefit-limits/index.html

Eviebeans · 04/05/2023 05:05

I can only speak for the services that I’ve had access to recently which have been excellent. Had an appointment at my gp surgery on 14th April, hospital appointment on 27th April and appointment for procedure on 6th may.
I give no credit to the government for this. The quality care was provided solely by committed staff within the NHS.
we should be looking at the reasons why not everyone has the same positive experience. If one Trust can do it then why can’t others.

AmIThatMam · 03/05/2023 22:09

I think people are protective over it. I get a bit defensive if anyone slags it off! I know there are massive problems but the basis on which it was started, the idea of universal health care, free at the point of use IS something that should be defended. It’s just shit that it’s being dismantled by Tory shit show.

Burgoo · 29/04/2023 11:58

No. If anything people bash it much more than is reasonable.

The money is there in many cases though the actual staff aren't available. Why? Because people abuse our nurses, demand more and more from the service and misuse it.

I have worked in the NHS for decades - at one point my average "did not attend" rate was 25 HOURS a month. TWENTY FIVE HOURS of non-attendance. I worked in outpatients so I couldn't just randomly book someone else into those slots. We have wait lists going into years and yet people don't respect or appreciate what is being offered. It is terribly demoralising and I often think "why are you wasting our time?"

There is also a huge issue with bureaucratic BS which doesn't help. We have to document EVERY TINY THING to the point that we spend upward of 60% of our working days on documenting things, in case someone complains.

Then there are so many issues with the way things are joined up. I had a medical complication not long back and went to A&E. I was told I needed to see a specialist and I had to go back to my GP to get a referral to that specialist. A specialist that was literally OVER THE CORRIDOR! I asked why they couldn't just send the referral over themselves but got told that it has to go through the GP because of commissioning. So it was a few weeks for a GP appointment just to ask them to refer on. Then multiple weeks before I got a specialist appointment.

I used to love the job when we could assess and treat complex conditions. It sound be seamless. If I have a problem with a patient I should be able to call another department and say "hey could you pop down at some point and review this case please?" and it just happens. Instead we have to do a formal referral, that gets triaged, then it gets put on a list blah blah blah. It is a never ending shitshow. Back in the "good ol days" we could have a ten minute chat with a colleague from another area and have no hassle. Its now a nightmare because of funding issues.

I always bang on about this but we need a few things here:

  1. People need to take MUCH more responsibility for their health. I recently got told I was overweight. I know that can lead to diabetes, heart disease etc. What did I do? Lost 8kg by dieting and exercising (and NOT lying to myself about what I am eating).
  2. Realise all the additional extras chip away at what is offered. Carers assessments? More money directed from clinical care. Equality officers. Same. Satisfaction questionnaires? Ditto. Patient outreach groups. Argh.
  3. If people DNA appointments there should be a charge. I don't buy that people can't let us know in advance for a huge majority of situations. They are lazy and it isn't okay.
  4. We need to get away from treatment to prevention. This means taking ownership and active steps to avoid getting ill. For example, I have a friend who works in psychiatry. People arrive having a poor diet, poor sleep hygiene, using alcohol to excess, sitting indoors and not socialising... these should be addressed before they even hit my colleagues office!

There is also a tendency (and it is a BIG issue) of people demanding to get diagnosis when it will not have any benefit for them and/or help for conditions that simply aren't all that severe. I've often had patients say they want an assessment because they are "curious" about whether they have a condition. CURIOUS! No. If you want to get assessed to satiate your curiosity you can pay for it, privately. At £1000 a pop.

I get very passionate about this. The NHS is misused and abused to a massive degree. It was NOT set up as a catch all for every social and health-care ill. Originally it was for actual health issues - now it is a monolith that is expected to take responsibility for everyone's (often poor) life choices.

KnickerlessParsons · 29/04/2023 11:24

DH's post cancer op treatment and support has been fantastic - really.
The whole team that support him - surgeon, dietician, SLT, physio, psychologist, nutritionist, ENT - have been really fab. They've responded quickly to any glitches in his recovery. They are available by zoom or phone pretty much anytime he's needed them and offer support and advice by email.
Honestly, I have nothing but praise for the NHS as we've experienced it.

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 29/04/2023 10:53

After having spent the last two months desperately trying to get any help medically and mentally for a dear friend I am still in shock and dis belief at how horrendous and dangerous our healthcare system actually can be.

I can totally see why the suicide rate in this country is so high when it takes days to get any type of response from a doctor or a 24/7 mental health crisis network.

Absolutely shocking

Lapland123 · 29/04/2023 10:25

Kendodd · 29/04/2023 10:10

Agree with most of what you've been saying on this thread, don't agree that we don't have enough people who want to work in healthcare though. What we don't have is enough training places. Medicine particularly, is an extremely difficult university course to get onto, many thousands of young people, who I'm sure many would have made excellent doctors, just don't get a place. I know expanding numbers then puts pressure on hospital rotations, but I'm sure that problem isn't insurmountable.

I think successive governments have just looked at the numbers and decided its cheaper to import medics that train them ourselves.

Agreed.
There are far more young people who could be great doctors who never get near a place.
At the other end to retain doctors and not lose them to other countries we need to address the huge pay erosion. Another poster has mentioned this is universal, but public sector stats show it is far far more in the public rather than private sector. And consultants have had the worst- heading for 45% pay erosion this year. If the country wants to retain fully qualified doctors and not loose them to going abroad where they are paid significantly better than UK, this needs addressing but is a worthwhile intervention. Junior doctors pay erosion needs addressing as well as more training positions or else they will of course go abroad rather than hang here on low pay plus unable to get onto a training run.

The future looks pretty bleak for anyone wanting medical care ( so that’s everyone) if this isn’t addressed but the government seem uninterested.

Kendodd · 29/04/2023 10:10

Howpo · 29/04/2023 08:03

err if we are to have a debate, then it might be a good idea not to embellish what i said?

I said nhs is efficient but poor outcomes NOT it is successful did i?

What is missing here is that the UK has not enough people who want to work in healthcare, we have always had to import medics, from the 50s onwards, its even more of crisis now with not enough school leavers with the correct A levels to go into health and social care hit by huge staff shortages.

However, maybe ask why the Govt refuses to do anything about Social Care? even Boris's plan has be ditched but that plan, weak as it was, had no extra money for wages.

Before reform can take place, we need to get back to an NHS that we had in 2019 or we will just make matters far worse.

Agree with most of what you've been saying on this thread, don't agree that we don't have enough people who want to work in healthcare though. What we don't have is enough training places. Medicine particularly, is an extremely difficult university course to get onto, many thousands of young people, who I'm sure many would have made excellent doctors, just don't get a place. I know expanding numbers then puts pressure on hospital rotations, but I'm sure that problem isn't insurmountable.

I think successive governments have just looked at the numbers and decided its cheaper to import medics that train them ourselves.

Jellycatspyjamas · 29/04/2023 09:22

It sounds like the person needs to access an IAPT talking therapies service as this exactly what they are there for. They aren't always run by NHS trusts in all areas though, some are run by not for profit or private companies. The GP will know.

IAPT doesn’t exist in Scotland, where I’m based.

hettie · 29/04/2023 08:23

Jellycatspyjamas · 28/04/2023 09:26

There’s some glorification of the US system on this thread, ignoring the role that insurance companies have to play.

The problem with having one national, cash strapped, service is that they then have a monopoly on deciding appropriate treatment. That’s not much of a problem when dealing with straightforward physical health issues but is when it comes to things like mental health where recovery is a very personal thing.

We have the glorification of CBT for everything from mild anxiety to complex trauma. CBT has its place but other very effective, relational therapies are often disregarded because they don’t fit an RCT model of evidence, and so the majority of NHS service don’t offer them, at least until you’ve done every other online process, a few rounds of CBT and are basically unable to function. It stifles innovation and reduces choice because trainees go into training with a view to employment at the end of their course so tend towards CBT, fewer practitioners of other modalities and less research into alternative effective treatments.

I was speaking to someone recently looking for therapy for a single traumatic incident that has left them struggling. Her NHS trust had nothing to offer her because she didn’t fit into one of their boxes. They have programmes for sexual abuse, domestic abuse, adult survivors etc etc but nothing for someone who needs support to recover from a single incident of traumatic accident. Relatively straightforward to work with therapeutically but computer says no.

It sounds like the person needs to access an IAPT talking therapies service as this exactly what they are there for. They aren't always run by NHS trusts in all areas though, some are run by not for profit or private companies. The GP will know.

Howpo · 29/04/2023 08:05

@Fererr Yes in one!

We don't spend per capita what is required and Brexit has cut us off from many EU workers happy to work in the NHS and Social Care.

Howpo · 29/04/2023 08:03

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 11:18

Or, conversly, if it was efficient and successful why is it failing?

err if we are to have a debate, then it might be a good idea not to embellish what i said?

I said nhs is efficient but poor outcomes NOT it is successful did i?

What is missing here is that the UK has not enough people who want to work in healthcare, we have always had to import medics, from the 50s onwards, its even more of crisis now with not enough school leavers with the correct A levels to go into health and social care hit by huge staff shortages.

However, maybe ask why the Govt refuses to do anything about Social Care? even Boris's plan has be ditched but that plan, weak as it was, had no extra money for wages.

Before reform can take place, we need to get back to an NHS that we had in 2019 or we will just make matters far worse.

Fererr · 28/04/2023 21:02

Also in 2010 a study by Commonwealth Fund ranked NHS no 1 overall compared to many other similar countries. Tories came in, spending plummeted and now the NHS is struggling.

To think people have inflated view of our healthcare system?
Fererr · 28/04/2023 20:57

Madamecastafiore · 28/04/2023 07:38

NHS isn't underfunded st all. It's badly run and haemorrhaging money.

There needs to be a government brave enough to change how it's funded and how it's run but there are so many idiots in this country that think privatisation means the US model and not that private companies are paid by the government to do the job the creaking dinosaur of the NHS is failing to do that they're scared they'd be an uprising.

It’s a complete lie NHS isn’t underfunded. I quote again what I wrote earlier.

“Health spending per person, adjusted for demographic change, grew at 2% a year under the Conservatives from 1979 to 1997; at 5.7% a year under Labour from 1997 to 2010; at -0.07% from 2010 to 2015; and at -0.03% from 2015 to 2021. In other words, even Margaret Thatcher, who declared there’s no such thing as society, increased NHS funding at a higher rate than the Conservatives in the 2010s. David Cameron declared he wanted to create a “big society”, and he and George Osborne reduced NHS funding per person. Cameron also said that there would be no more top-down reorganisation of the NHS and then, with his health secretary Andrew Lansley, did exactly that. It marked what Chris Ham, former head of the King’s Fund, described as the political failure that led to the decline of the NHS.
Other European countries have taken a different approach. If the UK had increased its healthcare expenditure from 2010 to 2019 as much as France did, we would have increased our current spend by 21%, and by 39% if we had matched Germany. The NHS needs more money. It would help in filling the 150,000 vacant full-time posts. Paying doctors and nurses appropriately would help. But we do need reform as well.”

And believe me the only model Tories would introduce is private for profit healthcare model.

sally-and-john.png,

The past, present and future of government spending on the NHS

With the Chancellor making further updates to government spending plans and the health service facing crisis on several fronts, there is uncertainty over what the future will hold for health care finances amid such instability. How much is this governm...

https://www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/news-item/the-past-present-and-future-of-government-spending-on-the-nhs

Fererr · 28/04/2023 20:44

Today there is a good thread today by a FT journalist on how NHS is acutely short of workers.

“1 in 7* UK-trained doctors are practising overseas. No other developed country is like this, which immediately tells you there’s a problem.”

https://twitter.com/jburnmurdoch/status/1651901173216038913?s=61&t=JdkndO417wUfB5xJiVIJww

https://twitter.com/jburnmurdoch/status/1651901173216038913?s=61&t=JdkndO417wUfB5xJiVIJww

Dorisbonson · 28/04/2023 15:19

Howpo · 28/04/2023 08:07

Based on per capita, which is what really matters and the UK spends far less per person.

We also have far less HCPs, beds, buildings and nurses.... in other words, a lack of investment since it first came into being.

Really don't get the "privatise it/insurance model" how would this generate more staff?
We have to face the fact that we don't have enough A level grade young people and if we encourage them to go into health, that would just leave shortages elsewhere in other sectors.

Leaving the EU has led to this latest crisis, not Covid.

The % element above covers your per capita observation and the UKs GDP per capita (therefore spend in £/$ rather than %) is either greater or comparable to the other countries mentioned. So your observation whilst useful for comparing UK to say India or Switzerland doesnt make a big difference to UK v Germany, Italy etc.

I think the point about privatise it is irrelevant. My personal view is that it's too big to manage properly and needs to broken down into smaller chunks to be more effective. They could all be state owned but better managed. Either way it's too big at the moment.

OdeToBarney · 28/04/2023 13:10

SweetSakura · 28/04/2023 08:41

Agreed. And let's be clear, there are just as many "fucking idiots" (nice) in the private sector. And there are some phenomenally good civil servants doing amazing work and this is a lazy trope.

Completely agree!

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 12:32

Kendodd · 28/04/2023 12:31

The only people I see saying "everything is fine, everything is great" is the government.

@fiftiesmum mum thinks things are just grand and it's all government propaganda:

"It isn't failing but the government are gaslighting people into thinking it is as they want people to go private."

Kendodd · 28/04/2023 12:31

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 12:08

Btw, I don't want private healthcare. I want an actual NHS that works and treats people as they should be treated. That's not going to happen by holding your ears and just repeating "everything is fine. everything is great."when people are complaining.

The only people I see saying "everything is fine, everything is great" is the government.

Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 12:20

Paloma66 · 28/04/2023 12:13

@Runaway0 why do you keep saying the NHS is free? It is not free. We are paying for it. The myth that it is free is what leads to people accepting poor service. It is free at the point of need, but it is not free. There is a very very big difference.

It's certainly not free we paid 60k in taxes last year and services seem to be getting worse.

OP posts:
Runaway0 · 28/04/2023 12:19

Iloveautumncolours · 28/04/2023 12:13

I think some people have a very unrealistic view on what healthcare looks like for people in other countries. Yes, if you are a high earner or are lucky enough to have a decent healthcare package with a job then you have nothing to worry about but if you are much poorer, life isn’t so rosey.
I used to work for the NHS in the maternity ward. We had obstetricians over from the states and I remember them saying that the rates of c-sections we’re so much higher than the U.K. and that was often down to getting as much out of the insurance companies as they could.
My gastroenterologist also told me the reason people are out under GA’s during colonoscopies in the USA is also down to money and the incidents of bowel perforation during colonoscopies is much higher in the US than over here in the U.K. where they tend to opt mainly for sedation.
I have a chronic health condition and am on several FB support groups, it saddens me just how many people over there are suffering and can not get hold of regular medication or standard procedures because their health insurance will not cover it and they don’t earn enough to get higher insurance. As an average earner myself this scares me shitless, I just hope our government never follows the US. With all of these things if you are health and earn well then life is a dream.
We can’t all be high earners for a myriad of reasons and I certainly don’t want to be like the unfortunate people in the US queuing for days at shopping malls just to get free or cheap treatment for everyday issues like hernias.

There's many other countries who don't follow the US system. It's not the US vs NHS no other countries copy the nhs system if it was that amazing they would?

OP posts:
Paloma66 · 28/04/2023 12:13

@Runaway0 why do you keep saying the NHS is free? It is not free. We are paying for it. The myth that it is free is what leads to people accepting poor service. It is free at the point of need, but it is not free. There is a very very big difference.

Iloveautumncolours · 28/04/2023 12:13

I think some people have a very unrealistic view on what healthcare looks like for people in other countries. Yes, if you are a high earner or are lucky enough to have a decent healthcare package with a job then you have nothing to worry about but if you are much poorer, life isn’t so rosey.
I used to work for the NHS in the maternity ward. We had obstetricians over from the states and I remember them saying that the rates of c-sections we’re so much higher than the U.K. and that was often down to getting as much out of the insurance companies as they could.
My gastroenterologist also told me the reason people are out under GA’s during colonoscopies in the USA is also down to money and the incidents of bowel perforation during colonoscopies is much higher in the US than over here in the U.K. where they tend to opt mainly for sedation.
I have a chronic health condition and am on several FB support groups, it saddens me just how many people over there are suffering and can not get hold of regular medication or standard procedures because their health insurance will not cover it and they don’t earn enough to get higher insurance. As an average earner myself this scares me shitless, I just hope our government never follows the US. With all of these things if you are health and earn well then life is a dream.
We can’t all be high earners for a myriad of reasons and I certainly don’t want to be like the unfortunate people in the US queuing for days at shopping malls just to get free or cheap treatment for everyday issues like hernias.