Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t trust pensions

119 replies

Orangepolentacake · 27/04/2023 13:37

I’m in my mid-30s and, for the first time, in a decent position to properly save for the future, pay into a pension, invest.

I also have some medical conditions, which means it’s possible I won’t live to see mid-70s, if that.

I know pensions come with tax and employer matching benefits but, hear me out:

I don’t trust pensions partly because the goal posts keep changing. Minimum access age for pensions is currently 55. This will soon increase to 57. It could keep increasing and increasing until it matches state pension age. What’s to say it won’t? What is certain is the average person won’t have much of a say in this.
And state pension age could be almost 80 by the time I reach the current retirement age of 67.

then there’s the matter of inheritance. I can nominate a beneficiary but, depending on how I choose to access my pension, the beneficiary won’t have access in case of my death. Who knows what perceived priorities I’ll have at an unknown age in the future and/or minor mistakes with drastic consequences I’ll make. The goalposts can just change along with access age and all my savings are then lost into some ether and my family isn’t able to access them. I don’t think the latter is that unlikely, given ageing population and need to fund longer lives with long term conditions etc

AIBU? What is the best and safest way to save for the future?

OP posts:
3BSHKATS · 27/04/2023 16:27

£618,000 they should have by 55. If they never contribute a penny, which they obviously will. But the power of compounded interest shouldn't be under estimated. Compare this with the child investment thing they all got at birth that yielded about £150 over 18 years

3BSHKATS · 27/04/2023 16:20

FloydPepper · 27/04/2023 16:07

Sorry 100 a month for 25 years, so approx 30k

so that 30 becomes 600?

Yes and thats a conservative estimate

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 27/04/2023 16:15

FloydPepper · 27/04/2023 16:06

Interesting. A 5k investment now becomes 30k a year (so a lot worth 600k?). In real terms?

feels very optimistic unless I’m missing something

You are missing something. The monthly contribution.

She has (and will continue to) put £100 a month into each child's pension from birth to age 25.

The £5k was an additional top up.

£100 a month for 25 years is £30k total contribution but there is compound interest on that which will mean it is worth MUCH more by the time the child is 57.

Hermione101 · 27/04/2023 16:07

For those asking about children's pensions, you can open up a junior SIPP from birth and you get similar tax advantages. If you put your money onto a low-cost S&P 500 index fund, which historically returns 8%. If you contribute 100/month until they are 18 and then contribute nothing at all, due to the beauty of compound interest x time in the markets, that pension pot will be around £1m. We do this for my DS.

OP, if I were you I wouldn't miss out on employer contributions, you're walking away from free money and the associated tax advantages. You could just contribute up to your employer match and put the rest in an S&S ISA for easier access. If you don't know what to invest in, educate yourself, and low-cost index funds are usually a good place to start. If you don't know much about investing, you likely won't be in high-risk assets, so at your age and unless you're a day trader, I wouldn't be worried about turbulent markets. If you're worried about "loss" the closer you are to retirement age, there is nothing stopping you from selling the assets in your pension and holding only cash or other relatively risk-free assets.

FloydPepper · 27/04/2023 16:07

Sorry 100 a month for 25 years, so approx 30k

so that 30 becomes 600?

AskMeMore · 27/04/2023 16:07

I agree OP. The age will increase from 57 to at least 60. My DP has an illness which means he never gets to claim his pension.

FloydPepper · 27/04/2023 16:06

3BSHKATS · 27/04/2023 15:00

It will be yes, assuming there's no 1920's style crashes but even then, they have 45 years to recover from them if they retire at 57.

Interesting. A 5k investment now becomes 30k a year (so a lot worth 600k?). In real terms?

feels very optimistic unless I’m missing something

declutteringmymind · 27/04/2023 16:00

Have a look at a SIPP. you are in full control of when you take the money. You just have to pay income tax, but can only really withdraw after 57.

I have one and will use it whil I'm waiting for my occupational and state pension to kick in.

Marmight · 27/04/2023 16:00

The government will never do away with the state pension. It would be a massive political own goal.
It's the biggest benefit cost at the moment.
Why would the UK be out of step with the rest of the developed nations?
Unless of course, all the developed nations are going to get rid of their state pensions too.
One way to reduce cost is to manage when the state pension becomes payable. Raise the age. Which the government are doing.
Have you seen the riots in France recently where they have raised the age from 62 to 64?

Inthesamesinkingboat · 27/04/2023 15:55

I don’t trust the state pension, I think that will have been done away with for most by time I retire. My suspicion is that state pension will only be available for those with little or no private pension and those of us with private pensions will be no better off than those who have not bothered saving.

restisall · 27/04/2023 15:50

I do trust pensions and pay heavily into mine but if you’re really worried you could get a LISA instead to save for old age? (I have both)

Pros

  • you get a 25% bonus from the government.
  • the money will be entirely tax free on withdrawal.
  • can be withdrawn at age 60.
  • this one is speculative but I believe the take up of them has been fairly small so there will likely be less incentive for the government to change the rules about when you can access them… if they even can change them, as they are tied to age 60 rather than ‘10 years before retirement age’ as with pensions.

Cons (compared to a pension)

  • no employer contribution (missing out on free money!)
  • you will have paid tax on the money before you pay it into a LISA.
  • if you’re a higher rate tax payer, you miss out on higher rate tax relief.
  • you have to open one before you’re 40 and can only pay in til you’re 50.

Have I missed any obvious ones?

3BSHKATS · 27/04/2023 15:48

CaptainSeven · 27/04/2023 15:41

Do you mean you still pay £100 per month or did you contribute a value of £5,000 total and have stopped?

We pay £20 per month into our DC pensions.

£100 a month, will continue until they are 25. And £5000 to even things up in one kids pension due to starting later on. and a few gaps. They are all at the same stage now.

PieInSpace · 27/04/2023 15:47

I think you're getting a hard time unfairly, OP. It's not a stupid concern at all. The tax incentives for pension saving are currently good but you are correct that there is huge risk not just in terms of investment risk as with any investment, but regulatory risk, particularly in terms of changing tax treatment for withdrawals or access age limits, as you note.

This is why various Governments raiding private pensions and changing rules has caused such damage to public trust in the system. We really need cross-party agreement that there will be a stable platform without further changes to encourage more people to save more, but sadly there's no sign of this.

As some PPs have suggested it is probably best to reduce risk by investing some money into a pension and some into ISAs etc, where the money has been taxed already and you have more control over it.

CaptainSeven · 27/04/2023 15:41

3BSHKATS · 27/04/2023 14:24

£100 per month per child.
I've topped it up a bit to even everything out to the tune of £5000 each.
But that's it now anything they choose to pay is a bonus, I'll be looking after them forever more beyond the grave.

Do you mean you still pay £100 per month or did you contribute a value of £5,000 total and have stopped?

We pay £20 per month into our DC pensions.

lunaloveroo · 27/04/2023 15:41

I have a LISA (alongside several pension pots). I pay in the maximum of 4K per year and government tops up by 1k. You need to open before you're 40. Can take out when you're 60. The gov.uk website has info on them. It's not just to buy a house.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/04/2023 15:39

Oh dear, I think I should be investing in aluminum foil with all these hats needed for some in this thread.

No investment is perfect…all of them have risks, none of them are appropriate for everyone. So the only thing you can do is to educate yourself, perform your own risk analysis, outline your goals, choose the best option(s) for your circumstances, and continue to re-evaluate your choices.

3BSHKATS · 27/04/2023 15:35

Precisely the reason pensions are being made to look attractive and buy to let being taxed to the hilt is to stop that kind of thinking, it's not good for society

Fererr · 27/04/2023 15:32

Moreorlessmentallystable · 27/04/2023 15:26

Assets. Tangible assets are the backbone of the economy, think property, gold, land,etc. When you think about it. I don't trust pensions either, you have good years and bad years and in the end is never growing enough, so with inflation you are losing money ..don't understand what's the point of it when I could take out and use it in property for example...

I wish property wasn’t viewed as an investment as it has contributed to our inflated housing market. Great for some, utterly crap for many.

Owchy · 27/04/2023 15:31

It’s hard as employer contributions are ‘free money’ plus tax benefits, but yes it seems like it’s tied up, there’s a limit to how it performs depending on control if it’s a group pension etc.

I have a pension and am of the view that is one of several investment assets for my retirement. House, cash (ISAs) pension and stocks. I’m not saying you have to be super wealthy, it’s about ratios in each. I take the view I’m a spread-better and can have instant access vs longer term pension. Higher and lower risk etc.

Fererr · 27/04/2023 15:31

3BSHKATS · 27/04/2023 15:00

It will be yes, assuming there's no 1920's style crashes but even then, they have 45 years to recover from them if they retire at 57.

Thanks. Wow, what a wonderful thing to be able to do for your children.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 27/04/2023 15:26

Assets. Tangible assets are the backbone of the economy, think property, gold, land,etc. When you think about it. I don't trust pensions either, you have good years and bad years and in the end is never growing enough, so with inflation you are losing money ..don't understand what's the point of it when I could take out and use it in property for example...

3BSHKATS · 27/04/2023 15:24

LakeTiticaca · 27/04/2023 15:21

You can trace these small pension pots yourself free of charge, you just need to know the name.of the company. You can then consolidate them into one pension pot or cash them.in if you are old enough. Don't use these firms who charge you % of the pot, you can do it for free yourself

And if you don't know the name of the company ? From memory they ask for dates and account numbers too.
We have a lot of catching up to do in terms of tracing services.

WannabeMathematician · 27/04/2023 15:23

@Orangepolentacake Ok, the house that's not your main residence makes things more complicated. The fact that it's not your main residence does have inheritance implications.

I'm not sure about Telling you about LISAs or ISAs as I'm not
sure how far your worry about changing the goal post goes. These are both tax
free wrappers (The gains you make in them a tax free) but have rules about how
much you can put in and how much you can take out. The LISA can only be used
for your first house or retirement, and I think if you're married to someone
who already owns a house you might not be a first-time buyer so the LISA might
be out the door for you due to the same concerns you have about Pensions and
potential shifting goal posts.

So, I would advise you to go look up three things:

  1. Diversification - This isn't a product or anything like that.
    It's a way of managing risk by owning lots of different things.

  2. Low-cost index funds - This is a type of fund that you can
    buy into that will track the market. Pretty good if you want to set and forget.

  3. S&S ISAs. If you are going to have your money in there
    for a long time this is probably the best way of holding SOME of it. Not all,
    see the note about diversification above.

I'm not going to tell you exactly what you should do as I'm not
a professional and I don't much about you but those things with hopefully be
enough to get you started. (Assuming you know what a stock is, and a bond is,
if not go look up what they are as well)

Best of luck and avoid anything thing that says it can guarantee
you a high return. They are scammers.

Dulra · 27/04/2023 15:22

I work with two people retiring this year who have no private pension. They are terrified about how they'll survive on the state pension and are resigned to the fact that they may have to get a part-time job to top it up. I do not want to be stressing over finances at that age and very glad I took my dad's advice and started a pension in my early 20s

LakeTiticaca · 27/04/2023 15:21

Greenissle · 27/04/2023 14:23

I have a few different pensions pots from jobs when I was younger but I wouldn't have a clue where they are with and how much is in them.

How many people are in the same situation as me and what happens to all these mini pensions pots. It is utterly confusing.

You can trace these small pension pots yourself free of charge, you just need to know the name.of the company. You can then consolidate them into one pension pot or cash them.in if you are old enough. Don't use these firms who charge you % of the pot, you can do it for free yourself

Swipe left for the next trending thread