Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think cyclists should use cycle lanes

209 replies

Krispybake · 27/04/2023 13:03

Today, a massive line of traffic was held up by a cyclist who was using a long main road when a cycle path (tarmacked the same as the road) ran parallel for the entire length of the road. Due to the volume of traffic coming in the opposite direction, it was impossible to overtake the cyclist and leave the safe distance so creating a huge tail back involving service buses, funeral cortege and multiple cars.
Genuine question, why do cyclists do this? If the cycle track has the same surface as the road, why will they not use it? Very annoying!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
TooBored1 · 27/04/2023 18:48

Krispybake · 27/04/2023 18:22

@Whichnumbers

"It wasn't the cyclist holding you up travelling too slowly, but the sheer volume of traffic travelling in the opposite direction."

Eh?😂😂😂😂It absolutely was the cyclist holding everyone up! Had the cyclist not been on the road, then traffic would have kept moving more quickly regardless of the volume of oncoming traffic. Apologies if you meant this as a joke.....it's been a long day! 🥴

Nope. If there was less traffic coming in the opposite direction, you would have been able to overtake.

drspouse · 27/04/2023 18:46

Krispybake · 27/04/2023 17:13

It is a very busy road. There was a constant stream of traffic coming in the opposite carriageway and the position of the cyclist (about a metre into the road) meant that motorists couldn't pass with enough safe clearance. It would have meant driving over into the opposite carriageway a little to get past. Obviously the odd one managed in some of the little gaps but for the most part, we were stuck for a good long way. Thank Goodness for an eventual dual carriageway.

If you can't overtake like this, it's not safe to overtake a cyclist in a bike lane either. You need just as much room to overtake a cyclist as a car.

To think cyclists should use cycle lanes
Krispybake · 27/04/2023 18:45

Guardiansofthegalaxi · 27/04/2023 18:32

It doesn’t sound like you’re open to hearing any suggestion of why a cyclist might cycle in the road - every option offered, you say no that’s not a problem here. You seem very set on assuming the cyclist was doing it just because he could.

Somebody posted a picture of a cycle lane with the bollards. I probably wouldn’t choose to cycle in that lane. All it takes is a large bit of debris or pothole and you have nowhere to go, no room to avoid it. If you’re cycling on skinny tyres, that is very different to cycling on wide knobbly tyres. I’d suggest if you really want to understand, spend some time cycling on skinny tyres with busy traffic on that road at a reasonable speed. You might also find the road feels much safer

I can only reply as I found the situation today. I have actually acknowledged, several times, that I appreciate there are unsafe cycle lanes which shouldn't be used and also that there are numerous occasions when cyclists must use a road.
What the cyclists on here seem to imply is that I am incapable of understanding the condition of a cycle lane and that despite it being new, wide, beautifully surfaced etc. it must be fraught with many hidden dangers and traps like something out of Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom.
As for potholes, do roads not also have these? Is it not dangerous for a cyclist to swerve to avoid a pothole in the road when motor vehicles are right behind them?

OP posts:
TooBored1 · 27/04/2023 18:45

What was the point of this thread? You asked why someone may choose to move around in a particular (legal) way, yet totally refuse to listen to or accept any of the many reasons given.

At the end of the day, that person has made a choice that is perfectly legal and owes you no explanation.

Guardiansofthegalaxi · 27/04/2023 18:32

It doesn’t sound like you’re open to hearing any suggestion of why a cyclist might cycle in the road - every option offered, you say no that’s not a problem here. You seem very set on assuming the cyclist was doing it just because he could.

Somebody posted a picture of a cycle lane with the bollards. I probably wouldn’t choose to cycle in that lane. All it takes is a large bit of debris or pothole and you have nowhere to go, no room to avoid it. If you’re cycling on skinny tyres, that is very different to cycling on wide knobbly tyres. I’d suggest if you really want to understand, spend some time cycling on skinny tyres with busy traffic on that road at a reasonable speed. You might also find the road feels much safer

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 27/04/2023 18:29

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Mostar · 27/04/2023 18:28

On a side issue: the three-abreast weekend bloke pelotón. Guys, I get it. Exercise is a good thing. However, you are not Bradley Fucking Wiggins in the Tour de France. If you insist in going out in groups of 40 or more, do it at 5 in the morning when the rest of the world isn't trying to drive somewhere.

And one more thing, chaps. If you have a fat arse, wear trackies instead of the lycra shorts. Thanks.

Whichnumbers · 27/04/2023 18:23

It absolutely was the cyclist holding everyone up

thats your bias mindset - if the opposite lane wasn't full of traffic everyone would have just passed the cyclist

Krispybake · 27/04/2023 18:22

@Whichnumbers

"It wasn't the cyclist holding you up travelling too slowly, but the sheer volume of traffic travelling in the opposite direction."

Eh?😂😂😂😂It absolutely was the cyclist holding everyone up! Had the cyclist not been on the road, then traffic would have kept moving more quickly regardless of the volume of oncoming traffic. Apologies if you meant this as a joke.....it's been a long day! 🥴

OP posts:
Whichnumbers · 27/04/2023 18:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Whichnumbers · 27/04/2023 18:14

It is interesting that you cite the slow pace in the cycle lanes as the cause for some cyclists to use the road. How ironic that they then become the "slow pace" for other motorists. So it is OK for them to be frustrated at being held up but not other motorists?

I was cycling home today on a not great cycle lane, an electric bike went in the other direction doing approximately 15mph - this is a shared path with pedestrians. Many pedestrians would complain that the cyclist was too fast - so we just can't win. Cyclists ride too fast and too slowly all at the same time. If were on the path we are to fast and don the road were to slow.

In your first post you wrote the reason that no one could over take Due to the volume of traffic coming in the opposite direction, it was impossible to overtake the cyclist

It wasn't the cyclist holding you up travelling too slowly, but the sheer volume of traffic travelling in the opposite direction

lljkk · 27/04/2023 17:54

@Northernsoullover : do cyclists using the Cardiff cycle lanes have to give way at junctions that cars can quickly get across? That would be a powerful reason to avoid the stupid cycle lanes and stick to the road, to just get places faster and not have to constantly divert to sides & wait & wait to get across the junctions, watching all the cars quickly sail thru....

Cycle lanes are typically designed by non-cyclists (engineers) for people like themselves (engineers who rarely ever use a bike I mean), especially designed for children, so for people who basically can barely ride a bike. Cycle lanes (in UK) are mostly poorly designed to help cyclists quickly get from A to B.

LordEmsworth · 27/04/2023 17:40

Krispybake · 27/04/2023 14:06

@LordEmsworth

"Did you not carefully explain to them that you are more important and have more rights than they do? That might have helped."

Where did I say that I am far more important and have far more rights? What a sarcastic and very rude response to what was a genuine question. I can only assume you are one such cyclist who believes you are far too important to use perfectly good and serviceable cycle lanes (not shared by pedestrians, an extension of the road they insisted on cycling on, EXACTLY the same surface covering and no inroads to have to stop and start). Perhaps if today's cyclist had to display a reg plate (you know, in case he caused an accident), pay insurance and road tax, then he might have thought differently. 🤷
I am not anti cyclists and I do appreciate that there are numerous occasions when they must use a road but today, I don't understand his reasoning.

I cycled to the office today. There is a shared use path with overgrown trees and large groups of unobservant school children and parents milling around. I used that rather than the road, because I am scared of drivers like you. It took me longer than it would've had I used the road next to it, but I felt that speed was not more important than reaching my destination without having snarling drivers trying to force me off the road because "there's a cycle path bitch".

Incidentally, I pay road tax on my car, but I prefer to keep that for longer journeys and cycle or walk locally. I also pay insurance on my bike including third party in case of accidents, though I am not exactly built for speed and generally prefer a pootle.

The genuine answer, which you don't seem to like, is that the cyclist has a right to be on the road; so doesn't have to make their decision based on what you want or what's best for you. Cycling infrastructure in this country is shit and apparently designed to eliminate cyclists https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2021/11/08/top-10-worst-cycle-lanes-in-the-uk/ so maybe you weren't looking at the path from the point of view of, what are the hidden death traps.

You're not anti cyclists but you do look down on us, don't you...

Top 10 Worst Cycle Lanes in the UK 

Not long ago, we staked out a bold new goal for We Love Cycling magazine: to collect as many of the worst cycle lanes across the globe as we could and

https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2021/11/08/top-10-worst-cycle-lanes-in-the-uk

Northernsoullover · 27/04/2023 17:38

In Cardiff the cycle lanes are brand spanking new, seperate and safe to get on and off (you have to be cautious at junctions but you should be anyway). I swear I'm the only one using them. I see cyclists weaving in and out of traffic while I'm happy in my safe lane. I just don't get it. YANBU OP.
Some of the older ones (which there aren't many) do need resurfacing but they are safe enough if you don't act like you are competing in the tour de France, it's still quicker in rush hour than driving.

00100001 · 27/04/2023 17:35

lljkk · 27/04/2023 17:32

Because you won't tell us exactly where it is, I don't believe you have given a fair description. I have zero comprehension why you won't tell us exactly where it is.

Because she doesn't want to be proved wrong!

Krispybake · 27/04/2023 17:33

Abra1t · 27/04/2023 17:28

I agree with you, OP.

Thank you. X

OP posts:
lljkk · 27/04/2023 17:32

Because you won't tell us exactly where it is, I don't believe you have given a fair description. I have zero comprehension why you won't tell us exactly where it is.

Abra1t · 27/04/2023 17:28

Krispybake · 27/04/2023 13:15

Yes they have the right to be on the road but my question was, if the cycle path is simply an extension of the road i.e. same surface, why not use it? Surely it is safer for them? I just don't get their thinking. Would drivers and cyclists feel the same way about pedestrians who insisted on walking along a busy main road rather than use the pavements?

I agree with you, OP.

Krispybake · 27/04/2023 17:25

lljkk · 27/04/2023 17:09

Tell us exactly which cycle lane it was, OP. Exactly where. And I will find the information to show you why it's lousy & difficult to use. This is not outing to you.

What happens to me is I arrive at a new road, ride along, and go... "Oh look! A cycle lane. On the wrong side of the road across several lanes of traffic. it has a big curb between me and it and no access points. It gives way every 100 metres to let random traffic across. It has thorns on it and glass, and is half gravel, not to mention a whole tree fallen across it. It has teenagers meandering all over it. Or mums or dogs or small children. There are random bollards and chicanes, too. "

I'd love to know which cycle lane in Uk has a surface as good as the nearby road, doesn't share with dozey pedestrians and never not even once gives way to cross traffic in a place where the main road doesn't give way. Please show us where that lovely cycle lane is.

Thanks for the offer but nope, I don't need to! I have explained exactly what the lane is like. If you choose to doubt that, then that is your problem. Clearly, you do not live in an area where a lot of money has been spent on the infrastructure. Here, massive amounts have been spent improving the roads and creating new cycle lanes that are not shared by "dozey pedestrians". It does not give way to cross traffic because the road doesn't between roundabouts for a considerable distance. Because you have never experienced it does not mean it does not exist. It is a lovely cycle lane though. We can agree on that!

OP posts:
Krispybake · 27/04/2023 17:13

dailytalk · 27/04/2023 17:05

Why couldn't people overtake

It is a very busy road. There was a constant stream of traffic coming in the opposite carriageway and the position of the cyclist (about a metre into the road) meant that motorists couldn't pass with enough safe clearance. It would have meant driving over into the opposite carriageway a little to get past. Obviously the odd one managed in some of the little gaps but for the most part, we were stuck for a good long way. Thank Goodness for an eventual dual carriageway.

OP posts:
lljkk · 27/04/2023 17:09

Tell us exactly which cycle lane it was, OP. Exactly where. And I will find the information to show you why it's lousy & difficult to use. This is not outing to you.

What happens to me is I arrive at a new road, ride along, and go... "Oh look! A cycle lane. On the wrong side of the road across several lanes of traffic. it has a big curb between me and it and no access points. It gives way every 100 metres to let random traffic across. It has thorns on it and glass, and is half gravel, not to mention a whole tree fallen across it. It has teenagers meandering all over it. Or mums or dogs or small children. There are random bollards and chicanes, too. "

I'd love to know which cycle lane in Uk has a surface as good as the nearby road, doesn't share with dozey pedestrians and never not even once gives way to cross traffic in a place where the main road doesn't give way. Please show us where that lovely cycle lane is.

dailytalk · 27/04/2023 17:05

Why couldn't people overtake

MotherOfCatBoy · 27/04/2023 17:05

I used to cycle a lot pre pandemic, both commuting to work (mostly separated from cars) and long Sunday rides with friends. A lot of PP experience chimes with me too. Many cycle lanes are poorly designed, unmaintained and unsafe, so I would cycle on the road, obeying all the rules of the road, positioning myself like a car and letting queues pass in country lanes if they arose as like a PP I both hate cars behind me and hate to feel I’m getting in their way. Some cycle lanes were excellent and I would turn on to them gratefully because generally wherever you are well separated from cars the experience is much nicer.

I wish before cycle lanes were signed off, the designers had to do a mandatory bike ride on their location first. I think a lot of the time they are LAs spending budget without real knowledge of how bike lanes work.

OP I think your question is answered as a pick of the following:

A the lane was badly designed but this is only discernible if you ride it
B the person was turning right
C they were being bolshy about their right to ride on the road
D they’re an arsehole

But you’ll never know. That’s life. I get your frustration but let it pass. There’ll be another mystery tomorrow 🤷‍♀️

drspouse · 27/04/2023 17:03

The main reasons why I cycle in the main road rather than on a tiny cycle path are:

  • Debris in the cycle path
  • Potholes in the cycle path (that you probably can't see)
  • Cycling with a child who is in the cycle path so I cycle next to them on the road.
  • Cycle path stops and starts or has more give-ways
  • Cycle path much too narrow
  • Safer to cycle in the main carriageway because the road is not wide enough for cars to pass me safely if I'm on the cycle path and they try to stay on the left of the road.
  • I'm turning right shortly
  • There are cars parked ahead either in or just after the cycle path so I'd have to pull out anyway.
Resilience · 27/04/2023 17:02

Like many others I cycle and drive a car.

Cycle lanes in the UK should largely be scrapped. They're mostly an easy way for virtue-signalling authorities to claim green credentials while actually making life more difficult for motorists and positively dangerous for cyclists.

Many authorities seem to think that simply painting the outermost strip of the road a different colour and painting a picture of a cycle in it is enough. Never mind that it isn't actually wide enough to fit a typical man's shoulder width, meaning that the car in the adjacent 'car' lane still has to overtake to pass safely, meaning crossing into oncoming traffic, which might not be possible if the roads are busy. The cycle lane lulls people into a false sense of security rather than encouraging cyclists to keep their wits about them and motorists to see them as vulnerable road users.

As others have said, even proper cycle lanes are often poorly maintained. When cyclists understandably ride on the road, they do so on a road that is now narrower (due to cycle lane) so it causes more congestion and has a higher safety risk than if they'd just not bothered.

The trouble with the UK is that our towns and cities are older and laid out differently to many parts of the world. This doesn't lend itself well to cycle lanes unless a proportionate amount of planning and money is ploughed into them. Often it isn't. Unless this changes, cycle lanes really are just an expensive white elephant.