Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about children getting different inheritances?

88 replies

KingsHeath53 · 27/04/2023 08:39

My 2 DC have different sets of godparents. Both lovely, hands on godparents and close friends. DC1 godparents are child-free, DC2 godparents have children. DC1 godparents have indicated when they die, DC1 will be in their will. Obviously not the case for DC2 where godparents would rightly leave their estate to their own kids. Should add when we chose godparents for DC1 we didn’t know they were going to be child-free forever, so this didn’t factor into our godparent selection!

I’ll say upfront i’m not hugely worried about this. I plan to raise my kids to be resilient and make their own way in life, not expecting or needing inheritances or hand outs. Also loads could happen in future, godparents could get other godchildren etc etc. Who knows.

However, it did get me wondering. If one (by then I assume adult) DC inherited a lot (godparents are wealthy with property etc) and the other one didn’t, based on an arbitrary choice of who would be godparents, would that cause tension between the siblings? Does anyone have family experience where one sibling inherited a lot from say, a distant relative, and others didn’t? Did that cause problems and jealousy? As a parent would you guide your one child to split an unequal inheritance with their sibling if the situation arose?

OP posts:
minipie · 27/04/2023 14:43

I would be asking the godparents to split any inherited between both kids.

If they didn’t (as is their right) then yes I would be asking the beneficiary DC to split equally.

I had some money from a family member which was gifted to me before my sibling existed. My parents told me they thought it should be split and I agreed without hesitation. It’s only fair. Obviously not quite the same situation but similar.

BishyBarnyBee · 27/04/2023 14:41

I guess you could in principle give DC2 the same amount of money as the godparents give DC1? Assuming you can afford it? I'd feel really odd about one of my children randomly inheriting from a friend of mine. Though I guess it would also feel odd if one won on the lottery and the other didn't. It feels different to them earning different amounts, somehow.

Hotcrossbunnowplease · 27/04/2023 14:40

My brother may inherit a lot (we’re talking millions) from his godmother, I won’t. I don’t give it much thought, it’s just one of those things in life. If I was struggling I imagine he’d share some but I’m not so don't expect him to

AllTheWatersTurnedToClouds · 27/04/2023 14:39

I'm leaving money to my Godson (I've no kids) and, to make it fair, I'm leaving the same amount to his sister.

I've spent the same amount of time with both of them, they are lovely young adults now, and if I can lend them a hand when I'm gone, I'm happy to do so.

Seemed very mean to just leave her out.

parietal · 27/04/2023 14:37

presumably your kids will also one day inherit from you?

if the inheritance from godparent to child A is small (less than 10% of what kids might inherit from you), then child A gets it and is lucky.

If the inheritance really is massive, then you could leave a bit more to child B in compensation. but if you do this, make it VERY clear to all over multiple conversations that you love both kids equally and you want them to have the same advantages, which is why you are trying to make the ££ more equal between them. Hopefully Child A will be secure enough that they won't be bothered.

caringcarer · 27/04/2023 14:35

SlipSlidinAway · 27/04/2023 14:00

That's a very different scenario to the one the op described. I think it's safe to assume that the great uncle would have included the third child had they been alive at the time he made his will.

DH's grandma left some money in her will to our very young dcs. We invested the money and shared it out amongst all our dcs - including the one that hadn't been born when their great grandma died - when they reached 18. We did that on the basis that she would have wanted all her great grandchildren to benefit - even one she never met.

But the people in the op's case are only godparents to one of her children .

I hope you got permission from the children who did actually inherit. To take it without asking to give to their sibling the Great Granma had never even met would be theft. I think my niece is leaving it with the DC named in will as they were the ones who had a relationship with her Great Uncle. I think my niece is hoping her eldest 2 son's offer to share. She wouldn't just take their money to give to their younger sibling. In OP's children's case the child that has Godparents who may leave them a legacy will end up with a helping hand it's sibling won't get. That is life.

LoveLuna · 27/04/2023 14:32

I have 4 kids (all adults now), 2 of them have the same Godmother, who is child-free by choice and have no nieces or nephews, and at present, her and her husband are leaving everything in their will's to be spilt between their Godchildren, this could be quite a substantial, life-changing amount of money, if they choose to share this with their other 2 siblings is a decision only they can make, and is not something I would even suggest to them.

Grasss · 27/04/2023 14:11

I get where you're coming from OP but I don't think it needs to cause resentment. Surely this sort of thing happens a lot due to a variety of reasons?

For example I have step children. My child with DH will likely inherit more from "us" than my step children because I don't intend to leave my share of the house to them. It will go to our child together and DHs share will be split 3 ways.

I don't see why that should cause my stepchildren to resent our child together. It's just life. Especially if this were to happen when they were adults themselves (I hope!) And therefore more mature and able to understand the differences better.

SlipSlidinAway · 27/04/2023 14:00

caringcarer · 27/04/2023 09:24

My niece has 3 children now. At the point her Great Uncle died she only had two children. He left each of the two children named in his will £60k each. This has been invested and grown a bit more. I don't know how much more. The youngest child being several years younger than siblings has no inheritance. My niece is intending to leave all her three children an equal share in her will as she says she loves them all equally. The Great Uncle had a very close relationship with her two older boys and saw them most days. He chose not to leave the money to his great niece, as he thought she'd inherited from her own parents but instead left her share split between her children. Youngest will miss out.

That's a very different scenario to the one the op described. I think it's safe to assume that the great uncle would have included the third child had they been alive at the time he made his will.

DH's grandma left some money in her will to our very young dcs. We invested the money and shared it out amongst all our dcs - including the one that hadn't been born when their great grandma died - when they reached 18. We did that on the basis that she would have wanted all her great grandchildren to benefit - even one she never met.

But the people in the op's case are only godparents to one of her children .

caringcarer · 27/04/2023 09:24

My niece has 3 children now. At the point her Great Uncle died she only had two children. He left each of the two children named in his will £60k each. This has been invested and grown a bit more. I don't know how much more. The youngest child being several years younger than siblings has no inheritance. My niece is intending to leave all her three children an equal share in her will as she says she loves them all equally. The Great Uncle had a very close relationship with her two older boys and saw them most days. He chose not to leave the money to his great niece, as he thought she'd inherited from her own parents but instead left her share split between her children. Youngest will miss out.

SlipSlidinAway · 27/04/2023 09:13

When they say your dc1 will be, 'in their will' that doesn't necessarily mean a massive sum. Also people change their minds about beneficiaries as the years roll by. They may lose touch with you and your family. They may divorce/die/remarry and acquire step children. They may decide to leave everything to charity.

But no - I wouldn't expect an adult to split an inheritance with a sibling. That would be a ridiculous expectation - though of course dc1 may choose to share.

Sarvanga38 · 27/04/2023 09:04

It may also not be a substantial sum of money, so don't assume they're being left the whole estate or anything resembling it, of course. My sister has godchildren who are named in her will, but we are talking a 'token' amount of £5k. (Obviously a nice sum of money, but not life changing.)

Boughtitdownthemarket · 27/04/2023 09:02

I've never come across Godparents leaving money to godchildren in their will, unless they have another connection e.g. an uncle with no children leaving money to nieces and nephews. I wouldn't be expecting anything from them but in terms of fairness, all you can do is if one child gets left money and the other doesn't, ask them if they'd share it? If they say no, they say no.