Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about children getting different inheritances?

88 replies

KingsHeath53 · 27/04/2023 08:39

My 2 DC have different sets of godparents. Both lovely, hands on godparents and close friends. DC1 godparents are child-free, DC2 godparents have children. DC1 godparents have indicated when they die, DC1 will be in their will. Obviously not the case for DC2 where godparents would rightly leave their estate to their own kids. Should add when we chose godparents for DC1 we didn’t know they were going to be child-free forever, so this didn’t factor into our godparent selection!

I’ll say upfront i’m not hugely worried about this. I plan to raise my kids to be resilient and make their own way in life, not expecting or needing inheritances or hand outs. Also loads could happen in future, godparents could get other godchildren etc etc. Who knows.

However, it did get me wondering. If one (by then I assume adult) DC inherited a lot (godparents are wealthy with property etc) and the other one didn’t, based on an arbitrary choice of who would be godparents, would that cause tension between the siblings? Does anyone have family experience where one sibling inherited a lot from say, a distant relative, and others didn’t? Did that cause problems and jealousy? As a parent would you guide your one child to split an unequal inheritance with their sibling if the situation arose?

OP posts:
TheChoiceIsYours · 27/04/2023 17:01

SlipSlidinAway · 27/04/2023 14:00

That's a very different scenario to the one the op described. I think it's safe to assume that the great uncle would have included the third child had they been alive at the time he made his will.

DH's grandma left some money in her will to our very young dcs. We invested the money and shared it out amongst all our dcs - including the one that hadn't been born when their great grandma died - when they reached 18. We did that on the basis that she would have wanted all her great grandchildren to benefit - even one she never met.

But the people in the op's case are only godparents to one of her children .

Did the children who had inherited give you permission to do that? If you just took it upon yourselves to redistribute their money as you saw fit then that’s wildly and completely illegal. You might see it as fair but legally you had absolutely no right to do anything with their money other than ensure they’re got it as the deceased intended. Even if you presented it to your children as something they should do, put any moral pressure on them, that’s really really wrong. Basically anything other than this being entirely their idea is not ok!

PonkyPonky · 27/04/2023 16:57

GasPanic · 27/04/2023 16:26

Probably because they are all comfortably off and what they stand to inherit (or not) isn't expected to be life changing.

No not the case. No one is particularly comfortable in this scenario. It’s just no one has an entitlement to anyone else’s money. Inheritance should be treated as a nice surprise if it comes. It’s no one’s right

greyhairnomore · 27/04/2023 16:52

minipie · 27/04/2023 14:43

I would be asking the godparents to split any inherited between both kids.

If they didn’t (as is their right) then yes I would be asking the beneficiary DC to split equally.

I had some money from a family member which was gifted to me before my sibling existed. My parents told me they thought it should be split and I agreed without hesitation. It’s only fair. Obviously not quite the same situation but similar.

Why should they give up any of their inheritance?

Natsku · 27/04/2023 16:48

My children will get different inheritances because they have different dads, DD will inherit a sum of money when she turns 18 (well she's already inherited it but she doesn't get access until then) because her dad died so she will start adult life in an easier position than her brother and that's not something I can afford to even up for DS.

whoateallthecookies · 27/04/2023 16:43

This actually happened in our family - DH's sister inherited her godmother's flat (all of it) and DH didn't. DH didn't really know his sister's godmother; she was almost certainly rather better at keeping in touch. It hasn't caused any issues, despite being a significant sum. It probably helps that DH (we) are comfortably off; it wouldn't be a life changing sum for us.

Blip · 27/04/2023 16:42

I think it's fine.
I wouldn't be bothered about "trying to even things up" in any way.
Your children are different people who will have different experiences of life.
Maybe they will marry people of different financial status to each other anyhow.
Maybe they will earn different amounts.
Maybe their health will differ.
I am planning to leave money in my will to my god children albeit not huge sums. I do have my own dc too.

ChristmasCurry · 27/04/2023 16:39

You could ask DC1 to do a Deed of Variation when the inheritance occurs, so that they could pass some of over to DC2.

But I suppose this would depend on the size of the inheritance and if DC1 wanted to pass some of the inheritance over.

Sugarfree23 · 27/04/2023 16:39

@PonkyPonky it might be a joke just now but in time if the 'elderly person admin' falls on one of the other siblings shoulders, and they don't inherit that becomes a major slap in the face.

When I say 'elderly person admin' I mean the stuff like helping with shopping, medical appointments, arranging cleaners, carers and the many other little jobs that elderly people need help with.

CalpolDependant · 27/04/2023 16:31

OP, I don’t mean this to sound “Mumsnetty” or owt but… is there anything else you could be worrying about instead? 😂😂😂

GasPanic · 27/04/2023 16:26

PonkyPonky · 27/04/2023 16:14

It’s no big deal IMO. DH is one of 3 and one of the other is set to inherit from childless godparents. No one gives a hoot. It makes for the occasional joke between siblings about how 1 got the ‘best’ godparents. But it’s tongue in cheek and really the other 2 have never thought anything of it

Probably because they are all comfortably off and what they stand to inherit (or not) isn't expected to be life changing.

TeaAndBrie · 27/04/2023 16:23

My Sister inherited £150k from a great aunt. I got nothing but knew I wouldn’t as we weren’t close. My sister promised for years she would split it with me. Until she actually had the money and then told me she wasn’t serious and thought I knew that. The money has destroyed her, her marriage and our relationship. Not because I expected or wanted any of it but it turned her into a self centred, showy person. Now the money has dried up she’s bitter and resentful and I’ve lost all respect for her

MargaretThursday · 27/04/2023 16:22

I'd say luck of the draw and definitely you shouldn't be asking them to leave to them equally or pressurising dc1 to give to dc2.
Assuming the godparents are similar age to you and dh, it's likely that it will be many years down the line, by which time your dc may have families of their own.

Will you be checking that dc2's ILs will not leave more to them than dc1's IL leave to their family? No. It's a similar thing.

PonkyPonky · 27/04/2023 16:14

It’s no big deal IMO. DH is one of 3 and one of the other is set to inherit from childless godparents. No one gives a hoot. It makes for the occasional joke between siblings about how 1 got the ‘best’ godparents. But it’s tongue in cheek and really the other 2 have never thought anything of it

cittigirl · 27/04/2023 15:58

AllTheWatersTurnedToClouds · 27/04/2023 14:39

I'm leaving money to my Godson (I've no kids) and, to make it fair, I'm leaving the same amount to his sister.

I've spent the same amount of time with both of them, they are lovely young adults now, and if I can lend them a hand when I'm gone, I'm happy to do so.

Seemed very mean to just leave her out.

Agree....I wouldn't dream of doing that. Presumably the god parents are in the whole families life. But....mn favourite saying, their money, their choice, which of course it is.

GasPanic · 27/04/2023 15:43

TanukiMario · 27/04/2023 15:32

Thats ridiculous.
If my sibling inherited from a godparent I would be over the moon for them. But if I inherited and my parents made me share I would definitely be resentful. If I inherit something then it should be my own decision to share.

Its like winning the lottery. I might share some of it, but in the end its mine to do with what I want 🤷🏻‍♀️

To me it's not like winning the lottery at all.

Winning the lottery is random. When you win the lottery you pay the price and you stand to benefit (or not) from the result. The lottery isn't taking any sort of active decision to make you benefit rather than anyone else. You can't claim the lottery is valuing one sibling more than the other. It has no concept of that. Your sibling could complain that you won, but it's hardly unfair as the same opportunity (to buy a ticket and potentially win) is equally open to them.

In the inheritance case then someone is actually making a proactive decision to benefit one sibling more than another, basically (seemingly) solely on the fact that they were nominated godparent to that sibling. It may be down to luck that one sibling got the right godparent, but the act of exclusion is not down to luck at all.

WateryDoom · 27/04/2023 15:42

It's just life, I think. My dickhead of an ex-DH has never paid much towards our DC (now adults) but is extremely wealthy and will presumably leave them quite a bit of money.

I remarried - and my youngest DC won't inherit much from their father and I (we are currently struggling financially and have little). Our estate will still be shared between all the DC equally. I'm sorry for the younger ones who obviously won't inherit as much as their older siblings, but that's not something I can do anything about.

Sugarfree23 · 27/04/2023 15:40

While they are children now and the Godparent is say in their 40s.
You can't really predict what the relationships will be like in 30 or 40 years time.

When the children are adults with lives of their own and the Godparent is in their 70s or 80s.

pinkyredrose · 27/04/2023 15:35

I'd respect the wishes of the deceased .

TanukiMario · 27/04/2023 15:32

minipie · 27/04/2023 14:43

I would be asking the godparents to split any inherited between both kids.

If they didn’t (as is their right) then yes I would be asking the beneficiary DC to split equally.

I had some money from a family member which was gifted to me before my sibling existed. My parents told me they thought it should be split and I agreed without hesitation. It’s only fair. Obviously not quite the same situation but similar.

Thats ridiculous.
If my sibling inherited from a godparent I would be over the moon for them. But if I inherited and my parents made me share I would definitely be resentful. If I inherit something then it should be my own decision to share.

Its like winning the lottery. I might share some of it, but in the end its mine to do with what I want 🤷🏻‍♀️

Hugasauras · 27/04/2023 15:24

GasPanic · 27/04/2023 15:03

Seems a bit weird. Do the godparents of DC1 have anything at all to do with DC2, or do they just interact and do birthdays and christmas for DC1 and ignore DC2 ?

And yes, anytime siblings are not treated equally then it is a cause for potential resentment, and it happens a lot. And anyone who sets them up to be treated unequally must know this unless they are completely insensitive.

If it were me then if possible I would try to make it up to DC2 by making sure they had a balancing amount. Of course if it is a massive sum it may not be possible.

Yes, I find this a bit weird too. Aren't they close to your other child too? How much do they actually have to do with DC1? I can't imagine close friends being so involved as to leave all their money to one of my children but nothing to the other, regardless of what their 'title' is. I'd treat both my best friend's children equally.

MammaTo · 27/04/2023 15:10

I’d like to think my kids would get on well enough to split the money between them and their siblings.

ASGIRC · 27/04/2023 15:04

Hotcrossbunnowplease · 27/04/2023 14:40

My brother may inherit a lot (we’re talking millions) from his godmother, I won’t. I don’t give it much thought, it’s just one of those things in life. If I was struggling I imagine he’d share some but I’m not so don't expect him to

While I have no such inheritance coming my way, and neither does my brother, I know that if either of us got a life changing amount (imagine winning a big lottery or euromillions), wed help the other. Even if it was just enough to pay the mortgage, so that the other could be debt free.

Obviously, neither of us would be obligated to do it. But I know that we would (weve talked about it, in a " what would you do if you won the 65M jackpot this week" kinda chat)

Godparents are such a luck of the draw thing... Im 40 and mine are still in the picture. But my brother s disappeared from the face of the earth when we were teens. They were really good friends of my parents, and when we were kids they were very present in our lives. But at some point, they just ghosted my parents.

I will not be inheriting anything from my godparents, as they have 3 adult children and several grandchildren.

GasPanic · 27/04/2023 15:03

Seems a bit weird. Do the godparents of DC1 have anything at all to do with DC2, or do they just interact and do birthdays and christmas for DC1 and ignore DC2 ?

And yes, anytime siblings are not treated equally then it is a cause for potential resentment, and it happens a lot. And anyone who sets them up to be treated unequally must know this unless they are completely insensitive.

If it were me then if possible I would try to make it up to DC2 by making sure they had a balancing amount. Of course if it is a massive sum it may not be possible.

Sugarfree23 · 27/04/2023 14:46

I've come across this yes it has caused massive tension and a 10 year long rift.

It didn't help that the child who wasn't God child was the one who visited, did the general running around, sorting stuff, arranging nursing home, etc etc
I think they were absolutely cut to the bone. It would have been better if the God parent had ignored that and split equally.

user1492757084 · 27/04/2023 14:43

You can't really do anything about it - except to teach your children to be supportive and respectful of each other.

Swipe left for the next trending thread