Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about children getting different inheritances?

88 replies

KingsHeath53 · 27/04/2023 08:39

My 2 DC have different sets of godparents. Both lovely, hands on godparents and close friends. DC1 godparents are child-free, DC2 godparents have children. DC1 godparents have indicated when they die, DC1 will be in their will. Obviously not the case for DC2 where godparents would rightly leave their estate to their own kids. Should add when we chose godparents for DC1 we didn’t know they were going to be child-free forever, so this didn’t factor into our godparent selection!

I’ll say upfront i’m not hugely worried about this. I plan to raise my kids to be resilient and make their own way in life, not expecting or needing inheritances or hand outs. Also loads could happen in future, godparents could get other godchildren etc etc. Who knows.

However, it did get me wondering. If one (by then I assume adult) DC inherited a lot (godparents are wealthy with property etc) and the other one didn’t, based on an arbitrary choice of who would be godparents, would that cause tension between the siblings? Does anyone have family experience where one sibling inherited a lot from say, a distant relative, and others didn’t? Did that cause problems and jealousy? As a parent would you guide your one child to split an unequal inheritance with their sibling if the situation arose?

OP posts:
Parker231 · 27/04/2023 19:04

I inherited from my godfather - he also paid for our very expensive wedding. I shared the inheritance with my DSis who wasn’t left anything by her godfather as he didn’t have anything to leave anyone.

Aria2015 · 27/04/2023 19:01

One of my siblings will likely inherit hundreds of thousands from their (childless) god parent. I see it as just luck. I don't think they should spilt or share it. They have kids and they'll use it for their own retirement and for their kids. I might have a pang of jealousy, but that's my problem, not theirs and I'd never let on! 🤣

Skybluepinky · 27/04/2023 18:57

I wouldn’t over think it, they could end up in a carehome and with no money left. They could also mean they would leave £100 in their will.

Sugarfree23 · 27/04/2023 18:50

@rivertoskateaway assuming the Aunt went through a 'getting frail' stage who was it who looked out for her?
Were you still close to the aunt as an adult?

rivertoskateaway · 27/04/2023 18:45

My half sister (said for clarity, I have never called her this in real life as we were raised together, she is my sister) inherited from her Aunt. It hurt because said Aunt had been in my life forever, and we had a lovely Aunt-Niece relationship even though we weren’t biologically related. However I have never begrudged my sister, or expected her to share.

SlipSlidinAway · 27/04/2023 18:41

@neslop - fine, but I'm happy that I did what I know their great grandmother would have wanted.

neslop · 27/04/2023 18:39

SlipSlidinAway · 27/04/2023 18:20

@TheChoiceIsYours
@AbsoIutelyLovely

Don't be so ridiculous. We're talking about a few grand and a great grandmother that would absolutely have wanted all her great grandchildren to benefit. I actually invested the money very wisely and added to it. So the original beneficiaries got what was owed to them - and a lot more.

You might think it's ridiculous but legally that is correct. The original sum plus any investment accrued should have been split equally between the 2 named in the will when they reached 18. So they didn't actually get everything they were entitled to.

SlipSlidinAway · 27/04/2023 18:20

@TheChoiceIsYours
@AbsoIutelyLovely

Don't be so ridiculous. We're talking about a few grand and a great grandmother that would absolutely have wanted all her great grandchildren to benefit. I actually invested the money very wisely and added to it. So the original beneficiaries got what was owed to them - and a lot more.

AbsoIutelyLovely · 27/04/2023 18:16

SlipSlidinAway · 27/04/2023 14:00

That's a very different scenario to the one the op described. I think it's safe to assume that the great uncle would have included the third child had they been alive at the time he made his will.

DH's grandma left some money in her will to our very young dcs. We invested the money and shared it out amongst all our dcs - including the one that hadn't been born when their great grandma died - when they reached 18. We did that on the basis that she would have wanted all her great grandchildren to benefit - even one she never met.

But the people in the op's case are only godparents to one of her children .

@SlipSlidinAway

Thats illegal. 😱

PrincessHoneysuckle · 27/04/2023 18:07

I was in my godparents will until she died and I wasn't left anything at all.Didnt give a shit but my mum had always told me that was the case.Dont take it as gospel

2bazookas · 27/04/2023 18:02

DC1 godparents have indicated when they die, DC1 will be in their will. Obviously not the case for DC2 where godparents would rightly leave their estate to their own kids.

You're making far too many assumptions. Even when testators have children, it's normal for Wills to list a number of exact requests to assorted beneficiaries "To my son Tim I leave the house and a million pounds; to my friend Fiona I leave my record collection and £500, to my God child Bob I leave £100. Everything else I leave to the Cat Home.

Either couple might leave their godchild a token sum in their Wills.

ittakes2 · 27/04/2023 17:28

If one of your children won the lottery you would not be overthinking it. I think you might be overthinking this. The poor god parent has to die first, may change their mind, you don’t know how much - I would stop worrying about it

Changeychang · 27/04/2023 17:28

It's an interesting question. I don't think you can ask the child who receives inheritance to share though, it's really up to them. I think it would be great if friend (if close to both kids) shares the inheritance between them.

This has actually made me think more about my own situation. I think I will change my gift in my will to divide between god child and their sibling instead of just god child. I'm actually quite close to my god child's sibling and think she's ace. Also, my GC's sibling's godparents have kids so unlikely to leave any to her.

So thanks for the thread.

jannier · 27/04/2023 17:27

Wasn't something similar posted on godparents and birthday money a few weeks ago?

If it worried you you should have given them the same godparents but I'm sure your kids won't worry about the £50 I hope is in the will

EggInANest · 27/04/2023 17:23

A lot can happen.

The godparents might need all their assets for care. Or other emergency in the 40+ years they have remaining.
One might outlive the other, remarry someone much younger and leave their estate to them. Do they have younger siblings? nieces / nephews? Probably most of the estate will go to them if so and the bequest will be modest.

You can’t plan to balance it in your own will, the godparents might outlive you and their will ultimately not what you expected, you might need your assets for care, and so on.

One Dc might win millions on the lottery or premium bonds.

They will (hopefully) be independent thriving adults by the time this happens, and if one gets a windfall, well, that’s life!

Twobigsapphires · 27/04/2023 17:15

This happened to my family. I wasn’t christened so no godparents for me, but my younger bother and sister were (different father who wanted this).
dbro had one godfather who was fairly wealthy and left 30k to mu dbro. Dsis had different godparents so didn’t get left any.
dbro pissed the money up the wall really. He was only 22 when he inherited it and spent it all on tech equipment for his band / dj equipment, weed and a car really. Dsis was a bit pissed off as she is super sensible and if she ever received a sum like that would have invested in in property / saved it.
I didn’t cause any bad feelings between any of us although me and my sis did roll our eyes a lot and bitch about what a fool he was wasting the money. I had two small kids at the time and high mortgage etc but I appreciated that dbro was in a completely different phase of life.
My mum did feel bad though as she knew my sister missed out and would’ve made better use of the money.
I think there would’ve been bitterness between us if he’d inherited a life changing amount though, say enough to buy a house outright whilst we either couldn’t afford to get on the ladder or had high mortgage etc.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/04/2023 17:12

I think by the time this comes to fruition your kids will likely be adults who organically are leading different lives with different opportunities, non of which can be controlled for. The theoretical Godparent inheritance is going to be one of many.

I would not get involved with trying to even things out as the parent. Madness, hurt, and anger are the only things that can come from that.

makemineadoublee · 27/04/2023 17:08

Worry when it happens

You could fall out, loose touch they could have dc

they might only leave £10 etc etc

Peterpiperpickedapeckof · 27/04/2023 17:08

I’ve just remember my godmother left me a little sum which I spent on my wedding dress. I don’t think my siblings even knew about it! They were adults and incredibly busy with work and their kids. If I had been larger they wouldn’t have noticed as they don’t know about my financial details… I’d have just put it into a house deposit and frankly again no one would be the wiser.

It might only cause issues with younger siblings I think.

Camablanca · 27/04/2023 17:07

Camablanca · 27/04/2023 17:05

Hrmm. I'm not sure whether it's that clear cut.
In the case of siblings close in age, and the Godparents being 'family friends' close to all then yes it's exclusion and seems unfair.
But say the siblings are far apart in ages... and/or the Godparents genuinely had contact with only their Godchild.
Nothing wrong with them leaving the money to the child they know.

Oh and also level of child's engagement!
If one has made more than the other why should they be equally rewarded?
Inheritance isn't a given.

honeylulu · 27/04/2023 17:06

It's a bit awkward I agree because it's been a bit "luck of the draw" as to which child got the set of benefactor godparents. But no one is obliged to do anything different. The child that inherits will be entitled to the money and the other child won't. The mother has the power to even things up herself but she's said she won't be doing that (though I think that would have been a fair way to address it but only once it's clear what dc1 is likely to inherit - it could all get spent before then!) Similar in my family. My godmother had no children, nieces or nephews. My sister's godmother did (and is still alive though very elderly). My godmother was aware of this and left equal bequests in her estate for me and my sister, knowing my sister wouldn't inherit anything from her own godmother. No one asked or expected her to, she just did it. Even her jewellery was divided between me, my sister and our mum. She was lovely!

Camablanca · 27/04/2023 17:05

GasPanic · 27/04/2023 15:43

To me it's not like winning the lottery at all.

Winning the lottery is random. When you win the lottery you pay the price and you stand to benefit (or not) from the result. The lottery isn't taking any sort of active decision to make you benefit rather than anyone else. You can't claim the lottery is valuing one sibling more than the other. It has no concept of that. Your sibling could complain that you won, but it's hardly unfair as the same opportunity (to buy a ticket and potentially win) is equally open to them.

In the inheritance case then someone is actually making a proactive decision to benefit one sibling more than another, basically (seemingly) solely on the fact that they were nominated godparent to that sibling. It may be down to luck that one sibling got the right godparent, but the act of exclusion is not down to luck at all.

Hrmm. I'm not sure whether it's that clear cut.
In the case of siblings close in age, and the Godparents being 'family friends' close to all then yes it's exclusion and seems unfair.
But say the siblings are far apart in ages... and/or the Godparents genuinely had contact with only their Godchild.
Nothing wrong with them leaving the money to the child they know.

Peterpiperpickedapeckof · 27/04/2023 17:04

Definitely wouldn’t worry about this or even think about it! So much can happen in life, so many rolls of the dice. Good luck or bad luck. A possible inheritance really isn’t something to worry about

IrregularChoiceFan · 27/04/2023 17:03

If I was the god parent, whatever money I was going to leave god child I would split with their sibling.

I don't think guilt and family drama is a great thing to leave someone but know others disagree.

Sugarfree23 · 27/04/2023 17:01

whoateallthecookies · 27/04/2023 16:43

This actually happened in our family - DH's sister inherited her godmother's flat (all of it) and DH didn't. DH didn't really know his sister's godmother; she was almost certainly rather better at keeping in touch. It hasn't caused any issues, despite being a significant sum. It probably helps that DH (we) are comfortably off; it wouldn't be a life changing sum for us.

Now think if that had been the other way round the sister keeps in touch but the Godchild brother inherits.