Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about children getting different inheritances?

88 replies

KingsHeath53 · 27/04/2023 08:39

My 2 DC have different sets of godparents. Both lovely, hands on godparents and close friends. DC1 godparents are child-free, DC2 godparents have children. DC1 godparents have indicated when they die, DC1 will be in their will. Obviously not the case for DC2 where godparents would rightly leave their estate to their own kids. Should add when we chose godparents for DC1 we didn’t know they were going to be child-free forever, so this didn’t factor into our godparent selection!

I’ll say upfront i’m not hugely worried about this. I plan to raise my kids to be resilient and make their own way in life, not expecting or needing inheritances or hand outs. Also loads could happen in future, godparents could get other godchildren etc etc. Who knows.

However, it did get me wondering. If one (by then I assume adult) DC inherited a lot (godparents are wealthy with property etc) and the other one didn’t, based on an arbitrary choice of who would be godparents, would that cause tension between the siblings? Does anyone have family experience where one sibling inherited a lot from say, a distant relative, and others didn’t? Did that cause problems and jealousy? As a parent would you guide your one child to split an unequal inheritance with their sibling if the situation arose?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 28/04/2023 16:01

I think you need to forget about it.

You don't know what the will says, when they will die, whether they will change their will or lose their money or what position your children will be in.

The chances are they are leaving a token gift, or a specific sum to any godchildren and not their whole estate.

Even if they were planning to leave the whole of the estate to their godchild the fastest way to damage the relationship and prompt them to reconsider their plans is to tell them they should consider your other children too!

Sugarfree23 · 28/04/2023 14:27

There might be a bit of envy, but do you really think they'll inherit that much?

That really is the biggest question. Do the Godparents not have neices and nephews who they'd like to share their money with?

But no matter what family or paper relationships people have, those who are writing wills especially in the later years should be looking around at who is actually looking out for them, who visits, who does the small jobs they can no longer manage, like changing light bulbs, putting fresh duvet covers on.

mondaytosunday · 28/04/2023 09:48

There might be a bit of envy, but do you really think they'll inherit that much? £I've left £500 to my godchildren, my husband left £2000 to his, and I never got anything (awkwardly my uncle was my godfather and at a family dinner we were discussing godparents and he asked me who mine were)!
As mentioned upthread people have different financial journeys. One sibling might have a higher paying job, or married a wealthy spouse etc. My stepsons have experienced this. One married into a very wealthy family and consequently were able to buy a lovely house in Zone 2, travel extensively and no doubt will send their child to private school (that's where they met). The brother could just about afford a house in a not a great part of Zone 6 and no way could afford private schooling. I'm sure he has pangs of envy but it hadn't affected their relationship with each other.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 28/04/2023 09:05

Remember that the average age at which people receive an inheritance is 61, by which time they have made their way in the world and a windfall may not be nearly as significant as if it had happened at 21. Also, the godparents may need nursing home care which would eat up all their reserves before death, or they may change their wills; or one could die and the other remarry, changing the inheritance. There are many things that could change before your child inherits - if, indeed, they do - so there's no point in worrying about it right now.

babyproblems · 28/04/2023 07:45

Agree I doubt it will be a huge sum of money. I’ve never heard of godparents leaving money like that so I wouldn’t worry about it until it happens. If it does, maybe your dc would share it anyway x

AspidistraFlying · 28/04/2023 07:43

Supersimkin2 · 27/04/2023 19:07

Love the way OP presumes her DC’s collecting the entire estate - house, the lot.

Most godparents leave tokens only for remembrance. Princess Diana left her sitting room ornaments to be split 39 ways between her godchildren.

Yes, that would be my default assumption unless the godparent actually specified a large sum of money.

SlippySarah · 28/04/2023 07:33

AllTheWatersTurnedToClouds · 27/04/2023 14:39

I'm leaving money to my Godson (I've no kids) and, to make it fair, I'm leaving the same amount to his sister.

I've spent the same amount of time with both of them, they are lovely young adults now, and if I can lend them a hand when I'm gone, I'm happy to do so.

Seemed very mean to just leave her out.

I would assume this would be the best option.

Luredbyapomegranate · 28/04/2023 07:30

I think you are overthinking it OP, once they are adults one of them might have a partner with money that means they are much better off than the other. It can cause resentment, but it’s just one of those things. It’s not a problem for you to solve.

As PPs say the godparents may be intending to leave the bulk of their cash to nieces and nephews, or they might loose touch with your child over the years, or get a lot more godchildren, so it may never happen.

Dedodee · 28/04/2023 07:25

Supersimkin2 · 27/04/2023 19:07

Love the way OP presumes her DC’s collecting the entire estate - house, the lot.

Most godparents leave tokens only for remembrance. Princess Diana left her sitting room ornaments to be split 39 ways between her godchildren.

Actually Diana left her godchildren 1/4 of the value of her belongings (except for jewellery) to be divided amongst them.
Her mother and sister gave one momento to each godchild instead.
Absolutely disgraceful imo.

mnisannoyingAF · 28/04/2023 07:18

Inheritance threads make me laugh and pissed off in equal measure. If someone wants their dying wish to be x gets xxxx then it's literally nothing to do with ANYONE else and being grumpy about it if either the kids or parents of the kids, is soo grabby!

mnisannoyingAF · 28/04/2023 07:16

minipie · 27/04/2023 14:43

I would be asking the godparents to split any inherited between both kids.

If they didn’t (as is their right) then yes I would be asking the beneficiary DC to split equally.

I had some money from a family member which was gifted to me before my sibling existed. My parents told me they thought it should be split and I agreed without hesitation. It’s only fair. Obviously not quite the same situation but similar.

😂😂😂😂😂😂 you cannot tell someone what to do with the own will. My god!

Blossomed · 28/04/2023 06:53

Presumably the godparents are close friends/relatives of yours, so surely if they were going to leave something to one of your children, they’d leave something for both? This may just be my experience, but god parents largely just seem to be a name thing and don’t actually do anything different or special with the child, compared to eg their siblings. But like I say, maybe that’s just what I’ve seen.

Snugglemonkey · 28/04/2023 06:51

caringcarer · 27/04/2023 09:24

My niece has 3 children now. At the point her Great Uncle died she only had two children. He left each of the two children named in his will £60k each. This has been invested and grown a bit more. I don't know how much more. The youngest child being several years younger than siblings has no inheritance. My niece is intending to leave all her three children an equal share in her will as she says she loves them all equally. The Great Uncle had a very close relationship with her two older boys and saw them most days. He chose not to leave the money to his great niece, as he thought she'd inherited from her own parents but instead left her share split between her children. Youngest will miss out.

In this case, if I were here, I would leave the youngest the £60k and then split the estate.

NameforMN · 28/04/2023 06:15

It's not much different to the scenario where one sibling may inherit more than another due to their spouse or partner inheriting. DH and I won't inherit from anyone. Dsis has married into a wealthy family and will. Just the way it is and not much you can do about it.

knittingaddict · 28/04/2023 05:34

Godparents leave money to their godchild? I've been robbed!!

ShippingNews · 28/04/2023 05:18
  • did, not did
ShippingNews · 28/04/2023 05:17

Sugarfree23 · 27/04/2023 15:40

While they are children now and the Godparent is say in their 40s.
You can't really predict what the relationships will be like in 30 or 40 years time.

When the children are adults with lives of their own and the Godparent is in their 70s or 80s.

Exactly. By the time the godparents both did, the kids could be middle aged. And all the estate could have gone to card fees or whatever. I'd forget it for the time being.

Lydiahateswashing · 28/04/2023 05:04

I had similar with my cousins when grandparents died. I was the benefactor of far more money than them, and decided I’d feel more comfortable if it were shared equally.

interestingly, subsequent events have made me think that they wouldn’t necessarily have thought in the same terms. But that does particularly change how I feel about my decision.

Wallywobbles · 27/04/2023 20:23

And it's fine. We don't care.

Wallywobbles · 27/04/2023 20:22

We all got different inheritances. My DGM didn't believe women needed money!

TanukiMario · 27/04/2023 19:33

GasPanic · 27/04/2023 15:43

To me it's not like winning the lottery at all.

Winning the lottery is random. When you win the lottery you pay the price and you stand to benefit (or not) from the result. The lottery isn't taking any sort of active decision to make you benefit rather than anyone else. You can't claim the lottery is valuing one sibling more than the other. It has no concept of that. Your sibling could complain that you won, but it's hardly unfair as the same opportunity (to buy a ticket and potentially win) is equally open to them.

In the inheritance case then someone is actually making a proactive decision to benefit one sibling more than another, basically (seemingly) solely on the fact that they were nominated godparent to that sibling. It may be down to luck that one sibling got the right godparent, but the act of exclusion is not down to luck at all.

I do think that the best thing would be to speak to the godparents and hopefully they share the inheritance with both children equally, since this is fair. I would hopefully make them see sense that they could be causing a strain on the siblings relationship with a one sided inheritance.

I just dont think its my place as a mother to take it away from one child and give to the other if the godparents refuse to do that.
I also dont think it would make it more fair to top it off and give the missing out child more from me. Because that is also not treating theim equally. Its like saying “Oh, DS is so well off already, I will just give DD more inheritance because she needs it more.”

Its a very difficult situation and basically theres no winning. I think in the end I would sit my children down and have a talk and find a solution everyones happy with.

CuriousGeorge80 · 27/04/2023 19:19

As with some other PP, I find it really odd (mean?) that they will leave it to just one of your children unless they basically have no relationship with your family and it’s symbolic only.

I have a god child. Her sibling will get the same from me.

LakieLady · 27/04/2023 19:08

caringcarer · 27/04/2023 09:24

My niece has 3 children now. At the point her Great Uncle died she only had two children. He left each of the two children named in his will £60k each. This has been invested and grown a bit more. I don't know how much more. The youngest child being several years younger than siblings has no inheritance. My niece is intending to leave all her three children an equal share in her will as she says she loves them all equally. The Great Uncle had a very close relationship with her two older boys and saw them most days. He chose not to leave the money to his great niece, as he thought she'd inherited from her own parents but instead left her share split between her children. Youngest will miss out.

These things can't be predicted.

My DSS was the only GC when his GM died. She had a significant sum in savings, which she left to her "grandchildren", ie DSS. The money was put in a trust until he was 21, by which time the fund had grown to the point where the amount enabled DSS to put down a 50% deposit on a decent house in a fairly expensive town.

It has caused a considerable degree of resentment among his cousins, all still renting in their late 20s, and their parents, especially as DSS's DM is really loaded and, as an only child, all that will go to him as well.

I wouldn't be at all surprised if his GF attempts to redress the balance somehow in his own will.

Iwasafool · 27/04/2023 19:08

One of mine has a Godparent who has no children, she made a point of telling us that both children are equal in her will. I thought that was so thoughtful.

Supersimkin2 · 27/04/2023 19:07

Love the way OP presumes her DC’s collecting the entire estate - house, the lot.

Most godparents leave tokens only for remembrance. Princess Diana left her sitting room ornaments to be split 39 ways between her godchildren.